Ted Taylor (physicist)
Theodore Brewster Taylor
July 11, 1925
Mexico City, Mexico
|Died||October 28, 2004 (aged 79)|
|Citizenship||Mexico, United States|
|Alma mater||California Institute of Technology, University of California, Berkeley, and Cornell University|
|Known for||Nuclear weapon designs and nuclear disarmament advocacy|
|Awards||E. O. Lawrence Award (1965)|
|Institutions||Los Alamos National Laboratory, General Atomics, Defense Atomic Support Agency|
Theodore Brewster Taylor (more commonly known as Ted Taylor) was an accomplished American theoretical physicist, specifically concerning nuclear energy. His higher education includes a PhD from Cornell University in theoretical physics. Although Taylor is relatively unknown to the public, his most noteworthy contributions to the field of nuclear weaponry were his small bomb developments at the Los Alamos Laboratory in New Mexico. He is credited with numerous landmarks in fission nuclear weaponry development, including having developed the smallest, most powerful, and most efficient fission weapons ever tested by the US. Though Ted was not considered a brilliant physicist from a calculative viewpoint, his vision and creativity allowed him to thrive in the field. The later part of Ted's career was focused on nuclear energy instead of weaponry, and included his work on Project Orion, nuclear reactor developments, and anti-nuclear proliferation.
Ted Taylor was born in Mexico City, Mexico on July 11, 1925. His mother and father were both Americans; his mother, Barbara Southworth Howland Taylor, held a PhD in Mexican literature from the Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, and his father, Walter Clyde Taylor, was the director of a YMCA in Mexico City. His father had been a widower with three sons. He then married Barbara in 1922, who was a widow with a son of her own. Therefore, Ted had four older half brothers, and they were old enough that Ted was essentially raised as an only child. Additionally, both of his maternal grandparents were Congregationalist missionaries in Guadalajara Ted grew up in a house in Cuernavaca which had no electricity and was on the street corner of Atlixco 13. His home was quiet and religious. It was also filled with literature, mainly atlases and geographies, which he would read by candlelight. This habituation followed him into adulthood, never quite adapting to the societal standards for electricity. Taylor showed interest in chemistry, specifically pyrotechnics, when he received a chemistry set at the age of ten. This fascination was enhanced when his neighborhood, Atlixco 13, added a chemistry laboratory that served a small and exclusive university in the area. Through the lab Ted had access to items from local druggists that otherwise would not have been readily available. These items included corrosive chemicals, explosive chemicals, nitric acid, and sulfuric acid, which allowed him to conduct his own experiments. Taylor often looked at the 1913 New International Encyclopedia, which contained extensive chemistry, for new concoctions to make. These included sleeping drugs, small explosives, guncotton, precipitates, and many more. His mother was extremely tolerant of his experimentation; however, she prohibited any experiments that involved nitroglycerin. He attended the American School in Mexico City from elementary school through high school. Taylor had a passion for music and in the mornings before school he would quietly sit for an hour and listen to his favorite songs. He was a gifted student and finished the fourth through sixth grades in one year. Being an accelerated student, Taylor found himself three years younger than all of his friends as he emerged into his teens. Taylor graduated early from high school in 1941 at the age of 15. After graduation he left Mexico to attend the Exeter Academy, located in New Hampshire, for one year while he waited to meet the age requirements for universities in America. While at the Academy he developed an interest in physics, though he displayed poor academic performance in his courses. At Exeter he took Modern Physics which was taught by Elbert P. Little, a teacher who was greatly admired at the university. Elbert P. Little gave Ted a letter grade D on his final winter term examination, however he quickly brushed this failure off. Shortly after he confirmed that he wanted to be a physicist. Apart from education, he also developed an interest in throwing discus at Exeter. This interest continued into his college career, as he continued to throw discus at Caltech. He enrolled at the California Institute of Technology in 1942 and then spent his second and third years in the Navy V-12 program. This accelerated his schooling and he graduated with a bachelor's degree in physics from the university in 1945 at just nineteen years old. After graduation, he attended the midshipman school at Throgs Neck, in Bronx, New York for one year to fulfill his naval active duty requirement. By the end of his time in the Navy he had received the status of Junior Grade Lieutenant. The Navy let him out in the summer of 1946 and he enrolled in a graduate program in theoretical physics at the University of California at Berkeley. During his graduate schooling, Ted worked part-time at the Berkeley Radiation laboratory, mainly on the cyclotron and a beta-ray spectrograph. After failing an oral preliminary examination on mechanics and heat, and a second prelim in modern physics in 1949, Taylor was disqualified from the graduate program.
Taylor married Caro Armin in 1948 and had five children in the following years- Clare Hastings, Katherine Robertson, Christopher Taylor, Robert Taylor, and Jeffrey Taylor. Caro Armin was majoring in Greek at Scripps College, a Liberal Arts University in Claremont California. The drive from the California Institute of Technology was a relatively short commute, so Taylor went down to visit her whenever he could. Both Caro and Taylor were very shy people, and unsure of what the future held. When they first met they both believed that Ted would be a college professor in a sleepy town, and that Caro would be a librarian. They felt that these professions in a small college town was their speed. After 44 years of marriage the couple divorced in 1992.
Taylor eventually gained acceptance into a physics PhD program at the University of Cornell in 1953 and completed the program in 1954. At Cornell, Ted maintained his childhood passion for music and had his room equipped with a speaker system. This was uncommon among his experimentalist physicist peers, but his theoretical physicists embraced the music. While at Cornell Taylor picked up the hobby of billiards, and in the afternoons after school he played billiards for almost ten hours a week. He believed that billiards related to particle physics; of capture cross-sections and neutron scattering, of infinite reflectors and fast-neutron-induced fission chain reaction. The behavior of the interacting balls on the table, and the nature of their elastic collisions, all within the confining framework of the reflector cushions, helped him to conceptualize these difficult abstractions.
Prior to Taylor's work at Los Alamos, he had actually firmly declared an anti-nuclear weapons stance. While at the midshipmen school, he received news of the atomic bomb that the U.S. dropped on Hiroshima Japan. He immediately wrote a letter home discussing the perils of nuclear proliferation and his fears that it would lead to the end of mankind in the event of another war. He showed some optimism though, as he felt with proper leadership the nuclear bomb could actually result in the end of wars on earth. Either way, he was still very curious about the field of nuclear physics after his time as an undergraduate.
Theodore Taylor began his work in nuclear physics in 1949 when he was hired to a junior position at Los Alamos in the Theoretical Division. He received this job after failing out of the PhD program at Berkley; J. Carson Mark connected Taylor with a leader at Los Alamos and recommended him for a position. Taylor was unsure of the details about his new job at Los Alamos prior to his arrival. He had only been briefed that his first assignment was to investigate the Neutron Diffusion Theory, which is a theoretical analysis of neutron movement within a nuclear core. While at work at Los Alamos, his strictly anti-nuclear development beliefs changed. His theory on preventing nuclear war turned to developing bombs of unprecedented power in an attempt to make people, including governments, so afraid of nuclear warfare that they wouldn't dare engage in this sort of altercation. He continued in his junior position at Los Alamos until 1953, when he took a temporary leave of absence to obtain his PhD from Cornell. He returned to the program in 1954, and by 1956 he was famous for his work in small bomb development. In fact, Freeman Dyson is quoted as saying, "A great part of the small-bomb development of the last five years [at Los Alamos] was directly due to Ted." Although the majority of the brilliant minds at Los Alamos were focused on developing the fusion bomb, Ted remained hard at work on improving fission bombs. His innovations in this area of study were so important that he was eventually given the freedom to choose whatever he wanted to study, instead of being confined to the narrow scope of direct orders. Eventually, Ted's stance on nuclear warfare and weapon development changed, and thus altered his projected career path. In 1956, Taylor left his position at Los Alamos and went to work for a company called General Atomics. Here, he developed TRIGA, which was a reactor that produced isotopes used in the medical field. Taylor then began working on Project Orion, which was a project that sought to develop a form of space travel that relied on nuclear energy as the fuel source, in 1958. The spacecraft was proposed to utilize a series of nuclear fission reactions as its source of propellant, thus improving space travel while eliminating the earth's source of fuel for nuclear weaponry. In collaboration with his close friend Freeman Dyson, Taylor lead the project development team for six years until the 1963 Nuclear Test Ban Treaty was instituted. After this treaty, the project was no longer viable because they could not test their developments.
Theodore Taylor's career shifted again after project Orion. He developed an even greater fear of the potential ramifications of his entire life's work, and began taking precautionary measures to mitigate those concerns. In 1964 he served as the deputy director of the Defense Atomic Support Agency (a branch within the Department of Defense), where he managed the U.S. nuclear weapons inventory. Then, in 1966 he created a consulting firm called the International Research and Technology Corporation, located in Vienna, Austria, which sought to prevent the development of more nuclear weapons programs. Taylor also worked as a visiting professor at the University of California, Santa Cruz and Princeton University. His focus eventually turned to renewable energy, and In 1980 Taylor started a company called Nova Incorporated, which focused on nuclear energy alternatives as a means of supplementing the energy requirements of the earth. He studied energy capture from sources like cooling ice ponds and heating solar ponds, and eventually turned to energy conservation within buildings. Concerning this work in energy conservation, he founded a not-for-profit organization in Montgomery County, Maryland called Damascus Energy, which focuses on energy efficiency within the home. Theodore Taylor also served on the President of the United States' commission concerning the Three Mile Island Accident, working to mitigate the issues associated with the reactor meltdown.
Theodore Taylor was involved in many important projects and made numerous contributions to nuclear development for the United States. During his time at Los Alamos, He was responsible for designing the smallest fission bomb of the era, named Davy Crockett, which weighed only 60 pounds, measured approximately 12 inches across, and could produce between 10 and 20 kilotons of TNT equivalent. This device was formerly known as the M28 Weapons System. The Davy Crockett itself was the M388 Atomic Round fired from the weapons system, which functioned similarly to how any other modern rocket propelled round would (see RPG-7). It was a mounted weapons system, which means that it would be set up, aimed, and fired as a crew-served weapon. Taylor also designed fission bombs even smaller than Davy Crockett, but those were not developed until long after he left Los Alamos. Furthermore, he even designed a nuclear bomb so small that it weighed only 20 pounds, but it was never actually developed and tested. Additionally, Taylor designed the Super Alloy Bomb, also known as the "SOB". It still holds the record for the largest fission explosion ever tested (as the Ivy King device tested during Operation Ivy), producing over 500 kilotons of TNT equivalent. Furthermore, Taylor was credited with developing multiple techniques that improved the fission bomb. For example, he was largely responsible for the development of fusion boosting, which is a technique that improves the reaction yield and efficiency of a nuclear reaction. This technique was a re-invention of the implosion mechanism that was used in the bomb detonated at Nagasaki. He theorized a series of nuclear reactions within the implosion mechanism that, in combination, trigger the large chain reaction to detonate. This eliminated much of the energy waste and necessity for precision of the original reaction mechanism. This technique is still found in all U.S. fission nuclear weapons today. He also developed a technique that greatly reduced the size of atomic bombs. First tested in a bomb called "Scorpion", it utilized a reflector made of beryllium, which was drastically lighter than the metals that generally were used as reflectors, such as tungsten carbide (WC). Taylor recognized that although a low-atomic-number element like beryllium did not "bounce" neutrons back into the fissile core as efficiently as heavy tungsten, its propensity for neutron spallation (in nuclear physics the so-called "(n,2n)" reaction) more than compensated in overall reflector performance.
After these types of breakthroughs, Taylor became more of an important figure at Los Alamos. He was included in high priority situations reserved for important personnel, and was even taken to the pentagon as a consultant on strategies and the potential outcomes of a nuclear war with Russia. In total, Taylor was responsible for the development of eight bombs: the Super Alloy Bomb, Davey Crockett, Scorpion, Hamlet, Bee, Hornet, Viper, and the Puny Plutonium bomb. The latter, called the Puny Plutonium bomb, was the first-ever dud in the history of U.S. nuclear tests. Furthermore, he produced the bomb called Hamlet after receiving direct orders from military officials to pursue a project in bomb efficiency, which ended up being the most efficient bomb in the history of the U.S.
Apart from bombs, Ted also explored concepts of producing large amounts of nuclear fuel in an expedited manner. His plans, known as MICE (Megaton Ice Contained Explosions), essentially sought to plant a thermonuclear weapon deep in the ice and detonate it, resulting in a giant underground pool of radioactive materials that could then be retrieved. While his idea had merit, he ultimately received little support for this concept and the project never came to fruition.
Publications and other works
Ted Taylor was an accomplished author in the latter part of his career. He worked in cooperation with many specialists in other fields to publish his work on anti-nuclear proliferation and sustainable nuclear energy. Perhaps the greatest fear that propelled him to work so fervently in these areas was the realization that the consequences of nuclear material ending up in the wrong hands could be severe.
Nuclear Theft: Risks and Safeguards is a book that Theodore Taylor wrote in collaboration with Mason Willrich in the 1970s. According to reviews, the book predicted a future where nuclear energy was the primary energy source in the United States, and therefore needed enhanced protective measures to protect the public. In the book, Taylor and Willrich provide multiple recommendations on ways to prevent nuclear material from ending up in the wrong hands, as they anticipated that there would be multiple more sources of nuclear byproducts and therefore more opportunity for nuclear theft. This book likely was a culmination of much of Ted's work in the field, as he often toured nuclear reactor sites and provided insight on potential weak points in their security measures.
Taylor also Co-authored the book, The Restoration of the Earth, with Charles C. Humpstone, which, according to reviews, focused on techniques to enhance sustainability, as well as expanded on different sources of energy that could be used alternatively to meet the power needs of the earth. This book was also a culmination of his focus on nuclear security and the ramifications of the use of nuclear weaponry. In it he addressed the potential effects of nuclear fallout on the environment. This 1973 hardcover discussed potential sources of energy in the year 2000, along with the conceptualization of safer alternatives to the methods of acquiring nuclear energy that were available at the time. In fact, Taylor indirectly referenced a concept for a nuclear reactor which is inherently similar to a reactor that he patented in 1964. Theodore Taylor spent much of his time studying the risk potential of the nuclear power fuel cycle after learning about the detrimental effects that his nuclear weapons had on the environment, so he sought to explore new opportunities for safer use of nuclear power. In his writing, Taylor argued that the most dangerous and devastating events that could possibly occur during nuclear research would most likely happen at reactors that are incapable of running efficiently and maintaining a safe temperature. Taylor went on to state that the prioritization of safety in nuclear reactors is relatively low compared to how it should be, and that if one were to create a nuclear reactor with the capability of cooling down—without the initiation of a fission reaction—then efforts at harvesting nuclear energy would be more incentivized and exponentially safer.
Taylor also wrote the book Nuclear Proliferation: Motivations, Capabilities and Strategies for Control with Harold Feiveson and Ted Greenwood. The book explains the two most dangerous mechanisms by which nuclear proliferation could be devastating for the world, as well as how to disincentivize nuclear proliferation within destabilizing political systems.
Taylor further collaborated with George Gamow on a study called, "What the World Needs Is a Good Two-Kiloton Bomb", which investigated the concept of small nuclear artillery weapons. This paper reflected another shift in Taylor's beliefs about nuclear weapons. He had changed from his deterrent position to a position that sought to develop small yield nuclear weapons that could target specific areas and minimize collateral damage.
Ted Taylor was not only involved in the publication of the aforementioned books, but he, along with a few of his colleagues, was also responsible for a number of patents involving nuclear physics. Taylor is credited with patenting a nuclear reactor with a prompt negative temperature coefficient and fuel element, along with a patent protecting their discovery of an efficient method of producing isotopes from thermonuclear explosions. The patent concerning the production of isotopes from thermonuclear explosions was groundbreaking because of its efficiency and cost effectiveness. It also provides a means for attaining necessary elements that otherwise are difficult to find in nature. prior to this discovery, the cost per neutron in a nuclear reaction was relatively high. The patent concerning the prompt negative temperature coefficient was groundbreaking because it provided a markedly safer reactor even in the event of misuse. With the negative temperature coefficient, the reactor can mitigate sudden surges of reactivity propelled into the system. These patented realizations would later become vital components in the future of nuclear technology.
The Curve of Binding Energy, by John McPhee, is written primarily about the life of Theodore Taylor, as he and McPhee traveled together quite often—spending a great deal of time with one another. It is evident that during their time together, McPhee was very inclined to learn from Taylor. Many of Taylor's personal opinions regarding nuclear energy and safety are mentioned throughout McPhee's writing. McPhee voices one of Taylor's bigger concerns in particular—that plutonium can be devastating if left in the wrong hands. According to McPhee, Taylor suspected that if plutonium were to be acquired by someone with ill-intentions and handled improperly, the aftermath could be catastrophic—as plutonium is a rather volatile element and can be lethal for anyone within hundreds of miles. This clearly can be avoided, Taylor suggests, if nuclear reactors are protected and all sources of nuclear fuel elements are heavily guarded. Ultimately, it is evident that most of Taylor's writing—along with McPhee's narration of Taylor's viewpoints and suggestions—is ahead of its time and still applicable today.
The Santa Claus machine and Pugwash
According to Freitas and Merkle, the only known extant source on Taylor's concept of the "Santa Claus machine" is found in Nigel Calder's Spaceships of the Mind. The concept would use a large mass spectrometer to separate an ion beam into atomic elements for later use in making products.
He died on October 28, 2004 of coronary artery disease.
Freeman Dyson On Ted Taylor
- Alvin C. Graves
- Amory Lovins
- List of books about nuclear issues
- List of nuclear whistleblowers
- National Security Archive
- Nevada Test Site
- Nuclear disarmament
- Nuclear weapons of the United States
- McPhee, John (2011-04-01). The Curve of Binding Energy: A Journey into the Awesome and Alarming World of Theodore B. Taylor. Farrar, Straus and Giroux. ISBN 9780374708610.
- Dyson, George (2002-04-16). Project Orion: The True Story of the Atomic Spaceship. Macmillan. ISBN 9780805059854.
- "Taylor, Barbara Howland @ SNAC". snaccooperative.org. Retrieved 2018-04-19.
- Fox, Margalit (2004-11-05). "Theodore Taylor, a Designer of A-Bombs Who Turned Against Them, Dies at 79". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved 2018-04-19.
- "Neutron Diffusion Theory - Nuclear Power". www.nuclear-power.net. Retrieved 2018-04-19.
- "Theodore Taylor Dies; Tried To Redirect Nuclear Power (washingtonpost.com)". www.washingtonpost.com. Retrieved 2018-04-19.
- Bolger, Daniel (July 2014). "The Crockett's Red Glare". Army Magazine. 64: 55–57 – via EBSCOhost.
- "Nuclear Theft: Risks and Safeguards". Retrieved 2018-04-19.
- Quester, George H. (1975). "Review of Nuclear Theft: Risks and Safeguards". Political Science Quarterly. 90 (1): 136–138. doi:10.2307/2148706. JSTOR 2148706.
- results, search (1973). The restoration of the earth (1st ed.). New York: Harper & Row. ISBN 9780060142315.
- "Nuclear proliferation: motivations, capabilities, and strategies for control". 1977-01-01.
- Production of isotopes from thermonuclear explosions, 1959-04-21, retrieved 2018-04-19
- Reactor with prompt negative temperature, 1964-03-31, retrieved 2018-04-20
- Robert A. Freitas Jr., Ralph C. Merkle, Kinematic Self-Replicating Machines, Landes Bioscience, Georgetown, TX, 2004; http://www.molecularassembler.com/KSRM.htm
- Calder, Nigel Spaceships of the Mind, Viking Press, New York, 1978.
- Holley, Joe (2004-11-02). "Theodore Taylor Dies; Tried To Redirect Nuclear Power". Washington Post. Retrieved 2008-04-25.
- McPhee, John (1974-05-22). The Curve of Binding Energy: A Journey into the Awesome and Alarming World of Theodore B. Taylor. Farrar, Straus and Giroux. p. 140. ISBN 0374133735. Archived from the original on 2010-04-09.
Very few people have Ted's imagination. Very few people have his courage. He was ten or twenty years ahead of the rest of us. There is something tragic about his life. He was the Columbus who never got to go and discover America. I felt that he–much more than von Braun or anyone else–was the real Columbus of our days. I think he is perhaps the greatest man I ever knew well. And he is completely unknown.
- Nigel Calder Spaceships of the Mind, Viking Press, New York, 1978. ISBN 0-670-66021-3
- Robert A. Freitas Jr. and Ralph C. Merkle. Kinematic Self-Replicating Machines, 2004, 3.10
- John McPhee, The Curve of Binding Energy, Ballantine, 1973, 1974. ISBN 0-345-28000-8. This book about proliferation is largely an account of Taylor's ideas, including his idea that it is "easy" for rogue actors to produce nuclear bombs.
- George Dyson, Project Orion: The True Story of the Atomic Spaceship, Henry Holt and Company, 2002. ISBN 0-8050-5985-7
- Mason Willrich, Ted Taylor, Nuclear Theft: Risks and Safeguards: A Report to the Energy Policy Project of the Ford Foundation, Ballinger, 1974, ISBN 0-88410-208-4
- Taylor, Theodore B., Humpstone, Charles C., The Restoration of the Earth, Harper and Row, 1973
- Nuclear Power and Nuclear Weapons, an anti-proliferation essay by Taylor (1996)
- Oral History interview transcript with Ted Taylor February 13, 1995, American Institute of Physics, Niels Bohr Library and Archives