Jump to content

Wikipedia:WikiProject Mammals

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This is an old revision of this page, as edited by Marskell (talk | contribs) at 09:47, 12 June 2007 (add section on our big debate). The present address (URL) is a permanent link to this revision, which may differ significantly from the current revision.

This page is not so much a project policy page as a means of getting a handle on how much of the mammals Wikipedia covers. Right now policy is covered by Grandmother project Wikipedia:WikiProject Tree of Life, sister project Wikipedia:WikiProject Birds, and children projects Wikipedia:WikiProject Primates, Wikipedia:WikiProject Cetaceans,Wikipedia:WikiProject Dog breeds and Wikipedia:WikiProject Cats.

Classification taken from the Mammal article which in turn was taken from the classic classification by Simpson (no end of controversy possible here).

Order, Size, Depth of coverage, Appropiateness of coverage (requires an expert in the field to judge, I guess)

Participants

Use a taxobox

Elephant
African Bush (Savannah) Elephant in Kenya.
Scientific classification
Kingdom:
Phylum:
Subphylum:
Class:
Order:
Family:
Elephantidae

Gray, 1821
Genera and Species

In general, mammal entries should have taxobox. This is something we have inherited from the Tree of Life WikiProject, and is standard anyway. If you dont know how to do a taxobox than leave a message on this talk page or the articles talk page.

Capitalization

The issue of the capitalization of the common names of mammal species is unresolved on Wikipedia and our pages are inconsistent. A large majority of reliable sources do not capitalize and thus there is a strong descriptive argument against doing so. Capitalization will often not "feel" right for editors for this reason. Conversely, because species names are proper nouns there is also a strong argument in favour of capitalization. Upper case usage is well-established with Aves species, for example. There are actually three possibilities in capitalizing:

  1. Never capitalize.
  2. Always capitalize.
  3. Capitalize when the species itself is referred to, as this is proper noun usage, but not where the phraseology indicates a common noun. Thus: "The Tiger is a carnivore" but "three tigers were observed in the conservation area."

The third is most correct orthographically, but it is also the most difficult to maintain. In the absence of consensus:

  • Respect the original or primary authors; do not up and change something without notification, as you may be reverted.
  • The form chosen should be used consistently across an article.


Talk pages

Place {{MaTalk}} at the top of an article's talk page. This will help direct editors to this page for guidance. As monotreme's and marsupial's already have there own template, this can be placed alongside the other or not at all.

Articles needing attention