Masoumeh Ebtekar: Difference between revisions
m cite web cleanup, Replaced: newspaper= → work=, using AWB |
→Questions about plagiarism: explanation |
||
(8 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown) | |||
Line 3: | Line 3: | ||
'''Masoumeh Ebtekar''' ({{lang-fa|معصومه ابتکار}}; born 1960) is an [[Iran]]ian scientist and politician. She is currently the director of Peace and Environment Center in Tehran. |
'''Masoumeh Ebtekar''' ({{lang-fa|معصومه ابتکار}}; born 1960) is an [[Iran]]ian scientist and politician. She is currently the director of Peace and Environment Center in Tehran. |
||
Ebtekar first achieved fame as the spokeswoman of the students who had occupied the US Embassy in 1979. Later she became the first female [[Vice President of Iran|Vice President]] of [[Iran]], the head of the [[Environment Protection Organization of Iran]] during the administration of President [[Mohammad Khatami]], and is currently a [[city council]]woman elect of [[Tehran]].<ref>[http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20061218/ap_on_re_mi_ea/iran_elections |
Ebtekar first achieved fame as the spokeswoman of the students who had occupied the US Embassy in 1979. Later she became the first female [[Vice President of Iran|Vice President]] of [[Iran]], the head of the [[Environment Protection Organization of Iran]] during the administration of President [[Mohammad Khatami]], and is currently a [[city council]]woman elect of [[Tehran]].<ref>[http://web.archive.org/web/20061227004151/http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20061218/ap_on_re_mi_ea/iran_elections] |date=November 2008}}</ref> She is a founding member of the Iranian reformist political party, the [[Islamic Iran Participation Front]].{{Citation needed|date=November 2008}} |
||
Originally known as Niloufar Ebtekar, she changed her public name sometime after the hostage crisis to Massoumeh. She is known as Niloufar among friends and relatives.<ref name="archives.upenn.edu">{{cite web|url=http://www.archives.upenn.edu/histy/features/intrntnl/country/mideast.html |title=A Brief History of Global Engagement at the University of Pennsylvania |publisher=Archives.upenn.edu |date= |accessdate=2008-11-18}}</ref> Ebtekar is married to Seyyed [[Mohammad Hashemi]], another former hostage activist who became highly-placed Iranian official, (he is now in the private sector). They have two children. |
|||
==Education and family== |
==Education and family== |
||
Line 32: | Line 32: | ||
On [[International Women's Day]] in 1998, as vice-president of environmental affairs, she made an impassioned {{Citation needed|date=May 2009}} speech condemning the [[Taliban treatment of women|horrific oppression of women]] by the [[Taliban|Taliban Movement]] in [[Afghanistan]]. Her performance caused comment by members of the Western [[news media]] in attendance as she herself was wearing a [[chador]], a reminder of cumpulsory hijab in Iran which many in the West view as a violation of women's rights. |
On [[International Women's Day]] in 1998, as vice-president of environmental affairs, she made an impassioned {{Citation needed|date=May 2009}} speech condemning the [[Taliban treatment of women|horrific oppression of women]] by the [[Taliban|Taliban Movement]] in [[Afghanistan]]. Her performance caused comment by members of the Western [[news media]] in attendance as she herself was wearing a [[chador]], a reminder of cumpulsory hijab in Iran which many in the West view as a violation of women's rights. |
||
In the United States her appointment and uncovering of her past led to a question of whether President Khatami was aware of "how deeply" the hostage taking and holding, and anger towards its foremost public defender "affected both the American government and the American people."<ref>"Top Woman in Iran's Government Once Spoke for Hostage-Takers," ''New York Times'', January 28, 1998, p.A6</ref> Many academics and literary critiques have written and expressed their views on these memoirs.<ref>[dialnet.unirioja.es/servlet/articulo?codigo=2419961 -]</ref> Following this, "some ambassadors" in Tehran reportedly stated they would no "longer meet with her" and would "discourage official contract with her office."<ref>"Haven't I seen you somewhere before?", ''New York Times'', Feb. 1, 1998</ref> |
In the United States her appointment and uncovering of her past led to a question of whether President Khatami was aware of "how deeply" the hostage taking and holding, and anger towards its foremost public defender "affected both the American government and the American people."<ref>"Top Woman in Iran's Government Once Spoke for Hostage-Takers," ''New York Times'', January 28, 1998, p.A6</ref> Many academics and literary critiques have written and expressed their views on these memoirs.<ref>[dialnet.unirioja.es/servlet/articulo?codigo=2419961 -]</ref> Following this, "some ambassadors" in Tehran reportedly stated they would no "longer meet with her" and would "discourage official contract with her office."<ref>"Haven't I seen you somewhere before?", ''New York Times'', Feb. 1, 1998</ref> However, in her published memoirs, Ebtekar insists she has had cordial and official contacts with European ambassadors, ministers and presidents.<ref>[http://greenebtekar.persianblog.ir/post/291/]</ref> |
||
===Post-vice-presidential environmental activism=== |
===Post-vice-presidential environmental activism=== |
||
Line 40: | Line 40: | ||
She co-founded the Center for Peace and Environment in 2005, a non-governmental organization devoted to the promotion of just and sustainable peace and the protection of the environment. Over 120 experts and academicians are currently members of the Center. {{Citation needed|date=November 2008}} |
She co-founded the Center for Peace and Environment in 2005, a non-governmental organization devoted to the promotion of just and sustainable peace and the protection of the environment. Over 120 experts and academicians are currently members of the Center. {{Citation needed|date=November 2008}} |
||
===Post-vice-presidential |
===Post-vice-presidential career=== |
||
Ebtekar ran for and was elected to the [[City Council of Tehran|city council of Tehran]] for the term beginning in 2007, coming in 9th out of 21 candidates, just after [[Parvin Ahmadinejad]], the sister of the current President of Iran.<ref>[http:// |
Ebtekar ran for and was elected to the [[City Council of Tehran|city council of Tehran]] for the term beginning in 2007, coming in 9th out of 21 candidates, just after [[Parvin Ahmadinejad]], the sister of the current President of Iran.<ref>[http://web.archive.org/web/20061227004151/http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20061218/ap_on_re_mi_ea/iran_elections Local vote embarrassing Iran president] By ALI AKBAR DAREINI, Associated Press, December 18, 2006]</ref> She established and heads the Tehran City Council Environment Committee and currently runs 20 working groups on environmental issues.{{fact}} |
||
Ebtekar |
Ebtekar considered for a time running in the the [[Iranian presidential election, 2009|Tenth Iranian presidency]] (election on June 12, 2009) after the Islamic Republic's [[Guardian Council]] indicated that there is no “legal restraint” against women doing so.<ref>[http://www.tehrantimes.com/Index_view.asp?code=192200 Ebtekar does not rule out presidential candidacy. ''tehran times'', April 14, 2009 ]</ref> |
||
⚫ | Ebtekar published her memoir as the first woman Vice President of Iran, entitled the ''Grapes of Shahrivar'' on May 3, 2009.<ref>[http://greenebtekar.persianblog.ir/post/291]/ and published by Etelleat Newspaper Publishing House, the memoirs refer to the events of the reforms period in Iran.</ref> She has also published a collection of he essays and speeches on the environment and sustainable development, called ''Natural Peace,'' <ref>published in 2005 by the Iranian Department of Environment. These speeches include titles such as Human Rights and Challenges of the Century, Perspectives on Sustainable Development and the Role of the Woman in Iranian Society, etc. She also had two articles from ''Natural Peace'' published in ''Our Planet'', the Magazine of the United Nations Environment Program (in 2005), and ''Market Messengers'' (in 2006). www.unep.org</ref> She teaches immunology at the MSc and PhD levels, and is a member of several research board committees and a reviewer for two international and four national immunology journals.<ref>[www.modares.ac.ir university website]</ref>. After leaving her government position in 2005 Ebtekar has spoken as inaugural or keynote speaker at many international events. |
||
===Grapes of Shahrivar=== |
|||
Ebtekar published her memoirs of the 8 years she served as the first woman Vice President of Iran, on May 3, 2009.[http://greenebtekar.persianblog.ir/post/291]/ Entitled the Grapes of Shahrivar and published by Etelleat Newspaper Publishing House, the memoirs refer to the events of the reforms period in Iran. The book launch ceremony was held in Baran Foundation the foundation established by President Khatami to disseminate the managerial experiences of the reform government. |
|||
In 2009 the ''[[New York Times]]'' described her as "informally represent[ing] the views of many of the former hostage-takers", supporting "engagement with the West" and a renewal of the "original ideals of the revolution, including justice and freedom," which many of her peers believe have been abandoned by the current Islamic regime.<ref>[http://www.nytimes.com/2009/11/04/world/middleeast/04hostages.html In Iran, From Heroes to State Enemies By MICHAEL SLACKMAN, November 3, 2009 ]</ref> |
|||
===Academic Career === |
|||
⚫ | |||
She teaches immunology at the MSc and PhD levels, and has published several articles in major international journals {{Which?|date=May 2009}} on immunobiology. She is a member of several research board committees and is a reviewer for two international and four national immunology journals.<ref>[www.modares.ac.ir university website]</ref>. After leaving her government position in 2005 Ebtekar has spoken as inaugural or keynote speaker at many international events. |
|||
On October 7, 2008 [[eTBLAST]], a text similarity search engine on [[MEDLINE]] database, noted that 85% of a paper published by Masoumeh Ebtekar came from several previously published articles. The paper, on cytokines and air pollution, was published in 2006 in the ''Iran Journal of Allergy Asthma Immunology'' (IJAAI) 5 47-56:2006.<ref name="eTBLAST">{{cite web|url=http://spore.swmed.edu/dejavu/duplicate/9866/ |title=Entry 9866 information | Deja vu > Browse |publisher=Spore.swmed.edu |date= |accessdate=2008-11-18}}</ref> A couple weeks after the eTBLAST report, [[Nature magazine]] covered the story, quoting one of the authors of original papers, ([[Ian Mudway]], a [[toxicologist]] at the [[King's College London]]) as saying, "the article is a veritable patchwork of other people's work, word for word, grammatical error for grammatical error." ''Nature'' also stated that Ebtekar had not replied to its emails.<ref>http://alef.ir/images/stories/you_alefusers_onnature.jpg Iranian paper sparks sense of deja vu], 23 October 2008, Vol 455, </ref> In response, the editor-in-chief of the IJAAI issued a statement saying: "We regret for this duplication that appeared in the journal. We are working with the editors of the JACI journal [J Allergy Clin Immunol, a journal that published three of the papers from which Ebtekar had copied] to find the best solution in this regard." In December 2008 Ebtekar's article was retracted. <ref name="eTBLAST"/> |
|||
⚫ | '' |
||
⚫ | |||
⚫ | The isue received some political and public attention in Iran<ref>{{cite web|url=http://alef.ir/content/view/32958/ |title=Alef.ir |publisher=Alef.ir |date= |accessdate=2008-11-18}}</ref> where Ebtekar issued a statement admitting she had made a mistake and apologizing for it, but including a list of complaints such as eTBLAST's failure to inform her of their finding in advance, the fact that the article was a review article she was invited to write for the Journal, and that more than 76 references were given in the text.<ref>{{cite web|url=http://greenebtekar.persianblog.ir/post/232/ |title=ابتكار سبز >> بازگشت از بارسلون و پاسخ به یک ادعا |publisher=Greenebtekar.persianblog.ir |date= |accessdate=2008-11-18}}</ref> |
||
On October 7, 2008, [[eTBLAST]] recognized an article published by Masoumeh Ebtekar in 2006 at the ''Iran Journal of Allergy Asthma Immunol'' as an 85% duplication of several previously published articles.<ref>{{cite web|url=http://spore.swmed.edu/dejavu/duplicate/9866/ |title=Entry 9866 information | Deja vu > Browse |publisher=Spore.swmed.edu |date= |accessdate=2008-11-18}}</ref> eTBLAST is a text similarity [[search engine]] on [[MEDLINE]] database sponsored by the Innovation Laboratory at the [[University of Texas Southwestern Medical School]] to study the scientific publication ethics. |
|||
⚫ | |||
⚫ | Ebtekar apologized for her [[plagiarism]] again at a public gathering about the US embassy hostage crisis held in [[Shiraz University]] saying: "I apologize, humans are not prudent from mistakes." <ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.rajanews.com/detail.asp?id=19131 |title=ابتكار: از بابت جعل مقاله عذر مي خواهم |publisher=Rajanews.com |date= |accessdate=2008-11-18}}</ref> |
||
On October 23, 2008, Vol 455 [[Nature magazine]] covered this case in a short story titled "Iranian paper sparks sense of Deja Vu". In an interiew with [[Ian Mudway]], a [[toxicologist]] at the [[King's College London]] and one of the authors of original papers referred to by Ebtekar, he said: "The article is a veritable patchwork of other people's work, word for word, grammatical error for grammatical error." It reported that Ebtekar has not answered emails from ''Nature''.<ref>http://alef.ir/images/stories/you_alefusers_onnature.jpg</ref> |
|||
⚫ | Ebtekar apologized for her [[plagiarism]] again at a public gathering about the US embassy hostage crisis held in [[Shiraz University]] saying: "I apologize, humans are not prudent from mistakes." <ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.rajanews.com/detail.asp?id=19131 |title=ابتكار: از بابت جعل مقاله عذر مي خواهم |publisher=Rajanews.com |date= |accessdate=2008-11-18}}</ref> |
||
==Sources== |
==Sources== |
Revision as of 21:47, 8 December 2009
This article has multiple issues. Please help improve it or discuss these issues on the talk page. (Learn how and when to remove these messages)
No issues specified. Please specify issues, or remove this template. |
Masoumeh Ebtekar (Template:Lang-fa; born 1960) is an Iranian scientist and politician. She is currently the director of Peace and Environment Center in Tehran.
Ebtekar first achieved fame as the spokeswoman of the students who had occupied the US Embassy in 1979. Later she became the first female Vice President of Iran, the head of the Environment Protection Organization of Iran during the administration of President Mohammad Khatami, and is currently a city councilwoman elect of Tehran.[1] She is a founding member of the Iranian reformist political party, the Islamic Iran Participation Front.[citation needed]
Originally known as Niloufar Ebtekar, she changed her public name sometime after the hostage crisis to Massoumeh. She is known as Niloufar among friends and relatives.[2] Ebtekar is married to Seyyed Mohammad Hashemi, another former hostage activist who became highly-placed Iranian official, (he is now in the private sector). They have two children.
Education and family
Ebtekar's father studied at the University of Pennsylvania, and she is reported to have lived with her parents in Upper Darby of Philadelphia for 3 years.[2] Another source lists her have having lived in Philadelphia for six years as a child, from whence she developed "near-perfect, American-accented English." [3] As a student in Iran she became a supporter of the political Islam of Ali Shariati and began wearing a traditional black chador covering everything except her face.[4]
She holds a BSc degree in laboratory science from Shahid Beheshti University, a MSc and PhD in immunology from Tarbiat Modares University in 1995, where she still teaches.
Early activism and role in Iran Hostage Crisis
Ebtekar served as spokeswoman for the students in the Iran hostage crisis of 1979, where Muslim Student Followers of the Imam's Line occupied the US Embassy and held 52 Americans hostage of 444 days. Selected because of her good command of English, she made regular appearances on American television where she listed the 'crimes' of America and denounced the hostages as spies who should be put on trial.
Asked by an ABC News correspondent one day whether she could see herself picking up a gun and killing the hostages, she replied: 'yes. When I've seen an American gun being lifted up and killing my brothers and sisters in the streets, of course.'[5]
She wrote an account of the embassy takeover with Fred A. Reed entitled Takeover in Tehran: The Inside Story of the 1979 U.S. Embassy Capture [6] She is said to be remembered by many Americans (hostages such as David Roeder, Barbara Timm, the mother of hostage Kevin Hermening and those who watched her on television) with a great lack of fondness, in part because "her familiarity with America added profound emphasis to her rejection of it." [7]
When asked by an American interviewer (Elaine Sciolino) in the late 1990s about her past as spokeswoman for the hostage-takers, why it did not appear on her resume, and why she had changed her name from Nilofar to Masoumeh, Ebtekar "had no apology and made no excuses" about her role[8] describing the hostage taking as "the best direction that could have been taken" by Iran at the time, but surprised the interviewer with her "chutzpah", insisting that the interviewer "not write much about these things." [9]
Social and Government career
In 1981, Ebtekar became the editor-in-chief of the English daily newspaper Kayhan International, selected by Khatami who was then the representative of Ayatollah Khomeini in Kayhan Institute. She served in the newspaper until 1983. In 1991 she co-founded the Institute for Women's Studies and Research. Since 1992, she has been the license holder and managing director of the journal Farzaneh for Women's Studies and Research. Ebtekar was appointed as the Head of Women's NGO Coordinating Office and Vice Head of the National Committee to the Fourth World Conference on Women in Beijing in 1995. Laterو she was elected as the President of the Network of Women's NGOs in Iran.
Vice presidency
Ebtekar is a founding member of the Islamic Iran Participation Front,[citation needed] a reformist party, and became the was the first woman to serve as Vice-President of Iran when the reformists came to power. Along with Zahra Shojaei, she participated in the first cabinet since the Islamic Revolution to include women. She has been described as a leftist in Mohammad Khatami's alliance.[10]
On International Women's Day in 1998, as vice-president of environmental affairs, she made an impassioned [citation needed] speech condemning the horrific oppression of women by the Taliban Movement in Afghanistan. Her performance caused comment by members of the Western news media in attendance as she herself was wearing a chador, a reminder of cumpulsory hijab in Iran which many in the West view as a violation of women's rights.
In the United States her appointment and uncovering of her past led to a question of whether President Khatami was aware of "how deeply" the hostage taking and holding, and anger towards its foremost public defender "affected both the American government and the American people."[11] Many academics and literary critiques have written and expressed their views on these memoirs.[12] Following this, "some ambassadors" in Tehran reportedly stated they would no "longer meet with her" and would "discourage official contract with her office."[13] However, in her published memoirs, Ebtekar insists she has had cordial and official contacts with European ambassadors, ministers and presidents.[14]
Post-vice-presidential environmental activism
Ebtekar was named one of the seven 2006 Champions of the Earth by the United Nations Environment Program as a prominent and "inspirational" environmental leader who has made an impact at policy level in a region of the world.[15][16] She was also named as one of 50 environmental leaders by the The Guardian newspaper in January 5, 2008 - the only Iranian or Muslim woman in the list."50 people who could save the planet". The Guardian. Saturday 5 January 2008 12.55 GMT. {{cite web}}
: Check date values in: |date=
(help)
She co-founded the Center for Peace and Environment in 2005, a non-governmental organization devoted to the promotion of just and sustainable peace and the protection of the environment. Over 120 experts and academicians are currently members of the Center. [citation needed]
Post-vice-presidential career
Ebtekar ran for and was elected to the city council of Tehran for the term beginning in 2007, coming in 9th out of 21 candidates, just after Parvin Ahmadinejad, the sister of the current President of Iran.[17] She established and heads the Tehran City Council Environment Committee and currently runs 20 working groups on environmental issues.[citation needed]
Ebtekar considered for a time running in the the Tenth Iranian presidency (election on June 12, 2009) after the Islamic Republic's Guardian Council indicated that there is no “legal restraint” against women doing so.[18]
Ebtekar published her memoir as the first woman Vice President of Iran, entitled the Grapes of Shahrivar on May 3, 2009.[19] She has also published a collection of he essays and speeches on the environment and sustainable development, called Natural Peace, [20] She teaches immunology at the MSc and PhD levels, and is a member of several research board committees and a reviewer for two international and four national immunology journals.[21]. After leaving her government position in 2005 Ebtekar has spoken as inaugural or keynote speaker at many international events.
In 2009 the New York Times described her as "informally represent[ing] the views of many of the former hostage-takers", supporting "engagement with the West" and a renewal of the "original ideals of the revolution, including justice and freedom," which many of her peers believe have been abandoned by the current Islamic regime.[22]
Questions about plagiarism
On October 7, 2008 eTBLAST, a text similarity search engine on MEDLINE database, noted that 85% of a paper published by Masoumeh Ebtekar came from several previously published articles. The paper, on cytokines and air pollution, was published in 2006 in the Iran Journal of Allergy Asthma Immunology (IJAAI) 5 47-56:2006.[23] A couple weeks after the eTBLAST report, Nature magazine covered the story, quoting one of the authors of original papers, (Ian Mudway, a toxicologist at the King's College London) as saying, "the article is a veritable patchwork of other people's work, word for word, grammatical error for grammatical error." Nature also stated that Ebtekar had not replied to its emails.[24] In response, the editor-in-chief of the IJAAI issued a statement saying: "We regret for this duplication that appeared in the journal. We are working with the editors of the JACI journal [J Allergy Clin Immunol, a journal that published three of the papers from which Ebtekar had copied] to find the best solution in this regard." In December 2008 Ebtekar's article was retracted. [23]
The isue received some political and public attention in Iran[25] where Ebtekar issued a statement admitting she had made a mistake and apologizing for it, but including a list of complaints such as eTBLAST's failure to inform her of their finding in advance, the fact that the article was a review article she was invited to write for the Journal, and that more than 76 references were given in the text.[26]
Ebtekar apologized for her plagiarism again at a public gathering about the US embassy hostage crisis held in Shiraz University saying: "I apologize, humans are not prudent from mistakes." [27]
Sources
- ^ [1] |date=November 2008}}
- ^ a b "A Brief History of Global Engagement at the University of Pennsylvania". Archives.upenn.edu. Retrieved 2008-11-18.
- ^ Sciolino, Elaine, Persian Mirrors : the Elusive Face of Iran, Free Press, (2005), p.116
- ^ Bowden, Mark, Guests of the Ayatollah, Atlantic Monthly Press, 2006, p.161
- ^ Sciolino, Persian Mirrors, (2005), p.116-118
- ^ (ISBN 0-88922-443-9), published in 2000 by Talonbooks. The Persian translation of this book was published in Tehran by Etellaat Newspaper Publications the same year and the Arabic translation was published in Beirut by Al Hadi Publications.
- ^ Bowden, Mark, Guests of the Ayatollah , Atlantic Monthly Press, 2006, p.162-3
- ^ "Top Woman in Iran's Government Once Spoke for Hostage-Takers", New York Times, January 28, 1998, p.A6
- ^ Sciolino, Persian Mirrors (2005), p.116-118
- ^ Sciolino, Persian Mirrors (2005), p.116
- ^ "Top Woman in Iran's Government Once Spoke for Hostage-Takers," New York Times, January 28, 1998, p.A6
- ^ [dialnet.unirioja.es/servlet/articulo?codigo=2419961 -]
- ^ "Haven't I seen you somewhere before?", New York Times, Feb. 1, 1998
- ^ [2]
- ^ Seven environmental heroes to be honoured by UN agency
- ^ BaniComm Co. "Iranian Students News Agency (in Persian)". Isna.ir. Retrieved 2008-11-18.
- ^ Local vote embarrassing Iran president By ALI AKBAR DAREINI, Associated Press, December 18, 2006]
- ^ Ebtekar does not rule out presidential candidacy. tehran times, April 14, 2009
- ^ [3]/ and published by Etelleat Newspaper Publishing House, the memoirs refer to the events of the reforms period in Iran.
- ^ published in 2005 by the Iranian Department of Environment. These speeches include titles such as Human Rights and Challenges of the Century, Perspectives on Sustainable Development and the Role of the Woman in Iranian Society, etc. She also had two articles from Natural Peace published in Our Planet, the Magazine of the United Nations Environment Program (in 2005), and Market Messengers (in 2006). www.unep.org
- ^ [www.modares.ac.ir university website]
- ^ In Iran, From Heroes to State Enemies By MICHAEL SLACKMAN, November 3, 2009
- ^ a b "Entry 9866 information | Deja vu > Browse". Spore.swmed.edu. Retrieved 2008-11-18.
- ^ http://alef.ir/images/stories/you_alefusers_onnature.jpg Iranian paper sparks sense of deja vu], 23 October 2008, Vol 455,
- ^ "Alef.ir". Alef.ir. Retrieved 2008-11-18.
- ^ "ابتكار سبز >> بازگشت از بارسلون و پاسخ به یک ادعا". Greenebtekar.persianblog.ir. Retrieved 2008-11-18.
- ^ "ابتكار: از بابت جعل مقاله عذر مي خواهم". Rajanews.com. Retrieved 2008-11-18.