Commercial Closet Association
|Dissolved||May 7, 2008|
|Purpose||Education on LGBT representation in advertising and media|
The Commercial Closet Association (CCA) was a New York City based non-profit organization, founded in 2001 to provide "training and best practices on the representation of" the lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender (LGBT) community. It hoped to affect the $1.1 trillion annual worldwide advertising market ($128 billion in the US alone). Its board announced its closure in 2009 after merging with the Gay & Lesbian Alliance Against Defamation (GLAAD).
The Association's programs targeted at the business and advertising industries included advertising training, an online Ad Library, Best Practices guidelines, a monthly LGBT advertising issues column, and the annual Images in Advertising Awards event to honor excellence of LGBT portrayals in advertising.
The organization targeted marketing and ad agency corporate officers and executives, university students/professors, the media, and consumers, aiming to make future advertising more inclusive and positive by contacting advertising and image creators in order to educate them directly.
The CCA stated it was not pressure group or advertising watchdog, instead aiming to educate advertisers. Its programs focused on raising industry awareness of the issues of homophobia and transphobia in mainstream advertising; some of its efforts were created in conjunction with the Association of National Advertisers, the American Association of Advertising Agencies, New York politicians like Thomas Duane, and major advertising agency executives. After the merger, GLAAD received the Ad Library, training resources, online materials, and the company's name.
The CCA Ad Library is an online collection of 4,000+ LGBT-themed ads from over 33 countries and hundreds of companies and ad agencies since 1917. It contained "video clips, still photo storyboards, descriptive critiques, and indexing to more than 600 television and print media ad representations," sortable by various statistics and also by overall depiction or message about gayness, "categorized as vague, neutral, positive, or negative." The site includes ratings, consumer feedback, Advertising Best Practices, and other resources.
The Best Practices guidelines outlined how to create respectful ad representations of LGBT people to be used as part of advertising training.
The CCA published original data reports on LGBT sponsorship spending, top spending companies, and top earning LGBT organizations and events.
The Commercial Closet Association was founded in 2001 "as a way to track and document [LGBT] themed advertisements." It developed out of work by Advertising Age magazine business journalist Michael Wilke, who was known for his work in writing about gay and lesbian matters in advertising. He had created a video program in 1997 called "The Commercial Closet", which was presented at film festivals internationally, and in 2001, Wilke was funded by broadcast historian Michael Collins, then of Quinnipiac College of Connecticut, to start a full nonprofit organization by the same name. The project received pro-bono work from web development firm Mediapolis and designer Stephen Mack of Gnomist to develop the first version of CCA's online advertising library and ad ratings system at CommercialCloset.org. In 2004, the name evolved to Commercial Closet Association to indicate that it was an organization and to distinguish it from the educational programs it produced.
Wilke had written about LGBT issues with Inside Media, Advertising Age (Crain Communications), Adweek (Nielsen Company), and other publications since 1992. He is credited with coining the term "gay vague" in 1997 while at Advertising Age. He served as the New York chapter president of the National Lesbian and Gay Journalists Association from 1998–2000, received a 1998 honor at the GLAAD Media Awards for his journalism on LGBT in related industries, was honored in 2001 as one of the "OUT 100" by Out magazine, and was a 2002 Crain Lecturer at the Medill School of Journalism at Northwestern University. He was a judge for the 2006 Association of National Advertisers Multicultural Excellence Awards. He writes a syndicated national column, The Commercial Closet, for LGBT newspapers and web sites.
The CCA began its Images in Advertising Awards in 2004, running until at least 2008.
In 2009, the Commercial Closet Associate's board of directors announced its closure and merger with GLAAD.
In December 2012, the Commercial Closet website was to be shut down by GLAAD but Wilke intervened and relaunched the project under the new name AdRespect.
Partnerships and sponsors
CCA is supported through foundation grants, corporate sponsorships, fundraising events, membership, individual donations, and training fees.
CCA has or had partnerships with advertising and media industry groups and with the LGBT organizations in the United States. Ad industry groups included the Association of National Advertisers and the Advertising Educational Foundation. Media included The New York Times, Sirius Satellite Radio, and Adweek. Gay community groups include the Human Rights Campaign, the Gay Lesbian Straight Education Network (GLSEN), and also GLAAD, pre-merger.
GLSEN carried a Student Viewing Guide for teachers, and Human Rights Campaign carried the CCA's monthly gay advertising issues column, the Advertising Best Practices, and excerpts from Commercial Closet in the marketing section of WorkNet.
- Adrienne Mand (2001), "Site for gay ads debuts", Advertising Age
- "Commercial Closet Closed, Remnants Assumed by GLAAD". Advertising Age. Retrieved 2019-03-02.
- Ikard, John (2005), Sustainable Capitalism: A Matter of Common Sense, Sterling, VA: Kumarian Press, ISBN 1-56549-206-4
- Ken Wheaton (2006), "Awards Show Proves to be Gay Affair", Advertising Age
- Andrew Hampp (2007), "The Gays Celebrate Advertising Progress", Advertising Age
- "Commercial Closet Association". Idealist. Retrieved 2019-03-02.
- Andrew Hampp (2008), "Mad Ave's Other Diversity Problem: Commercial Closet Calls on Agencies to Eliminate LGBT Stereotypes in Ads", Advertising Age
- Aparna Kumar (2001-05-08), "Commercials: Out of the Closet", Wired
- Pope, Daniel. "Making Sense of Advertisements" (PDF). History Matters.
- Eleftheria Parpis (2008), "The Joke's Over: Withdrawing allegedly offensive gay-themed ads puts industry on notice", Adweek
- McCarthy, Michael (2001-05-11), "Do Popeye and Bluto love juice — or each other?", USA Today, retrieved 2010-04-30
- Friess, Steve (2002), "Advertising: Sensitivity Training", Newsweek
- Chris Marlowe (2001), "Online Closet Outs Ads For Gay Community", The Hollywood Reporter
- Wilke, Michael (2017-08-28). "Guide to Commercial Closet, Ad Respect, and Michael Wilke LGBT Advertising Archive". The Fales Library and Special Collections. Retrieved 2019-03-02.
- Robin Wallace (2003-09-16), "Does Spending Power Buy Cultural Acceptance?", Fox News
- Ken Liebeskind (2001), "Gay Themed Ads and a Web Site That Tracks Them", MediaPost, archived from the original on October 9, 2013
- Stuart Elliott (1997-06-30), "Homosexual imagery is spreading from print campaigns to general-interest TV programming.", The New York Times, retrieved 2010-04-30
- Sender, Katherine, Business, Not Politics, (Columbia University Press, 2004), 261, Notes 20
- June Thomas (2001), "Briefs: Out, December 2001", Slate
- "Out 100, Alumni 2001", Out Magazine, 2001
- "2002 Crain Speakers", Official Medill/Northwestern website, 2002, archived from the original on 2010-06-13
- "Commercial Closet Association website". Commercialcloset.org. Retrieved 2014-01-15.
- "Commercial Closet Association's Images In Advertising Awards". Fleishman Hillard. 2008-08-01. Retrieved 2019-03-02.
- Advertising Educational Foundation - CCA Images In Advertising Awards winners
- Association of National Advertisers - "Gays in Commercials: Sales or Sellout?"[permanent dead link]
- Association of National Advertisers - "Building GLBT Awareness and Inclusion in Mass/ Business-to-Business Advertising"
- GLSEN/Gay, Lesbian and Straight Education Network - "Commercial Closet Student Viewing Guide"
- The Commercial Closet at IMDb