Thomas Mott Osborne
Thomas Mott Osborne
|Warden of Sing Sing|
December 1, 1914 – December 31, 1915
|Appointed by||John B. Riley|
|Preceded by||George S. Weed|
|Succeeded by||George Washington Kirchwey|
|Born||September 23, 1859|
Auburn, New York
|Died||October 20, 1926 (aged 67)|
Auburn, New York
(m. 1886; died 1896)
|Children||Charles, David, Lithgow, Robert|
|Parent||David Munson Osborne (1822–1886) Eliza Lidy Wright (1822-1866)|
|Education||Harvard University (1884) Harvard Law School 1887|
Thomas Mott Osborne (September 23, 1859 – October 20, 1926) was an American prison administrator, prison reformer, industrialist and New York State political reformer. In an assessment of Osborne's life, a New York Times book reviewer wrote: "His career as a penologist was short, but in the interval of the few years he served he succeeded in revolutionizing American prison reform, if not always in fact, then in awakening responsibility.... He was made of the spectacular stuff of martyrs, to many people perhaps ridiculous, but to those whose lives his theories most closely touched, inspiring and often godlike."
He was born on September 23, 1859, in Auburn, New York, to David Munson Osborne (1822–1886) and Agnes Lithgow Devens (1822-1886. Auburn was a center of progressive political activity, particularly anti-slavery activism before and during the American Civil War. His family included a number of eminent reformers, particularly his grandmother, Martha Coffin Wright and her sister, Lucretia Coffin Mott and his uncle William Lloyd Garrison, who were organizers of the 1848 Seneca Falls Convention on women's rights, with Elizabeth Cady Stanton, in Seneca Falls, New York.
His grandmother, Martha Coffin Wright, and in succession her daughter and Osborne's mother, Eliza Wright Osborne, and a niece, Josephine Osborne, oversaw the finances of Harriet Tubman, who spent her last half-century in Auburn. Martha's home in Auburn was part of the Underground Railroad where she harbored fugitive slaves. Both women frequented the Osborne household during Thomas Mott Osborne's upbringing. Thomas Osborne's aunt, Ellen, or as she is known to her descendants, Nella, married William Lloyd Garrison Jr., the son of the noted abolitionist William Lloyd Garrison. Thomas Mott Osborne's mother, Eliza Wright Osborne, wife of David Munson Osborne, was also a feminist leader, though of lesser note.
Upon David Munson Osborne's death in 1886, Thomas Osborne became president of his family's manufacturing company, DM Osborne & Co. He married Agnes Lithgow Devens in 1886. His wife died of cancer just a few months after giving birth to their fourth son on March 26, 1896.
Thomas Mott Osborne served on the Auburn School Board from 1885 to 1896, becoming the youngest chairman in its history. In 1896, he became a trustee on the board of the George Junior Republic, a self-governing youth colony, and soon its chairman, just in time to lead a campaign to prevent New York State from shutting it down.
Osborne was elected mayor of Auburn in 1902, serving two terms. He was known to disguise himself and visit local taverns to eavesdrop on conversations to get a sense of public opinion.
By 1903 DM Osborne & Co. grew to become North America's third largest producer of agricultural implements. In 1903, the family sold the company to the International Harvester Trust, leaving Osborne to pursue social reform and public service. International Harvester took over management in 1905.
In 1905 he launched a daily newspaper, the Auburn Daily Citizen, as a progressive voice to counter the city's dominant daily, the Auburn Daily Advertiser. The Osborne family still edits and owns "The Nation", first published during the 1836 abolitionist movement.
In 1907, Governor Charles Evans Hughes selected Osborne to serve as upstate commissioner on the state's first New York Public Service Commission. At one point, to determine whether railroads could safely trim staff as they proposed, Osborne dressed as a hobo and rode the rails and was once arrested by police in Syracuse, New York in the course of his sleuthing. His report to the commission, however, was instrumental in persuading the panel to order railroad staff maintained. However, his propensity to travel in a variety of odd disguises and his close relationship with Louis Schaedeline, a handyman with whom Osborne was rumored to be having a homosexual affair, proved fatal to Osborne's future political ambitions.
Between 1910 and 1912, Osborne teamed with Franklin Delano Roosevelt, then a New York State senator, and Louis McHenry Howe in unsuccessful efforts to reform the New York State Democratic Party. FDR, Howe, and Osborne were upstate New York's best-known foes of Tammany Hall and William Randolph Hearst. But after the 1912 national Democratic Convention, where the three worked for the presidential nomination of Woodrow Wilson, Wilson ignored their faction of the state Democratic party and instead selected the larger, Tammany Hall-led wing of the Democratic party to represent the state. Osborne quit politics in disgust.
In 1912, sick in bed, Osborne was inspired to read My Life In Prison by Donald Lowrie, a former inmate of San Quentin prison in California. The following year, he persuaded New York Governor William Sulzer to appoint him chairman of a new State Commission on Prison Reform. On behalf of the commission that year he entered the Auburn Prison, now Auburn Correctional Facility, in prison garb insisting to the administration that he be treated like any other prisoner. On September 29, Osborne began six days of imprisonment as "Tom Brown," Inmate 33,333X. He recorded his experiences in Within Prison Walls. Its publication in 1914 made him the most prominent prison reform crusader of his day.
Warden of Sing Sing
Osborne was appointed Warden of Sing Sing prison in Ossining, New York, on December 1, 1914, replacing Judge George S. Weed. After addressing the prisoners in chapel, he undertook a week's stay inside the prison, again experiencing the prison from the prisoners' point of view. He next stunned the guards and prisoners by visiting the prison yard unarmed and unescorted. He established a system of internal self-rule called the "Mutual Welfare League" within the prison and quickly won enthusiastic support from both guards and prisoners.
His principal opponents were prisoners who had lived comfortably within the system before his reforms, by intimidating others or using their financial resources to bribe guards for privileges. One of these, a former Manhattan banker in prison for larceny, used his financial and political connections to instigate a rigged "investigation" of Osborne's administration. When he was indicted for perjury, neglect of duty, and "unlawful [sexual] acts with inmates," Osborne fought back with a speaking tour of the state. Carnegie Hall saw two mass meetings supporting his defense, one attended by the retired president of Harvard University Charles William Eliot. The prison guards wrote a letter in support as well. After the judge in the case directed a verdict of acquittal, Osborne returned to Sing Sing in triumph. The front page of the New York Times described the celebration at the prison: "Convicts' Carnival Welcomes Osborne; Prisoners, in Costume and Wild with Joy, Give Pageant for Him at Sing Sing, Hundreds of Spectators."
He resigned his position as Sing Sing's warden later in 1916, tired of battling his superiors and New York State Governor Charles S. Whitman.
Commander at Portsmouth
In 1916 Josephus Daniels, the Secretary of the Navy at the likely suggestion of Assistant Secretary Franklin Delano Roosevelt, an ally of Osborne from his years in New York State reform politics, commissioned a report on conditions at the Portsmouth Naval Prison in Kittery, Maine. Osborne again investigated conditions by living inside the prison like any other inmate. He found a facility in desperate need of his reforms. In a speech at the Twentieth Century Club in New York City, he denounced "degrading" uniforms and "absurd" procedures: "When the men return from working on the seawall, a place where they could not possibly obtain anything but sand, boulders and seaweed, they are stripped and searched."
In July 1917, now a lieutenant commander in the U.S. Navy, he took up the position of commander of the Portsmouth Naval Prison, a post he held for two and a half years. It was during these years Osborne, as senior officer, met and mentored Austin MacCormick. Austin MacCormick would continue after Osborne's death in 1926 to publish his seminal work, "The Education of Adult Prisoners" in 1931. MacCormick would also become Dean of Criminology at U.C. Berkeley and executive director of Osborne Association, a prison reform organization still active to this day.
During his tenure at Portsmouth, Osborne also met and became a long-term mentor to prisoner and future author Victor Folke Nelson. In 1921, it would be Osborne who would convince Nelson to turn himself in after escaping from Charlestown State Prison in Boston.
His books, public speaking and notoriety helped end the so-called "rule of silence," floggings and other prisoner abuses common in U.S. prisons at the time. But Osborne's cherished prisoner self-government plan, the "Mutual Welfare League," vanished soon after his death in 1926. His initial experiments had been greeted by the press largely with derision, but over the course of his life he won grudging admiration from both the press and the public.
In 1933, the Welfare League Association and several other organizations Osborne had created were merged and reorganized as Osborne Association. The Association now works at every point of the criminal justice system, from arrest and "pre-entry," to programs in prison and in the community following release. True to Osborne's founding spirit, the Association's 25 programs are all designed to offer individuals the opportunity, the tools, and the support to build or rebuild their lives.
- "T. Mott Osborne, Reformer, is Dead. Body of Former Warden of Sing Sing, Heart Victim, Found in Auburn (N.Y.) Street. He Championed Prisoners. After Occupying Cell Himself, He Began Reform Drive. First Was Active in Politics". Associated Press in the New York Times. October 21, 1926. Retrieved 2011-05-04.
Thomas Mott Osborne, noted prison reform advocate and former Warden of Sing Sing Prison, dropped dead on the street here tonight. ...
- New York Times, July 8, 1934
- New York Times, Oct. 21, 1926
- Brian, 90
- Fenster 2009, p. 56–58. sfn error: no target: CITEREFFenster2009 (help)
- Mitchell Kennerley, 1912
- "Who We Are". Osborne Association., accessed October 18, 2021
- "T. M. Osborne To Be Warden At Sing Sing. Noted Prison Reformer Will Take Office on Dec. 1. Approved by Glynn and Whitman. Big Shake-Up Predicted. Warden-Elect Disapproves of Capital Punishment, but Would Make Executions 'Public Exhibitions". New York Times. November 20, 1914. Retrieved 2011-05-04.
Thomas Mott Osborne of Auburn, N.Y., retired manufacturer, world traveler, lecturer, writer, and prison reformer, has accepted the offer of John B. Riley, State Superintendent of Prisons, of the post of the Warden of Sing Sing Prison. He will take office on Dec. 1, and will relieve ex-Judge George S. Weed, who was temporarily assigned to Sing Sing, when Warden Thomas J. McCormick was ousted on Oct. 30 as the result of the Sullivan scandal. ...
- "Osborne In At Sing Sing. New Warden Outlines Plans. Makes C.H. Johnson Assistant" (PDF). New York Times. December 1, 1914. Retrieved 2013-12-15.
Thomas Mott Osborne took formal charge of Sing Sing at midnight, relieving George S. Weed, who acted since the removal of Warden McCormack, Mr. Osborne came from Little Falls in an automobile with two other men, one of whom was Charles H. Johnson, who has been named by the Warden as his assistant.
- Salman, Michael (2009). McCoy, Alfred; Scarano, Francisco (eds.). "The Prison That Makes Men Free": The Iwahig Penal Colony and the Simulacra of the American State in the Philippines, in Colonial Crucible: Empire in the Making of the Modern American State. Madison: The University of Wisconsin Press. p. 118. ISBN 9780299231040.
- New York Times, July 17, 1916
- Brian, 83-110
- New York Times, Dec 4, 1916
- "Thomas Mott Osborne and Paul Revere Frothingham letters to Victor Folke Nelson.." Retrieved on January 30, 2022.
- Prison Days and Nights, by Victor F. Nelson (New York: Garden City Publishing Co., Inc., 1936)
- "Osborne Brings Noted Escaped Convict Back to State Prison Here". The Boston Herald. September 12, 1921.
- Merrill, Anthony. "The Man Who Broke Charlestown". Boston Sunday Advertiser Green Magazine. December 17, 1939.
- "Who We Are". Osborne Association.
- (1914) Within Prison Walls: Being a Narrative of Personal Experience During a Week of Voluntary Confinement in the State Prison at Auburn, New York at Project Gutenberg
- Society and Prisons (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1916)
- Prisons and Common Sense (Philadelphia: J.B. Lippincott Company, 1924)
- Denis Brian, Sing Sing: The Inside Story of a Notorious Prison (Amherst, NY: Prometheus Press, 2005)
- Rudolph Chamberlain, There Is No Truce: A Life of Thomas Mott Osborne (1935)
- Julie M. Fenster (2009). FDR's Shadow: Louis Howe, the Force that Shaped Franklin and Eleanor Roosevelt. Palgrave Macmillan. ISBN 9780230609105.
- Jack M. Holl, Juvenile Reform in the Progressive Era (Cornell University Press, 1971)
- Rebecca M. McLennan, The Crisis of Imprisonment: Protest, Politics, and the Making of the American Penal State, 1776-1941 (Cambridge University Press, 2008)
- New York Times: "Condemns Navy Prison" Dec. 4, 1916, accessed Dec. 7, 2009
- New York Times: "Convicts' Carnival Welcomes Osborne" July 17, 1916, accessed Dec. 7, 2009
- New York Times: "Costume Welcome to Warden Osborne" Sept. 1, 1915, accessed Dec. 7, 2009
- New York Times: "Osborne in riumph and Defeat" July 8, 1934, accessed Dec. 7, 2009
- New York Times: "Roosevelt Charges Libel; Orders Suit" Oct 26, 1920, accessed Dec. 6, 2009
- New York Times: "T. Mott Osborne, Reformer, is Dead" Oct. 21, 1926, accessed Dec. 6, 2009
- Frederick R-L Osborne, "Introduction to excerpts from Thomas Mott Osborne's Within These Walls"
- Alfred Brooks Rollins and Alfred B. Rollins, Jr., Roosevelt and Howe (Transaction Publishers, 2001)
- Syracuse University Library: Osborne Family Papers
- Syracuse University Library: Biographical History
- Frank Tannenbaum, Osborne of Sing Sing (The University of North Carolina Press, 1933)