Uralic–Yukaghir languages
| Uralic–Yukaghir | |
|---|---|
| Uralo–Yukaghir | |
| (hypothetical) | |
| Geographic distribution | Northern Europe, Eastern Europe, Siberia |
| Linguistic classification | Proposed language family |
| Subdivisions | |
| Language codes | |
| Glottolog | None |
 The Uralic and Yukaghir languages | |
Uralic–Yukaghir, also known as Uralo-Yukaghir, is a highly controversial proposed language family composed of Uralic and Yukaghir.
Uralic is a large and diverse family of languages spoken in northern and eastern Europe and northwestern Siberia. Among the better-known Uralic languages are Finnish, Estonian, and Hungarian.
Yukaghir is a small family of languages spoken in eastern Siberia. It formerly extended over a much wider area (Collinder 1965:30) and it consists of two surviving languages, Tundra Yukaghir and Kolyma Yukaghir.
Proponents of the Uralo-Siberian proposal include Uralo-Yukaghir as one of its two branches, alongside the Siberian languages (sometimes Nivkh, (formerly) Chukotko-Kamchatkan and Eskimo-Aleut).[1]
History
[edit]Similarities between Uralic and Yukaghir were first pointed out by Paasonen (1907) and Lewy (1928), although they did not consider these to be sufficient evidence for a genetic relationship between the two.[2][3] Holger Pedersen (1931) included Uralic and Yukaghir in his proposed Nostratic language family, and also noted some similarities between them.[4] A genetic relationship between Uralic and Yukaghir was first argued for in detail in 1940, independently by Karl Bouda and Björn Collinder.[5][6][7] The hypothesis was further elaborated by Collinder in subsequent publications,[8][9][10] and also by other scholars including Harms (1977), Nikolaeva (1988) and Piispanen (2013).[11][12][13]
Uralic–Yukaghir is listed as a language family in A Guide to the World's Languages by Merritt Ruhlen (1987), and is accepted as a unit in controversial long-range proposals such as "Eurasiatic" by Joseph Greenberg (2000, 2002) and "Nostratic" by Allan Bomhard (2008), both based on evidence collected by earlier scholars like Collinder.[14][15]
Proposed evidence
[edit]Collinder based his case for a genetic relationship between Uralic and Yukaghir on lexical and grammatical evidence; the latter included according to him similarities between pronouns, nominal case suffixes, and verb inflection.[16]
The following list of lexical correspondences is taken from Nikolaeva (2006).[17]
| Proto-Yukaghir | Proto-Uralic / Proto-Finno-Ugric |
Meaning |
|---|---|---|
| *čupo- | *ćuppa | 'sharp' / 'narrow, thin' |
| *eme | *emä | 'mother' |
| *iw- | *ime- | 'suck' |
| *köj | *koje | 'young man' / 'man' |
| *leɣ | *sewe-/*seɣe- | 'eat' |
| *mon- | *monV- | 'say' |
| *ńu: | *nime | 'name' |
| *olo- | *sala- | 'steal' |
| *ör- | *or- | 'shout' |
| *pe: | *pije | 'mountain, rock' / 'stone' |
| *pöɣ- | *pukta- | 'run, jump' |
| *qa:r/*qajr | *kore/*ko:re | 'skin' |
| *qol- | *kule- | 'hear' |
| *wonč- | *wacV/*wančV | 'root' |
The following list of lexical correspondences is taken from Aikio (2019).[18]: 52
| Proto-Uralic | Proto-Yukaghir |
|---|---|
| *aŋi ‘mouth, opening’ | *aŋa ‘mouth’ |
| *emä / *ämä | *eme ‘mother’ |
| *̮ila- | *āl- ‘place under or below’ |
| *kälä- ‘wade / rise’ | *kile- ‘wade’ |
| *käliw ‘brother- or sister-in-law’ | *keľ- ‘brother-in-law’ |
| *kani- ‘go away’ | *qon- ‘go’ |
| *koji ‘male, man, husband’ | *köj ‘fellow, boy, young man’ |
| *mälki | *mel- ‘breast’ |
| *nimi | *ńim / *nim ‘name’ |
| *ńali- | *ńel- ‘lick’ |
| *pidi- ‘long / high’ | *puδe ‘place on or above’, *puδe-nmē- ‘tall, high’ |
| *pi̮ni- ‘put’ | *pöń- / *peń- ‘put; leave’ |
| *sala- | *olo- ‘steal’ |
| *sula- | *aľ- ‘melt, thaw’ |
| *wanča(w) | *wonč- ‘root’ |
| *wixi- ‘take, transport’ | *weɣ- ‘lead, carry’ |
In Yukaghir numbers also share similarities such as Proto-Uralic "ükte/*ikte" and Yukaghir "irke" 'one'.[19]
Criticism
[edit]The Uralic–Yukaghir hypothesis is rejected by many researchers as unsupported. While most agree that there is a core of common vocabulary that cannot be simply dismissed as chance resemblances, it has been argued that these are not the result of common inheritance, but rather due to contact between Yukaghir and Uralic speakers, which resulted in borrowing of vocabulary from Uralic languages (especially Samoyedic) into Yukaghir. Rédei (1999) assembled a large corpus of what he considered as loans from Uralic into Yukaghir.[20] Häkkinen (2012) argues that the grammatical systems show too few convincing resemblances, especially the morphology, and proposes that putative Uralic–Yukaghir cognates are in fact borrowings from an early stage of Uralic (c. 3000 BC; he dates Proto-Uralic to c. 2000 BC) into an early stage of Yukaghir, while Uralic was (according to him) spoken near the Sayan region and Yukaghir near the Upper Lena River and near Lake Baikal.[21] Aikio (2014) agrees with Rédei and Häkkinen that Uralic–Yukaghir is unsupported and implausible, and that common vocabulary shared by the two families is best explained as the result of borrowing from Uralic into Yukaghir, although he rejects many of their (especially Rédei's) examples as spurious or accidental resemblances and puts the date of borrowing much later, arguing that the loanwords he accepts as valid were borrowed from an early stage of Samoyedic (preceding Proto-Samoyedic; thus roughly in the 1st millennium BC) into Yukaghir, in the same general region between the Yenisei River and Lake Baikal.[22]
Proponents of the theory have attempted to respond to criticisms with arguments that Uralic correspondences are found very extensively in function words and in the most used vocabulary which is allegedly very rarely borrowed. In particular, demonstrative pronouns, personal pronouns, numbers, kinship terms, and many verbs - these kinds of words are very rarely borrowed from other languages and are very resistant to loaning. According to Peter S. Piispanen, these proposed common words include the Yukaghir numeral "irke" 'one' compared to Proto-Uralic *ikte 'one', the first and second person singular pronouns in Proto-Yukaghir "*mət" 'I' and "*tət" 'you', compared to Proto-Uralic "*mon" 'I' and "*te/*ton" 'you' alongside the Yukaghir demonstrative pronoun root *ta- compared to the Proto-Uralic root *ta-. [19] However, even basic vocabulary can be borrowed in cases of extensive contact.[23]
Urheimat
[edit]According to Vladimir Napolskikh, the split between Finno-Ugric and Samoyedic branches might have occurred somewhere in the area between the Ob River and the Irtysh River, following an earlier split between Proto-Uralic and Proto-Yukaghir somewhere in Eastern Siberia.[24]
See also
[edit]Notes
[edit]- ^ "Correlating Palaeo-Siberian languages and populations: recent advances in the Uralo-Siberian hypothesis". ResearchGate. Retrieved 22 March 2019.
- ^ Paasonen (1907), pp. 19.
- ^ Lewy (1928), pp. 287: "Das Jukagirische zeigt zahlreiche Anklänge an das Finnougrische [...] Beweisen tut das zunächst gar nichts, aber es kann veranlassen, weiter zu prüfen." ('Yukaghir shows numerous points of resemblance to Finno-Ugric [...] For the moment, this does not prove anything, but it can motivate further research.')
- ^ Pedersen (1931), p. 338.
- ^ Bouda (1940), p. 92: "Wir haben gesehen, daß das Jukagirische eine so starke uralische Schicht besitzt, daß man es als diesem Sprachgebiet zugehörig ansehen kann." ('We have seen that Yukhagir has such a strong Uralic stratum, that we can consider it to belong the latter's speech area.')
- ^ Collinder (1940).
- ^ Piispanen (2013), p. 167.
- ^ Collinder (1957).
- ^ Collinder (1965a).
- ^ Collinder (1965b).
- ^ Harms (1977).
- ^ Nikolaeva (1988).
- ^ Piispanen (2013).
- ^ Greenberg (2000), pp. 279–81.
- ^ Bomhard (2008), p. 176.
- ^ Collinder (1965b), p. 30: "The features common to Yukagir and Uralic are so numerous and so characteristic that they must be remainders of a primordial unity. The case system of Yukagir is almost identical with that of Northern Samoyed. The imperative of the verbs is formed with the same suffixes as in Southern Samoyed and the most conservative of the Fenno-Ugric languages. The two negative auxiliary verbs of the Uralic languages are also found in Yukagir. There are striking common traits in verb derivation. Most of the pronominal stems are more or less identical. Yukagir has half a hundred words in common with Uralic, in addition to those that may fairly be suspected of being loanwords. This number is not lower than should be expected on the assumption that Yukagir is akin to Uralic. In Yukagir texts one may find sentences of up to a dozen words that consist exclusively or almost exclusively of words that also occur in Uralic. Nothing in the phonologic or morphologic structure of Yukagir contradicts the hypothesis of affinity, and Yukagir agrees well with Uralic as far as the syntax is concerned."
- ^ Nikolaeva (2006), pp. 146, 158, 178, 215, 238, 274, 300, 325, 336, 344, 354, 379, 384, 458.
- ^ Aikio, Ante (2019). "Proto-Uralic". In Bakró-Nagy, Marianne; Laakso, Johanna; Skribnik, Elena (eds.). Oxford Guide to the Uralic Languages. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
- ^ a b Peter S. Piispanen (Stockholm). The Uralic-Yukaghiric connection revisited: Sound Correspondences of Geminate Clusters. SUSA/JSFOu 94, 2013
- ^ Rédei (1999).
- ^ Häkkinen (2012).
- ^ Aikio (2014).
- ^ Thomason, Sarah Grey; Kaufman, Terrence (15 November 2023). Language Contact, Creolization, and Genetic Linguistics. University of California Press. p. 48. ISBN 978-0-520-91279-3.
- ^ Предыстория народов уральской языковой семьи (in Russian).
Bibliography
[edit]Works cited
[edit]
- Aikio, Ante (2014). "The Uralic–Yukaghir lexical correspondences: genetic inheritance, language contact or chance resemblance?". Finnisch-Ugrische Forschungen [Finno-Ugric research]. 2014 (62): 7–76. doi:10.33339/fuf.86078.
- Bomhard, Allan R. (2008). Reconstructing Proto-Nostratic: Comparative Phonology, Morphology, and Vocabulary. Leiden: Brill.
- Bouda, Karl (1940). "Die finnisch-ugrisch-samojedische Schicht des Jukagirischen". Ungarische Jahrbücher (in German). 20: 80–101.
- Collinder, Björn (1940). Jukagirisch und Uralisch [Yukagirian and Uralic]. Uppsala Universitets Årsskrift 8. Uppsala: Almqvist & Wiksell.
- Collinder, Björn (1957). "Uralo-jukagirische Nachlese". Uppsala Universitets Årsskrift. 12: 105–130.
- Collinder, Björn (1965a). "Hat das Uralische Verwandte? Eine sprachvergleichende Untersuchung". Acta Societatis Linguisticae Upsaliensis. 1: 109–180.
- Collinder, Björn (2021) [First published 1965]. An Introduction to the Uralic Languages. Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press. ISBN 978-052036929-0.
- Greenberg, Joseph H. (2000). Indo-European and Its Closest Relatives: The Eurasiatic Language Family, Volume 1: Grammar. Stanford, California: Stanford University Press. ISBN 978-080473812-5.
- Greenberg, Joseph H. (2002). Indo-European and Its Closest Relatives: The Eurasiatic Language Family, Volume 2: Lexicon. Stanford, California: Stanford University Press. ISBN 978-080474624-3.
- Greenberg, Joseph H. (2005). Croft, William (ed.). Genetic Linguistics: Essays on Theory and Method. Oxford University Press. ISBN 978-019925771-3.
- Häkkinen, Jaakko (2012). "Early contacts between Uralic and Yukaghir". Mémoires de la Société Finno-Ougrienne. 264: 91–101.
- Harms, Robert (1977). Hopper, Paul J. (ed.). Studies in descriptive and historical linguistics. Festschrift for Winfred P. Lehmann. Current Issues in Linguistic Theory. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. pp. 301–316. ISBN 978-902720905-4.
- Lewy, Ernst (1928). "Possessivisch und Passivisch. Bemerkungen zum Verbalausdruck in der sprachlichen Typenlehre" [Possessive and passive. Notes on verbal expression in linguistic type theory]. Ungarische Jahrbücher. 8: 274–289.
- Nikolaeva, Irina (1988). Проблема урало-юкагирских генетических связей [The Problem of Uralo-Yukaghir Genetic Relationship] (PhD dissertation) (in Russian). Moscow: Institute of Linguistics.
- Nikolaeva, Irina (2006). A Historical Dictionary of Yukaghir. Trends in Linguistics. Documentation. Berlin/New York: Mouton de Gruyter. ISBN 978-311018689-5.
- Paasonen, Heikki (1907). "Zur Frage von der Urverwandschaft der finnisch-ugrischen und indoeuropäischen Sprachen" [On the question of the original relationship of the Finnish-Ugric and Indo-European languages]. Finnisch-Ugrische Forschungen. 7: 13–31 – via Internet Archive.
- Pedersen, Holger (1931). Linguistic Science in the Nineteenth Century: Methods and Results. Translated by John Webster Spargo. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University Press.
- Pedersen, Holger (1933). "Zur Frage nach der Urverwandtschaft des Indoeuropäischen mit dem Ugrofinnischen" [On the question of the original relationship between Indo-European and Ugro-Finnish]. Mémoires de la Société Finno-Ougrienne. 67: 308–325.
- Piispanen, Peter (2013). "The Uralic-Yukaghiric Connection Revisited: Sound Correspondences of Geminate Clusters". Journal de la Société Finno-Ougrienne. 2013 (94): 165–197. doi:10.33340/susa.82515.
- Rédei, Károly (1999). "Zu den uralisch-jukagirischen Sprachkontakten" [On Uralic-Yukagirian language contacts]. Finnisch-Ugrische Forschungen. 55: 1–58.[permanent dead link]
- Ruhlen, Merritt (1987). A Guide to the World's Languages, Volume 1: Classification. Stanford, California: Stanford University Press. ISBN 978-080471894-3.
Further reading
[edit]- Angere, J. 1956. Die uralo-jukagirische Frage. Ein Beitrag zum Problem der sprachlichen Urverwandschaft. Stockholm: Almqvist & Viksell.
- Bouda, Karl. 1940. "Die finnisch-ugrisch-samojedische Schicht des Jukagirischen." Ungarische Jahrbücher 20, 80–101.
- Fortescue, Michael. 1998. Language Relations Across Bering Strait: Reappraising the Archaeological and Linguistic Evidence. London and New York: Cassell.
- Hyllested, Adam. 2010. "Internal Reconstruction vs. External Comparison: The Case of the Indo-Uralic Laryngeals." Internal Reconstruction in Indo-European, eds. J.E. Rasmussen & T. Olander, 111–136. Copenhagen: Museum Tusculanum Press.
- Janhunen, Juha. 2009. "Proto-Uralic—what, where, and when?" Suomalais-Ugrilaisen Seuran Toimituksia 258. pp. 57–78. Online article.
- Mithen, Steven. 2003. After the Ice: A Global Human History 20,000 – 5000 BC. Orion Publishing Co.
- Nikolaeva, Irina. 1986. "Yukaghir-Altaic parallels" (in Russian). Istoriko-kul'turnye kontakty narodov altajskoj jazykovoj obshchnosti: Tezisy dolkadov XXIX sessii Postojannoj Mezhdunarodnoj Altaisticheskoj Konferencii PIAC, Vol. 2: Lingvistika, pp. 84–86. Tashkent: Akademija Nauk.
- Nikolaeva, Irina. 1987. "On the reconstruction of Proto-Yukaghir: Inlaut consonantism" (in Russian). Jazyk-mif-kul'tura narodov Sibir, 43–48. Jakutsk: JaGU.
- Nikolaeva, Irina. 1988. "On the correspondence of Uralic sibilants and affricates in Yukaghir" (in Russian). Sovetskoe Finnougrovedenie 2, 81–89.
- Rédei, K. 1990. "Zu den uralisch-jukagirischen Sprachkontakten." Congressus septimus internationalis Fenno-Ugristarum. Pars 1 A. Sessiones plenares, 27–36. Debrecen.
- Sauvegeot, Au. 1963. "L'appartenance du youkaguir." Ural-altaische Jahrbücher 35, 109–117.
- Sauvegeot, Au. 1969. "La position du youkaguir." Ural-altaische Jahrbücher 41, 344–359.
- Swadesh, Morris. 1962. "Linguistic relations across the Bering Strait." American Anthropologist 64, 1262–1291.
- Tailleur, O.G. 1959. "Plaidoyer pour le youkaghir, branche orientale de la famille ouralienne." Lingua 6, 403–423.
External links
[edit]- Bibliography at Online Documentation of Kolyma Yukaghir by Irina Nikolaeva