|Minerva has been listed as a level-4 vital article in Philosophy. If you can improve it, please do. This article has been rated as Start-Class.|
|This article is of interest to the following WikiProjects:|
- 1 Comments
- 2 is it true?
- 3 Minerva outside of Italy
- 4 Wisdom god/dess cetegory
- 5 Etruscan connection
- 6 Minerva
- 7 reference in culture
- 8 This article contradicts itself
- 9 Authoritative sources
- 10 Trivia
- 11 '... born from the godhead of Jupiter with weapons'
- 12 Etymology
- 13 How true is this statement?
What does 'Duck of Minerva' mean?
I dont know but there is a great politcal science blog with that name
 The Duck of Minerva
is it true?
okay....how do we know if minerva is real? i mean how do we know if any of the immortals are real....if they truly were immortal and truly were gods... where are they now? remember...immortals dont die? so are they in hiding....or just...made up?--184.108.40.206 16:02, 4 November 2005 (UTC)
- It's called Roman Mythology for a reason, friend. 220.127.116.11 17:27, 30 April 2007 (UTC)
- This one will have to repeat sixth grade again next year, I'm afraid. --Wetman 18:29, 30 April 2007 (UTC)
In a letter to John Adams on April 11, 1823, Thomas Jefferson said:
"The day will come when the mystical generation of Jesus, by the supreme being as his father in the womb of a virgin, will be classed with the fable of the generation of Minerva in the brain of Jupiter".
Minerva outside of Italy
Perhaps this should gain a mention - I note my home town of Harlow has one of the only major temples to minerva outside of Italy and since in 1st/2nd century the area was militarily controlled could this be an example of minerva the war goddess being worshiped outside of Rome?Meklin 12:18, 31 January 2006 (UTC)
On Modern Minerva - I corrected the item about Minerva at SUNY Albany. She now stands In the Library and not outside of it. Could not verify that she has a dog at her side so edited out the folklore about the dog paw. Go here for info on Minerva at SUNYA: http://www.albany.edu/main/features/2003/04-03/minerva/minervafacts.htm It would be nice to maybe add a photo of her statue but I don't quite know how to do that yet.Lisapollison 16:41, 9 May 2006 (UTC)
The unfinished temple of Minerva in Quetzaltenengo, Guatemala begun in 1917 is worth a mention.
Wisdom god/dess cetegory
This page was categorized both under Category:Wisdom goddesses and Category:Wisdom gods. Since both are subcategories of Category:Wisdom deities, I removed the "Wisdom gods" category. — Anna Kucsma 20:28, 7 July 2006 (UTC)
Misinformed text: "The name "ninerva" is likely imported from the Etruscans who called her Menrva." There was no "importation": Roman culture developed quite directly out of Etruscan culture. --Wetman 02:09, 26 October 2006 (UTC)
- I believe you but can you please cite your source in the article? (not here) I'll wait to add a citation need tag.Lisapollison 07:18, 31 October 2006 (UTC)
- You needn't "believe" anything: see Etruscan civilization for basic questions like this. --Wetman 10:00, 16 August 2007 (UTC)
Minerva can also be found on the U.S. Medal of Honor. Minerva's profile is on in the Medal of Honor. She is defined as the goddess of wisdom and righteous war.
Minerva is featured on the seal of the State of California Labrat2007 04:46, 26 October 2007 (UTC)
reference in culture
There is a song by the metal band, Deftones, titled Minerva which may or may not have been titled after the Goddess. Someone should research it.--18.104.22.168 22:55, 8 October 2007 (UTC)
Why is Virginia Brown's translation of Boccaccio being used to support statements like this: "Athens had built a statue of Minerva as a temple to the goddess, which had piercing eyes, a helmet on her head, attired with a cuirass and an extremely long spear. It also had a crystal sheild with the figure of the head of Medusa on it." What's happening to this article? I'm taking it off my watchlist. Before I go, I'll suggest the following outline:
- [Concise opening summary]
- Etruscan Menrva [merge from Menrva)
- Cult of Minerva in Rome
- Literary uses of Minerva in Latin
- Minerva in Roman Gaul
- Other provincial appearances
- Minerva in the Renaissance
What doesn't fall under these headings might not be relevant. That won't be my call. --Wetman 22:12, 2 December 2007 (UTC)
This article contradicts itself
The article states the following that "The name "Minerva" is imported from the Etruscans who called her Menrva. " It then goes on to state that " Her name has the Proto-Indo-European mn- stem, linked with memory as in Greek Mnemosyne (μνημοσύνη) and mnestis (μνῆστις: memory, remembrance, recollection). " This sounds very odd. The Etruscan language is not an Indo-European language, which is such a rudimentary fact among linguisticians that I really don't think I need to get a reference to 'substantiate my claims.' Admittedly, the article goes on to say " The Romans could have confused her foreign name with their word from the same stem... " but this sounds like an afterthought added by another user who had also noticed the contradiction.
The whole section would sound more authoritative and syllogistic if the order of the sentences were slightly changed to the following
- (1) The name "Minerva" is imported from the Etruscans who called her Menrva. Extrapolating from her Roman nature, it is assumed that in Etruscan mythology, Menrva was the goddess of wisdom, war, art, schools and commerce. She was the Etruscan counterpart to Greek Athena. Like Athena, Menrva was born from the head of her father, Jupiter (Greek Zeus).
- (2) The Romans could have confused her foreign name with their word from the same stem [In linguistics, this phenomenon is called folk etymology ]. mens meaning "mind", since one of her aspects as goddess pertained also to the intellectual.
- (3) Her name has the Proto-Indo-European mn- stem, linked with memory as in Greek Mnemosyne (μνημοσύνη) and mnestis (μνῆστις: memory, remembrance, recollection).
- #2 is speculative and without a cited analysis for support - More likely the Romans and Etruscians did not make a mistake in attributing wisdom to a goddess of war. Just remember that war tactics and strategics were the first intellectual studies of newly civilized hummans. Conquest was recognized as the primary means by which tribes were joined into civilizations. Since early generals or war leaders usually also later ruled and built the civilizations, or later directly supported the ruler and advised him, they were obviously wise. Rather than modern logic discussing what we now consider odd (wisdom + war) - why not omit explaining that which original Roman texts do not explain.
- Consider striking the entire etymology section as it contributes nothing definitive to the topic. Wikipedia front pages are not the place for what must be classified as intellectualized gossip. Perhaps secondary pages should be added to collect such material since so many people cannot resist adding it.
I'm not sure if there's some WP tag for this, but the cited sources are eyebrow elevators. The first cite is to a scholarly book about gender and colonialism, the second cite is to Hegel. Also unsure if the public domain dictionary incorporated in the article is still trustworthy. I'd love to try to throw some time at this problem myself but I don't have any source materials. JGorton (talk) 14:30, 4 May 2012 (UTC)
- Agree. I was hoping to find an actual encyclopedic article, but found a list instead. ~E of F:22.214.171.124 (talk) 05:50, 2 December 2012 (UTC)
'... born from the godhead of Jupiter with weapons'
The above phrase is meaningless to me, as it will be to other non experts. The source cited is not universally and freely accessible, and Encarta will no longer be produced meaning that it cannot be presumed that this information will be accessible in the future. Can we really say it is any source at all? And so there is little opportunity for the reader to obtain clarification of the phrase. The author, or another expert should edit the article to clarify the meaning of the text, or remove it; terms of art should not be used without explanation, or giving links to an explanatory article. The Godhead disambiguation page does not help clarify the text.
This may or may not tie in with a WP policy; I feel it is self-evident, however.
(See also "Etruscan connextion" above)
The section on Etymology has several problems.
1. Menerva with short e cannot be a "moon goddess" or "she who measures", since both interpretations would imply a long ē.
2. It is disputed whether the Roman adopted an Etruscan goddess or the other way round.
Assuming that the Etruscan name is of Roman origin, an old Italic adjective *men-es-wā from the PIE noun *men-es- (Greek μένος "fureur guerrière"), from the root *men-, would be a nice etymology, except that the Etruscan name with r is already attested in the 6th c. BC (A. Ernout - A. Meillet, Dictionnaire étymologique de la langue latine s. v. Minerva), which would require a Latin change *sv > rv between vowels centuries older than the known change *s > r between vowels (cf. M. de Vaan, Etymological Dictionary of Latin and the Other Italic Languages, s. v. Minerva).
If, on the contrary, the name is of Etruscan origin, of course its etymology cannot be known.
3. Also, I delete the two successive sentences "It is possible that such a goddess was "imported" to both Greece and Italy from beliefs originating in the Near East during the extreme antiquity. The very few extant Lemnian inscriptions suggest that the Etruscans may have originated in Asia Minor, in which case subsequent syncretism between Greek Athena and Italic Minerva may have been all the easier." The second of these sentences, i.e. the mention of the Lemnians, is totally irrelevant here, and the first is gratuitous speculation. The syncretism of Greek and Roman divinities is amply explained by the massive influence of Greek culture on Rome, and it applies no matter whether a given Roman divinity has an Etruscan counterpart or not. There is thus no sense even in linking to Lemnian from the Minerva page. (The link to Lemnian is justified on the Etruscan page, but not on the Minerva page.)
How true is this statement?
"Minerva was worshipped throughout Italy, though in Rome did she dispose of the warlike character of Athena."