Talk:Morning/Evening/GA1

GA Review

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch

Reviewer: IndianBio (talk · contribs) 10:35, 2 March 2016 (UTC)

Overall a pretty impressive article Sparklism. Some points to be considered before I see if it can be listed as a GA.

• File:Four Tet - Morning Evening album cover.jpg → should be made 300×300 pixels to comply with WP:NFCC#3b

•  Done

• Hebden played some of the records and began experimenting with sampling Indian playback singer Lata Mangeshkar's voice, looping a sample for three days --> Hebden played some of the records and began experimenting by playing a vocal sample of Indian playback singer Lata Mangeshkar for three days,

•  Done I went with "looping" here, to avoid repetition of 'play'. I hope that's OK.

• and decided to break the album into a --> Not "break", replace it with "divide"

•  Done

• coupled with complex drum programming[5][4] --> Avoid such instances where the ref 5 is coming before ref 4

•  Done

• to emphasise evening's relationship with nightclubs --> add "an" before evening, because you are not referring to evening here as a person, rather any evening's association with the night

•  Done Good spot!

• The song fades out --> link to Fade (audio engineering)

•  Done Good idea :)

• No marketing campaign was used --> Such stub sentences are not desriable, why don't join it with the next sentence as a contrast: "Although no marketing campaign was used, Hebden performed... "

•  Done OK

• from his page --> I assume this is a webpage? if so link it

• It's linked in the 'external links' section. I didn't see the need to link it in the article, since the cited source #1 covers what is said in the prose. How do you think I should link it - by inserting an external link into the text? Or by using it as a straightforward (primary) source?

• The critical response section is Immaculate

• Thanks. I had some fantastic help from Popcornduff!

• Remove Guardian news and media from the ref 1 and ref 17 publishers. You don't need to add publisher for same Work parameters

•  Done

• Use en-dash in place of normal dash in the reference titles.

•  Done I think I've got all of these now...

• Please note to make online sources with non-original content like AllMusic and Metacritic as non-italicized. Conversely, online sources with original content can remain italicized like Pitchfork Media etc.

• I've always been unclear about the guidelines for this. AllMusic qualifies as 'original content' though, surely? Not done (yet)
•  Done Actually, I think these are done now.

• Please note that you can actually remove all the publisher parameters, since it is now depreciated.

•  Done I didn't know that. I've left one in for the liner notes cite - should this be removed also? Thanks!

Let me know once they are taken care of. —IB ^{[ Poke ]} 13:43, 8 March 2016 (UTC)

Thanks for an excellent review IndianBio. I've got most of these covered already - will complete the rest shortly. Cheers! — sparklism ^hey! 14:11, 8 March 2016 (UTC)

Great work. I'm happy to pass the article now. —IB ^{[ Poke ]} 16:05, 8 March 2016 (UTC)

Thanks IndianBio! :) — sparklism ^hey! 16:12, 8 March 2016 (UTC)