Jump to content

Talk:Battle of Dangpo

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

WP:MILHIST Assessment

[edit]

Should this not be "Battle of Dang Harbor" or "Battle of Dangpo"? That's the much more standard & common form for battle names on Wikipedia. Also, there's no basic introduction to this article. Should read "The battle of Dangpo was...." or the like, describing briefly when and where it took place, who was involved, and what larger conflcit it was a part of. LordAmeth 17:01, 11 November 2006 (UTC)[reply]

Source?

[edit]

There's no primary historical materials saying "Kurushima Michiyuki(来島通之/Tokui Michiyuki(得居通幸)) dead in the battle of Dangpo". His battle of death is not found so far:

  • Arima Seiho(有馬成甫) in "朝鮮水軍史(1942)", Ito Yoshikazu(伊藤義一) in "文禄慶長の役と伊予水軍(上)(下)(1982-1983)", Utagawa Takehisa(宇田川武久)-"日本の海賊(1983)" → Died in Battle of Dangpo in 1592.
  • Tokutomi Sohō(徳富蘇峰) in "近世日本国民史豊臣時代丁篇(1921)" → Died in battle of Danghang-ri in 1592.
  • Kitajima Manji(北島万次) in "豊臣秀吉の朝鮮侵略(1995)" → Died in battle of 粟浦 in 1592.
  • Ikeuchi Hiroshi(池内宏) in "文禄慶長の役別編第一(1936)" → Died in battle of Battle of Busan in 1952.
  • Yamauchi Jo(山内譲) in "海賊衆得居通幸の死"(1997) → Died in Japan in 1594.

This article says "Then, Korean general Kwon Joon shot an arrow into Kurushima. The Japanese commander fell dead and a Korean captain jumped onboard and cut off his head." But in Yi Sun-sin's letter "唐浦(=Dangpo)破倭兵(=beating Japanese navy)状(=letter)", there's no phrases to express Kurushima's die. Where is the source of this sentence? I think this article was written consulting Korean movies/dramas.--Whatchutalkinbout (talk) 06:27, 27 August 2016 (UTC)[reply]