Jump to content

Wikipedia:Naming conventions (Ukrainian places): Difference between revisions

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Content deleted Content added
Kiev/Kyiv: changing the headline to one in line with the emphasis in the guidelines
Tag: Reverted
m Undid revision 1156020675 by Mzajac (talk) I find this headline to be even more confusing than the existing one. If you oppose this revert lets discuss it in the talk page: Perhaps we can find a better suited title.
Line 16: Line 16:
* When referring specifically to the [[Autonomous Republic of Crimea]] administrative unit, please write out the full name, e.g. {{xt|Autonomous Republic of Crimea}}, not {{!xt|Crimea}}. The republic does not include the Crimean city of [[Sevastopol]], which is administered separately as a ''city with special status''. If one is referring to the peninsula as a whole, including both the republic and Sevastopol: {{xt|Crimea}}, {{xt|Crimean Peninsula}}, or the use of a definite article with {{xt|the Crimea}} are all acceptable; On usage of either {{xt|Crimea}} or {{xt|the Crimea}} articles should use the variant chosen when they were first written.
* When referring specifically to the [[Autonomous Republic of Crimea]] administrative unit, please write out the full name, e.g. {{xt|Autonomous Republic of Crimea}}, not {{!xt|Crimea}}. The republic does not include the Crimean city of [[Sevastopol]], which is administered separately as a ''city with special status''. If one is referring to the peninsula as a whole, including both the republic and Sevastopol: {{xt|Crimea}}, {{xt|Crimean Peninsula}}, or the use of a definite article with {{xt|the Crimea}} are all acceptable; On usage of either {{xt|Crimea}} or {{xt|the Crimea}} articles should use the variant chosen when they were first written.
*The traditional English usage of the spelling {{!xt|Sebastopol}} is no longer common; write {{xt|Sevastopol}}. For the same reason, {{xt|Poltava}} is to be preferred to {{!xt|Pultava}}.
*The traditional English usage of the spelling {{!xt|Sebastopol}} is no longer common; write {{xt|Sevastopol}}. For the same reason, {{xt|Poltava}} is to be preferred to {{!xt|Pultava}}.
===Kyiv (also Kiev)===
===Kiev/Kyiv===
{{shortcut|WP:KYIV|WP:KIEV}}
{{shortcut|WP:KYIV|WP:KIEV}}
<onlyinclude>{{#ifeq:{{{transcludesection|kievkyiv}}}|kievkyiv|
<onlyinclude>{{#ifeq:{{{transcludesection|kievkyiv}}}|kievkyiv|

Revision as of 08:16, 21 May 2023

This page is intended to help clarify how places in Ukraine should be referred to on Wikipedia. There are the multiple levels of administrative division in Ukraine. This is general guidance; there may be exceptions. Remember to take into account Wikipedia policies and guidelines when applying this guidance, especially the policy on article titles and the guideline on naming conventions for geographic names.

General guidance

Some general principles apply when referring to places in Ukraine on Wikipedia:

First-level divisions

Ukraine is divided into twenty-four regions, called oblasts, one autonomous republic, and two cities with special status.

The conventions that govern the naming of articles on these subdivisions are as follows:

  • Most oblasts are named after their administrative centres, e.g. Donetsk Oblast for the oblast with its centre in the city of Donetsk. Use the Ukrainian national transliteration of oblast names, unless another transliteration is more common, e.g. Luhansk Oblast, not Lugansk Oblast,[note 1] and Odesa Oblast, not Odessa Oblast.[note 2] See the Wikipedia guidelines on the romanisation of Ukrainian for more information on romanisation. Two oblasts have historical names that are not related to their administrative centres. These are Volyn Oblast and Zakarpattia Oblast. For these oblasts, do not use anglicisations that are used to refer to historical regions of the same name, e.g. do not write Lodomeria Oblast or Volhynia Oblast for Volyn Oblast, and do not write Transcarpathian Oblast for Zakarpattia Oblast.
  • When referring specifically to the Autonomous Republic of Crimea administrative unit, please write out the full name, e.g. Autonomous Republic of Crimea, not Crimea. The republic does not include the Crimean city of Sevastopol, which is administered separately as a city with special status. If one is referring to the peninsula as a whole, including both the republic and Sevastopol: Crimea, Crimean Peninsula, or the use of a definite article with the Crimea are all acceptable; On usage of either Crimea or the Crimea articles should use the variant chosen when they were first written.
  • The traditional English usage of the spelling Sebastopol is no longer common; write Sevastopol. For the same reason, Poltava is to be preferred to Pultava.

Kiev/Kyiv

Whilst the standard transliteration of the Ukrainian name of the city with special status also known as Kiev in the English language is Kyiv, this form was less commonly used in English until recently, and "Kiev" was the longstanding title of Wikipedia's article on the subject.[note 3][note 4] A move discussion closed on 16 September 2020 resulted in that article being moved to the title "Kyiv", following a documented shift in usage in English-language media.

An RfC closed on 11 November 2020 discussion established the following guidance for whether to use Kyiv or Kiev in an article:

  • For unambiguously current/ongoing topics (e.g. Kyiv Metro), Kyiv is preferred.
  • For unambiguously historical topics (e.g. Kiev Offensive),[clarification needed] do not change existing content.
  • For any edge cases, or in case of doubt or dispute, an RfC or move request debate is recommended.
  • In all cases, name changes must follow the WP:BRD cycle.

The following rule of thumb for determining what is current or historical was also established:

  • From October 1995 (Resolution of the Ukrainian Commission for Legal Terminology No. 5), Kyiv is presumptively appropriate subject to specifics of the article.
  • From 24 August 1991 (Ukrainian independence), Kyiv is likely to be appropriate, but proceed with caution.

Second-level divisions

Oblasts and the Autonomous Republic of Crimea are divided into districts, called raions. Cities can also be divided into districts, termed "urban districts" or "raions of cities". The conventions that govern the naming of articles on these subdivisions are as follows:

  • Raions are titled "administrative centre Raion", e.g. Rivne Raion for the raion with its centre in Rivne. Use the Ukrainian national transliteration of the name of the administrative centre. See the Wikipedia guidelines on the romanisation of Ukrainian for more information on romanisation. Do not translate raion names, e.g. do not write Miner's Raion for Shakhtarsk Raion. Do not maintain the Ukrainian adjectival suffix, e.g. write Brody Raion for the raion with its centre in Brody, not Brodivskyi Raion. The word raion (Template:Lang-uk) should not be translated when referring to rural districts, e.g. Brody Raion, not Brody District.
  • The names of cities should be transliterated into Latin letters with the Ukrainian national system, e.g. write Donetsk, not Donets'k (BGN/PCGN). Generally, do not use transliterations derived from Russian names for cities of regional significance in Ukraine, e.g. write Lviv, not Lvov. A notable exception where common English usage does not conform to the Ukrainian national transliteration is the name of the city of Chernobyl.[note 5] Do not use the standard Ukrainian transliteration, which is Chornobyl respectively, as this is not in common use.
  • The names of urban districts vary, and are often named after an important feature in a given area. Articles about urban districts should therefore be transliterated with the Ukrainian national system, and should retain the Ukrainian adjectival suffix, e.g. write Zavodskyi District, not Zavod District. Do not translate urban district names, e.g. do not write Factory District for Zavodskyi District. The word raion (Template:Lang-uk) should be translated when referring to urban districts, e.g. Zavodskyi District, not Zavodskyi Raion.

Third-level divisions

Raions are divided into hromadas ("municipalities"), a category that includes cities, villages, and rural and urban-type settlements. In 2015-2020, many hromadas were merged. The names of pre-2015 hromadas and post–2020 hromadas should be transliterated into Latin letters with the Ukrainian national system. Do not use transliterations derived from Russian names for hromadas, e.g. write Dmytrivka, not Dmitrovka.

  • When referring to the administration of an urban-type settlement, write "settlement Council", e.g. Balabyne Council, not Balabyne Settlement Council or Balabyne Town Council.
  • When referring to the administration of a rural settlement, write "settlement Rural Council", e.g. Avhustynivka Rural Council, not Avhustynivka Village Council or Avhustynivka Council.
  • An article about a post–2020 hromada should be titled as follows:
    • For hromadas with their administrative seat in a city, use "Administrative Centre urban hromada", e.g. Ternopil urban hromada for the amalgamated hromada with its seat in Ternopil.
    • For hromadas with their administrative seat in an urban-type settlement, use "Administrative Centre settlement hromada", e.g. Pisochyn settlement hromada.
    • Finally, for hromadas with their administrative seat in a village or other rural locality, use "Administrative Seat rural hromada", e.g. Velyki Hai rural hromada.

Disambiguation

In many cases, multiple settlements or rural districts within Ukraine will have the same name.
In order to disambiguate one settlement with a name from another with the same name, follow these conventions:

  • If there is more than one settlement or district with a certain name in Ukraine, disambiguate by oblast, e.g. write Chornomorske, Odesa Oblast.
  • If there is more than one settlement with a certain name in an oblast, disambiguate by district, e.g. write Hrabove, Shatsk Raion.
  • If there is more than one settlement with a certain name in an oblast, and there is also a settlement of that name in another oblast, disambiguate with both district and oblast, e.g. write Kalynivka, Vasylkiv Raion, Kyiv Oblast.
  • If there is only one settlement of a certain name in Ukraine, but there is a place of the same name outside of Ukraine, disambiguate by country, e.g. write Dzerzhynsk, Ukraine.
  • If there is more than one urban district with a certain name in Ukraine, disambiguate by city, e.g. write Zavodskyi District, Zaporizhzhia.

Even if a name can refer to more than one settlement, it is important to consider whether one of these settlements may be the primary topic. For example, the Wikipedia article on the Russian town of Donetsk is titled Donetsk, Russia, but the article on the much larger and more significant city of Donetsk in Ukraine is titled simply Donetsk. These are only general guidelines. For more specific information on Wikipedia's policy on disambiguation, please go to this page.

Resources

Sources

WP:Naming conventions (geographic names)#Widely accepted name recommends using neutral and reliable sources to help determine the widely accepted name (per WP:COMMONNAME). Of the examples listed there, these are specifically applicable to Ukrainian place names:

Notes

  1. ^ The transliteration Lugansk is derived from the Russian name of the city (Russian: Луга́нск), whereas Luhansk is derived from the Ukrainian name (Template:Lang-uk).
  2. ^ The transliteration Odesa is derived from the Ukrainian name of the city (Template:Lang-uk), whereas Odessa is derived from the Russian name (Russian: Оде́сса).
  3. ^ The transliteration Kiev is derived from the Russian name of the city (Russian: Киев), whereas Kyiv is derived from the Ukrainian name (Template:Lang-uk).
  4. ^ For more information on the history of the Wikipedia debate about the naming of Kyiv/Kiev, see Talk:Kyiv/naming.
  5. ^ The transliteration Chernobyl is derived from the Russian name of the city (Russian: Чернобыль), whereas Chornobyl is derived from the Ukrainian name (Template:Lang-uk).