Jump to content

Talk:Bitch Lasagna

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

November 2019 page recreation

[edit]

For context, this page's history:

I am recreating this page because I believe these issues have been addressed. I believe this song's notability has changed since the first few weeks immediately following its release (when the first article failed to demonstrate notability). I believe a standalone article is appropriate because there is enough material to warrant a reasonably detailed article. I believe this new page is a sufficiently-sourced article to demonstrate WP:N and WP:NSONG via WP:GNG.

I've added some context to how I arrived at this decision below. I welcome discussion of any/all of the above and below points! —Shrinkydinks (talk) 07:11, 22 November 2019 (UTC)[reply]

Previous article criticism

[edit]

Elaborating on why this page should be re-created: An outline of previous issues with the article that led to deletion, and point-by-point addresses of these concerns:

The October 2018 article attempt:

  • "The article is extremely short and largely unsourced"
  • "not enough (or any found as of writing this) third party reliable sources that discuss it in significant detail (fails WP:GNG)"
  • "The song is already mentioned under PewDiePie#Discography"
    • Addressed: Expanded article by elaborating on more significant coverage since this AfD discussion. Provided sufficient detail to merit a standalone article by going beyond stub-class depth.

The December 2018 article attempt:

  • "There is no indication of notability per WP:NSONG. The "kotaku" and "variety" references only briefly mention the song and the "dexerto" reference may not a reliable source."
    • Addressed with higher quality sources, some of which directly discuss the song, and others of which comprise more significant coverage of the song since this discussion a year ago.

The April 2019 article attempt:

  • Recreation was objected to because "the sources you have cited fail to establish notability"
    • Addressed with higher quality/more sources.

Context from March 2019:

  • Two months after "Bitch Lasagna"'s original deletion, the broader topic "PewDiePie vs T-Series" was created. It was speedy-kept in an AfD in March 2019.

Quality sources

[edit]

Elaborating on why this page should be re-created: I believe there are sufficient quality sources on this topic, which support an article of sufficient depth, to merit a standalone page (covering relevant material that could not be condensed into a stub). These sources include

which are all approved on Wikipedia's list of discussed reliable sources. Other reliable sources included in the context section of this article include:

I believe these sources together comprise notability via WP:GNG.

Shrinkydinks (talk) 07:13, 22 November 2019 (UTC)[reply]

Sources of middling quality

[edit]

There are some sources of middling quality in this article. I have included the few of them that there are in the article as a start because I believe they are of high enough quality (defended below). That said, I believe the article could benefit from replacing these sources with ones of higher quality.

  • Know Your Meme — there is no consensus on their "confirmed" entries. To the extent that there are 1000s of articles covering online meme-specific content, and in this case the reference is only used to discuss online meme-specific content and that content's inclusion relevantly benefits the overall article, I believe its minimal inclusion is merited. —Shrinkydinks (talk) 07:01, 22 November 2019 (UTC)[reply]

Feedback from New Page Review process

[edit]

I left the following feedback for the creator/future reviewers while reviewing this article: Good article. I've reviewed your comments on the talk page and I have to say I agree with you. Cheers..

Willbb234Talk (please {{ping}} me in replies) 21:16, 22 November 2019 (UTC)[reply]

"B**** Lasagna" listed at Redirects for discussion

[edit]

An editor has asked for a discussion to address the redirect B**** Lasagna. Please participate in the redirect discussion if you wish to do so. – Lord Bolingbroke (talk) 17:11, 1 February 2020 (UTC)[reply]