Allegations of support system in Pakistan for Osama bin Laden
Allegations of a support system in Pakistan for Osama bin Laden have been made both before and after Osama bin Laden was found living in a compound in Abbottabad, Pakistan and was killed by a team of United States Navy SEALs on May 2, 2011. The United States had direct evidence that the ISI chief, Lt. Gen. Ahmed Shuja Pasha, knew of Bin Laden’s presence in Abbottabad, Pakistan.
The compound itself was located just half a mile from Pakistan’s premier military training academy in Abbottabad.
In the aftermath of bin Laden's capture and death, U.S. President Barack Obama asked Pakistan to investigate the network that sustained bin Laden. "We think that there had to be some sort of support network for bin Laden inside of Pakistan," Obama said in a "60 Minutes" interview with CBS news. He also added that U.S. was not sure "who or what that support network was." In addition to this, in an interview to Time magazine, CIA Director Leon Panetta stated that U.S. officials did not alert Pakistani counterparts to the raid because they feared the terrorist leader would be warned.
According to Fred Burton, vice-president of the global intelligence firm Stratfor, officials of ISI, Pakistani military, along with one retired Pakistani military general, had knowledge of the arrangements made for bin Laden and safe house. Bin Laden's compound was razed that day at his Abbottabad safe house.
David Ignatius in Washington Post referred to the claim of the former ISI chief General Ziauddin Butt that the Abbottabad compound was used by Intelligence Bureau and noted that a report in the Pakistani press in December had quoted him as saying that Osama's stay at Abbottabad was arranged by Brigadier (retired) Ijaz Shah, senior ISI officer and the head of the Intelligence Bureau during 2004-2008, on Pervez Musharraf's orders. Later Butt denied making any such statement.
|“||"It was decided that any effort to work with the Pakistanis could jeopardize the mission. They might alert the targets."||”|
Critics cited the very close proximity (800 yards) of bin Laden's heavily fortified compound (a custom-built luxury complex) to the Pakistan Military Academy, Pakistan's "West Point", and that the U.S. chose not to notify Pakistani authorities before the operation, and the alleged double standards of Pakistan regarding the perpetrators of the 2008 Mumbai attacks. U.S. government files leaked by Wikileaks disclosed that American diplomats were told that Pakistani security services were tipping off bin Laden every time U.S. forces approached. Pakistan's Inter-Services Intelligence (ISI) also helped smuggle al Qaeda militants into Afghanistan to fight NATO troops. According to the leaked files, in December 2009, the government of Tajikistan had told U.S. officials that many in Pakistan were aware of bin Laden's whereabouts.
″Obviously the concern has always been how could a compound like this, how could bin Laden be in an area where there were military establishments, where we could see the military operating and not have them know.″
Regarding US's decision to withhold intelligence about the raid from Pakistan, he said,
“The concern we had is that...we had provided intelligence to them with regards to other areas and unfortunately, for one way or another, it got leaked to the individuals we were trying to go after, so as a result of that we were concerned that if we were going to perform a sensitive mission like this, we had to do it on our own.”
Talking about the support network Panetta stated that some "lower rank" officers in the military knew where Bin Laden was hiding. The defense secretary said, “Well, you know, these situations sometimes, the leadership within Pakistan [sic] is obviously not aware of certain things and yet people lower down in the military establishment find it very well, they`ve been aware of it, ...But bottom line is that we have not had evidence that provides that direct link.”
|“||“It is inconceivable that bin Laden did not have support system in the country that allowed him to remain there for extended period of time,”||”|
Husain Haqqani the former-Pakistan Ambassador to the United States, who earlier said both countries "cooperated in making sure" that the operation leading to bin Laden's death was "successful", has admitted that Osama bin laden indeed had a support system in Pakistan, albeit without the Pakistani government being privy to this fact.
"Obviously, bin Laden did have a support system (in Pakistan). The issue was that support system within the government and the state of Pakistan or within the society of Pakistan, ...We all know that there are people in Pakistan who share the same belief system as bin Laden and other extremists... So that is a fact, that there are people who probably protected him... We did not know. We had no knowledge [about Bin Laden]. And if we had knowledge, we would have acted upon it long ago" —Mr. Haqqani said in an interview.
A Pakistani official, speaking anonymously, said "We assisted only in terms of authorization of the helicopter flights in our airspace" and that "we did not want anything to do with such an operation in case something went wrong."
U.S. Senator Joe Lieberman, Chairman of the Senate Homeland Security Committee, said "This is going to be a time of real pressure on Pakistan to basically prove to us that they didn’t know that bin Laden was there". John O. Brennan, Obama's chief counterterrorism advisor, said that it was inconceivable that bin Laden did not have support from within Pakistan. He further stated: "People have been referring to this as hiding in plain sight. We are looking at how he was able to hide out there for so long." Senator Dianne Feinstein said that "it's hard for me to understand how the Pakistanis ... would not know what was going on inside the compound", and that top Pakistan officials may be "walking both sides of the street." Senator Lindsey Graham questioned, "How could [bin Laden] be in such a compound without being noticed?", raising suspicions that Pakistan was either uncommitted in the fight against Islamist militants or was actively sheltering them while pledging to fight them. A Pakistani intelligence official said that they had passed on raw phone tap data to U.S. that led to the operation, but had failed to analyze this data themselves. Carl Levin who is chairman United States Senate Committee on Armed Services stated that he believes Pakistani officials knew the location of bin Laden and had "no doubt" they also know the location of other senior al-Qaeda operatives. He said Pakistan's intelligence and army have "got a lot of explaining to do," given that bin Laden was holed up in such a large house with surrounding buildings, the fact that its residents took the unusual step of burning their garbage and avoiding any trash collection. He further stated, "It's hard to imagine that the military or police did not have any ideas what was going on inside of that." After the raid, the U.S. asked that Pakistan identify its top intelligence operatives as it tried to establish if any of them had contact with bin Laden in the last few years.
|“||"Bin Laden was the ‘Golden Goose’ that the army had kept under its watch but which, to its chagrin, has now been stolen from under its nose. Until then, the thinking had been to trade in the Goose at the right time for the right price, either in the form of dollars or political concessions"||”|
WikiLeaks had revealed that a US diplomatic dispatch told the Americans that "many" inside Pakistan knew where bin Laden was. The document stated that "In Pakistan, Osama Bin Laden wasn't an invisible man, and many knew his whereabouts in North Waziristan, but whenever security forces attempted a raid on his hideouts, the enemy received warning of their approach from sources in the security forces."
Indian Minister for Home Affairs P. Chidambaram said that bin Laden hiding "deep inside" Pakistan was a matter of grave concern for India, and showed that "many of the perpetrators of the Mumbai terror attacks, including the controllers and the handlers of the terrorists who actually carried out the attack, continue to be sheltered in Pakistan". He called on Pakistan to arrest them.
In October 2011, former Pakistani Army Chief, General Ziauddin Butt has asserted that Osama bin Laden was kept in an Intelligence Bureau safe house in Abbottabad by the then Director-General of the Intelligence Bureau of Pakistan (2004–2008), Brigadier Ijaz Shah. According to him, this had occurred with the "full knowledge" of former army chief General Pervez Musharraf and possibly that of current Chief of Army Staff (COAS) General Ashfaq Pervez Kayani.
According to a police report dated Jan. 17, 2012 Osama Bin Laden’s youngest wife Amal Ahmad Abdul Fatah claims that except for the eight or nine months just after 9/11, Laden skipped from home to home in Peshawar, Swat and Haripur, Pakistan before settling in Abbottabad for about the last six years of his life.
In a 2005 interview, the then-president Musharraf emphatically denied bin Laden was in Pakistan, stating "One thing is very sure, let me assure you, that we are not going to hide him for a rainy day and then release him to take advantage."
Pakistan's president Asif Ali Zardari denied that his country's security forces may have sheltered Osama bin Laden, and called any supposed support for bin Laden by the Pakistani government "baseless speculation." The Pakistani foreign office issued a statement that "categorically denies" media reports that Pakistan's leadership, "civil as well as military, had any prior knowledge of the U.S. operation against Osama bin Laden."
Pakistan's former president Pervez Musharraf denied that officials in his country were responsible, calling bin Laden's presence in Pakistan a "blunder". Musharraf said instead that there was a possibility that rogue lower-level members of Pakistan's intelligence and military may have had knowledge of bin Laden's location. He conceded they might have known during the last year of his presidency six years ago, and said there ought to be an investigation.
"It's really appalling that he was there and nobody knew. I'm certainly appalled that I didn't know and that intelligence people from that time onward didn't know for 6 years that he was inside. And there is no excuse for this great, massive slip-up. And an investigation is in order and people must be punished for this big lapse."
"As a policy, the army and the ISI fighting terrorism and extremism, al Qaeda, Taliban. But rogue element within is a possibility," he said.
The head of Pakistan's powerful Directorate of Inter-Services Intelligence (ISI) Lieut. Gen. Ahmed Shuja Pasha, the ISI chief, conceded that Osama bin Laden's presence in Pakistan had been an "intelligence failure" but denied the ISI could have had any role in hiding Bin Laden. "If we had shielded Osama bin Laden, why would we have killed and arrested so many al-Qaeda leaders?" he stated "Would we have hidden such a large target in such an exposed area? Without any guards or escape route?"
Regardless of Pakistan's claims about their previous conduct, many outside observers have raised ongoing concerns that most of the people jailed by them since Bin Laden's killing have been those who were trying to help capture him, rather than those who helped shield him.
One such incident would be when Dr. Shakil Afridi who assisted the CIA in the hunt for Osama bin Laden, was arrested several weeks after the killing of bin Laden. A Pakistani court imposed a 33-year sentence Wednesday on the doctor. The doctor was eventually tried under a tribal judicial system that denies the accused the right to have an attorney or to present evidence. According to Washington post, the Doctor could have received the death penalty if he had been tried under normal Pakistani law.
″It is now indisputable that militancy in Pakistan is supported by the ISI (Inter-Services Intelligence). Pakistan's fight against militancy is bogus. It's just to extract money from America,″ Dr Shakil Afridi stated in an interview with Fox News. He was interviewed from inside Peshawar Central Jail, where he is being held by Pakistani authorities. According to his statements, the Pakistani authorities said, ‘The Americans are our worst enemies, worse than the Indians,’ and he suffered ′crippling torture′ and ′psychological abuse′ during the 12 months he was held by Pakistani spy agency for helping the US. He further revealed the fact that the ISI is in collusion with terrorists.
Abbottabad Commission report
A judge-led inquiry set up by Pakistani government in 2011, based on interviews with 201 sources found there was evidence of incompetence at every level in the Pakistan's intelligence and security services and it did not rule out the involvement of rogue elements within the Pakistani intelligence service. The 336-page Abbottabad Commission Report, obtained in July 2013 by Al Jazeera, blasted Pakistan's civilian and military leadership for “gross incompetence” over the bin Laden affair. It found that by 2005, Pakistani intelligence was no longer actively pursuing intelligence that could lead to his capture. The report called the handling of the bin Laden situation a "natural disaster" and even called on the leadership to apologize to the people of Pakistan for their “dereliction of duty.” Al Jazeera reported that the government’s intention in conducting the inquiry was likely aimed at “regime continuance, when the regime is desperate to distance itself from any responsibility for the national disaster that occurred on its watch” and was likely “a reluctant response to an overwhelming public and parliamentary demand.” Lack of intelligence on bid Laden's nine-year residence in the country was blamed on “Government Implosion Syndrome.” Lack of knowledge of a CIA support network without Pakistan being aware was “a case of collective and sustained dereliction of duty by the political, military, and intelligence leadership." Although the report focused on the night of the raid, it had other findings. One was that bid Laden had been living in Pakistan since 2002, after surviving the Battle of Tora Bora. Another was that he and some family members moved into the compound in Abbottabad in 2005, the same year Pakistani intelligence stopped independently looking for him.
Statements from other countries
- Afghanistan: Defense ministry spokesman said that ISI must have known that bin Laden was in Abbottabad prior to the U.S. killing him. The former chief of Afghan Intelligence, Amrullah Saleh, said he had told Pervez Musharraf in 2007 that bin Laden was hiding near Abbottabad, but Musharraf angrily shot down his claim.
- Australia: Prime Minister Julia Gillard on May 3, 2011 said bin Laden "absolutely" had a support network in Pakistan.
- India: Minister for Home Affairs, P. Chidambaram said that bin Laden hiding "deep inside" Pakistan was a matter of grave concern for India, and showed that "many of the perpetrators of the Mumbai terror attacks, including the controllers and the handlers of the terrorists who actually carried out the attack, continue to be sheltered in Pakistan". He also called on Pakistan to arrest them.
- France: Foreign Minister Alain Juppé said "I find it a little difficult to imagine that the presence of someone like bin Laden in a big compound in a relatively small town, even if located at 80 km from the center of Islamabad, could go completely unnoticed. [...] Pakistan's position [...] lacks clarity in our view, I hope that we will have more clarity."
- Tajikistan: According to U.S. documents leaked by Wikileaks in December 2009, the Government of Tajikistan had warned the U.S. that efforts to apprehend bin Laden were being thwarted by Pakistani intelligence.
- United Kingdom: Prime Minister David Cameron stated
"The fact that Bin Laden was living in a large house in a populated area suggests that he must have had a support network in Pakistan. We don't currently know the extent of that network, so it is right that we ask searching questions about it. And we will."
Impact on U.S.–Pakistan relations
The U.S. suspended about a third of its $2.7 billion annual defense aid to Pakistan.
|Wikinews has related news: U.S. did not inform Pakistan of bin Laden mission because of suspicions he was being harbored by government|
- Pakistan – United States relations
- Reactions to the death of Osama bin Laden#Pakistan
- Reactions to the death of Osama bin Laden#Pro-bin Laden rallies
- Pakistan and state sponsored terrorism
- Carlotta Gall (March 19, 2014). "What Pakistan Knew About Bin Laden". http://www.nytimes.com (The New York Times Company.). Retrieved March 19, 2014.
- Sears, Neil; Shipman, Tim (May 8, 2011). "Osama Bin Laden dead: Obama says compound raid was 'longest 40 minutes of my life' | Mail Online". London: Dailymail.co.uk. Retrieved May 12, 2011.
- "US presses Pakistan on Bin Laden". BBC. May 8, 2011. Archived from the original on 9 May 2011. Retrieved May 8, 2011.
- "Pakistan questions need answers, top Obama aide says". CNN. May 20, 2011.
- "REVEALED! The truth behind Osama's ISI connection". Rediff News. Retrieved 10 August 2012.
- Ignatius, David (February 19, 2012). "Pakistan and Osama bin Laden". Washington Post. Retrieved 10 August 2012.
- Ashraf Javed (16 February 2012). "Ijaz Shah to sue Ziauddin Butt". The Nation. Retrieved 14 November 2012.
- "CIA Chief: Pakistan Would Have Jeopardized Operation", Time, May 3, 2011, archived from the original on 4 May 2011, retrieved May 5, 2011
- "News Transcript: CBC Television Interview with Secretary Panetta". Defense.gov. Retrieved 2012-11-21.
- PTI Apr 2, 2012, 11.10PM IST (2012-04-02). "Pakistan considers India as 'threat' but US differs: Leon Panetta - Economic Times". Articles.economictimes.indiatimes.com. Retrieved 2012-11-21.
- "Inconceivable that Osama had no support system in Pakistan: U.S.". The Hindu (Chennai, India). May 3, 2011. Retrieved 10 August 2012.
- "U.S. troops kill Osama bin Laden in Pakistan". CNN. May 2, 2011. Archived from the original on 5 May 2011. Retrieved May 7, 2011.
- "Osama Bin Laden had support system in Pakistan: envoy". Indian Express. Retrieved 2012-11-17.
- Walsh, Nick Paton (May 2, 2011). "Official: Pakistan had but didn't probe data that helped make raid". CNN. Retrieved May 7, 2011.
- "Pakistan government knew where Osama was: Carl Levin". The Express Tribune. May 6, 2011. Retrieved May 7, 2011.
- "Pakistan's president denies harboring bin Laden". Recordnet.com. Retrieved May 12, 2011.
- Cooper, Helene (May 6, 2011). "Probing Link to Bin Laden, U.S. Tells Pakistan to Name Agents". The New York Times. Archived from the original on 7 May 2011. Retrieved May 7, 2011.
- The curious case of Osama bin Laden, May 3, 2011, archived from the original on 6 May 2011, retrieved May 10, 2011
- "Osama bin Laden killed near Pakistan's West Point. Was he really hidden?". The Christian Science Monitor.
- "Pak security always tipped off Osama". Daily Star.
- Wright, Tom (May 2, 2011). "India Uses Osama Death to Pressure Pakistan". The Wall Street Journal.
- Smith, Graeme (May 3, 2011). "Bin Laden given haven by militants linked to Pakistani security forces". The Globe and Mail (Canada). Archived from the original on 4 May 2011. Retrieved May 4, 2011.
- McDermott, Roger. "The Jamestown Foundation: Former Pakistan Army Chief Reveals Intelligence Bureau Harbored Bin Laden in Abbottabad". Jamestown.org. Retrieved 2013-05-01.
- "Osama Bin Laden hid in Pakistan, not caves, for decade says wife". Truth Dive. Retrieved 10 August 2012.
- Correspondent: Steve Kroft, Producer: Carol Kopp (September 25, 2005). "The Search For Bin Laden". 60 Minutes. CBS. http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2005/09/23/60minutes/main881268.shtml. Retrieved May 3, 2011.
- Toosi, Nahal (September 11, 2001). "The Canadian Press: Pakistan's president dismisses suspicions that his country was sheltering bin Laden". Google.com. Retrieved May 3, 2011.
- Your name:. "Zardari defends Pakistan over bin Laden intel". Emirates 24/7. Retrieved May 3, 2011.
- Brian Ross. "Osama Bin Laden Killed: U.S. Intelligence Probes Possible Pakistani Support System". ABC.
- Correspondent: Christopher Cuomo, Producer: Eamon McNiff (May 11, 2011). "Musharraf: If U.S. Alienates Pakistan, They Will "Lose"". ABC World News. ABC. http://abcnews.go.com/TheLaw/osama-bin-laden-pakistan-president-pervez-musharraf-concedes/story?id=13572519. Retrieved May 13, 2011.
- "Berating General Pasha: Pakistan's Spy Chief Gets a Tongue-Lashing". Yahoo!.
- "Pakistan jails doctor who helped CIA find Bin Laden". BBC. May 23, 2012.
- "EXCLUSIVE: Jailed doc who helped nail Bin Laden warns Pakistan sees U.S. as 'worst enemy'". Fox News. September 10, 2012. Retrieved 2012-11-18.
- "Bin Laden's life on the run revealed by Pakistani inquiry". Reuters. July 9, 2013.
- Leaked Pakistan report details bin Laden's secret life - Militarytimes.com, 8 July 2013
- "Afghanistan: Pakistan Must Have Known bin Laden Was Living in Abbottabad". Voice of America. May 4, 2011. Retrieved May 4, 2011.
- Boone, Jon (May 5, 2011). "Osama bin Laden death: Afghanistan 'had Abbottabad lead four years ago'". The Guardian (London). Archived from the original on 10 May 2011. Retrieved May 8, 2011.
- "Osama bin Laden has support network in Pakistan: Australian PM". News.xinhuanet.com. May 3, 2011. Retrieved May 12, 2011.
- Wright, Tom (May 2, 2011). "India Uses Osama Death to Pressure Pakistan". The Wall Street Journal.
- "Interview lors de la journée de la liberté de la presse" [Interview during the press freedom day] (in French). French Foreign Ministry. May 3, 2011. Retrieved May 29, 2011.
- Ross, Tim (May 2, 2011). "WikiLeaks: Osama bin Laden 'protected' by Pakistani security". The Guardian (London). Archived from the original on 7 May 2011. Retrieved May 7, 2011.
- Watt, Nicholas (May 3, 2011). "Osama bin Laden must have had support network in Pakistan – Cameron". The Guardian (London). Retrieved May 4, 2011.
- Woodcock, Andrew (May 2, 2011). "MP 'shocked' at bin Laden Pakistan discovery". The Independent (London). Retrieved May 4, 2011.
- Daya Gamage (2011-07-28). "Asia-Pacific region significant to global security and prosperity – Admiral Mike Mullen". Asian Tribune. Retrieved 2012-11-17.
- David Jackson (May 8, 2011). "Obama: Bin Laden must have had Pakistani 'support network'". USA TODAY. Retrieved May 9, 2011.