In Modern Standard Chinese usage, chi 螭 "hornless dragon" occurs in words such as:
- chilong 螭龍 (with "dragon") "hornless dragon"
- chiniu 螭紐 (with "handle; knob") "carved dragon handle (esp. on cups)"
- chiwen 螭吻 (with "mouth; lips") "a roof ornament shaped like a dragon", compare the homophonous variant 鴟吻 (with "owl; hawk")
- chishou 螭首 or chitou 螭頭 (both with "head") "an architectural adornment; gargoyle"
- panchiwen 蟠螭文 (with "coiled" and "pattern") "carved patterns of sinuous dragons (esp. on pillars/bronzes)"
- chibi 螭陛 (with "palace steps") "steps of the imperial palace; the Emperor"
The Chinese character 螭 for chi "hornless dragon" combines the "bug radical" 虫 (typically signifying words for insect, reptiles, and dragons, e.g., shen 蜃) with a phonetic of chi or li 离 "mountain demon; leave". This phonetic element 离 is pronounced either chi when used for chi 螭 "demon; dragon" or li when used for li 離 ("with the "bird radical" 隹) "leave; part from; ☲ The Clinging bagua". The (ca. 3rd century BCE) Seal script character for 螭, which is the earliest known writing, has the same radical-phonetic combination.
This chi 螭 "hornless dragon" is also a variant Chinese character for chi 魑 (differentiated with the "ghost radical" 鬼) "mountain demon", which only occurs in the compound chimei 魑魅 "mountain and forest demons; evil spirits; goblins". Chimei 魑魅 is sometimes written 螭魅 or 螭鬽 with chi 螭. Note the "ghost radical" in the mei characters 魅 (with a phonetic of wei 未) and 鬽 (with the "hair radical" 彡 representing the demon's hair, cf. chi 螭's variant 彲).
- chi 离: "a mountain spirit and wild beast, [the pictograph] comes from its birdlike head, legs, and tail." 山神獸也从禽頭从厹从屮。
- chi 螭: "[a creature] like a dragon and yellow, in the north, they call it dilou, [the graph] comes from the "bug radical" and a chi 离 phonetic, or, a hornless [dragon] is called chi." 若龍而黃北方謂之地螻从虫离聲或云無角曰螭。
- chi 魑: "a kind of ghost/demon, [the ideograph] comes from the "ghost radical" and chi 离 "mountain demon radical", which is also the phonetic." 鬼屬从鬼从离离亦聲。
This dilou 地螻 "earth cricket" compares with the tulou 土螻 "earth cricket," which the Shanhaijing (2, tr. Birrell 2000:23) mentions on 昆侖邱 ("Kunlun Mound"), "There is an animal here [Mound of Offspringline] which looks like a ram, but has four horns. Its name is the earth-cricket. It devours humans."
Boodberg (1935, 1979:165-7) proposed that chi 螭 or 魑 etymologically descends frolm a Sino-Tibetan root *brong-bri "wild oxen", from *brong "wild bull" and *bri or *brien "wild cow". He described this root as a "semantic atom, a referential complex with the meaning of 'wild' → 'wild animal' → 'couple'", and applied this etymon to many male and female animal couples, including *lywung < *blwong 龍 "male dragon" and *t'ia 魑 "female dragon". Compare how Yin and Yang cosmology dichotomized rainbow-dragons between Yang/male hong 虹 "primary rainbow" and Yin/female ni 蜺 "secondary rainbow". Benedict (1976:190) noted how Bernhard Karlgren (1957:26) inconsistently reconstructed Old Chinese *t'lia for chi 离 "a mountain demon", 魑 "a kind of demon", and 螭 "a kind of dragon; a demon"; but *lia for all the other words in this phonetic series (e.g., li 漓 "drip", li 縭 "ornamental scarf"). Benedict reconstructed Old Chinese *xlia 魑 "a mountain demon", deriving from a Proto-Tibeto-Burman *sri(-n) "demon" root, also evident in Tibetan sri "a species of devil or demon; a vampire", srin-po "demons", and Lushai hri < *sri "the spirit believed to cause sickness". He additionally hypothesized the *xlia 离 phonetic was cognate with shen < *[ly]yěn 神 "spirit; god" from Proto-Tibeto-Burman *[s-l]-rin < *[s-]rin.
Matisoff (1985:63) analyzes Benedict's *sri(-n) "demon" root as *s-r-i-n, and links Chinese *xlia 魑 with another Tibetan cognate hdre-srin "goblins and demons" (from hdre "goblin; demon; evil spirit").
Schuessler (2007:186) reconstructed Old Chinese *rhai for chi 离, 魑, and 螭 "mountain demon", and proposed a Sino-Tibetan etymology comparable with Tibetan ’dre < ɴdre "goblin; demon, evil spirit" and gre-bo "species of demon", Tangkhul rai "unclean spirit", Bodo ráj "devil", and possibly Porto-Kam–Sui la:l "devil; ghost" borrowed from Chinese.
Chinese classic texts use chi 螭 to mean both "a hornless dragon" and "a mountain demon". The following discussion focuses upon earliest recorded usages in pre-Han texts, some of which have uncertain dates of compilation.
The (ca. 239 BCE) Lüshi Chunqiu quotes Confucius comparing long 龍 "dragons", chi 螭 "hornless dragons", and yu 魚 "fish".
The dragon eats and swims in clear water; the one-footed dragon eats in clean water but swims in muddy water; fish eat and swim in muddy water. Now, I have not ascended to the level of a dragon but I have not descended to that of fish. I am perhaps a one-footed dragon!" (舉難, tr. Knoblock and Riegel 2000:505)
The (ca. 2nd century CE) Chuci uses chi 螭 five times, which is more than any other Chinese classic. Two contexts mention xuanchi 玄螭 "dark/black hornless-dragon"; (遠遊, tr. Hawkes 1985:198) "They lined water monsters up to join them in the dance"; and (思忠, tr. Hawkes 1985:275) , "Driving black dragons, I travel northwards." Another mentions qingqiu 青虯 "green horned-dragons" and 白螭 "white hornless-dragons"; (涉江, tr. Hawkes 1985:160) "With a team of azure dragons, white serpents in the traces." Two final contexts mention chi 螭 with long 龍 "dragons"; one describes a team of four dragons, (河伯, tr. Hawkes 1985:114) "I ride a water chariot with a canopy of lotus; Two dragons draw it, between two water-serpents"; the other uses the compound chilong 螭龍 "hornless dragon", (大招, tr. Hawkes 1985:233), "And water dragons swim side by side, swiftly darting above and below."
The (ca. 139 BCE) Huainanzi "Peering into the Obscure" chapter (覽冥訓) mentions chichi 赤螭 "red hornless-dragon" and baichi 白螭 "white hornless-dragon". The former occurs with qingqiu 青虯 "green horned-dragon"; (tr. Le Blanc 1987:144) "When the red hornless dragon and the green horned dragon roamed the land of Chi 冀, the sky was limpid and the earth undisturbed." The latter occurs with benshe 奔蛇 "fast snake", (tr. Le Blanc 1987:162), the chariot of Fu Xi and Nüwa was "preceded by white serpents and followed by speeding snakes."
The (ca. 100 BCE) Shiji "Records of the Grand Historian" biography of Sima Xiangru includes two of his fu 賦 poems (tr. Watson 1993:2:309, 312) that mention chichi 赤螭 "red hornless dragons." "The Shanglin Park" 上林賦 mentions them with jiaolong 蛟龍, "Here horned dragons and red hornless dragons"; "Sir Fantasy" 子虛賦 mentions them with qingqiu 青虯, "red hornless dragons and green horned dragons."
The above texts describe black, white, and red chi 螭 "hornless dragons", which contradicts the Shuowen Jiezi "like a dragon and yellow" definition. However, a possible explanation might be found in the Hanshu (揚雄傳) commentary of Wei Zhao, which describes the chi 螭 demon as "resembling a tiger with scales".
Groot (1910:5:1141-2) provides a picture of a sepulchral stone tablet decorated with a chi and the Gujin Tushu Jicheng illustration of this hornless dragon.
The chi 螭 "dragon" variant for chimei 螭魅 or 魑魅 "demon; evil spirit" only occurs as a bound morpheme in chimei, but mei 魅 occurs in other expressions such as meili 魅力 (with "power") "enchantment; fascination; charm". Both modern Chinese and Japanese normally use "ghost radical" 鬼 characters to write chimei or chimi 魑魅 and wangliang or mōryō 魍魎, but these were not regularly used in classical texts. The (111 CE) Hanshu first wrote chimei as 魑魅, but earlier texts (e.g., Zuozhuan below, and [91 BCE] Shiji) wrote it as 螭魅, with the "hornless dragon" variant. The (ca. 4th century BCE Guoyu) first wrote wangliang as 魍魎, but more classics (e.g., Shuoyuan, Zhuangzi, Huainanzi, and Chuci) phonetically wrote it as 罔兩, without the "ghost radical".
Chimei 螭魅 is joined with wangliang in the expression chimei-wangliang 魑魅魍魎 "demons and monsters; evil spirits". Since some commentators differentiate between chimei "demons of the mountains and forests" and wangliang "demons of the rivers and marshes", notes Carr (1990:137), chimei-wangliang can mean either "'demons, monsters' generally or 'mountain and water demons' separately". Groot (1910:5:505) describes chimei as "another demon-tribe" because the "Chinese place in their great class of hill-spirits certain quadrumana, besides actual human beings, mountaineers alien to Chinese culture, perhaps a dying race of aborigines."
Both the chimei contexts concern banishing evildoers into dangerous wilderness regions. The former (文公18; tr. Legge 1872:283) refers to the Sixiong 四凶 "Four Fiends" (Hundun 渾敦, Qiongqi 窮奇, Taowu 檮杌, and Taotie 饕餮); the legendary ruler Shun, "banished these four wicked ones, Chaos, Monster, Block, and Glutton, casting them out into the four distant regions, to meet the spite of the sprites and evil things". Du Yu's commentary glosses chimei demons as "born in the strange qi of mountains and forests, harmful to humans". The latter context (昭公 9, tr. Legge 1872:625) only mentions the villainous Taowu; "The ancient kings located T'aou-wuh in [one of] the four distant regions, to encounter the sprites and other evil things."
The chimei-wangliang 螭魅罔兩 context (宣公3 , tr. Legge 1872:293) records how Yu the Great, legendary founder of the Xia Dynasty, cast nine instructional bronze ding "tripod cauldrons" to acquant people with all the dangerous creatures in China's Nine Provinces.
Anciently, when Hea was distinguished for its virtue, the distant regions sent pictures of the [remarkable] objects in them. The nine pastors sent in the metal of their provinces, and the tripods were cast, with representations on them of those objects. All the objects were represented, and [instructions were given] of the preparations to be made in reference to them, so that the people might know the sprites and evil things. Thus the people, when they went among the rivers, marshes, hills, and forests, did not meet with the injurious things, and the hill-sprites, monstrous things, and water-sprites, did not meet with them [to do them injury].
Note how Legge translates each chimei-wangliang "demons; monsters" syllable individually: chimei "injurious things, and the hill-sprites" and wangliang "monstrous things, and water-sprites".
Wang Chong's (late 1st century CE) Lunheng 論衡 (tr. Groot 1910:5:506) considers the chimei as a dragon hybrid, "Those who give their opinion on the ch‘i, state that they are dragon-like beings; therefore, as the word mei is copulated to (the name of) a dragon, the mei must be a congener of this animal."
In Chinese folklore and art, most dragons, including the long 龍, are represented with two horns. Besides the chi 螭, only a few dragons supposedly lacked horns, for instance, jiaolong 蛟龍 "aquatic dragon; hornless dragon; crocodile" or qiulong 虯龍 "horned dragon; hornless dragon".
In comparative mythology as well, horned dragons are generally more common than hornless ones. Based upon the chishou 螭首 "hornless-dragon head" roof adornment, Kroll (1989:329) translates chi as wyvern, "a footed winged dragon with a serpent's tail, becoming in medieval times an oft-pictured heraldic beast."
- Benedict, Paul K. 1976. "Sino-Tibetan: Another Look," Journal of the American Oriental Society 96:167-197.
- Birrell, Anne, tr. 2000. The Classic of Mountains and Seas. Penguin.
- Boodberg, Peter A. 1935. "Sino-Tibetan Notes." Reprinted in 1979. Selected Works of Peter A. Boodberg, compiled by Alvin P. Cohen. University of California Press. 1979:162-70.
- Carr, Michael. 1990. "Chinese Dragon Names", Linguistics of the Tibeto-Burman Area 13.2:87-189.
- De Groot, Jan Jakob Maria. 1892-1910. The Religious System of China: Its Ancient Forms, Evolution, History and Present Aspect, Manners, Customs and Social Institutions Connected Therewith. 6 volumes. Brill Publishers.
- Hawkes, David, tr. 1985. The Songs of the South: An Anthology of Ancient Chinese Poems by Qu Yuan and Other Poets. Penguin.
- Karlgren, Bernhard. 1957. Grammata Serica Recensa. Museum of Far Eastern Antiquities.
- Knoblock, John and Jeffrey Riegel. 2000. The Annals of Lü Buwei: A Complete Translation and Study. Stanford: Stanford University Press.
- Kroll, Paul W. 1989. "[Review of] Le Symbolisme du dragon dans la Chine antique by Jean-Pierre Dieny," Journal of the American Oriental Society 109.2:325-30.
- Le Blanc, Charles. 1985. Huai-nan Tzu: Philosophical Synthesis in Early Han Thought: The Idea of Resonance (Kan-Ying) With a Translation and Analysis of Chapter Six. Hong Kong University Press.
- Legge, James, tr. 1872. The Ch'un Ts'ew with the Tso Chuen. Oxford University Press.
- Matisoff, James A. 1985. "God and the Sino-Tibetan Copula with some good news concerning Selected Tibeto-Burman Rhymes," Journal of Asian and African Studies 29:1-81.
- Schuessler, Axel. 2007. ABC Etymological Dictionary of Old Chinese. University of Hawaii Press.
- Visser, Marinus Willern de. 1913. The Dragon in China and Japan. J. Müller.
- Watson, Burton, tr. 1993. Records of the Grand Historian, by Sima Qian. Columbia University Press.
- Welch, Patricia Bjaaland. 2008. Chinese Art. Tuttle.
|Wikimedia Commons has media related to Chi.|
- 螭 entry[dead link], Chinese Etymology
- 螭 entry page, 1716 CE Kangxi Dictionary
- Jade awl of a chi dragon, Warring States period, National Palace Museum
- Marble chishou hornless dragon head, Yuan Dynasty, Los Angeles County Museum of Art
- Lacquerware vase with hornless dragon design, Qing Dynasty, National Palace Museum
- Hornless dragon on a porcelain plate, Qing Dynasty, Royal Alberta Museum