|Studio album by OutKast|
|Released||August 27, 1996|
Bosstown Recording Studios, Doppler Recording Studios, PatchWerk Recording Studio, Purple Dragon Studios, Studio LaCoCo
Chung King Recording Studio, Sound On Sound Recording
(New York, New York)
|Producer||Organized Noize, OutKast/Earthtone Ideas|
|Singles from ATLiens|
ATLiens is the second studio album by American hip hop duo OutKast, released on August 27, 1996, by LaFace Records. The duo wanted to improve on their 1994 debut album Southernplayalisticadillacmuzik and gain respect for their growing Southern hip hop scene. OutKast recorded ATLiens in sessions at several Atlanta studios—Bosstown Recording Studios, Doppler Recording Studios, PatchWerk Recording Studio, Purple Dragon Studios, and Studio LaCoCo—as well as Chung King Recording Studio and Sound On Sound Recording in New York City.
The record features outer space-inspired production sounds, with OutKast and producers Organized Noize incorporating elements of dub, reggae, and gospel into the compositions. Several songs feature the duo's first attempts at producing music by themselves. Lyrically, the group discusses a wide range of topics including urban life as hustlers, existential introspection, and extraterrestrial life. The album's title is a portmanteau of "ATL" (an abbreviation of Atlanta, Georgia) and "aliens", which has been interpreted by critics as a commentary about the feeling of being isolated from American culture.
ATLiens debuted at number two on the US Billboard 200 chart, and it sold nearly 350,000 copies in its first two weeks of release. The album was very well received by music critics upon its release, who praised the record's lyrical content. It has been certified double platinum by the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA), for shipments of two million copies in the United States. The album spawned the singles "Elevators (Me & You)", "ATLiens", and "Jazzy Belle". Since its release, ATLiens has been listed by several magazines and critics as one of the greatest hip hop albums of all time.
- 1 Background
- 2 Recording and production
- 3 Composition
- 4 Release and promotion
- 5 Reception
- 6 Legacy
- 7 Track listing
- 8 Personnel
- 9 Charts
- 10 Certifications
- 11 See also
- 12 References
- 13 External links
In 1994, the American hip hop duo OutKast released their debut album, Southernplayalisticadillacmuzik, which was recorded when members Big Boi and André 3000 were eighteen years old. Bolstered by the success of the single "Player's Ball", the record established OutKast as prominent figures in the Southern hip hop scene. After the album was certified platinum, LaFace Records gave OutKast more creative control and advanced money for their 1996 follow-up album ATLiens. The duo took the opportunity to recreate their image. On a trip to Jamaica with producer Mr. DJ, the two decided to abandon their cornrow hairstyles in favor of a more natural aesthetic, vowing to stop combing their hair. Dungeon Family member Big Rube observed an increase in the duo's confidence after returning from their first tour, remarking, "They started understanding the power they had in their music. They started showing a swagger that certain artists have—the ones that are stars." The members also underwent changes in their personal lives; in 1995, Big Boi's girlfriend gave birth to their first child and André 3000 and Total's Keisha Spivey ended their two-year relationship.
Despite its success, Southernplayalisticadillacmuzik had some detractors, including hip hop tastemakers who were unaccustomed to the album's style. As the East Coast and West Coast hip hop scenes were already well-established at the time, many did not view the South as a legitimate and respectable scene. At the 1995 Source Awards, an award ceremony held by The Source magazine, OutKast won in the "Best Newcomer" category, but were booed upon taking the stage and delivering their acceptance speech; Big Boi managed to deliver his shout outs, while André 3000 was nervous and only said, "The South got somethin' to say." The latter recalled how the album was received by some listeners, "People thought that the South basically only had bass music. At first people were looking at us like 'Um, I don't know.'" Taken aback by the backlash, André 3000 and Big Boi channelled their frustration in the studio to improve upon their debut.
Recording and production
After acquiring their own recording studio, the duo immediately started working on new material and assimiliated themselves with music recording and studio equipment, as they sought to become more ambitious artists and less dependent on other producers. The two also became more accustomed to playing live, particularly Big Boi, and André 3000 significantly changed his lifestyle, as he adopted a more eccentric fashion sense, became a vegetarian, and stopped smoking marijuana. Having dropped out months before graduation, André 3000 also returned to high school to earn his diploma during the recording of ATLiens.
Before beginning work on ATLiens, André 3000 purchased an SP1200 drum machine, an MPC3000 sampler, a TASCAM mixing board, and turntables with stacks of classic records. Although he had never produced a song before, he used techniques learned from observing the Dungeon Crew at work. "Elevators (Me & You)" was the first song the duo created together for the album. The duo refrained from sampling on the album, with Big Boi explaining "I feel like you cheat the listener when you sample. If it's an old school jam, leave it to the old. We wanna have our own school of music."
OutKast recorded the album in sessions at several Atlanta studios—Bosstown Recording Studios, Doppler Recording Studios, PatchWerk Recording Studio, Purple Dragon Studios, and Studio LaCoCo—as well as Chung King Recording Studio and Sound On Sound Recording in New York City. For ATLiens, the band aimed for a consistent set of songs in which a listener would not need to skip tracks; OutKast wrote around 35 songs for the album and reduced them to fourteen. The duo's songwriting style for the album had no solid structure and was mostly spontaneous; Big Boi noted, "Stuff'll just come to you. I'll be sittin' in the truck, and I'll start rhymin'. People look at me like I'm crazy, but that's how it starts."
The echo-laden track illustrates OutKast's rise to fame and exemplifies the album's sparse, atmospheric production with organ riffs, dub bass, and telephone tones.
|Problems playing these files? See media help.|
Two-thirds of the album is produced by Organized Noize, OutKast's primary production team. The rest is produced by Earthtone III, a production team that includes OutKast themselves and Mr. DJ. André 3000 and Big Boi produced the songs "Jazzy Belle" and "Elevators (Me & You)". It also has a notably more laid-back, spacey production sound, which they would continue to a certain extent on their follow-up album Aquemini. Although the group drew from George Clinton's outer-space inspired compositions, the band utilizes a more laid-back style as opposed to Clinton's hard funk leanings. Many tracks feature strong echo and reverb, taking influence from dub and reggae. Andrea Comer of The Hartford Courant perceives an "extraterrestrial feel" in the record's production.
OutKast also incorporated elements of gospel into the music; being from the South, the group felt obligated to "stay close to [their] slave roots". The album's introduction track "You May Die" has been described as "churchy". "Elevators (Me & You)" contains atmospheric elements including echoes, dub-influenced bass, organ riffs, and telephone tones. "13th Floor/Growing Old" contains a spoken word introduction from Big Rube, somber soul vocals from Debra Killings, and a "Prince-ish" piano riff, while "Wheelz of Steel" features "furious" turntable scratching by Mr. DJ. "Extraterrestrial" offers a break in the continuity of the record as it features no drum beat.
Lyrically, André 3000 and Big Boi abandon the "hard-partying playa characters" of their debut album in favor of more spacey, funky, and futuristic personas on ATLiens. With their lyrics, the duo hoped to reflect on maturity in the wake of the birth of Big Boi's daughter. André 3000 explained, "It's like everybody's talking about sipping champagne and being big time, so we just took it upon ourselves to do something new ... I want my children to say, 'Daddy really said something, he wasn't just trying to brag on himself.'" Many songs on ATLiens feature more unconventional subject matter for hip hop. The lyrical content ranges from addressing urban life as hustlers and pimps to extraterrestrial life and space travel. The title track's chorus expresses Southern pride, while its verses feature André 3000 explaining his newly-adopted drug-free lifestyle.
"Elevators (Me & You)" illustrates OutKast's rise to fame, and was inspired by a show the band played at Howard University with P. Diddy in the audience. The song also discusses the unlikely partnership of André 3000 and Big Boi, and uses the metaphor of an elevator for the ups and downs of fame. The final verse illustrates André 3000 dealing with a fan who pretends to have been childhood friends with him. It also references Southern culture, including mentions of Cadillacs and extended family gatherings. "Babylon" reflects on religious attitudes towards sex and illustrates André 3000's upbringing and his forbidden attractions throughout childhood. "Jazzy Belle" discusses the group's "increasingly enlightened" view regarding women: "Went from yellin' ... bitches and hoes to queen thangs". The album's closer "13th Floor/Growing Old" is a meditation on aging and emphasizes Southern hip hop's legitimacy.
Release and promotion
ATLiens was released on August 27, 1996, by LaFace Records. In September, LaFace created a promotion for the record in conjunction with Blockbuster in which customers could enter to win a 1970s Cadillac car, emphasizing OutKast and Cadillac's connection with the Southern lifestyle. The record's inner booklet features a 24-page comic strip foldout starring the members, who must defend "positive music" against the villain Nosamulli. The strip continues in the artwork for each single released from ATLiens except for "Elevators (Me & You)".
The album's title is a portmanteau of "ATL" (an abbreviation of Atlanta, Georgia) and "aliens". In his book Icons of Hip Hop: An Encyclopedia of the Movement, Music, and Culture, author Mickey Hess interprets the album's title as "partly a statement about being from Atlanta, while also signifying on the theme of the group's name (by using the term aliens) framing themselves as societal outcasts." Mark Bould, author of The Routledge Companion to Science Fiction, observes that the title symbolizes OutKast's "estrangement from American society", suggesting that "the inner city of their formative years is out of this world and its hostile conditions."
|The Rolling Stone Album Guide|||
|Martin C. Strong||7/10|
ATLiens was well received by contemporary music critics. Andrea Comer of The Hartford Courant felt that OutKast's "lyrical acumen shines through" despite "Heltah-Skeltah mumbling and Southern slang", and stated, "after a few rotations, the alien feeling wears away, and [the album is] just out of this world." Sonia Murray of The Atlanta Journal-Constitution called the album "more thoughtful" than its predecessor, noting, "What the second album lacks in adventurous arrangements it more than makes up for in lyrical dominance." The Source observed "growth" from OutKast and Organized Noize, and stated, "Big Boi and Dre have gone out of this world into a new dimension of sight, sound and mind".
Kevin Powell of Rolling Stone felt that, like OutKast's debut album, ATLiens is "a gritty document of what's happening here and now, an up-to-the-minute briefing on Southern black ghetto life on which OutKast members Andre and Big Boi cast their feelings of alienation in familiar, realistic characterizations". Powell asserted that unlike East Coast hip hop's "hedonistic materialism" or "the gunplay and pimpism" of West Coast hip hop, "Andre and Big Boi display a unique ability to describe ghetto life while offering up life-affirming possibilities, something all too rare in today's hip-hop nation." Richard Harrington of The Washington Post enjoyed the record's "more serious and focused lyrical sensibility", explaining, "The raps are generally inventive, clever without being cloying, more proof (if any were needed) that hip-hop innovation isn't just an East-West thang."
The album debuted at number two on the U.S. Billboard 200 chart, and it sold nearly 350,000 copies in its first two weeks of release. It ultimately spent 33 weeks on the Billboard 200 chart. Three singles were released for the album—"Elevators (Me & You)" on July 5, 1996, "ATLiens" in November 1996, and "Jazzy Belle" in April 1997. "Elevators (Me & You)" reached number 12 and spent 20 weeks on the Billboard Hot 100 chart. It was certified gold by the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA) on September 13, 1996, for shipments of 500,000 copies in the United States. "ATLiens" reached number 35 and spent 17 weeks on the Hot 100, and "Jazzy Belle" spent 14 weeks and peaked at number 52 on the Hot 100.
On November 6, the album was certified platinum by the RIAA on November 6, 1996, for shipments of one million copies in the US. By 1998, it had sold over 1.2 million copies. On June 24, 2003, the RIAA certified ATLiens double platinum, having shipped two million copies in the US.
Although ATLiens was well received, it would not be until they released Stankonia (2000) that OutKast would receive significant mainstream popularity. In a retrospective review, Allmusic editor Steve Huey viewed the album as OutKast's "most focused work" and commented that "In addition to the striking musical leap forward, Dre and Big Boi continue to grow as rappers; their flows are getting more tongue-twistingly complex, and their lyrics more free-associative". RapReviews critic Steve Juon recommended it to listeners who "want to be challenged by [their] hip-hop" and wrote of the album's aesthetic:
It's deep. So deep that listening to ATLiens you might feel like drowning, but the smooth vo-cals of Big Boi and the earthy flows of Andre always push you back up to the surface. They are players in the truest sense of the word; not just playing for ends but playing to win in the ultimate battle of life over death, good over bad, and righteousness over evil. Yet, it's not that heavy either. This album is nod your head music, shake your ass music. It makes you think and groove at the same time.
In The Rolling Stone Album Guide (2004), Roni Sarig felt that, strong rapping notwithstanding, the album's music "suffers as the duo make their first attempt at self-producing" and stated, "Although ATLiens promised expanded vistasa with its interstellar motif, the record delivered something of a sophomore slump ... At best, ATLiens is the sound of an ambitious group searching for its voice."
In 1998, the album was selected as one of The Source's "100 Best Rap Albums". In 2000, Exclaim! listed the album on their "100 Records That Rocked 100 Issues of Exclaim!" list. Hip Hop Connection ranked it number six on their list of "The 100 Greatest Rap Albums 1995–2005". Complex ranked the album fifth on their list of "The 50 Greatest Sophomore Albums in Hip-Hop History", its title 15th on "The 50 Best Rap Album Titles Ever", and the title track's beat 91st on "The 100 Greatest Hip-Hop Beats of All Time". Rappers Wiz Khalifa and Dom Kennedy, and DJ Jesse Marco have named ATLiens as one of their favorite albums.
Track listing and samples compiled from album liner notes.
|1.||"You May Die (Intro)"||Joi Gilliam, Myrna Crenshaw, Organized Noize||Organized Noize||1:05|
|2.||"Two Dope Boyz (In a Cadillac)"||André Benjamin, Organized Noize, Antwan Patton||Organized Noize||2:42|
|3.||"ATLiens"||Benjamin, Patton||Earthtone Ideas||3:50|
|4.||"Wheelz of Steel"||Benjamin, Patton||Earthtone Ideas||4:03|
|5.||"Jazzy Belle"||Benjamin, Organized Noize, Patton||Organized Noize||4:11|
|6.||"Elevators (Me & You)"||Benjamin, Patton||Earthtone Ideas||4:25|
|7.||"Ova da Wudz"||Benjamin, Erin Johnson, Patton||Earthtone Ideas||3:47|
|8.||"Babylon"||Andrea Martin, Benjamin, Ivan Doroschuk, Patton||Organized Noize||4:24|
|9.||"Wailin'"||Benjamin, Organized Noize, Patton||Organized Noize||1:58|
|10.||"Mainstream" (featuring Khujo and T-Mo)||Robert Barnett, Benjamin, Willie Knighton, Patton||Earthtone Ideas||5:18|
|11.||"Decatur Psalm" (featuring Big Gipp and Cool Breeze)||Frederick Bell, Benjamin, Cameron Gipp, Organized Noize, Patton||Organized Noize||3:58|
|12.||"Millennium"||Benjamin, Organized Noize, Patton||Organized Noize||3:09|
|13.||"E.T. (Extraterrestrial)"||Benjamin, Johnson, Patton||Earthtone Ideas||3:06|
|14.||"13th Floor/Growing Old"||Benjamin, Marqueze Ethridge, Organized Noize, Patton||Organized Noize||6:50|
|15.||"Elevators (Me & You) [ONP 86 Remix]"||Benjamin, Organized Noize, Patton||Organized Noize||4:37|
- Sample credits
- "You May Die (Intro)" is an interpolation of "Summer in the City" by Quincy Jones.
- "Two Dope Boyz (In a Cadillac)" contains a sample of "D.E.E.P." by OutKast and "Danger, She's A Stranger" by The Five Stairsteps
- "ATLiens" contains a sample of "Around The World" by Attilio Mineo and "So Tired" by The Chambers Brothers
- "Wheelz of Steel" contains a sample of "Focus III" by Focus, "Saturday Night Style" by Mikey Dread
- "Jazzy Belle" contains a sample of "It's Yours" by T La Rock and Jazzy Jay, and "Prelude" by Lamont Dozier
- "Elevators" contains a sample of "Blue Suede Shoes" by Carl Perkins
- "Elevators (Me & You) [ONP 86 Mix]" contains a sample of "Come In Out of the Rain" by Parliament; the original contains SFX from the video game Super Mario Bros.
- "Ova Da Wudz" contain a sample of "Judas" by Society of Soul
- "Babylon" contains a sample of "12 O'Clock" by Vangelis
- "Wailin" contains a sample of "To The Establishment" by Lou Bond
- "Mainstream" contains a sample of "Sesame Street" by Goodie Mob
- "Decatur Psalm" contains a sample of "Cebu" by The Commodores
Compiled from album liner notes.
|Canadian Albums Chart||16|
|German Albums Chart||82|
|U.S. Billboard 200||2|
|U.S. Top R&B/Hip Hop Albums||1|
|Canada (Music Canada)||Gold||50,000^|
|United States (RIAA)||2× Platinum||2,000,000^|
*sales figures based on certification alone
- Nickson (2004), pp. 32–33.
- Black Diaspora (New York) 18: 25. 1997.
- Westhoff, 2011. p. 135
- Sarig, 2007. p. 139
- Sarig, 2007. p. 140
- Nickson, p. 35
- Westhoff, 2011. p. 133
- Strong (2004), p. 1134.
- Johnson et al. Hess (2007), pp. 460–461.
- Nickson (2004), p. 42.
- Nickson (2004), p. 46.
- Leger, Dimitry (January 1997). "Good Vibrations". Spin. Bob Guccione, Jr. Retrieved July 8, 2012.
- "Outkast - ATLiens CD Album". CD Universe. Muze. Retrieved December 19, 2012.
- Jasper, Kenji (October 1996). "Outkast: Home on the Range". Vibe. Vibe Media Group. Retrieved July 8, 2012.
- Wang, 2003. p. 133
- Huey, Steve. "Aquemini - OutKast". AllMusic. Rovi Corporation. Retrieved December 21, 2012.
- Huey, Steve. "ATLiens - OutKast". AllMusic. Rovi Corporation. Retrieved July 10, 2012.
- Comer, Andrea (November 7, 1996). "ALBUM REVIEW OUTKAST ATLIENS" (Transcription of original review at talk page). The Hartford Courant. Richard Graziano. Retrieved December 19, 2012.
- Harrington, Richard (October 11, 1996). "OutKast: `ATLiens' From Hip-Hop Planet" (Transcription of original review at talk page). The Washington Post. Katharine Weymouth. Retrieved December 19, 2012.
- Sarig, 2007. pp. 140–141
- Sarig, 2007. p. 142
- Hess, 2007. pp. 461–462
- Smith, Shawnee (August 31, 1996). "'Elevators' Carries LaFace's OutKast to Top". Billboard: 7, 20. Retrieved December 19, 2012.
- Sarig, 2007. pp. 141–142
- Bradley, 2011. p. 498
- Sarig, 2007. p. 141
- Hess, 2007. p. 461
- Bould, 2009. p. 191
- Murray, Sonia (September 5, 1996). "OUTKAST: ATLiens" (Transcription of original review at talk page). The Atlanta Journal-Constitution. Cox Enterprises. Retrieved December 22, 2012.
- Big V. (2009). "Review: ATLiens". Blender.
- Juon, Steve 'Flash' (January 28, 2003). "OutKast :: ATLiens :: LaFace/Arista Records". RapReviews. Retrieved October 9, 2009.
- Powell, Kevin (October 31, 1996). "ATLiens". Rolling Stone. Jann Wenner. Retrieved October 9, 2009.
- Sarig, Roni et al. (November 2, 2004). Brackett, Nathan; Hoard, Christian, eds. The New Rolling Stone Album Guide (4th ed.). Simon & Schuster. pp. 610–611. ISBN 0-7432-0169-8.
- Scaruffi, Piero. "Outkast". Piero Scaruffi. Retrieved December 19, 2012.
- "OutKast: ATLiens". The Source (New York): 118. October 1996.
- Strong, Martin C. (2006). The Essential Rock Discography: Complete Discographies Listing Every Track Recorded by More Than 1,200 Artists (8th ed.). Canongate U.S. p. 797. ISBN 1-84195-860-3.
- "Outkast - ATLiens User Opinions". Sputnikmusic. Scroll down to Sobhi Youssef staff rating. Retrieved December 19, 2012.
- "Outkast - ATLiens User Opinions". Sputnikmusic. March 24, 2009. Scroll down to Angel staff rating. Retrieved June 27, 2013.
- "Outkast - ATLiens User Opinions". Sputnikmusic. Scroll down to Louis Arp emeritus rating. Retrieved June 27, 2013.
- "Pearl Jam's 'No Code' to Top Albums Chart". San Jose Mercury News. MediaNews Group. September 7, 1996. Retrieved March 5, 2011.
- "The Charts – 'ATLiens' Landing". Los Angeles Times. Eddy Hartenstein. September 15, 1996. Retrieved March 5, 2011.
- "OutKast Album & Song Chart History – Billboard 200". Billboard. Prometheus Global Media. Retrieved March 5, 2011.
- "Searchable Database". Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA). If necessary, click Advanced, then click Format, then select Album, then click SEARCH. Retrieved December 20, 2012.
- "OutKast Album & Song Chart History – Hot 100". Billboard. Prometheus Global Media. Retrieved March 5, 2011.
- Baker, Soren (September 27, 1998). "Record Rack – Four-Star Performers". Los Angeles Times. Eddy Hartenstein. Retrieved March 5, 2011.
- "OutKast". Billboard. Prometheus Global Media. February 2004. p. 56. Retrieved December 22, 2012.
- "100 Best Rap Albums". The Source (100). January 1998.
- "100 Records That Rocked 100 Issues of Exclaim!". Exclaim!. Ian Danzing. October 30, 2000. Archived from the original on September 30, 2003. Retrieved December 21, 2012.
- "The 100 Greatest Rap Albums 1995–2005". Hip Hop Connection (London). 2005.
- Ettelson, Robbie (January 9, 2013). "5. OutKast, ATLiens (1996)". Complex. Complex Media. Retrieved January 10, 2013.
- Gale, Alex (November 21, 2012). "15. OutKast, ATLiens (1996)". Complex. Complex Media. Retrieved December 21, 2012.
- Ettelson, Robbie; Drake, David; Ahmed, Insanul (November 9, 2012). "91. OutKast, 'ATLiens' (1996)". Complex. Complex Media. Retrieved January 10, 2013.
- Ahmed, Insanul (March 29, 2011). "#25. Outkast, ATLiens (1996)". Complex. Complex Media. Retrieved December 20, 2012.
- Diep, Eric (November 20, 2012). "OutKast, ATLiens (1996)". Complex. Complex Media. Retrieved December 20, 2012.
- Block, Justin (November 24, 2012). "OutKast, ATLiens (1996)". Complex. Complex Media. Retrieved December 20, 2012.
- ATLiens (CD liner). OutKast. LaFace Records. 1996. 0015133-02.
- "Results – RPM – Library and Archives – Top Albums/CDs – Outkast". RPM. Retrieved December 21, 2010.
- "Chartverfolgung / Outkast / Longplay". musicline.de (in German). Media Control Charts. Retrieved July 17, 2012.
- "Albums OutKast Album & Song Chart History – R&B/Hip-Hop Albums". Billboard. Prometheus Global Media. Retrieved March 5, 2011.
- "Canadian album certifications – Outkast – ATLiens". Music Canada.
- "American album certifications – Outkast – ATLiens". Recording Industry Association of America. If necessary, click Advanced, then click Format, then select Album, then click SEARCH
- Bould, Mark, ed. (March 18, 2009). The Routledge Companion to Science Fiction. Routledge. ISBN 0-415-45379-8.
- Hess, Mickey, ed. (2007). Icons of Hip Hop: An Encyclopedia of the Movement, Music, and Culture. ABC-CLIO. ISBN 0-313-33903-1.
- Nickson, Chris (September 1, 2004). Hey Ya!: The Unauthorized Biography Of Outkast. Macmillan. ISBN 0-312-33735-3.
- Sarig, Roni, ed. (May 1, 2007). Third Coast: OutKast, Timbaland, and How Hip-Hop Became a Southern Thing. Da Capo Press. ISBN 0-306-81430-7.
- Strong, Martin Charles (October 21, 2004). The Great Rock Discography (7th ed.). Canongate U.S. ISBN 1-84195-615-5.
- Wang, Oliver, ed. (May 1, 2003). Classic Material: The Hip-Hop Album Guide. ECW Press. ISBN 1-55022-561-8.
- Westhoff, Ben (May 1, 2011). Dirty South: OutKast, Lil Wayne, Soulja Boy, and the Southern Rappers Who Reinvented Hip-Hop. Chicago Review Press. ISBN 1-56976-606-1.
- ATLiens at Discogs (list of releases)
- "The Inside Story on Hip-Hop's Outsiders" by the Los Angeles Times