Wikipedia:WikiProject Articles for creation/feedback/Archive 10
 | This is an archive of past discussions about Wikipedia:WikiProject Articles for creation. Do not edit the contents of this page. If you wish to start a new discussion or revive an old one, please do so on the current main page. |
Feedback from ErikVKing (4 October 2012)
- Did you find the instructions clear?
- How quickly was your submission reviewed?
- Quickly, yet not so quickly. It took some time, but I was at the end of a very long line, so it's more than understandable. I moved through the line quickly for the amount of submissions prior to mine, however.
- Do you have any suggestions to improve the process?
- Maybe. I am new to creating a page, and as such I was baffled by the amount of information that can/does go into a nice wiki page. Not really just the information involved, but the amount of syntax(?)/scripting(?) involved in the pages.
There are many many pages with SO many help topics...and almost "too many" for the ley person to comprehend and utilize. If your system could "flag" a person that has never created a page, especially someone with no edits, or only a few "simple" edits, maybe some streamlining could be done.
How to explain this... Basically, anyone that has not done more than correct a spelling error or add a name to a file is "flagged". Anyone who has only added a simple syntax(?) to a page (i.e. added a bracketed Wiki link inside of a topic) would also be "flagged".
In other words, a system that would shuffle a new page around for someone, and have them put more into "talk" section rather than making the page itself for submission. People like myself want to make a page, but also want to do it quickly because we think Wiki is lacking a certain topic or other such area. We don't necessarily know the best layout, the best area to put Categories, and many other such information.
We may, however, be able to pick up good references and text from books that would work in a page.
With the "flagging" I mentioned above, the page being created may be moved to a "newby" section where a mentor in Wiki may be able to give feedback and provide Instant Messaging help with a page, or maybe even a message board could be used in conjunction with the page. Anything that can help people like me create a page with decent information on it, in a layout that can be understood, without tearing our hair out in the process.
The "flagging" might also alert a group of people that can take my references and the information I provide into a working page. I do the research, someone else creates (or, like I said above) helps *me* create the page.
Feedback from 122.167.8.6 (6 October 2012)
- Did you find the instructions clear?
- Yes
- How quickly was your submission reviewed?
- Fast
- Do you have any suggestions to improve the process?
- No
David sobie
- Did you find the instructions clear?
- yes
- How quickly was your submission reviewed?
- very fast
- Do you have any suggestions to improve the process?
Feedback from 31.54.6.11 (12 October 2012)
- Did you find the instructions clear?
- Hannah limbert is a freaking sexy chick
- How quickly was your submissio
- Do you have any suggestions to improve the process?
- Make a page on her
Feedback from George Slivinsky (18 October 2012)
- Did you find the instructions clear?
- yes
- How quickly was your submission reviewed?
- about a week
- Do you have any suggestions to improve the process?
- thanks for the email notif about acceptance. However the notif is not clear. It gives the "difference between revisions " and looks meaningless. Anyway I found my way.
Feedback from Mahensingha (20 October 2012)
- Did you find the instructions clear?
- Yes
- How quickly was your submission reviewed?
- within a week
- Do you have any suggestions to improve the process?
No
Chirag Paswan
Chirag Paswan | |
|---|---|
| Born | Chirag Paswan Error: Need valid birth date: year, month, day Mumbai, India |
| Nationality | Indian |
| Occupation(s) | Model, Actor |
| Years active | 2007-present |
Chirag Paswan, briefly known as Chirag itself, born 1987 in Mumbai, Maharashtra is an Indian film actor and model. He has appeared in popular film like Miley Naa Miley Hum .
Early life and career
Chirag Paswan was born in Mumbai, India, Ram Vilas Paswan's son who was introduced to the media two years back is finally gearing up for his debut vehicle.
References
External links
Feedback from CHHistory (23 October 2012)
- Did you find the instructions clear?
- Matthew Vanitas was most helpful in offering advice to ensure I got this right. As a first time contributor, it will be impossible to get from A to B without mentoring.
- How quickly was your submission reviewed?
- Very, within days.
- Do you have any suggestions to improve the process?
- I understand there are many pages of information related to help, and are very useful if you know how to find them. However, most people, likes to plunge right in and not read the instructions ahead of time. So, I think I would come up with a sheet of simple, basic instructions on format and how to code etc., including, examples that will help and expedite the process for the wiki beginners. I know I still have much to understand/learn but if I stay with what I learned from others for the first article, I basically could continue to contribution without much trials and tribulations. Again, thanks to a great and patient teacher -- Matthew V.
BTW, upon finishing the article, I went to Talk, asked a question on how to get the article through the production line, the next day, the article got moved by a kind hearted, helpful experienced editor. Is this how the process work?
I started the article in Article for creation. During the development/writing phase, I have help esp. from Matthew V. (Thanks so, so much) and when done.... the article somehow got over for review and release, if approved, which mine was.
IS This the normal process? Do I go through this everytime, though I am sure I can navigate with ease now after I have done the first one. CHHistory (talk) 16:00, 23 October 2012 (UTC)
Feedback from 183.83.42.153 (26 October 2012)
village people is a people
Feedback from 60.230.240.209 (26 October 2012)
- Did you find the instructions clear?
- Yes
- How quickly was your submission reviewed?
- N/A
- Do you have any suggestions to improve the process?
- N/A
Matheus Murilo Minussi Mattes
Criança
Feedback from 98.253.127.188 (28 October 2012)
HELLO IM DJ MEXICANPOWER ONE OF THE YOUNGEST DJ'S IN THE CHICAGO AREAS IM NOT KNOWN BY MANY PEOPLE BUT THATS MY GOAL TO BE KNOWN BY THE BEST DJ'S LIKE DJ FLIPSIDE,DJ HARDWELL AND MANY MORE OTHER DJ'S
Feedback from 42.107.175.147 (28 October 2012)
- Did you find the instructions clear?
- How quickly was your submission reviewed?
- Do you have any suggestions to improve the process?
Feedback from Plarkin50 (29 October 2012)
- Did you find the instructions clear?
- No. The whole process is very confusing. I believe all the information is there, but a quick guide or simplified process description would be helpful. For example;
1. photo copyrights - the information posted is daunting and needs a lawyers explanation. Can't this be simplified?
2. and how do I respond to comments or ask questions to the commentors?
3. What is the User Page for?
4. What is the Talk page for and how does it relate to the User Page?
5. and now I have a Project Page???
6. Should I pose these questions in the Tea House? Is that an open forum? The same (small) group of users? Thousands of users?
- How quickly was your submission reviewed?
- Quickly, within days, very good response.
- Do you have any suggestions to improve the process?
- See my comments above. A simplified user guide would be helpful.
- With regard to my article, what do I do next?
Feedback from Margaretwmiller (30 October 2012)
- Did you find the instructions clear?
- The instructions were very clear and I appreciate the toolbar, which made formatting easier.
- How quickly was your submission reviewed?
- It was reviewed, edited and posted within 48 hours! Kudos to your team!
- Do you have any suggestions to improve the process?
- I find the "talk" system a bit daunting. There were several of us in a chat room at one point and
I couldn't discern which person was there to help me. Margaretwmiller (talk) 14:54, 30 October 2012 (UTC)
Feedback from Minusminority (1 November 2012)
- Did you find the instructions clear?
- Yes.
- How quickly was your submission reviewed?
- Quickly enough (within a day or two for all my submissions).
- Do you have any suggestions to improve the process?
- I believe it should be mandatory that all new articles be reviewed by another Wikipedian before being published (whether the articles are created by a person with a user page or not).Minusminority (talk) 12:57, 1 November 2012 (UTC)
Feedback from 117.197.236.104 (1 November 2012)
- Did you find the instructions clear?
- yes
- How quickly was your submission reviewed?
- Do you have any suggestions to improve the process?
no
Feedback from 117.197.236.104 (1 November 2012)
- Did you find the instructions clear?
- yes
- How quickly was your submission reviewed?
- Do you have any suggestions to improve the process?
no
Feedback from 39.54.32.45 (4 November 2012)
- Did you find the instructions clear?
- i see it clear . but still have some questions/
- How quickly was your submission reviewed?
gud
- Do you have any suggestions to improve the process?
- there must be a help window to view experts opinion on history. because nowadays internet is education and everything.
Feedback from 70.39.185.227 (5 November 2012)
- Did you find the instructions clear?
- How quickly was your submission reviewed?
- Do you have any suggestions to improve the process?
"need of information technology in india"this article must be published on your site
Feedback from Eozhik (6 November 2012)
- Did you find the instructions clear?
- Yes, more or less clear.
- How quickly was your submission reviewed?
- Quite quickly.
- Do you have any suggestions to improve the process?
- To tell the truth, it remains not clear for me why my article was graded as "C-Class". I suppose, this means that I should improve it, but it is not clear, what should be done for this.
Anthropogeography recreation of quitman texas wood county rural homestead community settlement of sabine lake
- Did you find the instruct
- How quickly was your submission reviewed?
- Bold text
[[Anthropogeography recreation quitman texas wood county homestead community rural settlement of sabine lake legal documents land law real estate history archives
Feedback from Kirschblume (7 November 2012)
- Did you find the instructions clear?
- Yes
- How quickly was your submission reviewed?
- Fast
- Do you have any suggestions to improve the process?
- No. I am new, but I easily get used to the matter here (for a beginner) and I love the concept of wikipedia at whole! :) Kirschblume (talk) 16:14, 7 November 2012 (UTC)
Feedback from Only1Noodle (8 November 2012)
- Did you find the instructions clear?
- How quickly was your submission reviewed?
- Do you have any suggestions to improve the process?
Feedback from Only1Noodle (8 November 2012)
- Did you find the instructions clear?
yes
- How quickly was your submission reviewed?
yes
- Do you have any suggestions to improve the process?
no
you o idiots=
ha ha dude
'i am ha ha dude ...what i can say about me i am so cool.......
Feedback from Deidra C. (14 November 2012)
- Did you find the instructions clear?
- No I didn't.
- How quickly was your submission reviewed?
- Too quickly.
- Do you have any suggestions to improve the process?
- Yes. It needs to be much more thourough.RaidenRules! (talk) 22:32, 14 November 2012 (UTC)
Feedback from 86.129.252.70 (15 November 2012)
- Did you find the instructions clear?
- No
- How quickly was your submission reviewed?
- It wasnt reviewed.
- Do you have any suggestions to improve the process?
- BETTER INSTRUCTIONS PLZ!!!
Feedback from 68.70.234.90 (17 November 2012)
The unknown word known as notification is known as a note of an event that can be happening, may have happened, or will happen (past, present, future).
Feedback from 122.172.162.13 (17 November 2012)
- Did you find the instructions clear?
- no its lik telling son of a virgin dad
- How quickly was your submission reviewed?
- fuck it took a hell lotta time ....u guys r moron's....!!!
- Do you have any suggestions to improve the process?
- yes sell the process to me....regards...Rajesh mondal, exl employee, bangalore, 560086
Feedback from 173.225.242.209 (18 November 2012)
- Did you find the instructions clear?
- How quickly was your submission reviewed?
- Do you have any suggestions to improve the process?
Feedback from 202.141.47.6 (22 November 2012)
- Did you find the instructions clear?
- yes i found every indtructions very clear
- How quickly was your submission reviewed?
- in 10 minutes
- Do you have any suggestions to improve the process?
deepak das
- Did you find the instructions clear?
- How quickly was your submission reviewed?
- Do you have any suggestions to improve the process?
Feedback from 113.193.100.111 (22 November 2012)
- Did you find the instructions clear?
- How quickly was your submission reviewed?
- Do you have any suggestions to improve the process?
Feedback from Don Crioner Richmond (24 November 2012)
Don Crioner RichmonD real name Ico Georgiev BOrn In BUlagriq PLovdiv teach in Pgt Goce delchev he is song writerr ang rapperr nickname D.C.R he carrirer start's in PLovdiv he albumm relase decemver 9th with 18songs and 3 sonds added special for Bulgariq
Feedback from 2.180.88.41 (25 November 2012)
- Did you find the instructions clear?
- no
- How quickly was your submission reviewed?
- I couldn't at all
- Do you have any suggestions to improve the process?
- I've tried to submit something about SC2PL which is an abbreviation in two phase-locking. but the process was completely confusing.
Feedback from 41.186.11.211 (25 November 2012)
- Did you find the instructions clear?
- no
- How quickly was your submission reviewed?
- very quick
- Do you have any suggestions to improve the process?
- yes
Feedback from 99.119.14.205 (10 December 2012)
- Did you find the instructions clear?
- Yes
- How quickly was your submission reviewed?
- Do you have any suggestions to improve the process?
- Nope. ^^
Feedback from 24.50.129.229 (12 December 2012)
Hi!Wayne Umm So Far On what I got For Canis Rufus Is a Scientific Name for a RED WOLF.. Umm I think Canis Means Refured to DOG more possiblite.
Thanks For Helping!!!!!!!
Feedback from Teckelberg7 (12 December 2012)
- Did you find the instructions clear?
- Yes, fairly clear.
- How quickly was your submission reviewed?
- Over a week I think
- Do you have any suggestions to improve the process?
- I expected the article once it was accepted to leave my Sandbox empty! Empty so that I could start on my next article. I'm now hesitatnt to delete the article form my Sandbox. Can you offer advice please. --Teckelberg7 (talk) 10:15, 12 December 2012 (UTC)
- Responded on user's talk page. — Martin (MSGJ · talk) 10:49, 12 December 2012 (UTC)
Feedback from 120.59.21.29 (13 December 2012)
- Did you find the instructions clear?
- yes
- How quickly was your submission reviewed?
- 2 seconds
- Do you have any suggestions to improve the process?
- yes
Feedback from 65.100.196.71 (16 December 2012)
i was in the navy for like three years or something like that i don't really remember
way back then because i was drunk or something and also i was like 18 but i am only 19 now so if your looking ladies ladies come to papa by the way i am short and Asian and fat and i like bowling and i live in Texas and i live in your trash can and i can see you rite now just kidding i love you you are sexy and i know it and you can reach me at 801 259 0876 and i was wondering were you live so i can go visit you and bring you flowers and have a play date with you!!!!!!!
Feedback from Yebila david njafuh (18 December 2012)
- Did you find the instructions clear?
no
- How quickly was your submission reviewed?
- Do you have any suggestions to improve the process?
Feedback from Mcawesome3 (18 December 2012)
- Did you find the instructions clear?
not at all
- How quickly was your submission reviewed?
- it was so long i grew a beard
- Do you have any suggestions to improve the process?
make the directions more clear
Feedback from Emjayben (21 December 2012)
- Did you find the instructions clear?
- How quickly was your submission reviewed?
- Do you have any suggestions to improve the process?
Feedback from {{subst:Yadu Gopan}} (22 December 2012)
- Did you find the instructions clear?
- How quickly was your submission reviewed?
- Do you have any suggestions to improve the process?
Yadu Gopan is the son of Saju Kumar and Sreeja. He is now studing in Jawahar Navodaya Vidyalaya. He is 13 years old. His native place is trivandrum, Kerala, India. He participated in Regional Children Science Congress held at Bangalore, venue IISc. He is a small photographist also.
Feedback from 67.218.163.117 (24 December 2012)
bartle doo is said by mumbles a famous youtube character made by edbassmaster
- awsome word
Feedback from 67.218.163.117 (24 December 2012)
bartle doo is said by mumbles a famous youtube character made by edbassmaster
- awsome word
Feedback from 67.218.163.117 (24 December 2012)
bartle doo is said by mumbles a famous youtube character made by edbassmaster
- awsome word
Pablo Lewczuk was born in Oberá Misiones (Argentina) in 1964 is a lecturer in Christian History at different Superior School and Universities in Argentina
- Did you find the instructions clear?
- How quickly was your submission reviewed?
- Do you have any suggestions to improve the process?
Ola k ase
ola k ase soi una llama de mierda i el ke lee esto es gai