The Hobbit (South Park)

"The Hobbit (South Park)"

"The Hobbit" is the tenth and final episode of the seventeenth season of the animated television series South Park, and the 247th episode of the series overall. The episode premiered on Comedy Central on December 11, 2013. The story centers upon Wendy Testaburger's attempts to raise awareness of media impact on body image, which leads to a crusade by rapper Kanye West to convince the world that his fiancée, Kim Kardashian, is not a hobbit.

Plot

During cheerleading practice, South Park Elementary's fourth grade students realize that Lisa Berger, an underconfident girl who sees herself as "the fat ugly cheerleader", lacks enthusiasm in her cheers. When the team captain, Wendy Testaburger, learns Lisa has a crush on Butters, she suggests asking him on a date to help boost her confidence. When Lisa does this, Butters turns her down, saying that she is "too fat" for him. When Wendy excoriates Butters for this, Butters explains that he likes women who take care of themselves such as his celebrity crush, Kim Kardashian, whom he says is "skinny", despite having just had a baby. Wendy angrily tells Butters that Kim has "the body of a hobbit", and that commercialized images of her are photoshopped to make her look attractive, and lead to poor body image on the part of average-looking females.

When Mr. Mackey speaks to Wendy and Butters, instead of admonishing Butters for how he spoke to Lisa, he instead criticizes Wendy for her comments about Kardashian, accusing her of being motivated by jealousy. As a result of this, Kardashian's fiancé Kanye West appears before the fourth grade class to explain that Kardashian is in fact not a hobbit, but when he attempts to argue this point, he ends up undercutting his case by actually conceding attributes of hers that are indeed those of hobbits. He even calls her to ask her how she is not a hobbit, a gag that recurs throughout the episode.

Wendy subsequently tries to demonstrate to Butters how Photoshop is used to make people appear more attractive by altering a photo of Lisa to make her look more slim and glamorous, but instead of understanding Wendy's point that the popular image of Kim Kardashian is a fantasy, Butters instead thinks that the altered image of Lisa represents her true appearance. Horrified at the realization that he turned her down for a date, he uploads her altered photo to the Internet, and is about to ask her out when he discovers that she and Clyde Donovan are now dating. When Wendy sees that everyone else in the school now regards Lisa's photoshopped image as her true appearance, she tries to tell them that Lisa is actually "fat and ugly". As a result of this, she is called before Mr. Mackey for her being jealous, and agrees to change her behavior in order to pacify him.

At a ceremony in which Pope Francis is named Time magazine's Person of the Year, West storms the stage to challenge the characterization of Kardashian as a "hobbit", but again hampers his own position by mentioning that her film, The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug, premieres that week. He then produces a music video for the same purpose, but the same problem occurs.

As Lisa's popularity in school increases, the other cheerleaders point out to Wendy that no one is noticing the rest of them any more, and ask her to produce photoshopped images of them as well in order to increase their standing among the student body. When Wendy refuses, the cheerleaders, spurred by an increasingly shallow and haughty Lisa, photoshop their own photos. When the boys now take notice of them, Stan asks Wendy if he can have a photoshopped image of her, and she angrily refuses. She points out that all people have imperfections, including herself, Stan, and everyone else in the school. However, the cheerleaders, Mackey, and a crowd of other students overhear the latter portion of her statement and believe she is a "hater". Wendy appears on the Channel 9 Morning News to speak out against how the media's inauthentic images of women create an unrealistic standard for girls to live up to, but she is again dismissed as a "hater". Nonetheless, she refuses to cease speaking out in favor of having photoshopped images explicitly labeled as such.

In the middle of the night, Wendy is woken up by West, who appears in her bedroom to read her story of a hobbit who dreamed of being beautiful. In the story, which brings West to tears as he reads it, the hobbit becomes beautiful through a magical power called "Photoshop", but her true nature is exposed by a little girl who takes her Photoshop away. However, the hobbit's fiancé tells her that he loves her regardless. The story moves Wendy, who apologizes for being a "hater". Abandoning her crusade, Wendy tearfully photoshops her image and sends it out in a mass email. Her fate remains unknown after this.

Reception

Max Nicholson of IGN gave the episode a "Great" rating of 8.7 out of 10, saying, that it "ended Season 17 on a high note, thanks to a well-thought-out premise and a significant character arc for Wendy (probably her best). Meanwhile, the return of Kanye West made for a wealth of pop culture references that ranged from hilarious to decent. Overall, this year's finale was a great final bow for the season."

Ryan McGee of The A.V. Club gave the episode a B+ grade. He compared the final scene with Wendy emailing her Photoshopped picture to her classmates to the final scene in the episode "You're Getting Old", commenting that the scene "wrecked [him]". He went on to say, "The fact that South Park doesn't take its foot off the neck of this episode and return the world back to normal gives the entire endeavor more power."

David Crow of Den of Geek gave the episode 4 out of 5 stars. He called it "the series' most biting social satire of the whole season", and felt the episode started getting better and better once Butters turned down Lisa. Crow also praised Matt Stone and Trey Parker's ability to "tell the perfect 30-minute joke".

Danica Bellini of Mstarz found the episode to be "hilarious", and listed Kanye West's inadvertent comparing of Kim Kardashian to a hobbit among the episode's highlights.

External links

• "The Hobbit" on South Park Studios