User:Boynamedsue/sandbox
[The African gangs moral panic, sometimes referred to as the African gangs narrative, was a moral panic relating to the supposed presence of Sudanese-Australian criminal gangs in Melbourne, Australia. The most intense period of the panic occurred over 32 months between March 2016 and November 2018, in the run up to the Victorian state elections of 2018.
The trigger for the panic were clashes between young people and the police at the Moomba Festival of the 12th of March 2016, after which members of the Australian Liberal Party and the Australian media, especially the Herald Sun newspaper, made frequent reference to an "African gang" problem in Melbourne. During the panic, newspapers amplified any criminal activity committed, or alleged to be committed, by people of African origin, routinely publishing and focusing on the ethnicity of alleged offenders. This generated further comments from politicians, pressure on the police to take harsh action against the supposed threat, and led to fear amongst white Australians which was reported by the media, in a cycle which fuelled the moral panic.
Despite the salience of this discourse in the media, police and community organisations denied the existence of criminal gangs among the Sudanese-Australian community, and statistics showed that crime by Sudanese-Australian youth constituted only a tiny fraction of offences in Victoria. For this reason, media studies scholars view the African gangs narrative as an example of a racialised moral panic.
The media and political focus on Sudanese-Australians and crime in Melbourne declined sharply after the 2018 elections, but the effects of negative stereotyping, over-policing and racialisation of crime are still felt by the Sudanese community, and Black people generally, in Melbourne and across Australia. Melburnians of Sudanese origin report feeling distrust of the police and nervousness of gathering in public for fear of harassment by law enforcement.
History
Before 2016
Australia has a history of moral panics regarding immigrant criminality, specifically related to real or supposed "gangs" from communities involved in recent waves of immigration.[1][2] The folk devil in these panics has varied according to time and location;[2][1] in modern Sydney, Muslim and Arab immigrants have taken over from the Italian and Greek communities that were the cause of concern in the 1970s and 1980s, whereas in Melbourne and Perth discourse around gangs has centred on Asian groups.[1]
From the mid 1990s to 2011, 27,679 people who were born in Sudan migrated to Australia, mostly as refugees, with the peak years of settlement between 2002 and 2006.[3] This wave of African migration led to the creation of gang stereotypes similar to those which had been used to characterise previous newly-arrived migrant communities.[1][2]
The murder of Liep Gony and the events of 2007
In 2007, Liep Gony, a 19-year-old refugee who had migrated from Sudan in 1999, was badly beaten in the Melbourne suburb of Noble Park, dying from his injuries 24 hours later.[4] Despite the fact it later emerged that Gony had been murdered by white assailants, the immediate response to Gony's murder from politicians and the press was to frame it as an example of "African gang" violence.[3][5][2]
Soon after the murder, Kevin Andrews, the minster for immigration declared that "some groups of immigrants aren't settling and adjusting into the Australian life as quickly as we would hope."[4] Initial press reports took the position that the murder was an example of "ethnic gang violence", basing their stories on off-the-record comments from anonymous police officers and local residents, with Andrews stating that officers had told him Melbourne had "a serious Sudanese gang problem."[4] However, at the time of the murder, Melbourne Police's Multicultural Liaison officer told The Australian that police often mistook innocent groups of Black youths for gangs.[4]
When it became clear that Gony had been murdered by two white men, Andrews refused to apologise for his comments on Sudanese-Australians,[6] stating "I’m not proposing to apologise for saying what people are concerned about."[4] Minister Andrews was also reticent to comment on the white attackers who beat another Sudanese man in an openly racist attack the day after Gony's funeral, which sociologist Joel Windle contrasts with his immediate condemnation of an attack by Sudanese youths on a policeman as "un-Australian".[4] Clashes between Sudanese youth and police occurred on several occasions between September and December, with police accounts of the violence in one alleged "riot" contradicted by witnesses.[4] In the aftermath of the events, the Liberal party presented the murder and assaults in Melbourne as examples of a "failure of integration", and cited them as justification for a reduction in the percentage of humanitarian visas given to Africans from 70% to 30%.[4][3]
In his analysis of reporting on the events around Kory's murder, Windle highlights the process of racialisation by which the Australian and the Herald Sun universally labelled non-white individuals with ethnic markers when discussing them, contrasting this with the assumed default de-racialised status of whiteness when discussing anonymous "locals".[4] He also notes the frequent negative use of language in association with these ethnic markers, especially around groups of young people.[4]
| Group | Racial attributes | Collective attributes | Age attributes | Migration attributes | Locality | Moral quality |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Racialised African refugees | African, North African, Of African descent, Black, Sudanese, Sudanese-born | a mob, packs, a gang, gangs, a group, community | youth(s), kids, children, under-age, teenagers, teens, juvenile | refugees, immigrants, migrants | residents | delinquent, lawless, thugs, offenders |
| De-racialised "local" sources | White, Caucasian, Non-African | the community, the people | [age]'-year-old | long-term Australians, locally-born | locals, residents, long-time residents, home-grown neighbours, local businesses |
Two years later, in Adelaide, Alex Ngong Akok, a young man of African background, was murdered, with the attack again presented by the media in terms which criminalised the victim.[1][2] Despite the attack being committed by white youths, the local press published details of court charges he was facing, speculated that there was a gang link and suggested that his murder constituted "retaliation".[1]
The height of the panic (2016-2018)
The immediate trigger for the moral panic around "gangs" in Melbourne was a "riot" at the Moomba Festival in 2016.[2][6][5] In the two years prior to the festival, there were a total of four articles published in Melbourne's two most popular newspapers, The Age and the Herald Sun which mentioned the words Sudanese and gang, whereas in the two years which followed it there were 130.[6] Similarly, in the two-year-period preceding the festival, there were only two mentions of the supposed "Apex Gang", which would become a prominent feature of racialised discourse on crime, neither of them connecting it to a specific ethnicity.[6]
The panic fizzled out following the Labor victory in the Victorian State Election of 2018,[7] after which the media and Liberal Party politicians stopped aggressively pushing the African gangs narrative.[8] The period of intense media and political attention on Melbourne's Sudanese community lasted around 32 months.[8]
The Moomba Festival "riot" and the "Apex Gang"
On the night of 12th of March 2016, clashes broke out at Melbourne's annual Moomba Festival, a family orientated festival held in central Melbourne.[7][9] Reports on the evening suggested that brawls had occurred involving young people largely from African-Australian and Pacific-Islander backgrounds.[7][8][5] Several incidents of vandalism and disorder occurred at the festival,[5] with news reports suggesting that the fights had broken out between two separate groups of young people.[8] There were also reports, based on accounts by festival-goers, of young men of Sudanese-Australian origin picking fights with other festival-goers.[7] The disturbances culminated in members of the police employing capsicum spray to disperse a group of young men and boys in Federation Square.[7][6][5] Following the events, the Chief Commissioner of Victoria Police stated that that the heavy police presence may have caused an escalation in the violence,[7] interviews with Sudanese-Australians who attended the festival also suggest this to be the case.[6] Videos of the events quickly emerged and were published on Australian media websites, often embedded in articles which made reference to "ethnic gangs", they typically showed dark-skinned individuals who outnumber police and appear to be acting in a threatening manner.[10]
In the days which followed the clashes at Moomba, a media narrative emerged which placed the blame for the events on a group it identified as the "Apex Gang", which supposedly consisted principally of Sudanese-Australians.[5] Editorials and news articles regarding "Apex" first appeared in the Herald Sun, and the story was then picked up by local news channels and other newspapers.[6] Centre-left Melbourne paper The Age initially echoed the coverage of the Herald Sun, however, within a few weeks it ceased to include ethnic descriptors in its coverage and in time began to question aspects of the narrative.[6] The narratives also suggested a "surge in crime rates" was affecting Melbourne due to the activities of this gang.[5] These sensationalistic stories were often translated into Chinese and spread among Melbourne's Chinese student community on WeChat channels, creating panic and widespread fear of people of African origin.[9]
The Herald Sun's reports that the "riot" had been caused by "armed teenage street gangs" and the existence of the supposed Sudanese "Apex Gang" was rejected by local police leaders.[8] A survey of the local Sudanese population also suggest that the gang did not exist,[6] seemingly being little more than a social media phenomenon symbolising an anti-social attitude or lifestyle.[11] Sudanese-residents of Melbourne interviewed between 2017-2019 state violence at Moomba 2016 was heavily exaggerated, and that press attention was immediately focussed on people of African origin, despite the participation of people of various ethnicities, due to racism in the Austrlaian media and population/[6] Lee et al describe 'Apex" as "a media confected crime gang" and suggest that the name had initially covered an "unstructured group of young people" from various ethnic backgrounds but had come to serve as a stand in for Sudanese Australians.[7]
Media escalation of the panic (2016-2017)
In the months following the disorder at the 2016 Moomba Festival, the press linked the "Apex Gang" to a string of carjackings, assaults and burglaries.[7] Despite police, experts and even alleged gang members denying the existence of gangs in Melbourne, "Apex" had become a folk devil representing what Lee et al describe as "a broader crime threat that drew on xenophobic discourses that extended to border protection, anti-immigration fears, and a fear of terrorism."[7] "Apex" was now a racialised term by which crime could be linked to the Sudanese community.[7]
The African gangs narrative was picked up by broadcast media, which employed the testimony of crime victims when available as well a the use of CCTV footage.[12] Crimes with no clear link to gangs were often framed within the racialised narrative of the "Apex gang", as evidence of a supposedly out of control crime problem.[12] The Nine Network's A Current Affair broadcast a report in July suggesting that Melburnians had been forced to arm themselves with baseball bats due to a series of home invasions.[12] The programme suggested that the criminal justice system in the city had failed.[12]
At the 2017 Moomba Festival, 53 arrests were made and the press focussed its discussion on the so-called Apex gang.[7] However, 14 of these arrests were for being drunk and disorderly, and the Melbourne police stated that those arrested came from all parts of Melbourne and that the offences were not gang or race related.[7] Soon after the festival, the police commissioner stated that the "Apex Gang" did not currently exist, and when it had, it was not an ethnically based group.[7]
In May of 2017, A Current Affair broadcast an episode entitled "Apex Vigilante" which again suggested that victims of crime had been forced into vigilantism due to the supposed collapse of law and order in Melbourne.[12]
In Spring of 2017, Federal Member of Parliament Jason Wood, who was chair of the Joint Standing Committee on Migration, published an article in the Herald Sun based on crime statistics relating to the Sudanese community and stating, "With South Sudanese hugely over represented in violent crimes in Victoria, the protection of all those living in Melbourne and Australia must come first."[6]
Political controversy and the Victorian state election (Late 2017-2018)
Political controversy around supposed "African gangs" would play a prominent role in the lead up to the Victorian elections of 2018.[8] Both politicians and media made frequent use of the adjectives "African" and "Sudanese" in connection with crime and violence during this period.[2] Research with journalists working on crime stories also report a strong push from media organisations for the inclusion of an "African crime" angle in news stories at this time.[8]
In December 2017, the Liberal-led Australian Parliamentary Joint Standing Committee on Migration published a report which referred to an increase in "gang activity" and falsely suggested that Sudanese Australians were responsible for 1.4% of crime in Victoria.[6] The report used the term "gangs" throughout, despite the Victorian police position that no such gangs existed.[6] Following this publication, Jason Woods was quoted in The Australian saying, "A lot of migrants have no understanding of the law. I was told by South Sudanese people that ... breaking into someone’s house and stealing a car is not a big deal." This statement was followed by a series of sensationalist articles in the Herald Sun on alleged incidents which purportedly involved Sudanese youth.[6] The reports regularly focussed on the ethnicity of the alleged offender, specifically using the terms "African appearance" and "gang" as well as "feral thugs".[6]
The same month, a series of events were portrayed in the press as constituting "An African Crime Wave", especially in titles from the Newscorp stable.[7] These incidents included a street brawl, a party at an Airbnb which led to property damage, and the alleged assault of a police officer making an arrest; all of which were reported as being the work of people "of African appearance".[7] The coverage of these events in The Herald Sun and the Australian edition of the Daily Mail presented the brawl in populist racial terms, and incited a response from politicians.[7] The then Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull, Victorian Conservative Greg Hunt and Federal Immigration Minister Peter Dutton all gave statements relating to the supposed "gang problem" in Victoria, with Dutton stating:
"People are scared to go out to restaurants of a nighttime because they’re followed home by these gangs, home invasion and cars are stolen… [Politicians] need to call it for what it is, of course it’s African gang violence.''[7] [12]
In addition to this Dutton called for deportations of lawbreakers and spread the blame to the wider community by suggesting that parents of such offenders "don't belong in Australian society".[7] Dutton's comments on Melburnians being frightened to go out at night met with widespread mockery on social medi from members of the Sudanese community, and were contradicted by Victorian Labor politicians, Victoria Police Commissioner Graham Ashton and members of the Victorian public.[6]
Turnbull offered support for Dutton, suggesting that the Victorian Premier, Daniel Andrews lacked the will to "tackle the gang problem on the streets of Melbourne".[12] This view was echoed by Greg Hunt, the Federal Minister for Health, who stated: "We know that African gang crime in some areas is clearly out of control. [...] The failure is not police, but the Premier."[2] Former Prime Minister Tony Abbott challenged the Victorian government's denials of the existence of African gangs in Melbourne in a 2018 radio interview.[2]
In January 2018, Channel 7 aired an interview with leaser of the neo-fascist United Patriots Front, Blair Cottrell.[13] The report showed a meeting of the True Blue Crew far-right vigilante group with members of the United Patriots Front, relayed their concerns about "gang violence committed by young African men" and stated the organisations had "come together to help average Australians deal with what they are calling an immigrant crime crisis."[13]
At various points in 2018, A Current Affair produced reports suggesting Melbourne police were not being allowed to deal with "African gang crime", culminating in a report entitled "Cops gone soft?".[12] This programme contained interviews with former senior police officers who suggested the rank and file officers were not dealing with young criminals because they were scared of repercussions from management.[12]
This political discourse coupling questions of race and immigration led to an increase in anti-immigration posting on social media and web-based media articles.[7] It also stimulated the re-emergence of far-right groups such as Reclaim Australia, which shifted its focus from Muslims to supposed African Gangs.[7] The press and politicians frequently apportioned parental communal blame for the supposed crime wave, and suggested that the root of the problem was a failure of integration on the part of the Sudanese.[7]
The Liberal Party's campaign for the Victorian elections held on 24th November 2018 focussed heavily on law and order,[8][10] in what Weng and Mansouri described as a "fear campaign".[10] However, this met with limited success, as the election resulted in a victory for the incumbent Labor administration.[7] Following the election, the media attention paid to questions related to "African gangs" and supposed immigrant crime reduced drastically.[8]
Analysis of the moral panic
The term Moral panic was popularised by sociologist Stanley Cohen in the 1970s.[2] It describes the process by which the media use sensational headlines and melodramatic language to exaggerate events and actors, creating fear of supposed threats to the safety of society and othering groups which are identified as source of this threat.[2] Cohen specifically applied the term to the interplay of crime reporting and social reaction in the UK.[2] He states that a moral panic will emerge when "a condition, episode, person or group of persons emerges to become defined as a threat to societal values and interests; its nature is presented in a stylized and stereotypical fashion by the mass media,” and this media focus is echoed by politicians and experts.[2] These targeted groups are referred to by Cohen as folk devils. He notes that use the concept of a moral panic does not require the problem to be inexistent, merely exaggerated, usually in a way which is conditioned by the ideology of the dominant sector of society.[2]
Academic interpretations of the African gangs panic
The political and media storm around so-called African gangs of 2016-2018 is described by academics as an example of a moral panic.
Tebeje Molla notes that while racialised moral panics around race are not unusual around the world, the intensity of the panic around "African Gangs" in Melbourne was exceptional.[2] However, Molla also notes that, unlike in classic moral panics, where "experts" play a key role in the escalation of the panic, the police, statistical bodies and local authorities in Victoria resisted the narrative and denied the existence of a gang problem.[2]
Lee and colleagues state that the punitive narratives in the media and politics tying Sudanese young people to crime contained elements of a moral panic, there was more to them than just structural factors.[7] They argue that offending behaviour can stem from members of marginalised communities taking pleasure in transgressive actions.[7] They also indicate that evidence from interviews suggests that the media attention and scapegoating incited Sudanese youth to take part in antisocial activities, and that the widespread coverage of the supposed "Apex gang" may actually have caused youths to create a real gang of that name.[7]
Analysis of crime figures
While media reports in the 2016-208 focused heavily on crimes committed by people of African origin, in reality figures released by the Crime Statistics Agency in 2018 showed that they were responsible for only 1% of crimes in Victoria.[2][11] This was in excess of their share of the population, which was 0.14%, but this is not unusual given the fact that most crimes are committed by people between 16-24 years of age, and the Sudanese Australian population is over-represented in that cohort.[11] XXXX also points out the link between offending and social deprivation, which affects Sudanese-Australians disproportionately.
A great deal of media attention was directed to the offence of aggravated burglary. This offence did have a significant over-representation of Sudanese-Australians, but again the total only represented 4.8%, with the vast majority of offences being committed by White Australians.[7]
Molla states that, despite the "hyperbolic reporting", crime rates were actually lower in Victoria than in other states.[2] Furthermore, in terms of youth crime, the number of youth offenders in Victoria (population 6,526,400)[14] was 8,182, in New South Wales (population 8,046,100)[14] it was 17,972, while in Queensland (population 5,052,800)[14] it was 11,699.[2]
Lee and colleagues write that between 2009 and 2019, youth crime in Victoria decreased by 34.9%.[7] This meant that the state was the focus of a panic about youth crime during a period when the actual youth crime rate was falling drastically.[7]
Causes of the panic
Racism
Anxiety about crime
The role of police
Political considerations
The media
Effects of the panic on Black Australians
References
- ^ a b c d e f White, Rob (2012). Youth Gangs, Violence and Social Respect: Exploring the Nature of Provocations and Punch-Ups. Basingstoke: Springer. p. 49.
- ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s Tebeje, Molla (2021). "Racial moral panic and African youth in Australia". International Journal of Intercultural Relations (84): 95-106. Retrieved 14 June 2024.
- ^ a b c Baak, Melanie (2011). "Murder, community talk and belonging: an exploration of Sudanese community responses to murder in Australia". African Identities. 9 (4): 417-434.
- ^ a b c d e f g h i j k Windle, Joel (2008). "The racialisation of African youth in Australia". Social Identities: Journal for the Study of Race, Nation and Cultur. 14 (5): 553-566. Retrieved 14 June 2024.
- ^ a b c d e f g Benier, Kathryn; Wickes, Rebecca; Moran, Clare (2020). "'African gangs' in Australia: Perceptions of race and crime in urban neighbourhoods". Australian & New Zealand Journal of Criminology. 54 (2): 1-19. Retrieved 14 June 2024.
- ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p Benier, Kathryn; Blaustein, Jarrett; Johns, Diana; Maher, Sarah. "'Don't drag me into this' Growing up South Sudanese in Victoria after the 2016 Moomba 'riot'" (PDF). Centre for Multicultural Youth. Monash University. Retrieved 15 June 2024.
- ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s t u v w x y z aa ab Lee, Murray; Halsey, Mark; Flynn, Asher (2021). ""Streets of menace": Constructing and deconstructing youth "gangs" in two Australian cities". OÑATI SOCIO-LEGAL SERIES. 11 (5): 1114-1132. Retrieved 15 June 2024.
- ^ a b c d e f g h i Kounmouris, Gregory; Blaustein, Jarrett (2021). "Reporting 'African gangs': Theorising journalistic practice during a multi-mediated moral panic". Crime, Media, Culture. 18 (1): 105-125. Retrieved 15 June 2024.
- ^ a b Martin, Fran (2020). "Iphones and "African gangs": everyday racism and ethno-transnational media in Melbourne's Chinese student world". Ethnic and Racial Studies. 43 (5). Retrieved 16 June 2024.
- ^ a b c Weng, Enqi; Mansouri, Fethi (2021). "'Swamped by Muslims' and facing an 'African gang' problem: racialized and religious media representations in Australia". Continuum. 35 (3): 468-486. Retrieved 16 June 2024.
- ^ a b c Wahlquist, Calla (2 Jan 2018). "Is Melbourne in the grip of African crime gangs? The facts behind the lurid headlines". The Guardian. Retrieved 16 June 2024.
- ^ a b c d e f g h i Gaffey, John (2019). "Melbourne's 'African gangs' and media narratives". Salus. 7 (2): 68-84. Retrieved 19 June 2024.
- ^ a b Majavu, Mandisi (2018). "The 'African gangs' narrative: associating Blackness with criminality and other anti-Black racist tropes in Australia". African and Black Diaspora: An International Journal. 13 (1): 27–39. Retrieved 23 June 2024.
- ^ a b c "Australian Demographic Statistics, Dec 2018". Australian Government. Retrieved 29 June 2024.