Misfits & Mistakes: Singles, B-Sides & Strays 2007–2023 is a compilation album by American indie rock band Superchunk, released on October 27, 2023, through Merge Records. It contains 50 tracks from the period of the band's return from their semi-hiatus in 2007 to the year of the compilation's release, and is named after their song from the Aqua Teen Hunger Force Colon Movie Film for Theaters soundtrack, "Misfits and Mistakes". The album received acclaim from critics.
Misfits & Mistakes: Singles, B-Sides & Strays 2007–2023 received a score of 82 out of 100 on review aggregator Metacritic based on five critics' reviews, indicating "universal acclaim".[1]Under the Radar's Michael James Hall wrote that the band "have seen fit here to unlock a treasure trove overflowing with gems, oddities, and curiosities", and that they "remind us so often why they remain one of the greatest guitar bands of a generation with their insanely melodic, rapturously supercharged, endlessly loveable punk rock".[6] Christopher J. Lee of PopMatters called the compilation "a fascinating glimpse of them trying new things while reaffirming their signature contributions to the indie rock canon" but found the "curation of this album somewhat haphazard and the liner notes inconsistent about dates", so advised that it is "best to listen to what's on hand" as it "moves intuitively rather than logically".[5]
Tim Sendra of AllMusic opined that "Superchunk have always strengthened their reputation with music that ranks with the most powerful and important ever made, able to move, inspire, and impress no matter the sound or subject. This collection reinforces that notion, and proves that in their second act, the band remain at the very top of their game".[2]Mojo stated that "while the collection's title acknowledges the scary presence of three Misfits songs[,] as for "Mistakes", however, there really are none".[4]Classic Rock remarked that it is "ultimately a completist's set".[3]
[2]
[6]