Talk:S. I. Hayakawa: Difference between revisions
m Tagging for {{WikiProject Law}} |
|||
| Line 14: | Line 14: | ||
--[[User:Jerzy|Jerzy]][[User talk:Jerzy|(t)]] 21:42, 2004 Jul 20 (UTC) |
--[[User:Jerzy|Jerzy]][[User talk:Jerzy|(t)]] 21:42, 2004 Jul 20 (UTC) |
||
---- |
---- |
||
== Senile?== |
|||
This article had included, as a matter of fact, that S. I. Hayakawa was senile. Any such fantastic charges should be removed, until authenticated. Snide jokes, based on Sen. Hayakawa's advanced age and tendency to fall asleep, should not be treated as factual. |
|||
== Pre-merge Histories of the Articles == |
== Pre-merge Histories of the Articles == |
||
[[Samuel I. Hayakawa]] |
[[Samuel I. Hayakawa]] |
||
Revision as of 19:01, 23 April 2007
 | Law Unassessed | |||||||||
| ||||||||||
 | California Unassessed | |||||||||
| ||||||||||
 | Biography Unassessed | ||||||
| |||||||
Wikipedia:Naming conventions (common names)
There is no prior discussion page corresponding any of the 5 article pages that are, or redirect to the same place as, this one's article. So there is no discussion of the rationale for the redirection (by thedespised cut-and-paste method, no less) of S. I. Hayakawa to Samuel I. Hayakawa.
As should be clear from Wikipedia:Naming conventions (common names), people usually known by initials and surname should have their WP bios titled that way, just as Bill Clinton is the article and William Jefferson Clinton the redirect.
Anyone doubting this is such a case should do some serious research; i have not, since i spent a year or so unsure whether S. I. Hayakawa and Sessue Hayakawa were different people, and a number of decades thereafter (ending today) wondering whether the former might sometimes be known as Sessue I. Hayakawa. (That is to say, if anyone called him "Samuel" within my notice, i would have remembered the fact.)
(For the benefit of other similarly situated readers, Sessue was 16 or 17 when S.I. was born in Vancouver, so father-and-son seems farfetched. [smile])
--Jerzy(t) 21:42, 2004 Jul 20 (UTC)
Senile?
This article had included, as a matter of fact, that S. I. Hayakawa was senile. Any such fantastic charges should be removed, until authenticated. Snide jokes, based on Sen. Hayakawa's advanced age and tendency to fall asleep, should not be treated as factual.
Pre-merge Histories of the Articles
- 01:45, 2004 Jul 9 Guanabot m (Guanaco - Robot-assisted redirect bypassing: United States Senator)
- 03:13, 2004 Jun 23 Chrisn4255 (Add category.)
- 06:17, 2004 Jun 22 Chrisn4255 (Add Senate table.)
- 03:57, 2004 Apr 2 Moncrief
- 20:34, 2004 Mar 13 KeithH (wiki Republican)
- 19:24, 2003 Dec 31 Jengod m
- 19:23, 2003 Dec 31 Jengod m
- 19:16, 2003 Dec 31 Jengod m
- 19:14, 2003 Dec 31 Jengod (bioguide, et al)
- 19:17, 2003 Dec 31 Jengod m
- 03:05, 2003 Dec 16 130.212.118.18
- 05:31, 2003 Aug 17 RickK (photo, expand)
- 11:59, 2002 Nov 3 203.97.97.131
- 13:33, 2002 Aug 27 12.144.193.66
- 15:51, 2002 Feb 25 Conversion script m (Automated conversion)