The Irish Whales or "The Whales" was a nickname given to a group of Irish, Irish-American and Irish-Canadian athletes who dominated weight-throwing events in the first two decades of the 20th century. "This group dominated the field events, particularly throwing events, at the Amateur Athletic Union national championships and at the Olympic Games between 1896 and 1924." They were primarily members of the Irish American Athletic Club, and the New York Athletic Club and also members of the New York City Police Department. They were known as such because of their athletic prowess, physical size, voracious appetites, and their impact on a generation of sports fans.
The Irish Whales included; John Flanagan, Simon Gillis, James Mitchell, Pat McDonald, Paddy Ryan, Martin Sheridan, Matt McGrath and Con Walsh. What Sheridan lacked in girth, he made up for with his appetite and athletic accomplishments, nine Olympic medals in all. "Matt McGrath was built like a wedge. He was a six-footer, but he weighed 248 pounds. John Flanagan was about the same. Simon Gillis was 6′2″ and 240. Paddy Ryan was 6′5″ and 296, while Pat McDonald was 6′5″ and 300 pounds."
While it is not entirely clear when this moniker came into use, and was likely not used in the face of any of these giant men, it seems to have first appeared in print in 1937 in John Kieran's New York Times column, "Sports of the Times," written by John Drebinger (who was substituting for Kieran). The term was further popularized in "Sports of the Times" columns written by Arthur Daly in the New York Times, with the first reference to "The Whales" in 1942. On the subject of the origin of this nickname, Daly wrote:
"It was on the Olympic trip of 1912 that the 'whale' nickname took hold. Dan Ferris, then a cherubic little boy, recalls it with relish. 'Those big fellows,' he related, 'all sat at the same table and their waiter was a small chap. Before we reached Stockholm he had lost twenty pounds, worn down by bringing them food. Once as he passed me he muttered under his breath, 'It's whales they are, not men.' They used to take five plates of soup as a starter and then gulp down three or four steaks with trimmings. That Simon Gillis would think nothing of having a dozen eggs for breakfast. But what fascinated me was the way he ate them. He'd put a dab of mustard on each and eat it whole, shell and all.' The Irish American A.C. behemoths always were the life of any party."
Another tale of the Irish Whales' voracious appetites came from Arthur Daly's typewriter twenty-two years later. In a Times column in 1964 he wrote:
"Some of their more prodigious feats were at the table. The Irish American A.C. was competing in Baltimore when (Simon) Gillis placed an order for a post-meet snack with the head waiter at a local restaurant. He ordered 27 dozen oysters and six huge T-bone steaks. Slight Miscalculation - The waiter was ready when Gillis, McDonald and McGrath arrived. The table had been set for a party of 33. 'Do you want to wait for the rest of your group?' asked the headwaiter. He turned pale as he watched three whales devour 27 dozen oysters and six huge T-bone steaks."
Heights and weights are taken from various reference sources; heights given sometimes vary by several inches, while, obviously, weight can fluctuate substantially over an athlete's career. All Olympic medals won were for the United States, except for Con Walsh's which was for Canada.
|John Flanagan||January 28, 1868
|June 3, 1938
|6 ft 0 in (1.83 m)||248 pounds (112 kg)|
|Simon Gillis||April 6, 1875
Cape Breton Island
|January 14, 1964
|6 ft 1 in (1.85 m)||241 pounds (109 kg)||none|
|James Mitchel||January 30, 1864
Bartoose, County Tipperary
|July 3, 1921
|6 ft 1.5 in (1.87 m)||220 pounds (100 kg)||1904 St Louis — 56 pound weight throw|
|Pat McDonald||July 26, 1878
Killard, County Clare
|May 16, 1954
New York City
|6 ft 2.5 in (1.89 m)||265 pounds (120 kg)|
|Paddy Ryan||20 January 1883
|13 February 1964
|6 ft 2 in (1.88 m)||249 pounds (113 kg)|
|Martin Sheridan||March 28, 1881
|March 27, 1918
New York City
|6 ft 3 in (1.91 m)||194 pounds (88 kg)||
1904 St Louis — Discus
|Matt McGrath||December 28, 1875
|January 29, 1941
New York City
|6 ft 0 in (1.83 m)||254 pounds (115 kg)|
|Con Walsh||April 24, 1885
Carriganimma, County Cork
|December 7, 1961
|6 ft 4 in (1.93 m)||210 pounds (95 kg)|
- Lee, J. J.; Casey, Marion; Casey, Marion R. (February 9, 2006). Making the Irish American: History and Heritage of the Irish in the United States. NYU Press. ISBN 9780814752081 – via Google Books.
- "All About Whales." New York Times, July 13, 1964.
- "Cementing Friendly Relations" New York Times, Dec. 25, 1937.
- "About Some Whales, Human Variety."New York Times, June 12, 1942
- "Jim Mitchel Bio, Stats, and Results". Olympics at Sports-Reference.com. Archived from the original on 2020-04-17.
- Slattery, David (October 15, 2012). Poet Madman Scoundrel: 189 Unusual Irish Lives. Orpen Press. ISBN 9781871305968 – via Google Books.
- Lee, Joseph; Casey, Marion (2006). Making the Irish American: History and Heritage of the Irish in the United States. New York: Glucksman Ireland House / NYU Press. ISBN 978-0-8147-5208-1.
- McCarthy, Kevin (2010). Gold, Silver and Green: The Irish Olympic Journey 1896 – 1924. Cork, Ireland: Cork University Press. ISBN 978-1-85918-458-5.