Marxists Internet Archive
Screenshot of Marxists.org as of March 27, 2009
|Type of site||Internet encyclopedia project|
|Available in||Multi-lingual (45 languages)|
|Alexa rank||30,742 (April 2014[update])|
1993 (gopher site)
Marxists Internet Archive (also known as MIA or Marxists.org) is a non-profit website that hosts a multilingual library (created in 1990) of the works of Marxist, communist, socialist, and anarchist writers, such as Karl Marx, Friedrich Engels, Vladimir Lenin, Leon Trotsky, Rosa Luxemburg, Che Guevara, Mikhail Bakunin, and Pierre-Joseph Proudhon, as well as that of writers of related ideologies, and even unrelated ones (for instance, Sun Tzu and Adam Smith). The collection is maintained by volunteers, and is based on a collection of documents that were distributed by email and newsgroups, later collected into a single gopher site in 1993. It contains over 53,000 documents from over 600 authors, and in 61 languages.
The archive was created in 1990 by a person – known only by his Internet tag, Zodiac — who started archiving Marxist texts by transcribing the works of Marx and Engels into E-Text, starting with the Communist Manifesto. In 1993 the accumulated text was posted on a gopher site at csf.colorado.edu. Volunteers joined and helped spread and mirror the main archive. However, the main site and its mirrors were hosted on academic servers and by the end of 1995 almost all had been shut down.
By 1996 the website, Marx.org, was hosted by a commercial ISP. This was followed by an increased activity from the volunteers. In the following years, however, a conflict developed between the volunteers working on the website and Zodiac, who retained control of the project and domain name. As the scope of the archive expanded, Zodiac feared that the opening toward diverse currents of Marxism was a "slippery slope" toward sectarianism. The volunteers who had been undertaking the work of transcribing texts resented having little influence over the way in which the archive was organized and run. In early 1998 Zodiac decided that Marx.org would return to its roots and that all writers other than Marx and Engels would be removed.
In July 1998 the present form of the Marxists Internet Archive (marxists.org) was created by volunteers transferring files and archives from Marx.org. This led to a further increase in activity and an enlargement of the scope of the archive. As for Marx.org, Zodiac closed it down in 1999, and in 2002 he gave up the domain name, which was purchased by the MIA. Along with marx.org and marxists.org, the MIA can be reached by two other domain names: lenin.org and trotsky.org.
The site, and the group of volunteers working on it, has dramatically changed since its early beginnings. By 2014 it had grown to encompass 62 volunteers in 33 different countries, and held over 50,000 items in 54 languages covering the works of over 600 authors. Today the Marxists Internet Archive is a recognized repository for both Marxist and non-Marxist writers. It is listed in the OCLC WorldCat catalog, and has been selected for archiving by institutions such as the British Library and Ireland's University College Cork.
As with many politically oriented internet sites, MIA has had problems with malicious attacks from online sources. Beginning in November 2006, the Marxists Internet Archive faced a number of serious Denial-of-service attacks, attempting to exploit a misconfiguration in their server's operating system. By January 2007 the attacks had crippled much of the archive, and left volunteers with CPU issues. That the majority of systems involved in the attack were either in China or belonging to Chinese institutions led to speculation that the attacks may have been politically motivated and directed by the People's Republic of China. The severity of the attack, coupled with other hosting issues, led to the closure of the Marxists Internet Archive's main server and several of its mirrors for a number of weeks in February and March 2007. The problem was rectified.
Copyright issue on Marx/Engels Collected Works
In late April 2014, the small British publishers Lawrence and Wishart chose to revoke their permission for their English language version of the Marx/Engels Collected Works to be reprinted in part on MIA. In an email in late April 2014, L&W asked MIA to delete the contested material from their website by the end of April or face litigation. MIA chose to follow the request. An online petition was started against the L&W decision, and had the support of more than 4,500 people by the end of the month. The author of the petition, Ammar Aziz, was quoted in Vice magazine: "You cannot privatize their writings—they are the collective property of the people they wrote for. Privatization of Marx and Engels' writings is like getting a trademark for the words 'socialism' or ‘communism.'"
A representative of MIA, Andy Blunden, did not dispute that L&W has copyright over the material. He was quoted in the Washington D.C. based Chronicle of Higher Education: "The professors and the historians will be able to write learned articles about what Marx said, but the general population are going to be left back in 1975", the year when the publication of the Collected Works began.
In response to widespread criticism, Lawrence and Wishart issued a statement objecting to the "campaign of online abuse."
The MIA is controlled by a steering committee. The committee decides issues such as the categorization of writers, modifications to the bylaws (by 3/4 majority), financial issues of all kinds, and similar matters. Administrators are unpaid volunteers who assume additional responsibilities over certain section(s) of MIA.
According to the MIA charter, its content will always be offered 100% free, in compliance with all capitalist copyright laws. All the material stored in the archives is either public domain, under the GNU Free Documentation License, or used with the copyright holders' permission. Any work created by MIA volunteers is under the Creative Commons Attribute, Share-Alike 2.0 license.
Physical location and mirrors
The website is primarily served via an ISP in Germany, and four mirrors exist, two of them in Europe (in France, and Germany), one in Australia, and one in India. In addition, there is a mirror of the MIA's Spanish-language Section in the US state of Arizona.
A 3 CD/DVD volume archive (containing the material on the website) was sold, although many copies were distributed every year for free to individuals and groups in developing and underdeveloped countries, through 2013. It was decided at this point given the size of the MIA at almost 120 GB to distribute a portable USB hardrive that contains the entire contents of the MIA on it. The DVD is now discontinued. As of March 2014, the MIA was 138 GB.
These measures are not only meant to allow easy access to the material in the archive, but also as a way of ensuring the continuity of the archive. As they put it: "If the Archive is shut down by a publishing conglomerate or the government, having this information widely dispersed around the world, essentially untraceable, with the content entirely intact, is a great thing."
MIA as a book publisher
In addition to distribution of its hard drive archives, in 2008 the MIA launched Marxist Internet Archive Publications, which has, as of November 2010, published seven titles in philosophy, social history, and Soviet psychology and pedagogy, which it distributes through Erythrós Press.
Most of material on the website is formatted in HTML, and the style of the documents is determined with CSS. PDF is sometimes used, especially for languages which don't yet have computer fonts or OCR software available. Many PDFs have been added for the purposes of putting up revolutionary and socialist publications, presented as they were printed. This has added to the bulk of the growth of the MIA.
The markup and style of the archive varies from one section to the other, depending on the volunteers who work there, but all are built on a common basic document template.
The archive includes section dedicated to specific historical topics, such as the history of the Soviet Union and the Paris Commune as well as broader subject topics, such as philosophy. It also includes a reference section called the "Encyclopedia of Marxism," containing definitions of Marxist terms, short biographies, and historical material.
The MIA is also divided into a number of non-English language sections. As of May 1, 2014, the MIA website included content in 61 languages. Although each of the non-English sections is intended over time to replicate the basic structure of the main (English-language) section, in practice these vary widely in size and scope. Some of these archives have only a few documents by Marx and Engels, while others are more extensive — for example, the Chinese section has the complete collected works of Marx, Engels, and Lenin.
- "Marxists.org Site Info". Alexa Internet. Retrieved 2014-04-01.
- History of MIA, Marxists Internet Archive, accessed 06 Sept, 2009.
- Nathan Newman, "Marx/Engels WWW Archive – REMOVED (fwd)", message to PKT Mailing List, 20 Jun 1995 08:07:52 -0700; PKT Mailing List archives, retrieved 6 September 2009.
- Martin Empson,"Marxism on the Web", International Socialism no.105 (Jan. 2005)
- Introduction, Marxists Internet Archive, accessed 06 Sept, 2009.
- Mills Kelly, 2003,"Marxists Internet Archive", a review on the World History Sources website of George Mason University's Center for History and New Media (Fairfax County, Virginia, USA).
- Stefan Sullivan, Marx for a Post-Communist Era, Routledge, 2002, p. 173.
- Nestor Kohan and Pier Brito, Marxismo para principiantes: Leer a Marx desde el Siglo XXI, Era Naciente, Buenos Aires, 2007, p. 191
- Departamento de Filosofía, Universidad de Granada (Spain), Los mejores portales de filosofía contemporánea, 20 January 2009.
- Marxists Internet Archive listing, Online Computer Library Center (OCLC) Online Union Catalog, added 20 August 2003; entry retrieved 7 September 2009.
- UK Web Archive, British Library, 2005– .
- Archived copy of MIA hosted by University College Cork's College of Arts, Celtic Studies, and Social Sciences; entry retrieved 7 September 2009.
- Attack Log, Marxists Internet Archive, January 2007. Retrieved 6 September 2009.
- Noam Cohen, "Online Marxist archive blames China for electronic attacks", International Herald Tribune, February 5, 2007.
- Jennifer Howard "Readers of Marx and Engels Decry Publisher’s Assertion of Copyright", Chronicle of Higher Education, 29 April 2014
- Noam Cohen "Claiming a Copyright on Marx? How Uncomradely", New York Times, 30 April 2014
- "Radicals fight over a Karl Marx copyright", by Hector Tobar, Los Angeles Times, April 29, 2014
- "Not Even Radical Communist Literature Is Immune to Copyright Battles", Motherboard, May 2, 2014
- Bylaws of MIA, Marxists Internet Archive, ratified 21 March 2000, amended 18 November 2007.
- Letter from U.S. Internal Revenue Service to Marxists Internet Archive, 1 October 2003.
- Charter of the MIA, Marxists Internet Archive, ratified July 2000, amended 6 December 2004.
- Marxists.org on 160GB HD, Marxists Internet Archive, retrieved 6 September 2009.
- Noam Cohen, "Who’s Attacking an Online Marxist Archive? China Is Suspected of Trying to Block Access to Texts," New York Times, Feb. 5, 2007.
- Noam Cohen, "Claiming a Copyright on Marx? How Uncomradely," New York Times, April 30, 2014.
- Jennifer Howard, "Readers of Marx and Engels Decry Publisher’s Assertion of Copyright," The Chronicle of Higher Education, April 29, 2014.
|Wikimedia Commons has media related to Marxists Internet Archive.|
- Marxists Internet Archive Internet frontpage of MIA.
- Marxists Internet Archive Publications.
- Interview with volunteers of the Marxists Internet Archive, International Socialism, no. 105 (Jan. 2005).
- Research Note on the Archive, Capital and Class, no. 89.
- "Research Note on the Marxists Internet Archive", Conference of Socialist Economists, Summer 2006.
- Review from "WorldHistorySources", Mills Kelly, 2003 Center for History and New Media, George Mason University, Fairfax County (USA).