A Civil Action (film)
|A Civil Action|
Theatrical release poster
|Directed by||Steven Zaillian|
|Produced by||Scott Rudin
Henry J. Golas
|Written by||Steven Zaillian|
|Based on||A Civil Action
by Jonathan Harr
William H. Macy
Tony Shalhoub Stephen Fry James Gandolfini
|Music by||Danny Elfman|
|Cinematography||Conrad L. Hall|
|Edited by||Wayne Wahrman|
|Distributed by||Buena Vista Pictures (USA)
United International Pictures (International)
A Civil Action is a 1998 American drama film that was directed by Steven Zaillian, that stars John Travolta (as plaintiff's attorney Jan Schlichtmann) and Robert Duvall, and that is based on the book of the same name by Jonathan Harr. Both the book and the film are based on a true story of a court case about environmental pollution that took place in Woburn, Massachusetts, in the 1980s.
The movie and court case revolve around the issue of trichloroethylene, an industrial solvent, and its contamination of a local aquifer. A lawsuit was filed over industrial operations that appeared to have caused fatal cases of leukemia and cancer, as well as a wide variety of other health problems, among the citizens of the town. The case involved is Anne Anderson, et al., v. Cryovac, Inc., et al.. The first reported decision in the case is at 96 F.R.D. 431 (denial of defendants' motion to dismiss).
Duvall was nominated for an Academy Award for his performance.
Environmental toxins in the city of Woburn, Massachusetts contaminate the area's water supply, and become linked to a number of deaths of neighboring children. Jan Schlichtmann (John Travolta), a cocky and successful Boston attorney who zips around town in his Porsche, and his small firm of personal injury lawyers are asked by Woburn resident Anne Anderson (Kathleen Quinlan) to take legal action against those responsible.
After originally rejecting a seemingly unprofitable case, Jan finds a major environmental issue involving groundwater contamination that has great legal potential and a couple of defendants with deep pockets. The local tanneries could be responsible for several deadly cases of leukemia, but also are the main employers for the area. Jan decides to go forward against two giant corporations (real-life companies Beatrice Foods and W. R. Grace and Company) with links to the tanneries, thinking that the case could possibly earn him millions, as well as enhancing his and his firm's already considerable reputations.
Bringing a class action lawsuit in federal court, Jan represents families who demand a clean-up of the contaminated area and an apology. However, the case develops a life of its own and takes over the lives of Jan and his firm. The lawyers for the tanneries' parent corporations are not easy to intimidate, a judge (John Lithgow) makes a key ruling against the plaintiffs, and soon Jan and his partners find themselves in a position where their professional and financial survival has been staked on the outcome of the case.
Jan stubbornly declines settlement offers, gradually coming to believe that the case is about more than just the money. He allows his pride to take over, making outrageous demands and deciding that he must win at all costs. Pressures take their toll, with Jan and his partners going deeply into debt. After a lengthy trial, the case is dismissed in favor of Beatrice, Jan having turned down an offer of $20 million from Beatrice attorney Jerry Facher (Robert Duvall) while the jury was deliberating. The plaintiffs are forced to accept a settlement with Grace that barely covers the expense involved in trying the case, leaving Jan and his partners broke. The families are deeply disappointed, and Jan's partners dissolve their partnership, effectively breaking up the firm. Jan ends up alone, living in a small apartment and running a small time law practice. He later files for bankruptcy.
In a postscript, a montage of short scenes involving the key characters in the film, combined with on-screen captions, reveals that the Environmental Protection Agency, building on Jan's work on the case, later brought its own enforcement action against the offending companies, forcing them to pay millions to clean up the land and the groundwater. It takes Jan several years to settle his debts, and he now practices environmental law in Boston.
Differences from the book
|This article needs additional citations for verification. (August 2012)|
The plotline has been greatly simplified from the book, e.g. later findings by the Environmental Protection Agency and its potential consequences that might have allowed the plaintiffs another trial against Beatrice, and which did ultimately lead to a conviction of perjury against John Riley, and improper conduct for Mary Ryan, are referred to only briefly in the epilogue.
The characters Charles Nesson, Mark Phillips, Rikki Klieman, Teresa Padro and others have been removed from the film version, as well as the plot points that they contribute.
- John Travolta as Jan Schlichtmann, attorney
- Tony Shalhoub as Kevin Conway, attorney
- William H. Macy as James Gordon, financial adviser
- Željko Ivanek as Bill Crowley, attorney
- Kathleen Quinlan as Anne Anderson
- Mary Mara as Kathy Boyer
- Robert Duvall as Jerry Facher, attorney for Beatrice Foods
- Bruce Norris as William Cheeseman, attorney for W. R. Grace and Company
- Peter Jacobson as Neil Jacobs
- Sydney Pollack as Al Eustis, CEO of W. R. Grace and Company
- Other significant persons
- John Lithgow as Judge Walter J. Skinner
- Dan Hedaya as John Riley, owner of John J. Riley Tannery, a subsidiary of Beatrice Foods
- James Gandolfini as Al Love, W. R. Grace employee
- Stephen Fry as Dr. George Pinder, scientific expert witness
- Howie Carr as Radio Talk Show Host
- Kathy Bates as Bankruptcy Judge (uncredited)
Film review aggregation website Rotten Tomatoes certified the Film as "Fresh" with 60% of reviews favorable, summarizing the consensus as "intelligent and unconventional." Despite receiving mostly positive reception from critics and with Duvall getting an Oscar nomination, A Civil Action was nowhere near as successful as anticipated with audiences. Its domestic gross was a mere $56 million, well below its $75 million budget. During its original theatrical release A Civil Action was competing with other Christmas season blockbusters including Shakespeare in Love, The Prince of Egypt, You've Got Mail, Stepmom and Patch Adams. The film was successful on limited release.
The music score was written by Danny Elfman.
Other songs include:
- "There's a Rainbow 'Round my Shoulder"
- "Hard Workin' Man" (featured on the opening credits)
- Written by Jack Nitzsche, Ry Cooder, Paul Schrader
- Performed by Captain Beefheart
- Courtesy of MCA Records; under license from Universal Music Special Markets
- "Little Drummer Boy"
- "Take Me To The River"
- "Theme from A Summer Place"
- Written by Max Steiner
- Academy Awards, USA
- Blockbuster Entertainment Awards
- Boston Society of Film Critics Awards
- Chicago Film Critics' Association Awards
- Nominated: CFCA Award Best Supporting Actor (Robert Duvall)
- Florida Film Critics' Circle Awards
- Won: FFCC Award Best Supporting Actor (Robert Duvall)
- Golden Globes, USA
- Nominated: Golden Globe Best Performance by an Actor in a Supporting Role in a Motion Picture (Robert Duvall)
- Political Film Society, USA
- Won: PFS Award Human Rights
- Satellite Awards
- Nominated: Golden Satellite Award Best Performance by an Actor in a Supporting Role in a Motion Picture - Drama (Robert Duvall)
- Screen Actors' Guild Awards
- Won: Actor Outstanding Performance by a Male Actor in a Supporting Role (Robert Duvall)
- USC Scripter Award
- Won USC Scripter Award (Jonathan Harr (author), Steven Zaillian (screenwriter))
- Writers Guild of America, USA
- Nominated: WGA Award (Screen) Best Screenplay Based on Material Previously Produced or Published
- Aberjona River
- Anderson v. Cryovac
- Beatrice Foods
- Trial movies
- Erin Brockovich, which was released two years later and dramatized a similar real-life case
- W. R. Grace and Company
|Wikiquote has quotations related to: A Civil Action (film)|
- A Civil Action at the Internet Movie Database
- A Civil Action at Rotten Tomatoes
- A Civil Action at Metacritic
- A Civil Action at Box Office Mojo
- A Civil Action: Before the book and before the film (early newspaper articles by reporter Charles C. Ryan)
- Beyond A Civil Action[dead link] hosted by W. R. Grace & Co.
- In Toxic Tort Litigation, Truth Lies at the Bottom of a Bottomless Pit by Eric Asimow, Picturing Justice: The On-Line Journal of Law & Popular Culture, February 1999
- Anderson v. Beatrice Foods Index and copies of every pleading filed in the Woburn suit, maintained by Florida State University College of Law