Harrison Birtwistle

Harrison Birtwistle in 2008

Sir Harrison Birtwistle, CH (born 15 July 1934) is a British composer.

Life

Harrison Birtwistle was born in Accrington, a mill town in Lancashire some 20 miles north of Manchester. Regarding his name, Birtwistle has stated that 'in some reference books my name is down as Harrison Paul, which it isn't, and never has been. I don't have a second name.' His interest in music was encouraged by his mother, who bought him a clarinet when he was seven, and arranged for him to have lessons with the local bandmaster. He became proficient enough to play in the local military-style band, and also played in the orchestra that accompanied Gilbert and Sullivan productions and the local choral society's performances of Messiah. Birtwistle composed from around this time, later describing his early pieces as "sub Vaughan Williams".

In 1952 he entered the Royal Manchester College of Music in Manchester on a clarinet scholarship. While there he came in contact with a talented group of contemporaries including Peter Maxwell Davies, Alexander Goehr, John Ogdon and Elgar Howarth. Then followed two years of National Service in the Royal Artillery (Plymouth) Band, based in Oswestry (see N. Wilkins, Musical Encounters, London, 2018.) He served as Director of Music at Cranborne Chase School from 1962 until 1965, when a Harkness Fellowship gave him the opportunity to continue his studies at Princeton University, where he completed the opera Punch and Judy. This work, together with Verses for Ensembles and The Triumph of Time, established Birtwistle as an important voice in British music.

In 1972 he wrote the accompanying music to The Offence, starring Sean Connery, which was his only film score.

In 1975 Birtwistle became musical director of the newly established Royal National Theatre in London, a post he held until 1983. He has been honoured with a knighthood (1988) and as a Companion of Honour (2001). From 1994 to 2001 he was Henry Purcell Professor of Composition at King's College London. Birtwistle was the 1987 recipient of the University of Louisville Grawemeyer Award for Music Composition. In 1995 he was awarded the Ernst von Siemens Music Prize. At the 2006 Ivor Novello Awards he criticised pop musicians at the event for performing too loudly and using too many clichés.

His sons Adam Birtwistle and Silas Birtwistle are artists.

Style

It is not easy to link Birtwistle's music to any particular school or movement. For a time, he was described as belonging to the Manchester School, a phrase invented as a parallel to the Second Viennese School to refer to Birtwistle, Goehr and Davies. The phrase has since somewhat fallen out of use, since the three composers were united only by their early studies in Manchester, not by a common musical style. Birtwistle's music is complex, written in a modernistic manner with a clear, distinctive voice.

His early work is sometimes evocative of Igor Stravinsky and Olivier Messiaen (composers he has acknowledged as influences) and his technique of juxtaposing blocks of sound is sometimes compared to that of Edgard Varèse. His early pieces made frequent use of ostinati and often had a ritualistic feel. These have been toned down in recent decades as he has adapted and transformed the techniques into more subtle methods. With its strong emphasis on rhythm, the music is often described as brutal or violent, but this analysis mistakes the strong sound world for an attempt to evoke violent actions. The explicit violence of his first opera Punch and Judy – in which the murder of Judy by her husband is much more shocking when performed live on stage than by glove puppets in the classic British seaside entertainment – can easily be misinterpreted as a clue to the intention of his abstract music. The style is stark and uncompromising.

Birtwistle's favourite image for explaining how his pieces work is to compare them to taking a walk through a town—especially the sort of small town more common in continental Europe than Britain. Such a walk might start in the town square. Having explored its main features, we would set off down one of the side streets. As the walk continues, we might glimpse the town square down different streets, sometime a long way off, other times quite close. We may never return to the square in the rest of the walk or we may visit a new part of it that was not explored initially. Birtwistle suggests that this experience is akin to what he does in the music. His image conveys the way that a core musical idea is altered, varied and distorted as the piece of music progresses. The core music forms a reference point to which everything else is directed, even when we are walking in a completely different direction. Sometimes we will be less aware that it is the same musical material we are hearing; sometimes we may have been listening for a while before realising that we have heard this music before (just as one might have been looking up the street before realising that it is the town square that can be glimpsed through the traffic). He is not, therefore, suggesting that we imagine this walk through the town as a literal explanation of what is happening in the music; he does not 'recreate' the effect in the music (as Charles Ives does in some of his orchestral pieces).

An early variant of this technique involved literally cutting up the music, an example being Verses for Ensembles. Having composed a portion of music, Birtwistle would then cut it arbitrarily into a number of sections, which he then rearranged randomly. He would then add introductions, epilogues and music to link them together. This method was intended to give the whole piece unity, by having musical material with its own inner coherence scattered amongst musical material that still related to the core material but did not necessarily relate to itself.

Birtwistle's method of working is also reflected in the events of the first Act of his opera Gawain. Up to the point where the Green Knight is kneeling in front of Gawain awaiting the axe blow that will cut off his head, the action has proceeded mainly in chronological order. With Gawain holding the axe aloft, the stage is suddenly blacked out and, within a minute, the action has been rewound to the point preceding the Green Knight's entry to the Court of Arthur. Events are played through again, though compressed and with various small alterations, through the beheading and into the subsequent events. The events on stage are not randomly ordered, but the one event is portrayed from more than one perspective.

For the opera The Mask of Orpheus, this entailed two sets of singer/actors performing contradictory versions of the one event from the Orpheus myths. This non-linear portrayal of events on stage gives the listener a means of approach to the abstract compositions, with the same musical ideas being repeated but with extensive variation. The result is music that is often very episodic in structure. A clear example occurs in Silbury Air in which a readily identifiable musical motif – a blow from the tom-toms followed by scurrying figures from the strings and woodwind – is elaborated in a number of different ways as the piece progresses.

As a result, even when he is not writing a visual piece involving stage action, Birtwistle's music is frequently theatrical in conception. The music does not follow the logic and rules of classical forms such as sonata form, but is structured more like a drama. Furthermore, different musical instruments can almost be seen to take the part of different characters in the drama. This is especially apparent in a performance of Secret Theatre (1984). For various portions of the piece, a number of the instrumentalists perform in a 'soloist' capacity. For this, they leave their seat in the ensemble and stand separately, to one side of the ensemble, returning to the group when they are no longer given that role. Though not normally signaled by a change of position, this sort of changing role is constantly seen in his music. Related to this is the use of geological imagery to explain the structure of his 1986 orchestral piece Earth Dances. A number of different layers of musical material are present. At any one time, a layer might be to the fore, while at other times it might be buried deep beneath the other layers and no longer as apparent.

Media interest

Birtwistle has been described as "reticent", but he has given a number of interviews over the years. To cite a recent example, in 2019 he was interviewed for Composer of the Week on BBC Radio 3.

Controversies

Though well established and widely respected in the classical music world, Birtwistle was relatively unknown to the general public until the mid-1990s, when two events brought him to the attention of a wider audience:

• In 1994 two anti-modernist musicians, Frederick Stocken and Keith Burstein, calling themselves "The Hecklers," organised a demonstration at the first night of a revival of his opera Gawain at the Royal Opera House, London.
• In 1995 Birtwistle's saxophone concertante work Panic was premiered in the second half of the Last Night of the Proms to an estimated worldwide television audience of 100 million. According to the Daily Telegraph, it met with incomprehension from many viewers.

List of major works

For a comprehensive list, see List of compositions by Harrison Birtwistle.

Opera

• Punch and Judy (1967)
• Down by the Greenwood Side, A Dramatic Pastoral, chamber opera (1968–69)
• Bow Down, chamber opera (1977)
• The Mask of Orpheus (1973–84), winner of the 1987 Grawemeyer Award in Music Composition.
• Yan Tan Tethera, A Mechanical Pastoral, chamber opera (1986)
• Gawain (1990)
• The Second Mrs Kong (1994)
• The Last Supper (2000)
• The Io Passion, chamber opera (2004)
• The Minotaur (2008)
• The Corridor, chamber opera (2009)
• The Cure (2014–15)

Other works

• Tragoedia, for flute, oboe, clarinet, bassoon, horn, harp and string quartet (1965)
• Nomos (1968), for orchestra
• Verses for Ensembles (1968)
• Down by the Greenwood Side (1969)
• The Triumph of Time (1971–72), for orchestra
• Grimethorpe Aria (1973), brass band
• Silbury Air (1976–77), chamber orchestra
• ...agm... (1978)
• Secret Theatre, for chamber ensemble (1984)
• Earth Dances (1986), for orchestra
• Endless Parade (1986), for trumpet, vibraphone and strings
• Antiphonies (1992), piano and orchestra
• Panic (1995), alto saxophone, jazz drum kit and orchestra
• Pulse Shadows (9 Movements for string quartet interleaved with 9 Settings of Celan) (1989–96)
• The Axe Manual, for piano and percussion (2000)
• Theseus Game, for large ensemble with two conductors (2002)
• Angel Fighter (2010), dramatic cantata
• String Quartet: Tree of Strings (2007)
• Concerto for Violin and Orchestra (2009–10)
• In Broken Images (2011), for ensemble (after the antiphonal music of Gabrieli)
• The Moth Requiem (2012), for twelve female voices, three harps and flute
• Songs from the Same Earth (2012–13), for tenor and piano
• Responses (2013–14), piano concerto

Honours and awards

Awards

• 1986 Grawemeyer Award for Music Composition, University of Louisville
• 1986 Chevalier de l'Ordre des Arts et des Lettres, France
• 1995 Ernst von Siemens Music Prize
• 2003 Royal Philharmonic Society Music Awards Large-Scale Composition in London
• 2015 Wihuri Sibelius Prize

Commonwealth honours

Commonwealth honours

Country	Date	Appointment	Post-nominal letters
United Kingdom	1988 – Present	Knight Bachelor	Kt
United Kingdom	2001 – Present	Order of the Companions of Honour	CH

Harrison Birtwistle was awarded a knighthood in the 1988 Queen's Birthday Honours List. He was awarded the Companionship of Honour (CH) in the 2001 New Years Honours List.

Scholastic

University degrees

Location	Date	School	Degree
England		Royal Manchester College of Music

Chancellor, visitor, governor, rector and fellowships

Location	Date	School	Position
England	1986 – Present	Royal Academy of Music	Fellow, Hon FRAM
England	1989 – Present	Royal Northern College of Music	Fellow

Honorary degrees

Location	Date	School	Degree	Status
England	1994	University of Sussex	Doctor of Music (D.Mus)
England	1996	City, University of London	Doctor of Music (D.Mus)
England	2 December 2008	University of London	Doctor of Music (D.Mus)
England	2010	University of Cambridge	Doctor of Music (D.Mus)
England	2013	Bath Spa University	Doctorate
England	25 June 2014	University of Oxford	Doctor of Music (D.Mus)
England	2014	Edge Hill University	Doctor of Philosophy (Ph.D)

Memberships and Fellowships

Location	Date	Organisation	Position
England	1975 – 1983	Royal National Theatre	Musical Director

Sources

• Adlington, Robert: The Music of Harrison Birtwistle. (Cambridge University Press, 2000.)
• Beard, David: Harrison Birtwistle’s Operas and Music Theatre. Music Since 1900. (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2012.) ISBN 978-0-521-89534-7
• Beard, David; Gloag, Kenneth; Jones, Nicholas (editors): Harrison Birtwistle Studies (Cambridge University Press, 2015.)
• Birtwistle, Harrison; Maddocks, Fiona: Harrison Birtwistle: Wild Tracks - a conversation diary (Faber and Faber, 2014.)
• Cross, J.: Harrison Birtwistle: Man, Mind, Music. (Faber & Faber, 2000.)
• Hall, Michael: Harrison Birtwistle. (Robson Books, 1984.)
• Hall, Michael: Harrison Birtwistle in Recent Years. (Robson Books, 1998.)
• Wilkins, Nigel: 'Musical Encounters' (Austin Macaulay, 2018.)

External links

• Rayfield Allied profile
• Biography on publisher's website
• Sir Harrison Birtwistle biography and works on the UE website (publisher of his music until 1994)
• Photographs in the National Portrait Gallery
• Service, Tom (11 April 2008). "The beast within". The Guardian. London. Retrieved 9 November 2017. An interview with Birtwistle about The Minotaur.
• Harrison Birtwistle's Biography on NMC Recordings
• "Harrison Birtwistle (biography, works, resources)" (in French and English). IRCAM.
• Interview with Harrison Birtwistle, December 8, 1996