Jump to content

Fossil trade

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
(Redirected from Trade in fossils)
Part of a series on
Paleontology
Fossils
Natural history
Organs and processes
Evolution of various taxa
Evolution
History of paleontology
Branches of paleontology
Paleontology Portal
Category
This trilobite moulting bed discovered in China is an example of a fossil legally purchased through the fossil trade

The fossil trade is the purchase and sale of fossils. This is at times done illegally with stolen fossils, and important scientific specimens are lost each year.[1][2][3][4] The trade is lucrative, and many celebrities collect fossils.[5]

The fossil trade has attracted criticism from many paleontologists, who regard the private ownership of fossils to be damaging to science.

History

[edit]
Mary Anning, a famous collector and seller of fossils

The auction of the Tyrannosaurus skeleton known as Sue in 1997 for $8.3 million is considered to have caused an increased interest in the fossil trade.[6] According to the head of science and natural history at Christie's, James Hyslop, the market in fossils has been growing consistently since 2007.[7] Due to the increased awareness of the lucrative nature of fossils, many landowners have become more reluctant to work with scientists, preferring to instead offer prospecting rights to the highest bidder.[6][7]

The international trade in fossils for use in alternative medicine, commonly referred to as "dragon bone", was worth US$700 million annually as of 2010.[8]

Fossil poaching is common in Mongolia. In five years, the United States Immigration and Customs Enforcement seized $44 million worth of smuggled fossils.[9] Fossils from Mongolia and China, which are illegal to export, are often claimed to be from Central Asia.[6]

Fossils sold through the fossil trade are often composites of multiple specimens, not necessarily from a single species, combined to look like one skeleton.[10]

Legality

[edit]

In the United States, it is legal to sell fossils collected on private land.[7] In [[Mongolia]China the export of fossils is illegal.[9][11] Brazil considers all fossils as federal assets and prohibits their trade since 1942, banned the permanent exports of holotypes and other fossils of national interest in 1990, and requires permits by the Ministry of Science, Technology and Innovation for permanent exports.[12]

Ethics and controversy

[edit]
Officials with the Ubirajara jubatus specimen after its return to Brazil in 2023

The Society of Vertebrate Paleontology, an international association of professional and amateur vertebrate paleontologists, believes that scientifically important fossils—especially but not exclusively those found on public lands—should be held in perpetuity in the public trust, preferably in a museum or research institution, where they can benefit the scientific community as a whole as well as future generations.[13] In the United States, Paleontological Resources Preservation Act. S. 546 and H. R. 2416 were introduced in the US Congress with SVP's full support.[14]

Many commercial fossil collectors and dealers believe that such policies are a breach of their rights. The argument has also been put forth that there are too few professional paleontologists to collect and preserve fossils currently exposed to the elements, and that it is therefore essential that private citizens be allowed to collect them for the sake of their preservation. Eric Scott, the Curator of Paleontology for the San Bernardino County Museum, argues that 1) private citizens and amateur (not for profit) collectors can and do participate frequently in the permitted recovery and preservation of significant vertebrate fossils, and 2) preservation of significant fossils does not require or mandate sale of those fossils.[15] The Society of Vertebrate Paleontology's by-laws state that the society does not condone the trade of scientifically significant vertebrate fossils, except for the purpose of keeping fossils in the public trust.[13]

The illegal export of fossils has increasingly attracted criticism, considered by some a form of science colonialism. As a result, several fossils have been repatriated, and many more are being reclaimed by their countries of origin.[16][17] Notably, the fossil Ubirajara jubatus, illegally exported from Brazil and deposited in a German museum, was described by a team of German scientists. Their paper has been retracted, and the fossil is to be returned to Brazil.[18] In addition, some of these trafficked fossils are chimeric fabrications to some extent, or may carry less information of their exact origin than fossils extracted following the law. A 2023 description of a turtle fossil deposited in Switzerland revealed the bones present to be from two different genera, Santanachelys and Araripemys, plus unidentifiable fragments.[19] Forgeries like these might make fossils easier to sell to tourists and even to scientists not trained to identify the fakes.[20]

Notable incidents

[edit]
US customs officials with a confiscated Tarbosaurus skeleton in May 2013

A hoax specimen composed of parts of genuine Yanornis and Microraptor fossils obtained by a museum through the fossil trade was originally interpreted in 1999 as a "missing link" between dinosaurs and birds and planned to be named "Archaeoraptor", but was identified as a hoax before being formally published in a scientific journal.[10]

A Tyrannosaurus skeleton nicknamed "Stan" sold at an auction in 2020 for $31.8 million, a record-setting price.[7]

The skull of a Tyrannosaurus relative called Tarbosaurus bataar illegally exported from Mongolia was purchased by the actor Nicolas Cage for $276,000 in 2007. When contacted by U.S. authorities, Cage voluntarily handed over the specimen for repatriation to Mongolia.[21]

A smuggled skeleton of Tarbosaurus bataar, which is also called Tyrannosaurus bataar, was the subject of the in rem case United States v. One Tyrannosaurus Bataar Skeleton.[6] The fossil was being auctioned in the United States, and was returned to Mongolia in 2013.[22]

The holotype specimen of the dinosaur Halszkaraptor had been obtained through the fossil trade by 2011. Due to its provenance, several scientists initially expressed concern that it was a hoax, but scanning suggests the specimen was not tampered with.[10]

On 18 July 2024 Stegosaurus Apex was auctioned for $44,600,000. It sold eleven times bove pre-sale estimates to American billionaire financier Kenneth Griffin and became the most expensive fossil ever sold.[23]

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]
  1. ^ Milmo, Cahal (2009-11-25). "Fossil theft: One of our dinosaurs is missing". The Independent. London. Archived from the original on 2009-11-28. Retrieved 2010-05-02.
  2. ^ Simons, Lewis. "Fossil Wars". National Geographic. The National Geographic Society. Archived from the original on 2012-02-27. Retrieved 2010-01-08.
  3. ^ Willis, Paul; Clark, Tim; Dennis, Carina (18 April 2002). "Fossil Trade". Catalyst. Archived from the original on 24 May 2012. Retrieved 8 January 2010.
  4. ^ Farrar, Steve (5 November 1999). "Cretaceous crimes that fuel the fossil trade". Times Higher Education. Archived from the original on 20 August 2012. Retrieved 2 November 2011.
  5. ^ "Luxury Market For Dinosaur Remains Thrives", The Huffington Post, 10 November 2010, archived from the original on 12 February 2017, retrieved 21 May 2012
  6. ^ a b c d Williams, Paige (2013-01-20). "Bones of contention". The New Yorker. Archived from the original on 2022-12-26. Retrieved 2023-01-17.
  7. ^ a b c d Haigney, Sophie (2021-06-18). "Once again, fossils are hot". The New York Times. Archived from the original on 2021-10-22. Retrieved 2021-10-23.
  8. ^ van der Geer, Alexandra; Dermitzakis, Michael (2010). "Fossils in pharmacy: from "snake eggs" to "Saint's bones"; an overview". Hellenic Journal of Geosciences. 45: 323–332.
  9. ^ a b Timmins, Beth (2019-11-23). "Dinosaurs: restoring Mongolia's fossil heritage". BBC News. Archived from the original on 2021-10-23. Retrieved 2021-10-23.
  10. ^ a b c Yong, Ed (2017-12-08). "How to tell if a dinosaur is fake". The Atlantic. Archived from the original on 2022-08-12. Retrieved 2023-01-17.
  11. ^ Gibney, Elizabeth (2014-03-01). "Brazil clamps down on illegal fossil trade". Nature. 507 (7490): 20. doi:10.1038/507020a. ISSN 1476-4687.
  12. ^ Cisneros, Juan C.; Ghilardi, Aline M.; Raja, Nussaïbah B.; Stewens, Paul P. (15 November 2021). "The moral and legal imperative to return illegally exported fossils". Nature Ecology & Evolution. 6 (1): 2–3. doi:10.1038/s41559-021-01588-9. ISSN 2397-334X.
  13. ^ a b "Statement regarding the sale of vertebrate fossils online". The Society of Vertebrate Paleontology. Archived from the original on 2021-10-23. Retrieved 2021-10-23.
  14. ^ Chew, A. Z. (2004). Nothing besides remains: Preserving the scientific and cultural value of paleontological resources in the United States. Duke LJ, 54, 1031.
  15. ^ Scott, E. (2005). "Is Selling Vertebrate Fossils Bad For Science?". PALAIOS. 20 (6): 515–517. Bibcode:2005Palai..20..515S. doi:10.2110/palo.2005.S06. S2CID 86781030.
  16. ^ "Countries demand their fossils back, forcing natural history museums to confront their past". www.science.org. Retrieved 2023-06-01.
  17. ^ Cisneros, Juan Carlos; Raja, Nussaïbah B.; Ghilardi, Aline M.; Dunne, Emma M.; Pinheiro, Felipe L.; Regalado Fernández, Omar Rafael; Sales, Marcos A. F.; Rodríguez-de la Rosa, Rubén A.; Miranda-Martínez, Adriana Y.; González-Mora, Sergio; Bantim, Renan A. M.; de Lima, Flaviana J.; Pardo, Jason D. (2022). "Digging deeper into colonial palaeontological practices in modern day Mexico and Brazil". Royal Society Open Science. 9 (3). doi:10.1098/rsos.210898. ISSN 2054-5703. PMC 8889171. PMID 35291323.
  18. ^ Cisneros, Juan Carlos; Raja, Nussaïbah B.; Ghilardi, Aline M.; Dunne, Emma M.; Pinheiro, Felipe L.; Regalado Fernández, Omar Rafael; Sales, Marcos A. F.; Rodríguez-de la Rosa, Rubén A.; Miranda-Martínez, Adriana Y.; González-Mora, Sergio; Bantim, Renan A. M.; de Lima, Flaviana J.; Pardo, Jason D. (2022). "Digging deeper into colonial palaeontological practices in modern day Mexico and Brazil". Royal Society Open Science. 9 (3). doi:10.1098/rsos.210898. ISSN 2054-5703. PMC 8889171. PMID 35291323.
  19. ^ Scheyer, Torsten M.; Oliveira, Gustavo R.; Romano, Pedro S. R.; Bastiaans, Dylan; Falco, Lisa; Ferreira, Gabriel S.; Rabi, Márton (2023-05-05). "A forged 'chimera' including the second specimen of the protostegid sea turtle Santanachelys gaffneyi and shell parts of the pleurodire Araripemys from the Lower Cretaceous Santana Group of Brazil". Swiss Journal of Palaeontology. 142 (1): 6. doi:10.1186/s13358-023-00271-9. ISSN 1664-2376. PMC 10163108. PMID 37163143.
  20. ^ Martill, David M. (May–June 1994). "Fake fossils from Brazil". Geology Today. 10 (3): 111–115. doi:10.1111/j.1365-2451.1994.tb00882.x.
  21. ^ "Nicolas Cage returns stolen dinosaur skull he bought for $276,000". NBC news. 2015-12-22. Archived from the original on 2021-10-23. Retrieved 2021-10-23.
  22. ^ Parry, Wynne (6 May 2013). "It's official: Mongolia has disputed dinosaur skeleton back". NBC News. Retrieved 1 June 2023.
  23. ^ Badshah, Nadeem (2024-07-17). "Largest, most intact stegosaurus fossil ever found sells for $44.6m". The Guardian. ISSN 0261-3077. Retrieved 2024-07-17.
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Fossil_trade&oldid=1251104741"