Jump to content

Wikipedia:WikiProject Mixed martial arts/MMA notability: Difference between revisions

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Content deleted Content added
Current list of notable MMA organizations and promotions: moved Pancrase up to top tier category due to having multiple top 10 ranked fighters, particulary in the male strawweight division (See Fight Matrix MMA Rankings)
Reverted 1 edit by 109.154.182.72 (talk): Must be discussed and agreed upon in the talk page. (TW)
Line 76: Line 76:
| [[April 4]], [[2013]]
| [[April 4]], [[2013]]
| 93
| 93
|-
| [[Pancrase]]
| [[September 21]], [[1993]]
| [[December 1]], [[2012]]
| 266
|-
|-
| [[Shooto]] (Japan only)
| [[Shooto]] (Japan only)
Line 175: Line 170:
| [[May 31]], [[2013]]
| [[May 31]], [[2013]]
| 9
| 9
|-
| [[Pancrase]]
| [[September 21]], [[1993]]
| [[December 1]], [[2012]]
| 266
|-
|-
| [[Shark Fights]]
| [[Shark Fights]]

Revision as of 12:21, 28 June 2013

Template:Essay-project-note MMA notability, also known as WP:MMANOT, is an essay to give some guidance on points to consider when discussing the notability of the subjects of mixed martial arts (MMA) articles. It is a specific supplement to the overall policy of Wikipedia:Notability relating to mixed martial arts and in no way supersedes it.

These guidelines were created by WikiProject Mixed martial arts to help assess the notability of the subjects of articles. Feel free to discuss improvements on the project talk page or the discussion area for this page (WT:MMANOT).

General points

Reliable sourcing is the most important factor. Assertions of notability must be sourced from somewhere other than the individual or organization under discussion (see secondary sources); if referencing a title, the organization which sanctioned the event would be the first stop; if the subject of an article is an author, the publisher or ISBN of the subject's work should be given. A lack of any sources after looking around is a warning sign that an article may not be notable enough for inclusion.

Google and other search engines are a useful tool for finding sources, and may sometimes be persuasive (very high or very low result counts), but is not proof of whether or not something is notable (see WP:Google test). Using quotes around the search ("mixed martial art fighter") will look for only exact matches and using -Wikipedia at the end will remove self references.

Organizations


The methodology used to establish the list of notable organizations is given in the section listing notable organizations.


Criteria supporting notability

  1. Subject of multiple independent articles/documentaries--articles should be from national or international media, not just local coverage.
  2. Promotes a large number of events annually--the more fights it has sanctioned, the more notable.
  3. Has actively been in business for several years - the longer the organization has been around, the more notable.
  4. Large number of well-known and highly ranked fighters.

Criteria supporting deletion

  1. Has only promoted a single event.
  2. Short history as an organization.
  3. Few notable fighters fight in their events.
  4. Fights are no-holds-barred, or rules are much less restrictive than the unified rules of martial arts
  5. Promoted fights are not licensed by state or regional governing bodies.

Fighters

Amateur MMA fighters are not considered notable (unless they can pass WP:GNG under other criteria).

Criteria supporting notability

  1. Subject of multiple independent articles/documentaries--articles should be from national or international media, not just local coverage or press releases from organizations
  2. Fought for the highest title of a top tier MMA organization
  3. Fought at least three (3) fights for top tier MMA organizations

Criteria supporting deletion

  1. Only amateur bouts
  2. Few fights for notable organizations

Individual Events

Individual events are not inherently considered notable because, on the whole, the coverage they receive is routine in nature (consisting of the event announcement, who is going to take part, and the results). To be considered for a standalone article, the article will need to demonstrate the event's lasting effect using references from reliable and diverse sources that are both independent of the subject and show that the duration of coverage lasted beyond the end of the event. Should an event be evaluated as lacking in individual notability, alternatives to deletion (such as merging) should be prefered over outright deletion in accordance with WP:PRESERVE.

Current list of notable MMA organizations and promotions

MEN

This list is subject to change as organizations grow, merge, or go out of business. Changes in this list should be made by consensus after discussion at Wikipedia talk:WikiProject Mixed martial arts/MMA notability. The list is divided into two tiers. The top tier is the highest level. The organizations in this list were determined by looking at independent world rankings of MMA fighters in June, 2010. Active organizations with multiple fighters ranked in the top 10 in any of the 7 weight classes were placed in the top tier. Defunct and other active organizations were placed based on consensus agreement.

Promotion First Event Most Recent Event Total Events
Top Tier - Active
Bellator Fighting Championships April 3, 2009 April 4, 2013 93
Shooto (Japan only) May 18, 1989 June 8, 2013 373
Ultimate Fighting Championship November 12, 1993 June 8, 2013 230
Top Tier - Defunct
Strikeforce May 31, 1997 January 12, 2013 63
Affliction Entertainment July 19, 2008 January 24, 2009 2
Dream (mixed martial arts) March 15, 2008 December 31, 2012 20
Fighting Network Rings (events held between 1995 and 2002)
(Japan, Holland, USA and Russia only)
January 25, 1995 September 23, 2012 126 (64 notable)
Pride Fighting Championships October 11, 1997 April 8, 2007 69
World Extreme Cagefighting June 30, 2001 December 16, 2010 53
World Victory Road March 5, 2008 December 30, 2010 19
Second Tier - Active
BAMMA June 27, 2009 December 1, 2012 11
Cage Warriors July 27, 2002 December 8, 2012 57
Deep (mixed martial arts) January 8, 2001 December 8, 2012 188
Jungle Fight September 13, 2003 November 15, 2012 45
King of the Cage October 30, 1999 December 8, 2012 294
Konfrontacja Sztuk Walki February 27, 2004 December 1, 2012 27
Maximum Fighting Championship March 3, 2001 October 26, 2012 38
M-1 Global November 1, 1997 December 8, 2012 154
ONE Fighting Championship September 3, 2011 May 31, 2013 9
Pancrase September 21, 1993 December 1, 2012 266
Shark Fights October 24, 2008 November 11, 2011 21
Ultimate Challenge MMA December 6, 2008 December 1, 2012 33
Universal Reality Combat Championship November 23, 2002 December 1, 2012 44
World Series of Fighting November 3, 2012 June 14, 2013 3
Second Tier - Defunct
Cage Rage Championships September 7, 2002 September 20, 2008 42
Elite Xtreme Combat February 10, 2007 October 10, 2008 17
Palace Fighting Championship January 18, 2007 May 8, 2009 19
Tachi Palace Fights July 16, 2009 November 12, 2012 16
Last Updated - January 13, 2013

WOMEN

This list is subject to change as organizations grow, merge, or go out of business. Changes in this list should be made by consensus after discussion at Wikipedia talk:WikiProject Mixed martial arts/MMA notability. The list is divided into two tiers. The top tier is the highest level. The organizations in this list were determined by looking at the Unified Women's Mixed Martial Arts world rankings of female MMA fighters in October, 2012. Active organizations with at least three fighters ranked in the top 5 (regardless of weight class) were placed in the top tier. Organizations with two fighters ranked in the top 5 were placed in the second tier.

Promotion First Event Most Recent Event Total Events
Top Tier - Active
Bellator Fighting Championships April 3, 2009 February 21, 2013 88
Invicta Fighting Championships April 8, 2012 January 5 , 2013 4
Ultimate Fighting Championship November 12, 1993 February 23, 2013 230
Top Tier - Defunct
Strikeforce May 31, 1997 January 12, 2013 64
Second Tier - Active
Cage Warriors July 27, 2002 December 8, 2012 57
Jewels (mixed martial arts) November 16, 2008 December 15, 2012 23
Last Updated - February 4, 2013