Vahidnia got significant media attention for his face-to-face criticism of Iran's supreme leader on October 28, 2009, during a meeting between Ali Khamenei and students. During this meeting, Khamenei was challenged by Vahidnia in what was called "an unusual encounter". The event was being broadcast by Iranian state-run TV. That made the authorities stop airing the programme.
On October 28, 2009, during the annual meeting of Tehran intellectual elites with the Supreme Leader, in Tehran University, Vahidinia spoke for 20 minutes without interruptions, critiquing the status of ignorant idol in a golden cage of the Supreme ayatollah Khamenei. Some time before, Khamenei had announced that "Contestation of the 12 June vote is the worst crime possible". The Iranian state-run TV stopped the broadcasting, but the audience's cellphones managed to record the full speech. Mahmoud asked: "I want to ask you something: why does nobody in this country dare to criticize you? Do you think that you never make mistakes? Isn't this ignorance? You have been changed into a kind of inaccessible idol that nobody can criticize. I don't understand why everybody is forbidden to criticize your choices.".
Structure of the speech
Vahidnia classified his criticism in four parts:
- State-run TV: IRIB (Islamic Republic of Iran Broadcasting) for trying to show a reverse image of what is happening in Iran after June 12, 2009, election and destroying the figures that people trust. He brought up that since the head of IRIB is selected by the Supreme Leader, Ali Khamenei, Khamenei is either unaware of what is happening in an organization under his control or he has direct control and is responsible for their programs.
- Freedom of speech: intelligence-based atmosphere ruling the media and press and brought up the issues that critical newspapers have been facing. He asked for an end to closure of press offices and demanded freedom of the press even when they criticize the supreme leader.
- Supreme leader is criticize-able: Lack of openness in society so that people and intellectuals could freely criticize the supreme leader since the supreme leader, like anyone else, is prone to making mistakes. In his speech, Vahidnia mentioned that the ones around the supreme leader are making an idol.
- Organization of power: Cycle of power in the Islamic Republic and the structure of Guardian Council and Assembly of Experts.
Vahidnia was ranked 37th on 2009 national math Olympiad in Iran and has received the gold medal for it. Although some media reported he was the "international mathematics Olympiad winner", he didn't compete at any international mathematics Olympiads.
- "Piercing the Veil" Archived 2009-11-04 at the Wayback Machine.
- واکنش رهبر انقلاب به انتقادات صريح يکي از نخبگان
- Khamenei And The Student
- Brave student defies the Supreme Leader of Iran
- Le Figaro, 1 November 2009 11h48
- "Archived copy" (PDF). Archived from the original (PDF) on 2010-12-27. Retrieved 2009-11-02.
- fa: BBC Mahmod Vahid nia- official TV report.
- (video of the full speech welcome)