Janet Malcolm (born 1934) is an American writer, journalist on staff at The New Yorker magazine, and collagist. She is the author of Psychoanalysis: The Impossible Profession (1981), In the Freud Archives (1984) and The Journalist and the Murderer (1990).
Craig Seligman wrote of her: "Like Sylvia Plath, whose not-niceness she has laid open with surgical skill, she discovered her vocation in not-niceness ... Malcolm's blade gleams with a razor edge. Her critics tend to go after her with broken bottles." The influential critic Harold Bloom has praised her "wonderful exuberance," writing that Malcolm's books, "transcend what they appear to be: superb reportage."
Background and personal
Malcolm was born in Prague in 1934, one of two daughters—the other is author Marie Winn—of a psychiatrist father. She has resided in the United States since her family emigrated from Czechoslovakia in 1939. Malcolm was educated at the University of Michigan and lives in New York City. Her first husband, Donald Malcolm, reviewed books for The New Yorker in the 1950s and 1960s. Her second husband, whom she wed in 1975, was long-time New Yorker editor Gardner Botsford; Botsford died at age 87 in September, 2004.
Early Malcolm book jackets report her "living in New York with her husband and daughter." Her daughter is also mentioned in the text of The Crime of Sheila McGough.
Articles published in The New Yorker, and in Malcolm's subsequent book In The Freud Archives, triggered a $10 million legal challenge by psychoanalyst Jeffrey Moussaieff Masson, former project director for the Freud Archives. In his 1984 lawsuit, Masson claimed that Malcolm had libelled him by fabricating quotations attributed to him; these quotes, Masson contended, had brought him into disrepute.
Malcolm claimed that Masson had called himself an "intellectual gigolo", and that he had slept with over 1000 women. She also claimed that he said he wanted to turn the Freud estate into a haven of "sex, women and fun"; and claimed that he was, "after Freud, the greatest analyst that ever lived." Malcolm was unable to produce all the disputed material on tape. The case was partially adjudicated before the Supreme Court, which held, against Malcolm, that the case could go forward for trial by jury. After a decade of proceedings, a jury finally decided in Malcolm's favor on November 2, 1994, on the grounds that, whether or not the quotations were genuine, more evidence would be needed to rule against Malcolm. (For the opinion of the Supreme Court that allowed the case to proceed to trial, see the opinion at Masson v. New Yorker Magazine, Inc. (89-1799), 501 U.S. 496 (1991).)
In August, 1995, Malcolm claimed to have discovered a misplaced notebook containing three of the disputed quotes. As reported in The New York Times, the author "declared in an affidavit under penalty of perjury that the notes were genuine."
The Journalist and the Murderer
The thesis of The Journalist and the Murderer is contained in its first sentence: "Every journalist who is not too stupid or too full of himself to notice what is going on knows that what he does is morally indefensible."
Malcolm's example was popular non-fiction writer Joe McGinniss, author of The Selling of the President, among others; while researching his non-fiction, true crime book Fatal Vision, McGinniss lived with the defense team of former Green Beret doctor Jeffrey MacDonald, then on trial for the 1970 murders of his two daughters and pregnant wife. In the published Fatal Vision, McGinniss concluded that MacDonald was a sociopath and had been unbalanced by amphetamines when he slew his family. McGinniss drew upon the work of social critic Christopher Lasch to construct a portrait of MacDonald as a "pathological narcissist".
Malcolm contended that McGinniss was pressed into this strategy for professional and structural reasons — by MacDonald's "lack of vividness" as a real-life character who would be carrying the book. "As every journalist will confirm," Malcolm writes,
- "MacDonald's uninterestingness is not unusual at all...When a journalist fetches up against someone like [him], all he can do is flee and hope that a more suitable subject will turn up soon. In the MacDonald-McGinniss case we have an instance of a journalist who apparently found out too late that the subject of his book was not up to scratch — not a member of the wonderful race of auto-fictionalizers, like Joseph Mitchell's Joe Gould and Truman Capote's Perry Smith, on whom the "non-fiction novel" depends for its life...The solution that McGinniss arrived at for dealing with MacDonald's characterlessness was not a satisfactory one, but it had to do."
Per Malcolm, it was to conceal this deficit that McGinniss quoted liberally from Lasch's 1979 study The Culture of Narcissism. This, to her, was a professional sin. McGinniss' moral sin, his "indefensible" act in her view, was to pretend to a belief in MacDonald's innocence, long after he'd become convinced of the man's guilt.
The book created a sensation when in March 1989 it appeared in two parts in The New Yorker magazine. Roundly criticized upon first publication, the book is still controversial, although it has come to be regarded as a classic, and ranks ninety-seventh in The Modern Library's list of the twentieth century's "100 Best Works of Nonfiction". As Douglas McCollum wrote in the Columbia Journalism Review, "In the decade after Malcolm's essay appeared, her once controversial theory became received wisdom."
Psychoanalysis: The Impossible Profession
The Yale University Freud scholar Peter Gay wrote of Malcolm's study of the modern psychoanalytic profession, "Janet Malcolm's witty and wicked Psychoanalysis: The Impossible Profession has been praised by psychoanalysts (with justice) as a dependable introduction to analytic theory and technique. It has the rare advantage over more solemn texts of being funny as well as informative".
Malcolm’s penchant for controversial subjects and tendency to insert her beliefs and opinions into her narratives has brought her both admirers and critics. “Leaning heavily on the techniques of psychoanalysis, she probes not only actions and reactions but motivations and intent; she pursues literary analysis like a crime drama and courtroom battles like novels,” wrote Cara Parks in The New Republic. Parks also praised Malcolm’s “intensely intellectual style” as well as her “sharpness and creativity.”  But in Esquire, Tom Junod characterized Malcolm as “a self hater whose work has managed to speak for the self-hatred (not to mention the class issues) of a profession that has designs on being ‘one of the professions’ but never will be.” Junod found her to be devoid of “journalistic sympathy” and observed, “Very few journalists are more animated by malice than Janet Malcolm.” He concluded that Malcolm is both “self-serving” and “utterly full of shit.”
- Diana & Nikon: Essays on the Aesthetic of Photography (1980)
- Psychoanalysis: The Impossible Profession (1981)
- In The Freud Archives (1984)
- The Journalist and the Murderer (1990)
- The Purloined Clinic: Selected Writings (1992), which contains the essays "A Girl of the Zeitgeist" and "The Window Washer"
- The Silent Woman: Sylvia Plath & Ted Hughes (1994)
- The Crime of Sheila McGough (1999)
- Reading Chekhov: A Critical Journey (2001)
- Two Lives: Gertrude and Alice (2007)
- Iphigenia in Forest Hills: Anatomy of a Murder Trial (2011)
- Forty-one False Starts: Essays on Artists and Writers (2013)
Awards and honors
- 2008 PEN/Jacqueline Bograd Weld Award for Biography, Two Lives: Gertrude and Alice 
- 2013 National Book Critics Circle Award (Criticism) shortlist for Forty-One False Starts
- Goldberg, Nan. "Seligman, Craig. ''Salon'', "Brilliant Careers: Janet Malcolm". February 2, 2000". Salon.com. Retrieved 2012-01-05.
- Bloom, Harold, The New York Times Book Review, "War Within The Walls", May 27, 1984.
- Masson v. New Yorker Magazine, Inc., 501 U.S. 496 (1991)
- "Boynton, Robert, Till Press Do Us Part: The Trial of Janet Malcolm and Jeffrey Masson.". The Village Voice. 1994-11-28. Retrieved 2015-01-08.
- "Stout, David, ''The New York Times'', "Malcolm's Notes and a Child at Play", August 30, 1995". New York Times. 1995-08-30. Retrieved 2012-01-05.
- Malcolm, Janet, The Journalist and the Murderer, New York: Knopf, 1990.
- Malcolm, The Journalist and the Murderer, pp. 28, 72-3.
- Malcolm, p.68
- Malcolm, pps. 71-3.
- Scardino, Albert, The New York Times. "Ethic, Reporters and The New Yorker", March 21. 1989. "Janet Malcolm, a staff writer for The New Yorker, returned her magazine to the center of the long-running debate over ethics in journalism this month...Her declarations provoked outrage among authors, reporters and editors, who rushed last week to distinguish themselves from the journalists Miss Malcolm was describing."
- See Friendly, Fred W., The New York Times Book Review, "Was Trust Betrayed?", February 25, 1990, and Lehmann-Haupt, Christopher, The New York Times, "Deception and Journalism: How Far to Go for the Story", February 22, 1990.
- McCollum, Douglas, Columbia Journalism Review, "You Have The Right to Remain Silent", January, February, 2003.
- Search for a Title or Author. "The Modern Library 100 Best". Randomhouse.com. Retrieved 2012-01-05.
- Peter Gay, Freud: A Life for Our Times (London 1988) p. 763
- "Our Critic’s Tip Sheet on Current Reading: Kingsley Amis Drinks; Bill Bryson Admonishes; and PEN Bestows Prizes". The New York Observer. May 19, 2008. Retrieved August 11, 2012.
- Kirsten Reach (January 14, 2014). "NBCC finalists announced". Melville House Publishing. Retrieved January 14, 2014.
- "Announcing the National Book Critics Awards Finalists for Publishing Year 2013". National Book Critics Circle. January 14, 2014. Retrieved January 14, 2014.
- Janet Malcolm by Craig Seligman, Salon.com, February 29, 2000
- Katie Roiphe (Spring 2011). "Janet Malcolm, The Art of Nonfiction No. 4". The Paris Review.
- NOTHING BUT THE TRUTH?
- The Lives They Lived: Kurt Eissler, b. 1908; Keeper of Freud's Secrets, By JANET MALCOLM, Published: January 2, 2000
- Malcolm archive from The New York Review of Books