Designers have attempted to encourage emergent play by providing tools to players such as placing web browsers within the game engine (such as in Eve Online, The Matrix Online), providing XML integration tools and programming languages (Second Life), fixing exchange rates (Entropia Universe), and allowing a player to spawn any object they desire to solve a puzzle (Scribblenauts).
Intentional emergence occurs when some creative uses of the game are intended by the game designers. Since the 1970s and 1980s board games and table top role playing games such as Cosmic Encounter or Dungeons & Dragons have featured intentional emergence as a primary game function by supplying players with relatively simple rules or frameworks for play that intentionally encouraged them to explore creative strategies or interactions and exploit them toward victory or goal achievement.
Immersive sims, such as Deus Ex and System Shock, are games built around emergent gameplay. These games give the player-character a range of abilities and tools, and a consistent game world established by rules, but do not enforce any specific solution onto the player, though the player may be guided into suggested solutions. To move past a guard blocking a door, the player could opt to directly attack the guard, sneak up and knock the guard unconscious, distract the guard to move away from their post, or use parkour to reach an alternate opening well out of sight, among other solutions. In such games, it may be possible to complete in-game problems using solutions that the game designers did not foresee; for example in Deus Ex, designers were surprised to find players using wall-mounted mines as pitons for climbing walls. A similar concept exists for roguelike games, where emergent gameplay is considered a high-value factor by the 2008 Berlin Interpretation for roguelikes.
Such emergence may also occur in games through open-ended gameplay and sheer weight of simulated content, in Minecraft, Dwarf Fortress or Space Station 13. These games do not have any endgame criteria though like immersive sims present a consistent, rule-based world, but will often present the player with tutorials of what they could do within the game. From this, players may follow the intended way to play the game, or can verve in completely different directions, such as extravagant simulated machines within Minecraft.
Certain classes of open-ended puzzle games can also support emergent gameplay. The line of games produced by Zachtronics, such as Spacechem and Infinifactory, are broadly considered programming puzzles, where the player must assemble pieces of a mechanism to produce a specific product from various inputs. The games otherwise have no limits in how many components can be used and how long the process needs to complete, though through in-game leaderboards, players are encouraged to make more efficient solutions than their online friends. While each puzzle is crafted to assure at least one possible solution exists, players frequently find emergent solutions that may be more elegant, use components in unexpected fashions, or otherwise diverge greatly from the envisioned route.
Some games do not use a pre-planned story structure, even non-linear.
In The Sims, a story may emerge from the actions of the player. But the player is given so much control that they are more creating a story than interacting with a story. Emergent narrative would only partially be created by the player. Warren Spector, the designer of Deus Ex, has argued that emergent narrative lacks the emotional impact of linear storytelling.
Left 4 Dead features a dynamic system for game dramatics, pacing, and difficulty called the Director. The way the Director works is called "Procedural narrative": instead of having a difficulty which increases to a constant level, the A.I. analyzes how the players fared in the game so far, and tries to add subsequent events that would give them a sense of narrative.
Minecraft and Dwarf Fortress also have emergent narrative features due to the abstraction of how elements are represented in game, allowing system-wide features to apply across multiple objects without the need to develop specialized assets for each different state; this can create more realistic behavior for non-player controlled entities that aid in the emergent narrative. For example, in Dwarf Fortress, any of the living creatures in the game could gain the state of being intoxicated from alcohol, creating random behavior in their movement from the intoxication but not requiring them to display anything uniquely different, in contrast to a more representational game that would need new assets and models for a drunk creature. Because these are abstract and interacting systems, this can then create emergent behavior the developers had never anticipated.
Unintentional emergence occurs when creative uses of the video game were not intended by the game designers.
Using game glitches
Emergent gameplay can arise from a game's AI performing actions or creating effects unexpected by even the software developers. This may be by either a software glitch, the game working normally but producing unexpected results when played in an abnormal way or software that allows for AI development; for example the unplanned genetic diseases that can occur in the Creatures series.
Glitch- or quirk-based strategies
In several games, especially first-person shooters, game glitches or physics quirks can become viable strategies, or even spawn their own game types. In id Software's Quake series, rocket jumping and strafe-jumping are two such examples. In the game Halo 2, pressing the melee attack button (B) quickly followed by the reload button (X) and the primary fire button (R trigger) would result in the player not having to wait for the gun to be back in position to shoot after a melee attack. Doing this has become known as "BXR-ing".
Starsiege: Tribes had a glitch in the physics engine which allowed players to "ski" up and down steep slopes by rapidly pressing the jump key, gaining substantial speed in the process. The exploitation of this glitch became central to the gameplay, supplanting the vehicles that had been originally envisioned by the designers as the primary means of traversing large maps.
Thanks to a programming oversight by Capcom, the combo (or 2-1 combo) notion was introduced with the fighting game Street Fighter II, when skilled players learned that they could combine several attacks that left no time for their opponents to recover, as long as they were timed correctly.
Changing game objectives
In online car racing games, particularly Project Gotham Racing, players came up with an alternate objective known as "Cat and Mouse". The racers play on teams of at least two cars. Each team picks one very slow car as the mouse, and their goal is to have their slow car cross the finish line first. Thus the team members in faster cars aim to push their slow car into the lead and ram their opposing teams' slow cars off the road.
Completing games without getting certain items or by skipping seemingly required portions of gameplay results in sequence breaking, a technique that has developed its own dedicated community. Often, speed of completion and/or minimalist use of items are respectable achievements. This technique has long been used in the Metroid game series and has developed into a community devoted to speedruns. NetHack has over time codified many such challenges as "conduct" and acknowledges players who manage to finish characters with unbroken pacifist or vegetarian disciplines, for example. A comparable form of restricted gameplay has been implemented within World of Warcraft, known as "Iron Man" leveling.
A change in gameplay can be used to create a de facto minigame, such as the "Green Demon Challenge" in Super Mario 64, where the object is to avoid collecting a 1-up which chases the player, even passing through terrain, while the player attempts to collect all red coins on a level. Other challenges have been built around reaching normally unreachable areas or items, sometimes using glitches or gameplaying tools, or by completing a level without using an important game control, such as the 'jump' button or joystick.
Machinima, the use of computer animation from video game engines to create films, began in 1996. The practice of recording deathmatches in id Software's 1996 computer game Quake was extended by adding a narrative, thus changing the objective from winning to creating a film. Later, game developers provided increased support for creating machinima; for example, Lionhead Studios' 2005 game The Movies, is tailored for it.
Real economy interaction
Traders in MMOs with economic systems play purely to acquire virtual game objects or avatars which they then sell for real-world money on auction websites or game currency exchange sites. This results in the trader's play objective to make real money regardless of the original game designer's objectives.
Some players provide real world services (like website design, web hosting) paid for with in-game currency. This can influence the economy of the game, as players gain wealth/power in the game unrelated to game events. For example, this strategy is used in Blizzard Entertainment's World of Warcraft.
- Alternate reality game
- Cellular automaton, a 0-player "game" that can produce various emergent patterns
- Corrupted Blood incident
- Game Genie
- Immersive sim
- Procedural generation § Software examples
- Rom hacking
- Hacker culture
- Sandbox game
- "Le Gameplay emergent (in French)". jeuxvideo.com. 2006-01-19.
- "Deus Ex designer Harvey Smith discusses emergent gameplay". IGDA.[dead link]
- Harris, John (December 18, 2009). "COLUMN: @Play: The Berlin Interpretation". Game Set Watch. Retrieved November 17, 2015.
- Allen Tan (July 10, 2008). "Indie Treasures: Dwarf Fortress". brighthub.com. Retrieved 2008-11-20.
There's so much content that is simulated in the game that emergent gameplay finally has a meaning.
- Smith, Quentin (January 23, 2011). "My Chemical Romance: Zach Barth Interview". Rock Paper Shotgun. Retrieved February 11, 2020.
- Rollings, Andrew; Ernest Adams (2006). Fundamentals of Game Design. Prentice Hall. pp. 194–204. ISBN 0-13-168747-6.
- "GDC 2004: Warren Spector Talks Games Narrative". Xbox.ign.com. Archived from the original on June 6, 2004. Retrieved 2009-09-16.
- Newell, Gabe (2008-11-21). "Gabe Newell Writes for Edge". edge-online.com. Archived from the original on 2012-09-09. Retrieved 2008-11-22.
The events are trying to give them a sense of narrative. We look at sequences of events and try to take what their actions are to generate new sequences. If they've been particularly challenged by one kind of creature then we can use that information to make decisions about how we use that creature in subsequent encounters. This is what makes procedural narrative more of a story-telling device than, say, a simple difficulty mechanism.
- Kline, Dan (2009-01-03). "Procedural Narrative: Left 4 Dead". Retrieved 2009-05-10.
The horror setting, the tight team dynamic and situations, the swaying difficulty, the orthogonally designed super-zombies, all compound to push the players alongside the pacing and set up dramatic conflict and hard, human choices. As opposed to hard, systematic choices. Even though there’s barely a traditional “narrative” at all in L4D, the mechanics and the experience manager seem to create a framework that allows the player’s to build their own unique story, but in a different way then the Sim and Civilization-likes designers refer to it. This is player story built on structure, rather than player story built in a sandbox. And we know from experience that structured storytelling creates something special
- Chauvin, S., Levieux, G., Donnart, J. Y., & Natkin, S. (2015). Making Sense of Emergent Narratives: An Architecture Supporting Player-Triggered Narrative Processes. 2015 IEEE Conference on Computational Intelligence and Games (CIG). Tainan, Taiwan: IEEE. pp. 91–98.CS1 maint: uses authors parameter (link)
- Dwarf Fortress Creator Explains its Complexity & Origins. Noclip. June 9, 2020. Retrieved June 9, 2020 – via YouTube.
- "The Origin of CyberLife: An interview with Steve Grand by Sue Wilcox" retrieved from biota.org, in which Grand discusses emergence.
- Butts, Steve. "Tribes: Vengeance Review". IGN. Retrieved 2009-09-07.
- "The Essential 50, Part 32: Street Fighter II". 1up.com. 2009-08-13. Archived from the original on 2012-07-20. Retrieved 2009-09-16.
- WoW Challenges
- "Outrunning A 1-Up Mushroom In Super Mario 64 Is A Great Tradition", Kotaku
- "The Super Mario 64 Coin That Took 18 Years To Collect", Kotaku
- "The Man Who Does The Impossible in Super Mario 64", Kotaku
- Lowood, Henry (2005). "Real-Time Performance: Machinima and Game Studies" (PDF). The International Digital Media & Arts Association Journal. 2 (1). 13. ISSN 1554-0405. Archived from the original (PDF) on 2006-08-23. Retrieved 2006-08-07.
- Sotamaa, Olli (2007). "Let Me Take You to The Movies: Productive Players, Commodification and Transformative Play". Convergence: The International Journal of Research into New Media Technologies. Sage Publications. 13 (4): 383. doi:10.1177/1354856507081961. S2CID 143022303.
- Sotamaa, Olli (2007). "Let Me Take You to The Movies: Productive Players, Commodification and Transformative Play". Convergence: The International Journal of Research into New Media Technologies. Sage Publications. 13 (4): 392–393 . doi:10.1177/1354856507081961. S2CID 143022303.
- World of Warcraft EULA, Blizzard.
- Diablo III EULA, Blizzard.
- Guild Wars Real-Money Trading Policy, NC Interactive.
- Guild Wars 2 User Agreement, NCSOFT.