Talk:Climatic Research Unit email controversy/Climategate usage

This is just a collection of different (secondary) sources using Climategate. This has been an ongoing discussion on the article Climatic Research Unit hacking incident to rename it and/or include the term Climategate. Please don't add blogs for the moment since they're not WP:RS/WP:V for this discussion (maybe except blogs under full editorial control published per WP:RS in newspapers like these refs: ).

See also this list User:A Quest For Knowledge/List of reliable sources which use the term Climategate.

Jimbo Wales has made a comment about the term here:

• "I think there's a pretty strong case to be made for "Climategate" as the name for the article, as it is clearly the most common name in the press for this. I think it fairly obvious why people don't want it called that - but that call is not up to Wikipedia. We must call it what it is called, and what it is called, is climategate. (This is not a decree, but my point is that it is pretty obvious that - contrary to the wild claims of coverup and so on - we do have a well-sourced article that is comprehensive and informative and fair... but with a pretty silly title that no one uses. The scandal here is clearly not the "hacking incident" - about which virtually nothing is known. The scandal is the content of the emails, which has proven to be deeply embarrassing (whether fairly or unfairly) to certain people.) The result of the silly title is that there is traction (unfairly) for claims that Wikipedia is suppressing something.--Jimbo Wales (talk) 03:26, 10 March 2010 (UTC)" [1]
• "I think these results are pretty compelling. Dave Souza, I notice that you used the example of an article in The Guardian of the UK as an example of what "more reputable" sources are saying - but although The Guardian is of course a high quality newspaper, I don't think it's clearly superior to, for example, the New York Times [2]. Also, you may not want to use The Guardian as the bedrock of the argument that reputable sources don't use the term, since google counts 9,830 pages using that term on the site. One can firmly believe in science, the scientific method, the scientific consensus, etc., and still acknowledge the simple truth that the name of this incident which matches Wikipedia policy is "Climategate". I'm quite sure you wouldn't deny that this is, in fact, a scandal - and even some of the scientists involved have admitted that some of the emails were 'pretty awful', etc. If there's anything partisan here, it is the attempt to control political language by Wikipedia editors, no matter how well-intentioned. It is not up to Wikipedia to decide what it is called - it is up to the world at large, and they have - overwhelmingly - decided.--Jimbo Wales (talk) 22:17, 11 March 2010 (UTC)" [3]

Sources

2009-11-23 'Climategate' hack – Computerworld (Data-leak lessons learned from the 'Climategate' hack).

2009-11-23 Already dubbed "Climategate," e-mails – Reuters (Hacked climate e-mails awkward, not game changer).

2009-12-01 "ClimateGate" affair –BBC ('Show Your Working': What 'ClimateGate' means).

2009-12-04 "Climategate" E-Mail Controversy –Scientific American (Scientists Respond to "Climategate" E-Mail Controversy).

2010-12-05 ‘Climategate’ Hacked e-mails – Newsweek (The Truth About ‘Climategate’ Hacked e-mails have compromised scientists—but not the science itself.)

2009-12-05 "Climategate scandal" –Financial Times Backlash by sceptics gains ground after 'Climategate'

2009-12-07 Has 'Climategate' Been Overblown? The controversy over – Time (Has 'Climategate' Been Overblown?)

2009-12-16 Russia affected by Climategate – Kommersant (The Moscow-based Institute of Economic Analysis (IEA) issued a report claiming that the Hadley Center for Climate Change had probably tampered with Russian-climate data.)

2009-12-23 "Climategate" revelations – The Wall Street Journal (Copenhagen's Delay Fires Coal)

2010-01-12 alleged scandal was dubbed "Climategate." – Yomiuri Shimbun (Worlds biggest newspaper, see List_of_newspapers_in_the_world_by_circulation) (Build foundation for break from oil, coal)

2010-01-22 A U.S. ClimateGate? – Investors Business Daily(Were NOAA and NASA guilty of the same data manipulation as Britain’s Climate Research Unit)

2010-01-28 “Climategate” debacle –Financial Times Climate sceptics bask in warmth of bad news

2010-02-01 'climategate' scandal – The Guardian (How the 'climategate' scandal is bogus and based on climate sceptics' lies),

2010-02-01 "climategate" controversy – The Independent (Climategate scientist 'hid flaws in data', say sceptics The "climategate" controversy)

2010-02-05 'Climategate' review member resigns – The Daily Mail (Police question global warming 'sceptic' scientist over 'Climategate' email leak)

2010-02-07 “climategate” email scandal – Girling, Richard, "I thought of killing myself, says climate scandal professor Phil Jones", The Times, February 7, 2010- "THE scientist at the centre of the “climategate” email scandal has revealed that he was so traumatised by the global backlash against him that he contemplated suicide."

2010-02-11 “climategate” review member resigns – Channel 4 (Within hours of the launch of an independent panel to investigate claims that climate scientists covered up flawed data on temperature rises, Phillip Campbell has resigned after his impartiality is called into question.)

2010-02-12 The quip was timely, given the recent controversies over Climategate – LA Times (Q & A Snowstorm and climate change).

2010-02-13 'Climategate' resignation / "Climategate" dispute – Financial Times (http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/d6c1501a-183b-11df-9256-00144feab49a.html?nclick_check=1).

2010-02-14 Climategate U-turn – Daily Mail (Climategate U-turn as scientist at centre of row admits: There has been no global warming since 1995).

2010-02-13 BBC interview with Phil Jones: transcript – BBC (PJ agrees with many skeptics' claims; the questions reference "Climategate") —Preceding unsigned comment added by Oiler99 (talk • contribs) 21:57, 14 February 2010 (UTC)

ProQuest NewsStand articles referring to the incident as "Climategate"

[These are all articles or letters to the editor from NewsStand that returned on the search term "Climategate"] Cla68 (talk) 23:24, 7 February 2010 (UTC)

• Psu Climategate Review Lacking

Author: Anonymous Journal: Intelligencer Journal / Lancaster New Era ( Lancaster, Pa. ) Pub.: 2010-02-06 Pages: A.11

• UN's climate chief flew half a million miles on his green crusade [Edition 2]

Author: Martin Evans Journal: The Daily Telegraph ( London (UK) ) Pub.: 2010-02-06 Pages: 12

• Special Report: Climate wars: The aftermath: Amid the rows, one truth: the world is still warming

Author: Fred Pearce Journal: The Guardian ( London (UK) ) Pub.: 2010-02-05 Pages: 19

• Special Report: Climate Wars: Hack, inside job or accident - who stole 'Climategate' files?: In the final part of our investigation, Guardian writers follow a trail that stretches from a server in Norwich to websites in the US and Canada - via computers in Turkey and Saudi Arabia

Author: David Leigh, Charles Arthur, Rob Evans, Fred Pearce Journal: The Guardian ( London (UK) ) Pub.: 2010-02-05 Pages: 18

• Pachauri, acorralado por el 'Climategate'. Nuevas revelaciones ponen en tela de juicio algunos estudios sobre el cambio climático - El director del IPCC defiende la credibilidad de sus informes y asegura que no dimitirá

Author: EDUARDO SUÁREZ Journal: El Mundo ( Madrid ) Pub.: 2010-02-04 Pages: 25

• Climate scientist did not falsify data: review; 'Climategate'

Author: Mike De Souza Journal: National Post ( Don Mills, Ont. ) Pub.: 2010-02-04 Pages: A.18

• Inquiry clears prof accused of fudging data; 'Climategate' surfaced after hackers stole e-mails before international talks in Copenhagen

Author: Mike De Souza Journal: The Vancouver Sun ( Vancouver, B.C. ) Pub.: 2010-02-04 Pages: B.2

• Scientist: data on climate is correct

Author: Anonymous Journal: Belfast Telegraph ( Belfast ) Pub.: 2010-02-03 Pages: 12

• Now Climategate scientist accused of study cover-up

Author: Anonymous Journal: Daily Mail ( London (UK) ) Pub.: 2010-02-03 Pages: 19

• How climate-change fanatics corrupted science

Author: Michael Barone Journal: The Examiner ( Washington, D.C. ) Pub.: 2010-02-03 Pages: 12

• Special Report: Climate wars Censorship or high standards? How scientists kept sceptics out of print: Peer review is meant to be the gold standard underpinning the credibility of science. But in the second part of a major investigation of the 'climategate' emails, we reveal how climate researchers manipulated the system to keep critics out of respected journals

Author: Fred Pearce Journal: The Guardian ( London (UK) ) Pub.: 2010-02-03 Pages: 12

• Climate gambit

Author: Peter Foster Journal: National Post ( Don Mills, Ont. ) Pub.: 2010-02-02 Pages: FP.13

• National: Special report: Strange case of moving weather posts and a scientist under siege: In the first part of a major investigation of the so-called 'climategate' emails, one of Britain's top science writers reveals how researchers tried to hide flaws in a key study

Author: Fred Pearce Journal: The Guardian ( London (UK) ) Pub.: 2010-02-02 Pages: 6

• Climategate scientist 'hid flaws in data', say sceptics

Author: Michael McCarthy ENVIRONMENT EDITOR Journal: The Independent ( London (UK) ) Pub.: 2010-02-02 Pages: 10

• Osama and Obama on global warming. Discredited climate theories make strange bedfellows

Author: THE WASHINGTON TIMES Journal: Washington Times ( Washington, D.C. ) Pub.: 2010-02-02 Pages: B.2

• Caught again! UN climate claims on ice loss melt away [Scot Region]

Author: Fiona MacRae, David Derbyshire Journal: Daily Mail ( London (UK) ) Pub.: 2010-02-01 Pages: 12

• Amazongate: new evidence of the IPCC's failures

Author: CHRISTOPHER BOOKER Journal: The Sunday Telegraph ( London (UK) ) Pub.: 2010-01-31 Pages: 33

• Confusion over the law in climate email case

Author: Anonymous Journal: The Sunday Telegraph ( London (UK) ) Pub.: 2010-01-31 Pages: 33

• Sailing through the perfect storm [Edition 2]

Author: GEOFFREY LEAN Journal: The Daily Telegraph ( London (UK) ) Pub.: 2010-01-30 Pages: 28

• Scientists broke the law by hiding climate data. But legal loophole means they won't be prosecuted [Edition 2]

Author: David Derbyshire Journal: Daily Mail ( London (UK) ) Pub.: 2010-01-29 Pages: 10

• Alarmists' credibility melting. New revelations of rigged climate research.

Author: Anonymous Journal: Orange County Register ( Santa Ana, Calif. ) Pub.: 2010-01-29 Pages: n/a

• 'Climategate' university broke freedom of information law [Scot Region]

Author: Anonymous Journal: The Daily Telegraph ( London (UK) ) Pub.: 2010-01-29 Pages: 18

• 'Climategate' and disbelief

Author: Gwynne Dyer Journal: Gulf Daily News ( Manama ) Pub.: 2010-01-28 Pages: n/a

• Research is robust but communication is weak

Author: Vicky Pope Journal: The Times ( London (UK) ) Pub.: 2010-01-28 Pages: 17

• Climate agency going up in flames; Exit of Canada's expert a sure sign IPCC in trouble

Author: Terence Corcoran Journal: National Post ( Don Mills, Ont. ) Pub.: 2010-01-27 Pages: A.1

• Climategate: Step by step

Author: Anonymous Journal: Tribune - Review / Pittsburgh Tribune - Review ( Greensburg, Pa. ) Pub.: 2010-01-26 Pages: n/a

• Sloppy science is seeping into the climate watchdog [Edition 2]

Author: CHARLES CLOVER Journal: Sunday Times ( London (UK) ) Pub.: 2010-01-24 Pages: 23

• 'Climategate' emails face investigation [Edition 2]

Author: Louise Gray Journal: The Daily Telegraph ( London (UK) ) Pub.: 2010-01-23 Pages: 17

• A Glacier Meltdown

Author: Anonymous Journal: Wall Street Journal Eastern edition ( New York, N.Y. ) Pub.: 2010-01-23 Pages: A.14

• Climate science

Author: Kate Mackenzie Journal: Financial Times ( London (UK) ) Pub.: 2010-01-22 Pages: 10

• La ciencia responde al 'Climategate'. 'Nature' contesta a los escépticos, reconoce que hay incertidumbres y señala cuáles son

Author: PEDRO CÁCERES Journal: El Mundo ( Madrid ) Pub.: 2010-01-21 Pages: 36

• IPCC imperialism on Indian glaciers

Author: Swaminathan S Anklesaria Aiyar Journal: McClatchy - Tribune Business News ( Washington ) Pub.: 2010-01-20 Pages: n/a

• First Climategate, now Glaciergate

Author: Lorne Gunter Journal: National Post ( Don Mills, Ont. ) Pub.: 2010-01-20 Pages: A.12

• CALL THIS GLOBAL WA W RMING?. THE recent big freeze has prompted doubts about climate change. Butenvironment reporter MARY GRIFFIN hears that, despite the snow, the heat isstill on.

Author: MARY GRIFFIN Journal: Coventry Telegraph ( Coventry (UK) ) Pub.: 2010-01-18 Pages: 1011

• Do we look like we're vanishing? [Eire Region]

Author: David Derbyshire Journal: Daily Mail ( London (UK) ) Pub.: 2010-01-18 Pages: 27

• Why melting glaciers claim was all hot air [Scot Region]

Author: David Derbyshire Journal: Daily Mail ( London (UK) ) Pub.: 2010-01-18 Pages: 18

• Damaged credibility doesn't alter climate facts

Author: RICHARD TOL Journal: Irish Times ( Dublin ) Pub.: 2010-01-18 Pages: 11

• Better off with Bing; Googlegate

Author: Lawrence Solomon Journal: National Post ( Don Mills, Ont. ) Pub.: 2010-01-16 Pages: FP.19

• ClimateGate's Michael Mann Received Stimulus Funds; And the media remained mum.

Author: Noel Sheppard Journal: Wall Street Journal ( New York, N.Y. ) Pub.: 2010-01-15 Pages: n/a

• Climate 'scam' exposed

Author: Anonymous Journal: Taranaki Daily News ( New Plymouth, New Zealand ) Pub.: 2010-01-14 Pages: 11

• This is global warming?: As teeth chatter, experts say, it's exceptions proving the rule.

Author: Anthony R. Wood Journal: McClatchy - Tribune Business News ( Washington ) Pub.: 2010-01-10 Pages: n/a

• Brrrr, the thinking on climate is frozen solid [Scot Region]

Author: DOMINIC LAWSON Journal: Sunday Times ( London (UK) ) Pub.: 2010-01-10 Pages: 22

• Our views:. Global warming is not settled science; Earth is far more complicated than mere mortals can comprehend

Author: Dmedit Journal: Charleston Daily Mail ( Charleston, W.V. ) Pub.: 2010-01-04 Pages: A.4

• Climate change is just a hypothesis

Author: Lars Hagen Journal: Roanoke Times & World News ( Roanoke, Va. ) Pub.: 2009-12-28 Pages: A.17

• Biased reporting on Climategate. Associated Press coverage raises eyebrows

Author: THE WASHINGTON TIMES Journal: Washington Times ( Washington, D.C. ) Pub.: 2009-12-28 Pages: A.16

• CLIMATEGATE Global warming debate stumbles over shady tactics

Author: ELIZABETH OVDE Journal: The Oregonian ( Portland, Or. ) Pub.: 2009-12-27 Pages: n/a

• The myths of 'Climategate'

Author: Paul Templet Guest Columnist Journal: The Courier ( Houma, La. ) Pub.: 2009-12-24 Pages: n/a

• Whistleblower for Climategate

Author: Anonymous Journal: Star - News ( Wilmington, N.C. ) Pub.: 2009-12-23 Pages: n/a

• Trouble over tree rings; Climategate emails reveal rift between scientists

Author: Terence Corcoran Journal: National Post ( Don Mills, Ont. ) Pub.: 2009-12-21 Pages: A.1

• Global warming. The real significance of climategate

Author: Patrick J. Michaels Journal: The Daily Progress ( Charlottesville, Va. ) Pub.: 2009-12-20 Pages: n/a

• Obama faces new global warming skeptic: Joe Sixpack. [As President Obama returns from Copenhagen, polls show that Americans are becoming more more wary of his global warming agenda - and of global warming itself. 1]

Author: Patrik Jonsson Journal: The Christian Science Monitor ( Boston, Mass. ) Pub.: 2009-12-19 Pages: n/a

• CLIMATE SKEPTICS FEED ON E-MAILS. As world leaders discuss warming in Denmark, critics say Climategate shows it's all a hoax.

Author: CRAIG PITTMAN Journal: St. Petersburg Times ( St. Petersburg, Fla. ) Pub.: 2009-12-18 Pages: A.1

• Climategate is a convenient sideshow

Author: Chris Genovali Journal: The Ottawa Citizen ( Ottawa, Ont. ) Pub.: 2009-12-18 Pages: A.13

• 'Climategate' Exposes Lies

Author: Anonymous Journal: Intelligencer Journal Lancaster New Era Combined Saturday edition ( Lancaster, Pa. ) Pub.: 2009-12-17 Pages: A.9

• 'Climategate' tempest in a teapot

Author: Frank Munley Journal: Roanoke Times & World News ( Roanoke, Va. ) Pub.: 2009-12-16 Pages: A.21

• Schwarzenegger urges US to lead climate battle

Author: Matthew Garrahan Journal: Financial Times ( London (UK) ) Pub.: 2009-12-14 Pages: 8

• Trust the public on climate change

Author: Clive Crook Journal: Financial Times ( London (UK) ) Pub.: 2009-12-14 Pages: 9

• 'Climategate' casts doubt on figures. YOUR VIEWS

Author: Anonymous Journal: Herald Express ( Torquay (UK) ) Pub.: 2009-12-14 Pages: 8

• Climategate hackers are the bad guys

Author: Anonymous Journal: The Gazette ( Montreal, Que. ) Pub.: 2009-12-14 Pages: A.27

• Media bias apparent in coverage of 'Climategate'.

Author: Anonymous Journal: Herald Sun with Chapel Hill Herald ( Durham, N.C. ) Pub.: 2009-12-13 Pages: CH.1

• POINT OF VIEW. GLOBAL WARMING AND THE LIMITS OF THEORY

Author: Thomas Rickenbach Journal: News & Observer ( Raleigh, N.C. ) Pub.: 2009-12-13 Pages: A.29

• Blackburn leads GOP climate plan criticism -- Claims controlling emissions would be at expense of jobs

Author: Bartholomew Sullivan Journal: The Commercial Appeal ( Memphis, Tenn. ) Pub.: 2009-12-13 Pages: B.1

• A remarkable case of Snow blindness

Author: Christopher Booker Journal: The Sunday Telegraph ( London (UK) ) Pub.: 2009-12-13 Pages: 35

• Warming activists need to use science

Author: Jonathan Gurwitz San Antonio Express-News Journal: Deseret News ( Salt Lake City, Utah ) Pub.: 2009-12-12 Pages: A.17

• 'Climategate' in context

Author: Anonymous Journal: National Post ( Don Mills, Ont. ) Pub.: 2009-12-12 Pages: A.24

• The Goracle speaks on Climategate

Author: Peter Foster Journal: National Post ( Don Mills, Ont. ) Pub.: 2009-12-12 Pages: FP.21

• 'Climategate': An Unfortunate Sideshow

Author: Glen MacDonald Journal: Valley News ( White River Junction, Vt. ) Pub.: 2009-12-12 Pages: A.10

• Climate change and "Climategate"

Journal: Daily News Egypt ( Cairo ) Pub.: 2009-12-11 Pages: n/a

• Climategate doesn't mean science is wrong

Author: Glen MacDonald Journal: Herald ( Rock Hill, S.C. ) Pub.: 2009-12-11 Pages: n/a

• Climategate' should derail Copenhagen climate conference

Author: Ben Lieberman Journal: McClatchy - Tribune News Service ( Washington ) Pub.: 2009-12-11 Pages: n/a

• Climategate's not evil, it's just unhinged

Author: Rick Salutin Journal: The Globe and Mail ( Toronto, Ont. ) Pub.: 2009-12-11 Pages: A.21

• Climategate, Warming

Author: Anonymous Journal: The Ledger ( Lakeland, Fla. ) Pub.: 2009-12-11 Pages: n/a

• Scientists fight back in climate change data row

Author: Jenny Fyall environment correspondent Journal: The Scotsman ( Edinburgh (UK) ) Pub.: 2009-12-11 Pages: 14

• Misreading 'Climategate'

Author: GLEN MACDONALD Journal: Virginian - Pilot ( Norfolk, Va. ) Pub.: 2009-12-11 Pages: B.7

• Climategate

Author: Anonymous Journal: Waikato Times ( Hamilton, New Zealand ) Pub.: 2009-12-11 Pages: 6

• The tip of the Climategate iceberg. Misleading 'evidence' is central to the global-warming fraud

Author: THE WASHINGTON TIMES Journal: Washington Times ( Washington, D.C. ) Pub.: 2009-12-11 Pages: A.20

• No to 'Climategate'. LETTERS [Scot Region]

Author: Anonymous Journal: Daily Mail ( London (UK) ) Pub.: 2009-12-10 Pages: 78

• Real debate or just hot air? A primer on 'climategate'

Author: Renee Schoof Journal: McClatchy Washington DC News Bureau ( Washington, D.C. ) Pub.: 2009-12-10 Pages: n/a

• Weaver's Web II; Climate modeler's break-in caper spreads across Canadian university, exposing Climategate as monster cross-disciplinary big-oil funded attack on psychology labs

Author: Terence Corcoran Journal: National Post ( Don Mills, Ont. ) Pub.: 2009-12-10 Pages: FP.11

• Climategate taints global warming science

Author: Steve Prisley Journal: Roanoke Times & World News ( Roanoke, Va. ) Pub.: 2009-12-10 Pages: A.19

• Gore dismisses 'Climategate' emails; Ten years old; Says private messages taken out of context

Author: Anonymous Journal: The Gazette ( Montreal, Que. ) Pub.: 2009-12-10 Pages: A.16

• Climategate' gives ammo to global warming skeptics

Author: Anonymous Journal: USA TODAY ( McLean, Va. ) Pub.: 2009-12-10 Pages: A.12

• Science Problems Go Beyond Climategate

Author: Anonymous Journal: Wall Street Journal Eastern edition ( New York, N.Y. ) Pub.: 2009-12-10 Pages: A.24

• On board the climate express

Author: Elizabeth Dunningham On The Climate Express Journal: McClatchy - Tribune Business News ( Washington ) Pub.: 2009-12-09 Pages: n/a

• ORNL chief: 'Climategate' a distraction: Strong science will survive scrutiny, Mason says

Author: Frank Munger Journal: McClatchy - Tribune Business News ( Washington ) Pub.: 2009-12-09 Pages: n/a

• Myriam Vachez / Copenhague y el 'Climategate'

Author: Myriam Vachez Journal: Mural ( Guadalajara, Mexico ) Pub.: 2009-12-09 Pages: 6

• The Tip of the Climategate Iceberg

Author: Anonymous Journal: Wall Street Journal Europe ( Brussels ) Pub.: 2009-12-09 Pages: 13

• BRIEF: UA president: "No substance" to Climategate allegations

Author: Becky Pallack Journal: McClatchy - Tribune Business News ( Washington ) Pub.: 2009-12-08 Pages: n/a

• Is Climategate the New Downing Street Memo?

Author: A BARTON HINKLE Journal: Richmond Times - Dispatch ( Richmond, Va. ) Pub.: 2009-12-08 Pages: A.11

• 'Climategate' issue mars opening day; Saudis raise question early; But one U.S. negotiator dismisses controversy as 'a small blip'

Author: GERARD WYNN Journal: The Gazette ( Montreal, Que. ) Pub.: 2009-12-08 Pages: A.4

• 'Climategate' a stumbling block

Journal: Times of Oman ( Muscat ) Pub.: 2009-12-08 Pages: n/a

• FBI probes death threats in 'climategate'

Journal: UPI Energy Resources ( Washington ) Pub.: 2009-12-08 Pages: n/a

• 2nd UA prof defends Climategate e-mails

Author: TONY DAVIS Journal: Arizona Daily Star ( Tucson, Ariz. ) Pub.: 2009-12-07 Pages: A.1

• 'Climategate' news

Author: Anonymous Journal: Bangor Daily News ( Bangor, Me. ) Pub.: 2009-12-07 Pages: 6

• More to 'climategate'

Author: Anonymous Journal: Bangor Daily News ( Bangor, Me. ) Pub.: 2009-12-07 Pages: 6

• Climategate jury out

Author: Ken Owen Journal: Business Day ( Johannesburg ) Pub.: 2009-12-07 Pages: n/a

• Public trust in climate science hit by 'Climategate'

Author: Anonymous Journal: Irish Times ( Dublin ) Pub.: 2009-12-07 Pages: 13

• Jonah Goldberg: Here are a few more inconvenient truths

Author: Anonymous Journal: Journal News ( Hamilton, Ohio ) Pub.: 2009-12-07 Pages: n/a

• Readers: Give us less Tiger, more Climategate

Author: Paul Russell Journal: National Post ( Don Mills, Ont. ) Pub.: 2009-12-07 Pages: A.15

• Fears for climate summit. UN likens theft of e-mails to Watergate scandal Climate scientists' e-mails hacked by professionals, says UNCOPENHAGEN 7-18 DECEMBER [Eire Region]

Author: Ben Webster Journal: The Times ( London (UK) ) Pub.: 2009-12-07 Pages: 1

• Media complicity in Climategate. The global-cooling cover-up is not considered newsworthy

Author: THE WASHINGTON TIMES Journal: Washington Times ( Washington, D.C. ) Pub.: 2009-12-07 Pages: A.18

• 'CLIMATEGATE' EXPOSES GLOBAL WARMING HOAX

Author: MIKE MAGUIRE SPECIAL TO THE COURIER, PRESS Journal: Evansville Courier & Press ( Evansville, Ind. ) Pub.: 2009-12-06 Pages: A.13

• Climategate debate

Author: Frank Warner Journal: McClatchy - Tribune Business News ( Washington ) Pub.: 2009-12-06 Pages: n/a

• Cooler heads should prevail in Copenhagen. Climategate revelations debunk any call for quick, drastic greenhouse-gas cuts.

Author: Anonymous Journal: Orange County Register ( Santa Ana, Calif. ) Pub.: 2009-12-06 Pages: n/a

• Climategate 'gravy train' Professor at centre of international row over 'faked' global warming data received millions from government bodies, the EU, quangos and Nato

Author: ROBERT MENDICK Journal: The Sunday Telegraph ( London (UK) ) Pub.: 2009-12-06 Pages: 12

• EDITORIAL. Climategate a warning

Author: Anonymous Journal: Boston Herald ( Boston, Mass. ) Pub.: 2009-12-05 Pages: 16

• Backlash by sceptics gains ground after 'Climategate'

Author: Clive Cookson Journal: Financial Times ( London (UK) ) Pub.: 2009-12-05 Pages: 8

• Point missed in 'climategate' scandal

Author: Anonymous Journal: Herald Express ( Torquay (UK) ) Pub.: 2009-12-05 Pages: 8

• Dirty climate data; Climategate emails prove that we must redo the science with data and a process that can be trusted

Author: Lawrence Solomon Journal: National Post ( Don Mills, Ont. ) Pub.: 2009-12-05 Pages: FP.23

• Prof shouldn't fear Climategate. [1]

Author: Doug Beck Journal: National Post ( Don Mills, Ont. ) Pub.: 2009-12-05 Pages: A.25

• Science or fiction?; In the wake of climategate, the carbon debate is hotter than ever

Author: Anonymous Journal: National Post ( Don Mills, Ont. ) Pub.: 2009-12-05 Pages: A.21

• Don't let 'Climategate' melt down your portfolio

Author: Avner Mandelman Journal: The Globe and Mail ( Toronto, Ont. ) Pub.: 2009-12-05 Pages: B.12

• The Canadians who changed the climate debate; Canadians Steve McIntyre and Ross McKitrick have discovered faulty calculations in some of the key scientific studies behind the reports of the UN Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. As Richard Foot reports, that's made them pretty unpopular in some circles.

Author: Richard Foot Journal: The Ottawa Citizen ( Ottawa, Ont. ) Pub.: 2009-12-05 Pages: A.3

• In Climategate, sunlight best reply to skeptics

Author: ERIC POOLEY Journal: The Providence Journal ( Providence, R.I. ) Pub.: 2009-12-05 Pages: B.6

• All the president's climategate deniers

Author: Anonymous Journal: The Sun ( Lowell, Mass. ) Pub.: 2009-12-05 Pages: n/a

• 'Climategate' could melt summit deal. E-mails seized on by global warming scepticsCOUNTDOWN TO COPENHAGEN 7-18 DECEMBER [Eire Region]

Author: Ben Webster Journal: The Times ( London (UK) ) Pub.: 2009-12-05 Pages: 3

• Met Office to re-examine 160 years of climate data. Climategate scandal forces temperature review [Ulster Region]

Author: Ben Webster Journal: The Times ( London (UK) ) Pub.: 2009-12-05 Pages: 1

• Climategate changes everything. [1]

Author: H Sterling Burnett Journal: National Post ( Don Mills, Ont. ) Pub.: 2009-12-04 Pages: A.17

• Climategate fallout; Discussion of the hacked emails from East Anglia University reinforce one thing

Author: Anonymous Journal: National Post ( Don Mills, Ont. ) Pub.: 2009-12-04 Pages: FP.15

• What's 'Climategate' all about? Here's a primer. The world's top scientific backers of 'climate change' have had their private views exposed.

Author: MD Harmon Journal: Portland Press Herald ( Portland, Me. ) Pub.: 2009-12-04 Pages: A.11

• Global warming skeptics find solace in 'climategate'

Author: Michael Scott Journal: The Plain Dealer ( Cleveland, Ohio ) Pub.: 2009-12-04 Pages: B.2

• The Science and Politics of Climate Change

Author: Mike Hulme Journal: The Wall Street Journal Asia ( Hong Kong ) Pub.: 2009-12-04 Pages: 11

• Wonder Land: Climategate: Science Is Dying

Author: Daniel Henninger Journal: Wall Street Journal Europe ( Brussels ) Pub.: 2009-12-04 Pages: 13

• You missed the 'Climategate' storm

Author: Ken Owen Journal: Business Day ( Johannesburg ) Pub.: 2009-12-03 Pages: n/a

• EPA rejects Inhofe's call for delay on finding: He had requested a hearing on what he calls "climategate," involving scientists' e-mails.

Author: Jim Myers Journal: McClatchy - Tribune Business News ( Washington ) Pub.: 2009-12-03 Pages: n/a

• In Wake of Climategate Revelations, Duke Energy CEO Jim Rogers Should Stop Lobbying for Cap-and-Trade Legislation and Reassess his Climate Change Business Strategy, Says Free Enterprise Project

Author: Anonymous Journal: PR Newswire ( New York ) Pub.: 2009-12-03 Pages: n/a

• Panel grills climate advisers over hacked, leaked e-mails

Author: Seth Borenstein Journal: Topeka Capital Journal ( Topeka, Kan. ) Pub.: 2009-12-03 Pages: 14

• Global-warming fraud harms science. Fellow academics shocked by Climategate

Author: THE WASHINGTON TIMES Journal: Washington Times ( Washington, D.C. ) Pub.: 2009-12-03 Pages: A.22

• Climategate: Dissent on ice. Jeff Jacoby

Author: Anonymous Journal: Boston Globe ( Boston, Mass. ) Pub.: 2009-12-02 Pages: A.17

• CLIMATEGATE' BIG STEPS DOWN

Author: Anonymous Journal: New York Post ( New York, N.Y. ) Pub.: 2009-12-02 Pages: 7

• 'Climategate' makes us address real issues

Author: Steve Moretti Journal: The Ottawa Citizen ( Ottawa, Ont. ) Pub.: 2009-12-02 Pages: A.13

• Climategate: Follow the Money

Author: Bret Stephens Journal: The Wall Street Journal Asia ( Hong Kong ) Pub.: 2009-12-02 Pages: 14

• Universities take action on Climategate. Investigating academic fraud by global-warming theocracy

Author: THE WASHINGTON TIMES Journal: Washington Times ( Washington, D.C. ) Pub.: 2009-12-02 Pages: A.22

• Flushing out the high priests of climate change

Author: CHARLES CLOVER Journal: Sunday Times ( London (UK) ) Pub.: 2009-11-29 Pages: 21

• Climategate denial foundering on army of Davids

Author: Glenn Harlan Reynolds Journal: The Examiner ( Washington, D.C. ) Pub.: 2009-11-29 Pages: 19

• Who's to blame for Climategate?; The fallout from damning e-mails about climate change is gathering momentum -- and the scandal just might change the future of the planet. Gordon Rayner takes a look at ground zero of the controversy.

Author: Gordon Rayner Journal: The Ottawa Citizen ( Ottawa, Ont. ) Pub.: 2009-11-29 Pages: A.8

• From Climategate to Copenhagen; Will hacked e-mails cast a chill on the UN's environment summit? Richard Foot rises above the hot air and heated debate to consider the long-term repercussions of the controversy.

Author: Richard Foot Journal: The Ottawa Citizen ( Ottawa, Ont. ) Pub.: 2009-11-28 Pages: B.2

• 'Climategate' puts warming in question

Author: Nolan Finley Journal: Detroit News ( Detroit, Mich. ) Pub.: 2009-11-26 Pages: B.1

• Climategate; What the climate scientists wrote and when they wrote it

Author: Anonymous Journal: National Post ( Don Mills, Ont. ) Pub.: 2009-11-24 Pages: FP.11

Articles from journals listed in Infotrac referring to "Climategate"

• Title:On the scene in Copenhagen.(Inside Track) Pub:The New American Detail:26.1 (Jan 4, 2010): p8(1). (132 words)
• Hot mess.(CLIMATEGATE)(leaked e-mails from Britain's Climatic Research Unit) Pub:National Review Detail:61.24 (Dec 31, 2009): p16. (693 words)
• Title:Spotlight: The Climate E-Mail Controversy.(Special Issue The Year in Pictures)(Briefing) Pub:Time Detail:Bryan Walsh. 174.24 (Dec 21, 2009): p26. (552 words)
• Title:THE MCLAUGHLIN GROUP HOST: JOHN MCLAUGHLIN PANEL: PATRICK BUCHANAN, MSNBC; ELEANOR CLIFT, NEWSWEEK; MONICA CROWLEY, WASHINGTON TIMES; JONATHAN CAPEHART, WASHINGTON POST TAPED: FRIDAY, DECEMBER 11, 2009 BROADCAST: WEEKEND OF DECEMBER 12-13, 2009 (Part 1). Pub:Congressional Hearing Transcript Database Detail:(Dec 14, 2009)(1222 words)
• Title:THE TRUTH ABOUT 'Climategate'.(Environment)(Viewpoint essay) Pub:Newsweek Detail:Sharon Begley. 154.24 (Dec 14, 2009): p64. (603 words)
• Title:Watching the Climategate scandal explode makes me feel like a proud parent.(YOU KNOW IT MAKES SENSE) Pub:Spectator Detail:James Delingpole. 311.9459 (Dec 12, 2009): p27(1). (1278 words)
• Title:PRESS CONFERENCE WITH REPRESENTATIVE MIKE PENCE (R-IN); REPRESENTATIVE MARSHA BLACKBURN (R-TN); REPRESENTATIVE JAMES SENSENBRENNER (R-WI); REPRESENTATIVE JOE BARTON (R-TX); REPRESENTATIVE DARRELL ISSA (R-CA); SUBJECTS: ENERGY, CLIMATEGATE, PRESIDENT OBAMA'S TRIP TO COPENHAGEN LOCATION: HVC STUDIO A, CAPITOL VISITORS CENTER, THE CAPITOL, WASHINGTON, D.C. TIME: 2:34 P.M. EST DATE: TUESDAY, DECEMBER... (Part 1).(Congressional Hearing) Pub:Congressional Hearing Transcript Database Detail:(Dec 9, 2009)(1233 words)
• Title:CNN "CAMPBELL BROWN" INTERVIEW WITH REPRESENTATIVE DARRELL ISSA (R-CA) REPRESENTATIVE JAY INSLEE (D-WA) SUBJECT: CLIMATEGATE INTERVIEWER: CAMPBELL BROWN TIME: 8:24 P.M. EST DATE: TUESDAY, DECEMBER 8, 2009 (Part 1).(Broadcast Interview)(Interview) Pub:Congressional Hearing Transcript Database Detail:(Dec 9, 2009)(1287 words)
• CNN "AMERICAN MORNING" INTERVIEW WITH FORMER VICE PRESIDENT AL GORE INTERVIEWERS: JOHN D. ROBERTS, KIRAN CHETRY SUBJECT: CLIMATEGATE; COPENHAGEN CLIMATE CHANGE SUMMIT TIME: 7:15 A.M. EST DATE: WEDNESDAY, DECEMBER 9, 2009.(Broadcast Interview)(Interview) Pub:Congressional Hearing Transcript Database Detail:(Dec 9, 2009)(2654 words)
• Title:PRESS CONFERENCE WITH REPRESENTATIVE MIKE PENCE (R-IN); REPRESENTATIVE MARSHA BLACKBURN (R-TN); REPRESENTATIVE JAMES SENSENBRENNER (R-WI); REPRESENTATIVE JOE BARTON (R-TX); REPRESENTATIVE DARRELL ISSA (R-CA); SUBJECTS: ENERGY, CLIMATEGATE, PRESIDENT OBAMA'S TRIP TO COPENHAGEN LOCATION: HVC STUDIO A, CAPITOL VISITORS CENTER, THE CAPITOL, WASHINGTON, D.C. TIME: 2:34 P.M. EST DATE: TUESDAY, DECEMBER... (Part 1).(Congressional Hearing) Pub:Washington Newsmaker Transcript Database Detail:(Dec 9, 2009)(1233 words)
• Title:"Science" responds to Climategate.(Blog entry) Pub:Atlantic.com Detail:(Dec 8, 2009)(675 words)
• Title:CNN "AMERICAN MORNING" INTERVIEW WITH SENATOR JAMES INHOFE (R-OK) INTERVIEWER: KIRAN CHETRY SUBJECT: CLIMATEGATE DEBATE; CAP AND TRADE TIME: 8:15 A.M. EST DATE: TUESDAY, DECEMBER 8, 2009.(Broadcast Interview)(Interview) Pub:Congressional Hearing Transcript Database Detail:(Dec 8, 2009)(1383 words)
• Title:James Hansen Wants A Source Fuels Tax.(Blog entry) Pub:Atlantic.com Detail:(Dec 7, 2009)(462 words)
• Title:Copenhagen meltdown.(Inside Washington) Pub:Feedstuffs Detail:Sally Schuff. 81.50 (Dec 7, 2009): p2(1). (481 words)
• Title:Data-leak lessons learned from the 'Climategate' hack. Pub:Network World Detail:(Nov 25, 2009)(537 words)
• Title:For a fresh look at climate change. Pub:The Hindu (English) Detail:(Jan 5, 2010)(1431 words)
• Title:Call for greater scrutiny of climate data.(WORLD NEWS) Pub:The Financial Times Detail:Fiona Harvey. (Feb 3, 2010): p4. (414 words)
• Title:Smeared scientists must still mend their ways.(COMMENT) Pub:The Financial Times Detail:Tom De Castella. (Dec 17, 2009): p11. (845 words)
• Title:The arguments of 'Climategate'. Pub:International Business Times - US ed. Detail:(Dec 14, 2009)(966 words)
• Title:If climate change doesn't grab you, meet its evil twin.(News) Pub:Sunday Times (London, England) Detail:(Dec 13, 2009): p23. (917 words)
• Title:Nominee list for Chinese academy of sciences said leaked by blogger. Pub:BBC Monitoring International Reports Detail:(Dec 11, 2009)(485 words)
• Title:1,700 UK scientists sign climate science statement.(Brief article) Pub:International Business Times - US ed. Detail:(Dec 10, 2009)(146 words)
• Title:UN Climate Chief: Hacked emails were planned and well-funded.(Brief article) Pub:International Business Times - US ed. Detail:(Dec 6, 2009)(281 words)
• Title:'Climategate' could melt summit deal; E-mails seized on by global warming sceptics; COUNTDOWN TO COPENHAGEN 7-18 DECEMBER.(News) Pub:The Times (London, England) Detail:(Dec 5, 2009): p3. (544 words)
• Title:Probe into ClimateGate Scandal to begin. Pub:International Business Times - US ed. Detail:(Dec 3, 2009)(465 words)
• Title:British Climate Scientist in hacked email controversy to step down. Pub:International Business Times - US ed. Detail:(Dec 2, 2009)(409 words)
• Title:Congress, Climategate and science. Pub:Delta Farm Press (Online Exclusive) Detail:David Bennett. (Dec 22, 2009)(1240 words)
• Title:Inhofe: Climategate Will End Cap-and-Trade Battle. Pub:Newsmax Detail:Jim Meyers. (Dec 11, 2009)(906 words)
• Title:Administration officials defend science in wake of 'climategate'.(University of East Anglia report leakage) Pub:Govexec.com Detail:Katherine McIntire Peters. (Dec 2, 2009)(643 words)
• Title:Climategate.(DATELINE) Pub:Fuel Oil News Detail:74.12 (Dec 2009): p3(1). (447 words)
• Title:Climategate Crashers. Pub:The Hotline Detail:(Dec 18, 2009)(81 words)
• Title:Agency: 'Climategate' scientists hid data. Pub:UPI NewsTrack Detail:(Jan 28, 2010)(293 words)
• Title:A U.S. ClimateGate?(Issues & Insights) Pub:Investor's Business Daily Detail:(Jan 25, 2010): pA14. (418 words)
• Title:- reeling from the "climategate" email scandal, and Pitman said it will give climate change sceptics ammunition to continue their attacks. Pub:PTI - The Press Trust of India Ltd. Detail:(Jan 25, 2010)(101 words)
• Title:CLIMATE SKEPTICS FEED ON E-MAILS; As world leaders discuss warming in Denmark, critics say Climategate shows it's all a hoax.(NATIONAL) Pub:The St. Petersburg Times (St. Petersburg, FL) Detail:Craig Pittman. (Dec 18, 2009): p1A. (1046 words)
• Title:The arguments of 'Climategate'. Pub:International Business Times - US ed. Detail:(Dec 14, 2009)(966 words)
• Title:ORNL chief: 'Climategate' a distraction: Strong science will survive scrutiny, Mason says. Pub:Knoxville News-Sentinel (Knoxville, TN) Detail:(Dec 9, 2009)(684 words)
• Title:UN scientific community condemns 'Climategate'. Pub:PTI - The Press Trust of India Ltd. Detail:(Dec 9, 2009)(482 words)
• Title:SENSENBRENNER URGES IPCC TO EXCLUDE CLIMATEGATE SCIENTISTS. Pub:The America's Intelligence Wire Detail:(Dec 8, 2009)(1367 words)
• Title:Jobs From Bailout Cash; Talks on Public Option Alternatives; Climategate and Copenhagen.(Broadcast transcript) Pub:CNN Newsroom Detail:(Dec 8, 2009)(7548 words)
• Title:Penn State scientist at center of a storm. Pub:Philadelphia Inquirer (Philadelphia, PA) Detail:(Dec 8, 2009)(1663 words)
• Title:Climategate jury out. Pub:Business Day (South Africa) Detail:(Dec 7, 2009)(331 words)
• Title:'Climategate' does not make case for sceptics stronger: US. Pub:PTI - The Press Trust of India Ltd. Detail:(Dec 7, 2009)(190 words)
• Title:Pachauri attacks climategate as the issue rocks the Summit. Pub:PTI - The Press Trust of India Ltd. Detail:(Dec 7, 2009)(157 words)
• Title:Howard Kurtz discusses Tiger Woods, Stephanopoulos, Climategate, more.(Discussion) Pub:Washingtonpost.com Detail:(Dec 7, 2009)(3433 words)
• Title:Accidental Heroes - Climategate Saga Could Be a Blessing in Disguise [editorial].(Editorial) Pub:Africa News Service Detail:(Dec 4, 2009)(477 words)
• Title:Is climate change scepticism the new Holocaust denial? Pub:Europe Intelligence Wire Detail:(Dec 4, 2009)(533 words)
• Title:You missed the 'Climategate' storm. Pub:Business Day (South Africa) Detail:(Dec 3, 2009)(315 words)
• Title:EPA rejects Inhofe's call for delay on finding: He had requested a hearing on what he calls "climategate," involving scientists' e-mails. Pub:Tulsa World (Tulsa, OK) Detail:(Dec 3, 2009)(560 words)