Comparison of research networking tools and research profiling systems
Research networking (RN) is about using web-based tools to discover and use research and scholarly information about people and resources. Research networking tools (RN tools) serve as knowledge management systems for the research enterprise. RN tools connect institution-level/enterprise systems, national research networks, publicly available research data (e.g., grants and publications), and restricted/proprietary data by harvesting information from disparate sources into compiled expertise profiles for faculty, investigators, scholars, clinicians, community partners, and facilities. RN tools facilitate the development of new collaborations and team science to address new or existing research challenges through the rapid discovery and recommendation of researchers, expertise, and resources.
RN tools differ from search engines such as Google in that they access information in databases and other data not limited to web pages. They also differ from social networking systems such as LinkedIn or Facebook in that they represent a compendium of data ingested from authoritative and verifiable sources rather than predominantly individually asserted information, making RN tools more reliable. Yet, RN tools have sufficient flexibility to allow for profile editing. RN tools also provide resources to bolster human connector systems: they can make non-intuitive matches, they do not depend on serendipity, and they do not have a propensity to return only to previously identified collaborations/collaborators. RN tools also generally have associated analytical capabilities that enable evaluation of collaboration and cross-disciplinary research/scholarly activity, especially over time.
Researcher networking tools and research profiling systems can help researchers gain recognition for their work in the increasingly crowded publication environment. Active promotion of scholarship has become another aspect of the publication cycle. Recent years have seen a proliferation of both commercial and non-profit services that help researchers increase visibility and recognition of their work. A plethora of digital researcher services exist to effort to enhance discoverability, shareability, and citability of researchers and their scholarship. According to Shanks and Arlitsch, digital researcher services fall into three categories:
- Author/Researcher Identification—these services provide some necessary infrastructure that may be used in the other two categories, such as unique identifiers and name disambiguation
- Academic and Professional Networking—most succinctly described as “social networking for academics,” these services focus on connecting users based on research interest, affiliation, geography, or other variables.
- Reference and Citation Management—while these tools and services include some of the functionality and features of other categories, they are distinct given their primary focus on management of citations that a researcher compiles for use within a publication or for sharing with other researchers.
Importantly, data harvested into robust RN tools is accessible for broad repurposing, especially if available as Linked Open Data (RDF triples). Thus RN tools enhance research support activities by providing data for customized, up-to-date web pages, CV/biosketch generation, and data tables for grant proposals.
The following tables compare research networking (RN) software.
- 1 General
- 2 Data sources, ingest and export formats
- 3 Data interoperability and integration
- 4 Users profiled, user interactivity and networking functionality
- 5 Controlled vocabulary, ontologies and author disambiguation
- 6 Bibliometrics
- 7 See also
- 8 Notes and references
- 9 Bibliography
- 10 External links
This table provides general information for each tool: name, developing institution, external links to information, whether the code is Open Source and known adopters of the software.
|Research Networking Tool||Link to Product Page||Developer/Owner||Open Source||Adopters|
|Activity Insight||Activity Insight||Digital Measures||No||Hundreds of major research institutions around the world|
|C-IKNOW||C-IKNOW||Science of Networks in Communities (SONIC) - Northwestern University||Yes||National Cancer Institute, National Science Foundation|
|PROFILES by Mentis® (formerly Collaborative Partnership / Profile System)||PROFILES by Mentis® (formerly Collaborative Partnership and Research Expertise at UT Arlington)||Inknowledge, Inc (previously University of Texas at Arlington)||No (Profiles is available in a free forever plan)||UT Arlington, UT Pan American, University of North Texas Health Science Center, UT El Paso, UT San Antonio, UT Tyler, UT Health Science Center, University of North Texas (formerly), UT Dallas, UT Health Center at Tyler, Texas Christian University, Gulf Coast Consortia: Rice University, Baylor College of Medicine and several others)|
|Community Academic Profiles - CAP||Community Academic Profiles||Stanford University||No||Stanford University|
|CurvitaTM Profile Manager||Curvita Profile Manager||SciMed Solutions||No||University of North Carolina, University of Virginia, Duke University|
|CUSP - Columbia University Scientific Profiles||CUSP||Columbia University||No||Columbia University|
|Digital Vita||DigitalVita||Center for Dental Informatics - University of Pittsburgh||Yes||University of Pittsburgh, Pitt Health Sciences Center|
|Elsevier's Pure (now integrated with SciVal Experts)||Pure||Elsevier||No||220 implementations worldwide containing profiles for over 160,000 researcher profiles. See Pure client list.|
|Elsevier's SciVal||SciVal||Elsevier||No||Over 200 adopters worldwide|
|Epernicus Solutions & Epernicus Network||Epernicus||Epernicus||No (but Epernicus Network is free to use)||Harvard, MIT, Indiana University, Stanford, University of California Berkeley (but not exclusively)|
|Epistemio||Epistemio||Epistemio||No||N/A (platform is directed toward individual researcher use)|
|ERIM Member Profile System (ERIM MIS)||People ERIM People profile system||Erasmus Research Institute of Management, Erasmus University Rotterdam, Netherlands||No||Erasmus University|
|EUREKA!TM Enhancing Student Research||EUREKA||University of Texas at Austin (UTA)||No||University of Texas at Austin|
|Expertise @ Maryland||UM Experts||University of Maryland||Yes (will be)||University of Maryland College Park|
|Faculty Profile System||UC Irvine Faculty Profile System||University of California Irvine||No||UC Irvine|
|Faculty Profiles System||Stony Brook University Faculty Profiles System||Stony Brook University||No||Stony Brook University|
|Faculty Research Information Profile (FRIP)||Discontinued. Work on this system ceased; moved on to developing Digital Vita||University of Pittsburgh||N/A||(formerly) University of Pittsburgh|
|Faculty Scholarly Productivity Index||Academic Analytics||Academic Analytics, LLC||No||Unknown|
|GENIUS||InfoEd GENIUS||InfoEd Global||No||Many Big Ten/CIC institutions|
|Google search generated from an institution's home page or Google search limited to only one domain (e.g. university.edu)||No (but anyone can access Google)||Anyone can access|
|HUBzero||HUBzero||Purdue University||Yes||Indiana CTSI, Indiana University, Purdue University, Notre Dame|
|iamResearcher||iamResearcher||University of Southampton, UK||Unknown||N/A (platform is directed toward individual researcher use)|
|i2iConnect||i2iConnect||Indiana University||No (but original software from ThemesJoomla is)||N/A (platform is directed toward individual researcher use)|
|INDURE (Indiana Database for University Research Expertise)||INDURE||Indiana University / Purdue University||No||Ball State, Indiana University, Purdue University, University of Notre Dame|
|IRIS (Institutional Research Information System)||IRIS||CINECA||Yes (will be in CERIF mode in first half of 2016)||60 universities|
|Knode||Knode||Knode||No||Multiple, anyone can use, collaborating with VIVO and UCSF|
|Lattes Platform||Lattes||CNPq - Brazil||Unknown||N/A (Platform is directed toward individual researcher use in Brazil)|
|LatticeGrid||LatticeGrid public Wiki||Northwestern University Clinical and Translational Sciences Institute (NUCATS) - Biomedical Informatics Center (NUBIC)||Yes||Northwestern Feinberg School of Medicine & Cancer Center, UCSF Cancer Center, Fox Chase Cancer Center, University of Michigan, Case Western University|
|No (but LinkedIn is free to use)||N/A (Platform is directed toward individual researcher use. Millions of users are registered globally.)|
|Life Science Network||Life Science Network||Life Science Network gGmbH||Yes (upon request)||Anyone can use.|
|Loki||Loki||University of Iowa||No||University of Iowa Institute for Clinical and Translational Science|
|Lyterati||Lyterati||Entigence Corporation||No||George Washington University, The New School, Lehigh University|
|McCormick Collaboration Visualization Tool||Collaboration at McCormick||Northwestern University||No||McCormick School of Engineering and Applied Science at Northwestern University|
|Mendeley||Mendeley||Mendeley||No||Anyone can use|
|MizzouLinks||none available||University of Missouri||Unknown||University of Missouri|
|MyScienceWork||MyScienceWork||Unknown||No (but anyone can register and use the network)||Anyone can register and use. The network is directed at the individual researcher|
|OSU:pro||OSU:pro||Ohio State University||No (but can be licensed)||Ohio State University|
|Pivot||Pivot||ProQuest, LLC||No||100 university campuses and research organizations globally|
|Profiles Research Networking Software||Profiles||Harvard University||Yes (BSD license)||Harvard, UCSF, and many others (see Profiles users )|
|REACH NC Life Science Experts Visualization Tool||REACH NC||RENCI (Renaissance Computing Institute, a collaboration between University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Duke University and North Carolina State University) Duke Research Triangle Institute University of North Carolina General Administration||No (but free to the public)||Appalachian State University Duke University East Carolina University Elizabeth City State University Fayetteville State University NC A&T North Carolina Central University North Carolina State University RTI International UNC-Asheville University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill UNC-Charlotte UNC-Greensboro UNC-Pembroke UNC-Wilmington Western Carolina University Winston-Salem State University|
|Research Accelerator||YCCI Research Accelerator||ResearchAccelerator.org||Unknown||Yale University|
|ResearcherID||ResearcherID||Thomson Reuters||No (but ResearcherID network is free to access and use by individual users)||N/A (Platform is directed toward individual researcher use)|
|ScholarBridge||ScholarBridge||ScholarBridge LLC||No||14 university members and free access for any individual student or researcher|
|SciENcv||SciENcv||A pilot program sponsored by the Federal Demonstration Partnership and the National Science and Technology Council (NSTC) supported by the STAR METRICS program||Yes||Sponsored by the Federal Demonstration Partnership and the NSTC's interagency groups: Research Business Model (RBM) and Science of Science Policy (SoSP)|
|Symplectic Elements||Symplectic Elements||Symplectic||No (However, an open source VIVO Harvester extension is available.)||80+ major research institutions around the world, including the University of Cambridge (UK), University of Oxford (UK), University of Melbourne (AUS), Duke University (US), University of Auckland (NZ), Cornell University (US), Georgia Tech (US). (see Some of Symplectic's clients)|
|UNIWeb||UNIWeb||Proximify||No||University of Ottawa, McGill University, Dalhousie University, University of British Columbia Okanagan Campus, École de technologie supérieure, CIMVHR|
|VIVO||VIVO||Duraspace||Yes||Cornell University, University of Florida, Washington University in St. Louis, Weill Cornell Medical College, Indiana University, Ponce School of Medicine, Scripps Research Institute, Duke University, University of Colorado at Boulder, Northwestern University, University of Nebraska, University of Melbourne, Griffith University, Chinese Academy of Sciences, etc. There are currently over 140 VIVO implementations in the United States and international VIVO projects in over 25 countries.|
|WorkWeb||WebWork at archive.org||Columbia University||No||Columbia University|
|Yaffle||Yaffle||Memorial University of Newfoundland||Yes||Memorial University of Newfoundland|
Data sources, ingest and export formats
|Research Networking Tool||Data Source / Infeed Functionality||Auto Ingest?||Linked Open Data?||Data Export Types|
|Academic Room||Manual entry of data by users. May be some auto-ingest of PubMed citation data||Unknown||Unknown||Unknown|
|Activity Insight||Information typically imported from the following sources: PubMed, Google Scholar, Scopus, Web of Science, RefWorks, Banner, Datatel, PeopleSoft, CampusVue, Jenzabar, Sedona, EndNote, Mendeley, Zotero, BiBTeX, a RESTful web services API, CSV Data Imports, etc. Also supports various methods of manual entry.||Yes||Yes||RTF, XLS, CSV, PDF, HTML, XML|
|C-IKNOW||Network Surveys, automated upload for any kind of network data including archival, scientometric, webometric and computer log data. Also import data in GraphML, RDF, and DL (used by UCINET)||Yes(for defined data)||Yes||RDF, XML/RDF|
|PROFILES by Mentis® (formerly Collaborative Partnership / Profile System)||Automated or on-demand import from PubMed, Google Scholar, Web of Science, Scopus, Banner, PeopleSoft, Web Services, Flat files and Manual Entry. Can be easily configured with any institutional subscription or database.||Yes||Yes||RTF, XLS, CSV, PDF, HTML, XML, JSON|
|Community Academic Profiles - CAP||CAP automatically generates a profile for all faculty, physicians, students, postdocs and staff (both academic and administrative) in the School of Medicine. Data flows automatically from a variety of source systems.||Yes||Unknown||Unknown|
|Converis||Default connection to Thomson Reuters Web of Science, Scopus, oubmed, europubmed, etc. Ay internal data feed (HR, finance can be configured)||Yes—can be pre-populated and alerts recommend new data||Yes—can be used to power VIVO||XML, .mbb, XLS|
|CurvitaTM Profile Manager||Information collected from university systems||Yes||Unknown||Unknown|
|CUSP - Columbia University Scientific Profiles||Databases for employees and grants; PubMed for publications||Yes||Unknown||Unknown|
|Digital Vita||PubMed, some from HR system, direct input from investigators. System authenticates users through an application developed by the IT group that supports the Senior Vice Chancellor of Health Sciences; that system accesses the HR system for data about employees' rank and status (active or not); Working with the grants office to get a regular report of data from their proposal database. Manually entered publications/presentations automatically forwarded to co-authors.||Yes (Some)||Yes||PDF, RTF|
|Elsevier's Pure (now integrated with SciVal Experts)||Sources include Scopus, Web of Science, PubMed, Embase, Mendeley, arXiv, Worldcat, CrossRef, Journal TOC, CAB Abstracts, SAO/NASA Astrophysics Data System and SciVal Funding opportunities; Data from institutions' internal systems, including HR data, grants, publications, patents, core facilities/resources, etc. Researchers or proxy users can enter additional content into the profiles, including research statements, research interest keywords, publications, grants, patents, books, creative works, education, researcher datasets, press clippings, awards and honors; free text can also be imported. Integration with all major institutional repositories.||Yes||Yes||XML, RDF, SPARQL, CSV, CERIF XML, MS Word, Excel, PDF, ATOM/XML web services, EndNote/Reference Manager, BibTex, various government assessment submission formats|
|Elsevier's SciVal||Scopus and ScienceDirect usage data||Yes||No||CSV, PDF, PNG, JPEG|
|Epernicus Solutions & Epernicus Network||Data entered by applicant||No||Unknown||Unknown|
|ERIM Member Profile System (ERIM MIS)||ERIM MIS database, Erasmus Publication Repository, Oracle portal||Yes||Unknown||Unknown|
|EUREKA!TM Enhancing Student Research||Information about faculty research interests||No||Unknown||Unknown|
|Expertise @ Maryland||Central university faculty database||Yes||Unknown||Unknown|
|Faculty Profile System||Manually entered data about the faculty (faculty can enter, a proxy can enter, or designated staff work on maintaining profiles)||No (Faculty status verified by comparison with UC Irvine HR's Academic Personnel system)||Unknown||Unknown|
|Faculty Research Information Profile (FRIP)||Discontinued. Work on this system ceased; moved on to developing Digital Vita||N/A||N/A||N/A|
|Faculty Scholarly Productivity Index||FSP Database (2007–2008)||Yes||Unknown||Unknown|
|GENIUS||InfoEd proprietary grant funding databases||Yes (But only of InfoEd database data. Faculty profile information must be entered manually.)||Unknown||Unknown|
|Institution's directory, news releases, and other institutional websites||Yes||Yes||Many types, depending on the format of the file retrieved.|
|HUBzero||Comprehensive portal to support virtual research organizations including modular Web 2.0 tools, modeling and simulation tools, computational integration, identity management, workflow, personal profile management, data management, education||Yes||Yes||Unknown|
|i2iConnect||Listings of industry licensing representatives categorized by product and disease categories with matchmaking and collaborator discovery features||Yes||Unknown||Unknown|
|InCites||Thomson Reuters Web of Science, ESI, JCR||No||No||XML, .mbb, XLS|
|INDURE (Indiana Database for University Research Expertise)||Faculty-entered information about research, faculty home pages||Yes? (Partial?)||Unknown||Unknown|
|LatticeGrid||Medical School Faculty database, PubMed, InfoEd, Northwestern's eIRB database||Yes||Yes||Microsoft Word, Excel, PDF|
|Information entered manually by user||No||Unknown||Unknown|
|Life Science Network||PubMed / Information entered manually by user.||No||Yes||CSV (for some modules).|
|Loki||Local Medline, PubMed, local NSF award database, local NIH RePORTER database, campus directory services||Yes (Partial)||Unknown||Unknown|
|Lyterati||PubMed, Google Scholar, BibTex, Ellucian, PeopleSoft, Workday, RESTful APIs, Template Driven Imports, CSV, Excel, Manual Entry Using Webpages, Faculty CVs||Yes||Unknown||PDF, MS Word, Excel, CSV, Web Services|
|McCormick Collaboration Visualization Tool||Thomson Reuters Web of Science||Yes||Unknown||Unknown|
|MizzouLinks||Information collected from interviews and imported from a few institutional systems||No||Unknown||Unknown|
|MyScienceWork||Information input by user||No||Unknown||Unknown|
|Pivot||Combines editorially created data on funding opportunities and profiles. Profile data sources from publicly available university organization and faculty member/researcher information, user-generated data, PubMed, Agricola, ERIC, and ProQuest citation databases, indexed faculty/researcher webpages.||Yes (for all citation data from sources listed in DataSource. Profiles editorially created, but user-generated profiles also included)||No||Unknown|
|Profiles Research Networking Software||HR systems, PubMed, NIH RePORTER, commercial sources of publication data, institution-provided and user managed data||Yes||Yes||XML, RDF, SPARQL|
|REACH NC Life Science Experts Visualization Tool||SciVal Experts, RAMSES||Yes||Yes||RSI, CSV, Web-service API|
|Research Accelerator||Information entered by individual members||No||Unknown||Unknown|
|ResearcherID||Manually entered biographical and bibliographical information. Members can search Web of Science, Web of Knowledge, and other online collections, or manually enter publication data. Accounts can be created by individuals or by administrators using a web service.||Yes (Partial; profiles created by administrators are pre-populated for individuals to review.)||No||None|
|SciENcv||Information that would normally be found in a curriculum vitae or biosketch||Yes||Unknown||Uses open data exchange standards|
|Symplectic Elements||Custom import from any internal data source via API, out of the box automatic bibliographic import (subject to subscriptions where appropriate) from arXiv, Cinii, CrossRef, DBLP, Europe PMC, figshare, PubMed, RePeC, Scopus, Web of Science, with more planned. Secure ORCID integration also available. In-feed from HR/Identity systems, internal grant databases. Integration with all major repository technologies.||Yes Through integrated portals like VIVO and Profiles RNS||Yes Source for linked data||CSV, CERIF XML, MS Word, Excel, PDF (APA6), ATOM/XML web services, EndNote/Reference Manager, BibTex, RDF (Linked Data),
various government assessment submission formats
|UNIWeb||Users can enter their CV or bibliographic data manually, or import from the Canadian Common CV, PubMed, Google Scholar, Scopus, Web of Science, Bibtek, Endnote.||Unknown||Unknown||XML, MS Word, Excel|
|VIVO||PubMed, NIH RePORTER, PeopleSoft, internal HR & administrative databases, Scopus (with institutional license), Web of Science (with institutional license); emphasis on verified data sources, many many others being ingested at various institutions.||Yes (manual data entry possible, too)||Yes||RDF, GraphXML, CSV file|
|Yaffle||Memorial University systems||Yes||Unknown||Unknown|
Data interoperability and integration
This table provides information on whether the research networking tool is compatible with institutional enterprise systems (e.g. human resources databases), can be integrated with other external products or add-ons, and can be used for regional, national, international or federated connectivity.
|Research Networking Tool||Interoperability with Institutional Enterprise Systems||Interoperability with External Systems||Integration with Add-on Components or Products||Regional, National, International or Federated Connectivity?|
|Academic Room||No||unknown||unknown||The system is voluntary, so national and international by active inclusion|
|Activity Insight||Yes (Banner, Datatel, PeopleSoft, CampusVue, Jenzabar, etc.)||Yes (Google Scholar, Scopus, Web of Science, RefWorks, etc.)||Yes (EndNote, Mendeley, Zotero, tools which generate BiBTeX, CSV or XML files)||No|
|PROFILES by Mentis® (formerly Collaborative Partnership / Profile System)||Yes||Yes (has API, works with Elsevier PURE, Activity Insight, VIVO etc.)||Yes (funding opportunities from grants.gov)||Yes (National and International)|
|Community Academic Profiles - CAP||Yes||Yes||Yes||No|
|Converis||Yes (Bisynchronous and one way operations with institution's enterprise system both possible.)||Yes (Yes, Web of Science, ORCID, pubmed, europubmed.)||Yes (Integrates with Pentaho Research Analytics module and InCites)||No|
|CurvitaTM Profile Manager||Yes||Yes||Unknown||No|
|CUSP - Columbia University Scientific Profiles||No||Yes PubMed only||Unknown||No|
|Digital Vita||No||Yes (only PubMed)||Unknown||Yes National federated connectivity through DIRECT2Experts|
|Elsevier's Pure (now integrated with SciVal Experts)||Yes institutions have access to Web Services in order to feed data into internal databases; Web Services can be consumed as directed by institution. Pure currently ingests a range of data from institutions' own systems, including grants data, HR data, institutional repositories, publication databases, book listings and more.||Yes Scopus, PubMed, NIH RePORTER, SciVal Funding, Embase, Mendeley, arXiv, Worldcat, CrossRef, JournalTOC, CAB Abstracts, SAO/NSA Astrophysics Data System, Web of Science, institution's internal databases, including HR data, grants, publications, patents, etc.||Yes the Funding Discovery module within Pure integrates with SciVal Funding, automatically recommending funding opportunities and suggested collaborators to profiled researchers with no manual effort. Pure also integrates with SciVal to allow easy analysis of your researcher impact with the benchmark capabilities of SciVal.||Yes the Pure Experts Community interconnects all participating Pure Portal applications internationally into a single search (participation is voluntary); Additional functionality enables users to search across different institutions participating in DIRECT2experts network (including VIVO instances, Harvard Profiles, Stanford CAP, etc.). Institutions can participate in VIVO through Pure|
|Elsevier's SciVal||Yes (Institutions have access to the API with Scopus data in order to feed data into internal databases.)||Yes (Integrates with Pure.)||Yes (Scopus & ScienceDirect)||No|
|Epernicus Solutions & Epernicus Network||Yes (Possible, for Epernicus Solutions)||No||Unknown||No|
|ERIM Member Profile System (ERIM MIS)||Yes||Yes ID resolver included, so links to external systems are created, like SSRN, ResearcherID, Google scholar alerts & Search, social mention search from personal page, MEEBO sharing possible, Tynt statistics included||Unknown||No|
|EUREKA!TM Enhancing Student Research||No||No||Unknown||No|
|Expertise @ Maryland||May be possible||No||Unknown||No|
|Faculty Profile System||No||No||Unknown||No|
|Faculty Research Information Profile (FRIP)||Discontinued. Work on this system ceased; moved on to developing Digital Vita||N/A||N/A||N/A|
|Faculty Scholarly Productivity Index||Unknown||Unknown||Unknown||No|
|GENIUS||Yes||Yes Only other InfoEd modules (SMARTS: Service that automatically sends notices of funding opportunities via email. You provide keywords that describe your research interests, and SMARTS matches those keywords with present funding programs; SPIN: Enables subscribers to directly search for all sponsored programs - past and present, contained within the InfoEd database)||Unknown||No|
|HUBzero||No||Yes PubMed; data is semantic web compliant as of August 2011||Possibly||No|
|InCites||Yes (Institutions have access to Web Services in order to feed data into internal databases.)||Yes (Integrates with Converis.)||Yes (Web of Science, ResearcherID)||No|
|INDURE (Indiana Database for University Research Expertise)||No||No||Unknown||Yes for 4 Indiana institutions only|
|LatticeGrid||Yes InfoEd, eIRB, Medical School faculty database||Yes (PubMed)||Yes (Possible)||Yes National federated connectivity through DIRECT2Experts|
|Life Science Network||No||Yes (Pubmed)||No||No|
|Lyterati||Yes (Ellucian, PeopleSoft, Workday InfoEd, Coeus)||Yes (PubMed, VIVO, Google Scholar, BibTex or CSV Sources)||Yes (BibTex and CSV)||Yes, capable|
|McCormick Collaboration Visualization Tool||No||Yes Only Thomson Reuters Web of Science||Unknown||No|
|Profiles Research Networking Software||Yes||Yes Pubmed, commercial sources of publication data, semantic web applications via VIVO ontology.||Yes||Yes Profiles Users Group has regular conference calls and works on collaborative software development projects. Profiles can perform federated queries across other Profiles instances, and with other products using linked open data (VIVO ontology) and the DIRECT2Experts API.|
|REACH NC Life Science Experts Visualization Tool||Yes||Yes Through SciVal API||No||No|
|ResearcherID||No||Yes Through ResearcherID download service, institutions can load data into their internal systems. Also is integrated with other Thomson Reuters offerings, including Web of Knowledge, EndNote, and Research In View||Unknown||No|
|SciENcv||Yes (is possible through open data exchange standards)||Yes||Unknown||No|
|Symplectic Elements||Yes Clients have the ability to integrate with existing web profile management systems, export data for business intelligence solutions and easily submit research outcomes for various government assessment exercises. This includes HR, publications, teaching activities, grants, institutional repositories, and any other system providing or consuming research data.||Yes Elements integrates with a variety of external systems including: Altmetric, figshare, ORCID, SHERPA/RoMEO (licensing information), DOAJ (licensing information)||Yes Elements can be linked to all major open repository technologies and an open source VIVO Harvester extension is also available.||No|
|VIVO||Yes Data can be ingested from a wide variety of local sources (including HR, grants, course databases, institutional repositories, membership rosters, research interests, and many others) to reflect a complete view of the institution's priorities and efforts.||Yes see mini-grants <http://www.vivoweb.org/blog/2011/01/award-announcement-vivo-collaborative-research-projects-program>; eagle-i; Drupal; many others - any tool that can consume open linked data. Other ongoing collaborations with Wellspring (maintaining VIVO profiles with a focus upon tech transfer and also as a 3rd party implementation service provider) and with Symplectic.||Yes VIVO collaborates with eagle-I on research resources. Future plans include adding many additional data types which are meaningful in the academic research setting. VIVO data are structured using a comprehensive ontology designed for local extension and major ontology "plugins" such as BIBO and eagle-i.||Yes VIVO Consortium received $12.2M NIH ARRA U24 award in 2009 to fully develop software and create national system of federated research expertise directories/research networking systems; All other semantic web-compliant software platforms can be integrated into the consortium (example: Harvard Profiles). Participant in Direct2Experts and VIVO Search|
|Yaffle||No||No||Unknown||The Canadian research funding councils as well as knowledge mobilization networks across the country (governments and universities) are working to develop a model to share what Yaffle has built|
Users profiled, user interactivity and networking functionality
This table provides information on what user population is profiled for each tool, ability for users to edit their own profile data and type of networking. Active networking means that the user can enter connections to the network by entering colleagues' names. Passive networking means that the software infers network connections from a user's publication co-authors and builds a network from these names.
|Research Networking Tool||Profiled User Population||Can Users Update Their Own Profile Data?||Type of Networking (Active or Passive)||Includes Functionality to Match Expertise with Funding Opportunities|
|Academic Room||Anyone can create a profile. Profiled categories include "Faculty", "Grad Students", "Undergrads", "Professionals"||Yes||Active||No|
|Activity Insight||Faculty, Staff, Graduate Students||Yes||Active and Passive||Yes|
|C-IKNOW||Defined using Web of science ID or on an ad hoc basis||No||Active and Passive||No|
|PROFILES by Mentis® (formerly Collaborative Partnership / Profile System)||Faculty, Students, Staff, Equipment Owners, Research Centers, Facilities, Technologies, Units etc. as per institution's needs||Yes||Active and Passive||Yes|
|Community Academic Profiles - CAP||Active Stanford physicians, School of Medicine faculty, students, staff and postdocs.||Yes||Active and Passive||Unknown|
|CurvitaTM Profile Manager||All||Unknown||No networking||Unknown|
|CUSP - Columbia University Scientific Profiles||All Columbia faculty||Yes||Active||Unknown|
|Elsevier's Pure (now integrated with SciVal Experts)||Any researchers can be included||Yes the Administration module enables users to enter content into their profiles via forms, uploads or imports. Content types supported include (but not limited to): Persons, awarded grants, journals, org units, projects, events, equipment, activities, press clippings, funding opportunities, research outputs (from journal articles to memorandums of understanding), impacts, applications, datasets, student theses, courses taught and prizes||Passive||Yes the Funding Discovery module within Pure automatically recommends funding opportunities from SciVal Funding and suggested collaborators to profiled researchers with no manual effort.|
|Elsevier's SciVal||All published researchers||Yes, SciVal links to profiles in Scopus and researchers can submit feedback on profiles within Scopus to have papers added or removed.||Passive||No|
|Epernicus Solutions & Epernicus Network||Anyone who enters a profile (for Epernicus Network)||Yes (for Epernicus Network)||Passive||Unknown|
|Epistemio||Any researcher who creates a profile||Yes||N/A||No|
|ERIM Member Profile System (ERIM MIS)||Multiple faculties at Erasmus use it||Unknown||Active||Unknown|
|EUREKA!TM Enhancing Student Research||University of Texas at Austin faculty||Unknown||No networking||Unknown|
|Expertise @ Maryland||All||Unknown||Currently passive, but building active||Unknown|
|Faculty Profile System||Any faculty at UC Irvine||Yes||No networking||Unknown|
|Faculty Research Information Profile (FRIP)||N/A||N/A||N/A||N/A|
|Faculty Scholarly Productivity Index||Federally funded, published faculty||Unknown||No networking||Unknown|
|GENIUS||Any faculty member who creates a profile on the system||Yes||Passive||Unknown|
|Anyone can be searched on Google||N/A||No networking||No|
|HUBzero||Indiana University, Indiana University School of Medicine, Purdue University, U. of Notre Dame, Regenstrief||Unknown||Active||Unknown|
|iamResearcher||Any researcher who creates a profile||Yes||Passive (?)||Unknown|
|iAMscientist||Any researcher who creates a profile||Yes||Passive||Unknown|
|i2iConnect||Industry licensing representatives||Unknown||Passive||Unknown|
|INDURE||All faculty at 4 Indiana institutions||Unknown||Passive||Unknown|
|LatticeGrid||Currently Medical School faculty only. Developed for biomedical research organizations||Yes (Users can update the Medical School faculty database, which then feeds LatticeGrid||Passive)||Yes (Connected to a Northwestern tool called FacultyConnect to match faculty with a special limited set of Northwestern-specific non-federal funding opportunities in the life and biomedical sciences domains)|
|Lattes Database||Curriculum and institutions database of Science and Technology areas in Brazil. Anyone can create a profile.||Yes||No apparent networking||Unknown|
|Anyone who creates a LinkedIn profile||Yes||Passive and Active||Unknown|
|Life Science Network||Anyone who creates a profile||Yes||Active and Passive||No|
|Loki||All faculty at University of Iowa||Yes||Passive||Unknown|
|Loop||Anyone who creates a profile||Yes||Passive and Active||Unknown|
|Lyterati||Faculty, academic administrators (department chairs, deans, provost), center directors, grad students, staff||Yes||Active and Passive||Yes (through advanced searching and web profile exploration)|
|McCormick Collaboration Visualization Tool||All Northwestern publications from Web of Science||No||Passive||No|
|MizzouLinks||Currently a pilot group from two Missouri interdisciplinary centers||Unknown||Passive||Unknown|
|MyScienceWork||Anyone who creates a profile||Yes||Active and Passive||Unknown|
|OSU:pro||All OSU faculty||Unknown||No apparent networking||Unknown|
|Pivot||3 million profiles (and growing, according to the publisher). Profiles are compiled even without user registration, but can only be viewed by registered users||Yes||Passive||Yes through a direct connection with the COS product|
|Profiles||All users as defined by each institution. "Profiles" are also created for institutions, departments, concepts, publications, networks, events or any other class defined in the ontology||Yes||Passive and Active||No|
|ReachNC||UNC faculty in various disciplines, Duke, and RTI Fellows||Yes||Passive||No|
|Research Accelerator||Any member of the Yale research enterprise||Yes (?)||Passive||Unknown|
|ResearcherID||Anyone who creates a profile||Yes||Passive and Active||Unknown|
|SciENcv||Not yet established||Not yet established||No apparent networking||No|
|Symplectic Elements||All users may be included (as defined by institution).||Yes (Profiles are automatically populated with data, as dictated by internal and external data feeds. Some profile data can be manually curated by end users, proxy users, or administrators. Users can create new relationships between elements.)||Passive and Active||Yes - Through integrations with research news and funding information provider *Research, researchers are able to get tailored funding opportunities linked to their Elements accounts.|
|VIVO||All users (as defined by the institution)||Yes||Passive and Active||Possibly|
|Yaffle||All Memorial University faculty||Yes||Passive||Unknown|
This table provides information on the types of controlled vocabulary or thesauri used by the tools, as well as ontologies supported and whether author disambiguation is performed by the software.
|Research Networking Tool||Thesaurus/Controlled Vocabulary Used||Ontology/Ontologies Supported||Automatic Author Disambiguation|
|Activity Insight||Yes||Fully customizable data collection screens; campus, college and department-defined ontologies||Yes|
|C-IKNOW||Not applicable||Uses elements of FOAF and Dublin Core in RDF; uses Pellet reasoning engine||No (but can be done in conjunction with software developed at Northwestern University)|
|PROFILES by Mentis® (formerly Collaborative Partnership / Profile System)||Yes||Dublin Core, Social Media and compatible with VIVO and other popular ontologies||Yes|
|Community Academic Profiles - CAP||MeSH||Unknown||Yes (partial)|
|Converis||In some fields||CASRAI, VIVO||Yes (Author clustering capabilities used to match authors with papers)|
|CurvitaTM Profile Manager||Unknown||Unknown||No|
|CUSP - Columbia University Scientific Profiles||Unknown||Unknown||Yes|
|Digital Vita||Unknown||Unknown||No (but can be done manually by authors)|
|Elsevier's Pure (now integrated with SciVal Experts)||The "Elsevier Fingerprinting Engine" uses ten thesauri including MeSH to match and identify key concepts for an individual or group of people. Thesauri updates and expansion are ongoing.||Maps to VIVO ontology||Yes|
|Elsevier's SciVal||The "Elsevier Fingerprinting Engine" uses ten thesauri including MeSH to match and identify key concepts for an individual or group of people. Thesauri updates and expansion are ongoing.||Maps to VIVO ontology||Yes|
|Epernicus Solutions & Epernicus Network||Unknown||Unknown||No (can be done manually by authors)|
|ERIM Member Profile System (ERIM MIS)||Unknown||Unknown||Yes (uses author ID numbers)|
|EUREKA!TM Enhancing Student Research||Unknown||Unknown||No|
|Expertise @ Maryland||Unknown||Unknown||Yes|
|Faculty Profile System||Unknown||Unknown||No|
|Faculty Research Information Profile (FRIP)||N/A||N/A||N/A|
|Faculty Scholarly Productivity Index||Unknown||Unknown||Unknown|
|None (Google uses generic keywords)||Unknown||No (but can be done manually through Google Scholar "My Citations" functionality)|
|InCites||In some fields||Unknown||No (Though InCites can accept data from ResearcherID and Converis profiling systems for disambiguation)|
|LatticeGrid||MeSH||Uses elements of FOAF and other ontologies||No (but can be done manually by authors)|
|Life Science Network||Unknown||Unknown||No (but can be done manually)|
|Loki||Unknown||Unknown||Yes (uses campus directory for authentication)|
|Lyterati||Yes||Fully customizable ontology that maps to VIVO||Yes (using parsing algorithm on free text)|
|McCormick Collaboration Visualization Tool||None||Unknown||Yes|
|ORCID (Open Researcher and Contributor ID)||Unknown||Unknown||Yes|
|Profiles||MeSH, others are being developed to go beyond the life and biomedical sciences||VIVO RDF ontology with additional Profiles RDF classes and properties||Yes Harvard Profiles uses an XML-based "disambiguation service" to import Medline publications and uses configurable heuristics in its disambiguation algorithm|
|ReachNC||Scopus taxonomy uses MeSH and general keywords||Maps to VIVO ontology||Yes|
|ResearcherID||Unknown||Unknown||No (although authors can build their publication list and manually disambiguate)|
|SciENcv||No thesaurus used||Unknown||No|
|Symplectic Elements||MeSH, Fields of Research, ScienceMetrix.||Supports mapping of publication, person and grants data to the VIVO ontology via their open source VIVO Harvester Extension, as well as Harvard Catalyst's Profiles RNS.||Yes|
|VIVO||VIVO uses several thesauri that are available through Semantic Web, including MeSH||The VIVO Ontology was developed and supported by NIH-funded efforts and continues to be developed and built by its open source community at GitHub and in collaboration with the eagle-i project.||Yes|
This table provides information on the types of bibliometrics provided in the tool.
|Research Networking Tool||h-index||Citation count||Altmetrics||SNIP and SJR||Journal Impact Factor*||Other||Comment|
|PROFILES by Mentis® (formerly Collaborative Partnership / Profile System)||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes|
|Community Academic Profiles - CAP|
|InCites||Yes||Yes||Yes Can integrate with altmetric data feed||No||Yes|
|CurvitaTM Profile Manager|
|CUSP - Columbia University Scientific Profiles|
|Elsevier's Pure (integrated with SciVal Experts)||Yes||Yes||Yes Altmetric and PlumX||Yes||No||Field-weighted Citation Impact, Number of Authors, CiteScore|
|Elsevier's SciVal||Yes||Yes||Yes Views data from ScienceDirect and Scopus||Yes||No||20+ indicators ranging from h, g & m indices, to Publications in Top Journal Percentiles, Field-Weighted Citation Impact, Academic-Corporate Collaboration Impact & Views per Publication|
|Epernicus Solutions & Epernicus Network|
|ERIM Member Profile System (ERIM MIS)|
|EUREKA!TM Enhancing Student Research|
|Expertise @ Maryland|
|Faculty Profile System|
|Faculty Research Information Profile (FRIP)|
|Faculty Scholarly Productivity Index|
|InCites||Yes||Yes||Yes Recorded Future partnership provides customized newsfeed and instition activity from web content||No||Yes|
|Life Science Network||No||No||Yes (views counts, recommendations, rating scores calculated from anonymous and non-anonymous contributions)||No||No (but journals can be entered into the database and their IF indicated)|
|McCormick Collaboration Visualization Tool|
Notes and references
- Carey J (2011). "Faculty of 1000 and VIVO: Invisible colleges and team science". Issues in Science and Technology Librarianship Spring 2011.
- Fazel-Zarandi M, Devlin HJ, Huang Y and Contractor N (2011). "Expert recommendation based on social drivers, social network analysis, and semantic data representation". 2nd International Workshop on Information Heterogeneity and Fusion in Recommender Systems. pp. 41-48. (ACM, Chicago, IL)
- Gewin, V (15 December 2010). "Collaboration: Social networking seeks critical mass". Nature. 468 (7326): 993–4. doi:10.1038/nj7326-993a.
- Contractor, NS; Monge, PR (November 2002). "Managing knowledge networks". Management Communication Quarterly. 16 (2): 249–58. doi:10.1177/089331802237238.
- Shanks, Justin; Arlitsch, Kenning (2016-04-02). "Making Sense of Researcher Services". Journal of Library Administration. 56 (3): 295–316. ISSN 0193-0826. doi:10.1080/01930826.2016.1146534.
- Huang Y, Contractor N and Yao Y (2008). "CI-KNOW: Recommendation based on Social Networks." In The Proceedings of the 9th Annual International Digital Government Research Conference (Digital Government Society of North America), pp. 27-33.
- Peter J. Carrington; John Scott, eds. (2011). The SAGE Handbook of Social Network Analysis. SAGE. p. 590. ISBN 1847873952.
- This Purdue Team is Super - At Computing
- Kibbe, W. (2010). LatticeGrid
- "A CTSA-sponsored program for clinical research coordination: networking, education, and mentoring". Clin Transl Sci. 4 (1): 42–7. February 2011. PMC . PMID 21348955. doi:10.1111/j.1752-8062.2011.00259.x.
- Brooks E, Case C, Corson-Rikert J, et al. (2010). National VIVO network: Implementation plan Retrieved 2012-01-24.
- VIVO Looks To Next-Gen Scholarship And Its Interconnected Future
- VIVO Implementations In Progress
- Elizabeth Church (2012-08-23). "Web tools aim to open the gates to the ivory tower - The Globe and Mail". M.theglobeandmail.com. Retrieved 2012-11-09.
- Canada (2009-06-04). "Looking for a researcher near you? Yaffle it! - Concordia Journal - Concordia University - Montreal, Quebec, Canada". Cjournal.concordia.ca. Retrieved 2012-11-09.
- "A multi-level systems perspective for the science of team science". Sci Transl Med. 2 (49): 49cm24. September 2010. PMC . PMID 20844283. doi:10.1126/scitranslmed.3001399.
- Contractor, NS; Wasserman, S; Faust, K (July 2006). "Testing multitheoretical, multilevel hypothesis about organizational networks: An analytic framework and empirical example". Academy of Management Review. 31 (3): 681–703. doi:10.5465/AMR.2006.21318925.
- Cressman, D., Holbrook, J.A., Lewis, B.S., and Wixted, B. (2011). Understanding the Structure of Formal Research Networks (Vancouver, BC: Simon Fraser University).
- "The road we must take: multidisciplinary team science". Sci Transl Med. 2 (22): 22cm9. March 2010. PMID 20374998. doi:10.1126/scitranslmed.3000421.
- Falk-Krzesinski H, Shaw PL and Wimbiscus-Yoon L (2010). "Comparative Matrix of Research Networking Tools". (Poster presentation). National VIVO Conference: Enabling National Networking of Scientists (Queens, NY).
- Falk-Krzesinski HJ, Börner K, Contractor N, et al. (October 2010). "Advancing the science of team science". Clin Transl Sci. 3 (5): 263–6. PMC . PMID 20973925. doi:10.1111/j.1752-8062.2010.00223.x.
- Fried, NF; Gibbons, S (2005). "Understanding faculty to improve content recruitment for institutional repositories". D-Lib Magazine. 11: 1. doi:10.1045/january2005-foster.
- Guimerà, R; Uzzi, B; Spiro, J; Amaral, LAN (2005). "Team assembly mechanisms determine collaboration network structure and team performance". Science. 308 (5722): 697–702. PMC . PMID 15860629. doi:10.1126/science.1106340.
- "Multi-university research teams: shifting impact, geography, and stratification in science". Science. 322 (5905): 1259–62. November 2008. PMID 18845711. doi:10.1126/science.1158357.
- Maxmen A (April 2010). "Science networking gets serious". Cell. 141 (3): 387–9. PMID 20434976. doi:10.1016/j.cell.2010.04.019.
- Pober JS, Neuhauser CS, Pober JM (November 2001). "Obstacles facing translational research in academic medical centers". FASEB J. 15 (13): 2303–13. PMID 11689456. doi:10.1096/fj.01-0540lsf.
- Schleyer, T.; Spallek, H.; Butler, B. S.; Subramanian, S.; Weiss, D.; Poythress, M. L.; Rattanathikum, P.; Mueller, G. (2008). Requirements for expertise location systems in biomedical science and the Semantic Web. International Semantic Web Conference 2008. CiteSeerX .
- Schleyer, T.; Spallek, H.; Butler, B. S.; Subramanian, S.; Weiss, D.; Poythress, M. L.; Rattanathikum, P.; Mueller, G. (2008). "Facebook for scientists: requirements and services for optimizing how scientific collaborations are established". J Med Internet Res. 10 (3): e24. PMC . PMID 18701421. doi:10.2196/jmir.1047.
- Spallek H, Schleyer T and Butler BS (2008). "Good partners are hard to find: the search for and selection of collaborators in the health sciences". Paper presented at: Fourth IEEE International Conference on eScience (Indianapolis, IN: IEEE Computer Society).
- Stewart D (2011). "Enterprise content management in three easy questions". In Gartner Blog Network (Stamford, CT: Gartner).
- Stewart DL (2010). "Knowing what you know: Expertise Discovery & management - Part 1". In Connected Knowledge, DL Stewart, ed. (Portland, OR Oregon Health & Science University).
- Stewart DL (2010). "Sustaining the collaborative enterprise". In Connected Knowledge, DL Stewart, ed. (Portland, OR Oregon Health & Science University).
- Wieder B (2011). "Academic-reference firm offers $10,001 for best new research tool". In The Wired Campus, L Schamber, ed. (Washington, DC: The Chronicle of Higher Education).
- "The increasing dominance of teams in production of knowledge". Science. 316 (5827): 1036–9. May 2007. PMID 17431139. doi:10.1126/science.1136099.
This page has been cited by "AAMC Technology Now Research Networking" (pdf).