In 1922 the American League created a new award to honor "the baseball player who is of the greatest all-around service to his club".[12] Voters were required to select one (and only one) player from each team and player-managers and prior award winners were disqualified. These flaws resulted in the award being dropped after 1928. The National League award, without these restrictions, lasted from 1924 to 1929.[2]
| Year |
National League |
American League |
| 1931 |
Frankie Frisch†, St. Louis Cardinals, 2B |
Lefty Grove†, Philadelphia Athletics, P |
| 1932 |
Chuck Klein†, Philadelphia Phillies, OF |
Jimmie Foxx†, Philadelphia Athletics, 1B |
| 1933 |
Carl Hubbell†, New York Giants, P |
Jimmie Foxx†, Philadelphia Athletics, 1B |
| 1934 |
Dizzy Dean†, St. Louis Cardinals, P |
Mickey Cochrane†, Detroit Tigers, C |
| 1935 |
Gabby Hartnett†, Chicago Cubs, C |
Hank Greenberg†§, Detroit Tigers, 1B |
| 1936 |
Carl Hubbell†§, New York Giants, P |
Lou Gehrig†, New York Yankees, 1B |
| 1937 |
Joe Medwick†, St. Louis Cardinals, OF |
Charlie Gehringer†, Detroit Tigers, 2B |
| 1938 |
Ernie Lombardi†, Cincinnati Reds, C |
Jimmie Foxx†, Boston Red Sox, 1B |
| 1939 |
Bucky Walters, Cincinnati Reds, P |
Joe DiMaggio†, New York Yankees, OF |
| 1940 |
Frank McCormick, Cincinnati Reds, 1B |
Hank Greenberg†, Detroit Tigers, OF |
| 1941 |
Dolph Camilli, Brooklyn Dodgers, 1B |
Joe DiMaggio†, New York Yankees, OF |
| 1942 |
Mort Cooper, St. Louis Cardinals, P |
Joe Gordon†, New York Yankees, 2B |
| 1943 |
Stan Musial†, St. Louis Cardinals, OF |
Spud Chandler, New York Yankees, P |
| 1944 |
Marty Marion, St. Louis Cardinals, SS |
Hal Newhouser†, Detroit Tigers, P |
| 1945 |
Phil Cavarretta, Chicago Cubs, 1B |
Hal Newhouser†, Detroit Tigers, P |
| 1946 |
Stan Musial†, St. Louis Cardinals, 1B |
Ted Williams†, Boston Red Sox, OF |
| 1947 |
Bob Elliott, Boston Braves, 3B |
Joe DiMaggio†, New York Yankees, OF |
| 1948 |
Stan Musial†, St. Louis Cardinals, OF |
Lou Boudreau†, Cleveland Indians, SS |
| 1949 |
Jackie Robinson†, Brooklyn Dodgers, 2B |
Ted Williams†, Boston Red Sox, OF |
| 1950 |
Jim Konstanty, Philadelphia Phillies, P |
Phil Rizzuto†, New York Yankees, SS |
| 1951 |
Roy Campanella†, Brooklyn Dodgers, C |
Yogi Berra†, New York Yankees, C |
| 1952 |
Hank Sauer, Chicago Cubs, OF |
Bobby Shantz, Philadelphia Athletics, P |
| 1953 |
Roy Campanella†, Brooklyn Dodgers, C |
Al Rosen§, Cleveland Indians, 3B |
| 1954 |
Willie Mays†, New York Giants, OF |
Yogi Berra†, New York Yankees, C |
| 1955 |
Roy Campanella†, Brooklyn Dodgers, C |
Yogi Berra†, New York Yankees, C |
| 1956 |
Don Newcombe, Brooklyn Dodgers, P |
Mickey Mantle†§, New York Yankees, OF |
| 1957 |
Hank Aaron†, Milwaukee Braves, OF |
Mickey Mantle†, New York Yankees, OF |
| 1958 |
Ernie Banks†, Chicago Cubs, SS |
Jackie Jensen, Boston Red Sox, OF |
| 1959 |
Ernie Banks†, Chicago Cubs, SS |
Nellie Fox†, Chicago White Sox, 2B |
| 1960 |
Dick Groat, Pittsburgh Pirates, SS |
Roger Maris, New York Yankees, OF |
| 1961 |
Frank Robinson†§, Cincinnati Reds, OF |
Roger Maris, New York Yankees, OF |
| 1962 |
Maury Wills, Los Angeles Dodgers, SS |
Mickey Mantle†, New York Yankees, OF |
| 1963 |
Sandy Koufax†, Los Angeles Dodgers, P |
Elston Howard, New York Yankees, C |
| 1964 |
Ken Boyer, St. Louis Cardinals, 3B |
Brooks Robinson†, Baltimore Orioles, 3B |
| 1965 |
Willie Mays†, San Francisco Giants, OF |
Zoilo Versalles, Minnesota Twins, SS |
| 1966 |
Roberto Clemente†, Pittsburgh Pirates, OF |
Frank Robinson†§, Baltimore Orioles, OF |
| 1967 |
Orlando Cepeda†§, St. Louis Cardinals, 1B |
Carl Yastrzemski†, Boston Red Sox, OF |
| 1968 |
Bob Gibson†, St. Louis Cardinals, P |
Denny McLain§, Detroit Tigers, P |
| 1969 |
Willie McCovey†, San Francisco Giants, 1B |
Harmon Killebrew†, Minnesota Twins, 3B |
| 1970 |
Johnny Bench†, Cincinnati Reds, C |
Boog Powell, Baltimore Orioles, 1B |
| 1971 |
Joe Torre, St. Louis Cardinals, 3B |
Vida Blue, Oakland Athletics, P |
| 1972 |
Johnny Bench†, Cincinnati Reds, C |
Dick Allen, Chicago White Sox, 1B |
| 1973 |
Pete Rose, Cincinnati Reds, OF |
Reggie Jackson†§, Oakland Athletics, OF |
| 1974 |
Steve Garvey, Los Angeles Dodgers, 1B |
Jeff Burroughs, Texas Rangers, OF |
| 1975 |
Joe Morgan†, Cincinnati Reds, 2B |
Fred Lynn, Boston Red Sox, OF |
| 1976 |
Joe Morgan†, Cincinnati Reds, 2B |
Thurman Munson, New York Yankees, C |
| 1977 |
George Foster, Cincinnati Reds, OF |
Rod Carew†, Minnesota Twins, 1B |
| 1978 |
Dave Parker, Pittsburgh Pirates, OF |
Jim Rice†, Boston Red Sox, OF |
| 1979 |
Keith Hernandez, St. Louis Cardinals, 1B |
Don Baylor, California Angels, DH |
| Willie Stargell†, Pittsburgh Pirates, 1B |
| 1980 |
Mike Schmidt†§, Philadelphia Phillies, 3B |
George Brett, Kansas City Royals, 3B |
| 1981 |
Mike Schmidt†, Philadelphia Phillies, 3B |
Rollie Fingers†, Milwaukee Brewers, P |
| 1982 |
Dale Murphy, Atlanta Braves, OF |
Robin Yount†, Milwaukee Brewers, SS |
| 1983 |
Dale Murphy, Atlanta Braves, OF |
Cal Ripken, Jr.†, Baltimore Orioles, SS |
| 1984 |
Ryne Sandberg†, Chicago Cubs, 2B |
Willie Hernandez, Detroit Tigers, P |
| 1985 |
Willie McGee, St. Louis Cardinals, OF |
Don Mattingly, New York Yankees, 1B |
| 1986 |
Mike Schmidt†, Philadelphia Phillies, 3B |
Roger Clemens, Boston Red Sox, P |
| 1987 |
Andre Dawson, Chicago Cubs, OF |
George Bell, Toronto Blue Jays, OF |
| 1988 |
Kirk Gibson§, Los Angeles Dodgers, OF |
José Canseco, Oakland Athletics, OF |
| 1989 |
Kevin Mitchell, San Francisco Giants, OF |
Robin Yount†, Milwaukee Brewers, OF |
| 1990 |
Barry Bonds, Pittsburgh Pirates, OF |
Rickey Henderson†, Oakland Athletics, OF |
| 1991 |
Terry Pendleton, Atlanta Braves, 3B |
Cal Ripken, Jr.†, Baltimore Orioles, SS |
| 1992 |
Barry Bonds, Pittsburgh Pirates, OF |
Dennis Eckersley†, Oakland Athletics, P |
| 1993 |
Barry Bonds, San Francisco Giants, OF |
Frank Thomas§, Chicago White Sox, 1B |
| 1994 |
Jeff Bagwell§, Houston Astros, 1B |
Frank Thomas, Chicago White Sox, 1B |
| 1995 |
Barry Larkin, Cincinnati Reds, SS |
Mo Vaughn, Boston Red Sox, 1B |
| 1996 |
Ken Caminiti§, San Diego Padres, 3B |
Juan González, Texas Rangers, OF |
| 1997 |
Larry Walker, Colorado Rockies, OF |
Ken Griffey, Jr.^§, Seattle Mariners, OF |
| 1998 |
Sammy Sosa, Chicago Cubs, OF |
Juan González, Texas Rangers, OF |
| 1999 |
Chipper Jones^, Atlanta Braves, 3B |
Iván Rodríguez^, Texas Rangers, C |
| 2000 |
Jeff Kent, San Francisco Giants, 2B |
Jason Giambi^, Oakland Athletics, 1B |
| 2001 |
Barry Bonds, San Francisco Giants, OF |
Ichiro Suzuki^, Seattle Mariners, OF |
| 2002 |
Barry Bonds, San Francisco Giants, OF |
Miguel Tejada^, Oakland Athletics, SS |
| 2003 |
Barry Bonds, San Francisco Giants, OF |
Alex Rodriguez^, Texas Rangers, SS |
| 2004 |
Barry Bonds, San Francisco Giants, OF |
Vladimir Guerrero^, Anaheim Angels, OF |
| 2005 |
Albert Pujols^, St. Louis Cardinals, 1B |
Alex Rodriguez^, New York Yankees, 3B |
| 2006 |
Ryan Howard^, Philadelphia Phillies, 1B |
Justin Morneau^, Minnesota Twins, 1B |
| 2007 |
Jimmy Rollins^, Philadelphia Phillies, SS |
Alex Rodriguez^, New York Yankees, 3B |
| 2008 |
Albert Pujols^, St. Louis Cardinals, 1B |
Dustin Pedroia^, Boston Red Sox, 2B |
| 2009 |
Albert Pujols^, St. Louis Cardinals, 1B |
Joe Mauer^, Minnesota Twins, C |