Jump to content

Transposing instrument: Difference between revisions

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Browse history interactively
← Previous editNext edit →
Content deleted Content added
VisualWikitext
→Tone and sound quality: linking to British style brass band
Nothing physical
Line 1: Line 1:
A '''transposing instrument''' is a musical instrument for which written notes are read at a pitch different from [[Pitch (music)#Concert pitch|concert pitch]], which a non-transposing instrument, such as a [[piano]], would play. On a transposing instrument, a concert C is written as a different note; the concert pitch that is played for a written C determines the key that an instrument transposes in. For example, a B{{music|flat}} [[clarinet]]ist playing a written C would sound a concert B{{music|flat}}. Transposing [[harmonium|harmonia]] or electronic keyboards with a transpose function can also play a different set of pitches from what is notated, but these are not usually called transposing instruments.
A '''transposing instrument''' is a musical instrument for which written notes are read at a pitch different from [[Pitch (music)#Concert pitch|concert pitch]], which a non-transposing instrument, such as a [[piano]], would play. On a transposing instrument, a concert C is written as a different note; the concert pitch that is played for a written C determines the key that an instrument transposes in. For example, a B{{music|flat}} [[clarinet]]ist playing a written C would sound a concert B{{music|flat}}. Transposing [[harmonium|harmonia]] or electronic keyboards with a transpose function can also play a different set of pitches from what is notated, but these are not usually called transposing instruments.

There is no fundamental physical difference between a transposing instrument and a non-transposing instrument; rather, it is a matter of convention whether any instrument is transposing.


== Reasons for transposing ==
== Reasons for transposing ==

Revision as of 08:37, 7 April 2010

A transposing instrument is a musical instrument for which written notes are read at a pitch different from concert pitch, which a non-transposing instrument, such as a piano, would play. On a transposing instrument, a concert C is written as a different note; the concert pitch that is played for a written C determines the key that an instrument transposes in. For example, a B♭ clarinetist playing a written C would sound a concert B♭. Transposing harmonia or electronic keyboards with a transpose function can also play a different set of pitches from what is notated, but these are not usually called transposing instruments.

There is no fundamental physical difference between a transposing instrument and a non-transposing instrument; rather, it is a matter of convention whether any instrument is transposing.

Reasons for transposing

Though writing for transposing instruments entails more work for a composer or arranger, there are several reasons why instruments are transposed.

Transposition at the octave

See also octave clef.

If an instrument has a range that is too high or too low for their music to be easily written on bass or treble clef, the music may be written either an octave higher or an octave lower than it sounds, in order to reduce the use of ledger lines. Instruments that "transpose at the octave" are not playing in a different key from concert pitch instruments, but sound an octave higher or lower than written. Some instruments with extremely high or low ranges use a two-octave transposition.

Music for the contrabassoon and the double bass is written on the bass clef, one octave higher than concert pitch. Music for the guitar and, frequently, the tenor voice is written on the treble clef, one octave higher than concert pitch. Music for the piccolo is written on the treble clef, one octave lower than concert pitch. If these instruments did not transpose at the octave, many of their pitches would have to be written with frequent ledger lines above or below the staff, making reading comparatively cumbersome.

Historical reasons

Historically, some instruments have come to be accepted (and widely manufactured) with a certain transposition as a standard, and most music written for those instruments would be transposed. Were non-transposed versions to be used, any pieces written for the instrument would have to be "de-transposed" into a C key, which would entail additional work.

Families of instruments

Many instruments are members of a family of instruments that differ mainly in size, such as the saxophone, clarinet, flute, etc. The instruments in these families have differing ranges, with the members sounding lower as they get larger. It is desirable for all members of the same instrument family to have the same fingerings, so that a player can play any member of the family using the same fingerings. As a result, these instruments are transposed based on their range such that each written note is fingered the same way on each instrument.

Instruments that transpose this way are often referred to as being in a certain "key", such as the A clarinet (clarinet in A), or the F horn (horn in F). The instrument's key tells which pitch will sound when the player plays a note written as "C". A player of a B♭ clarinet who reads a written C will sound a B♭, while the player of an F horn will read the same note and sound an F.

The flute family contains instruments with different transpositions. The standard concert flute is a non-transposing instrument with a range from middle C up about 3 octaves. The alto flute is a very similar instrument, but longer, and hence pitched lower, with a range starting from the G below middle C. The fingering that would produce a C on a standard flute produces the G a fourth lower on the alto flute.

The situation is similar in other families of instruments. For example, clarinets come in various pitches (A, B♭, C, E♭), with music transposed appropriately for each so that the player can maintain the same fingerings for the same written notes. For reasons of timbre or to minimize switching between different instruments, expert clarinet players sometimes use a different instrument than their part calls for — usually substituting the B♭ for the A or vice-versa — transposing the parts at sight instead.[citation needed] Advanced trumpet players may do this also, usually with the B♭ and C instruments.[citation needed]

In some families of instruments, the non-transposing C version had fallen into disuse; the clarinet family is one example, where only the B♭ and A members are common, but in recent years, there is a tendency to utilize the C clarinet when called for. Horns are another example.

Some families containing transposing instruments:

Before valves became common about 1800, the horn could play only the notes of the overtone series from a single fundamental pitch. This fundamental could be changed by inserting one of a set of crooks into the instrument, shortening or lengthening the total length of its sounding tube. As a result, all horn music was written as if for a fundamental pitch of C, but the crooks could make a single instrument a transposing instrument into almost any key. Changing the crooks was a time-consuming process, so it took place only between pieces or movements. The introduction of valves made this process unnecessary (although Richard Wagner wrote horn parts as if crooks were still in use, evoking the tradition which was quickly becoming archaic). While an F transposition became standard in the early 19th century, composers differed in whether they expected the instruments to transpose down a fifth or up a fourth, especially when written in bass clef.

There are a few families of instruments which have instruments of various sizes and ranges, but whose music is rarely or never transposed. The recorder family is one of these. The higher members of the family (soprano and above) transpose at the octave, as do the bass instruments (bass and great bass). However, they are referred to as "C-fingered" or "F-fingered" depending on the lowest note, which is fingered the same on all sizes. A player may go from one C-fingered instrument to another easily, and from one F-fingered instrument to another easily, but switching between the two requires learning a new set of fingerings or the ability to transpose the music at sight.

Tone and sound quality

Because of tone quality issues, some C (concert pitch) instruments — the C melody saxophone, C soprano saxophone, and C soprano clarinet, for example — have declined in popularity in favor of the standard versions (B♭ soprano and tenor saxophone; B♭ and A clarinets).

It was found that sometimes instruments sounded better when built in certain keys. For instance, the C clarinet was not a very pleasant sounding instrument, nor was the D or the E♭ clarinet; it was generally agreed that the B♭ clarinet was the most pleasant sounding, and for this reason was the one which remained in dominant use in the present day. This is also true of the B♭ trumpet, as well as several other instruments, such as the French horn and the trombone (which, outside the United Kingdom brass band tradition, is not treated as a transposing instrument, although its basic overtone series is B♭ or E♭).

Mechanical and physical considerations

On woodwind instruments there is one major scale whose execution involves (more or less) simply picking up each finger sequentially from the bottom to top. This is usually the scale which reads as a C scale (the major scale with no sharps or flats) on that instrument. If it is a transposing instrument, the note written as C sounds as the note of the instrument's transposition — on an E♭ alto saxophone, that note sounds as a concert E♭, on an A clarinet, that note sounds as a concert A. The bassoon is an exception; it is not a transposing instrument, yet its "home" scale is F.

Brass instruments, when played with no valves engaged (or, for trombones, with the slide all the way in) play a series of notes which form the overtone series based on some fundamental pitch, e.g., the B♭ trumpet, when played with no valves being pressed, can play the overtones based on B♭ (although not the fundamental pitch). Usually, that pitch is the note which indicates the transposition of that brass instrument. Trombones are an exception — they do not transpose, instead reading at concert pitch, although tenor and bass trombones are pitched in B♭, alto trombone in E♭. Music for baritone or euphonium is sometimes written in bass clef at concert pitch also.

In the cases above, there is some reason to consider a certain pitch the "home" note of an instrument, and that pitch is usually written as C for that instrument. The concert pitch of that note is what determines how we refer to the transposition of that instrument.

With the exception of the bass trombone, all of the instruments in United Kingdom brass band music (including cornet, flugelhorn, tenor horn, euphonium, baritone horn, tenor trombone, and even the bass tuba) are notated in treble clef as transposing instruments in either B♭ or E♭.

On the conductor's score

In conductors' scores, music for transposing instruments is generally written in transposed form, just as in the players' parts. A few publishers, especially of modern music, provide conductors with scores written entirely in concert pitch, making the pitch relationships of the entire score easier for the conductor to see.

List of instruments by transposition

  • Instruments in G (high - sounding a perfect fifth higher than written
    • Soprano Bugle


Timpani

In the 17th and early 18th century, timpani were often treated as transposing instruments, as they were almost always tuned to the tonic and dominant notes. These were notated as C and G, and the actual tuning was indicated at the top of the score (for example, Timpani in A–D). This notation style was not universal: Bach, Mozart, and Schubert (in his early works) used it, but their respective contemporaries Handel, Haydn, and Beethoven wrote for the timpani at concert pitch. [3]

See also

Notes

  1. ^ The modern saxophone family is in B♭ and E♭, but there is also an orchestral family of saxophones in C and F: F-sopranino, C-soprano, F-alto (sometimes called mezzo-soprano), C-tenor (now called C-melody), F-baritone, C-bass, and F-contrabass. The last of these was manufactured in the 1930s.
  2. ^ There are two complications with horn transposition. First, some older editions write for valved horns as if they still had crooks, and thus may change the transposition several times within a piece or movement. Second, when horn parts are written in bass clef, they may be written an octave lower than expected, transposing up, rather than down as in treble clef. In today's scores, horns always transpose down, even in bass clef; but the other notation was standard until the beginning of the 20th century."Written Vs. Sounding Pitch" (PDF). Retrieved 2007-03-22.
  3. ^ Del Mar, Norman (1981). The Anatomy of the Orchestra. Univ of California press.

References

  • Kennan, Kent Wheeler. The Technique of Orchestration, Second Edition. Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey: Prentice-Hall, Inc., 1970, 1952; ISBN 0-13-900316-9
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Transposing_instrument&oldid=354490188"