||This article contains too many or too-lengthy quotations for an encyclopedic entry. (December 2013)|
|Born||Edinburgh, Scotland, November 1840.|
|Died||Dumfries, Scotland, January 1938.|
|Fields||psychiatry, public health, medical psychology|
|Institutions||Royal Medical Society, West Riding Pauper Lunatic Asylum, Court of Chancery, Medico-Psychological Association, Royal Institution, Royal Society|
|Alma mater||Edinburgh University|
|Known for||Functional specialization (brain), cerebral asymmetry, biological psychiatry, Scottish medical history, photography, memoirist|
|Influences||George Combe, Thomas Carlyle, Andrew Combe, Robert Chambers, William A.F. Browne, Duchenne de Boulogne, Hugh Welch Diamond, Charles Darwin, Thomas Laycock, Paul Broca, Henry Maudsley|
Sir James Crichton-Browne MD FRS (29 November 1840 – 31 January 1938) was a leading British psychiatrist and medical psychologist. He is famous for studies on the relationship of mental illness to brain injury and for the development of public health policies in relation to mental health. Crichton-Browne was the second son of the phrenologist Dr William A.F. Browne who was Superintendent of The Crichton Royal Institution in Dumfries from 1838 till 1857 - and Crichton-Browne spent much of his childhood at the Crichton Royal.
Crichton-Browne was a celebrated author and orator, editor of the highly influential West Riding Lunatic Asylum Medical Reports (six volumes, 1871 to 1876), one of Charles Darwin's most significant correspondents and collaborators - on The Expression of the Emotions in Man and Animals (1872) - and - like Duchenne de Boulogne and Hugh Welch Diamond - a pioneer of neuropsychiatric photography. Crichton-Browne was based at the West Riding Asylum in Wakefield from 1866 to 1875, and there he set up a unique asylum laboratory, establishing instruction in psychiatry for students from the nearby Leeds School of Medicine. In 1895, he delivered his celebrated Cavendish Lecture On Dreamy Mental States which attracted the disapproval of the American psychologist William James and - in 1907 - he summarised the conclusions of his neuropsychiatric research in his Royal Institution Lecture Dexterity and the Bend Sinister. In 1908, he joined the Board of the Bovril Company. In 1920, after forty-five years as Lord Chancellor's Medical Visitor, Crichton-Browne delivered the first Maudsley Lecture to the Medico-Psychological Association in the course of which he outlined his memories of Henry Maudsley. From around 1910, Crichton-Browne became publicly identified with the eugenics movement and social Darwinism, and this damaged his reputation towards the end of his life; but, in his last fifteen years or so, he also published seven volumes of reminiscences and established himself as the outstanding memoirist of British psychiatry.
Throughout his career, Crichton-Browne warned of the dangers of subjecting children to emotional stress during their education; emphasised the asymmetrical character of the human brain and behaviour; and also - like Emil Kraepelin and Alois Alzheimer - made some remarkable predictions about the neurological changes associated with severe psychiatric disorder.
"When considering the relative weights of the two hemispheres of the brain, it occurred to me that their ordinary relations....might possibly be reversed by disease of long standing. It seemed not improbable that the cortical centres which are last organized, which are the most highly evolved and voluntary, and which are supposed to be localised in the left side of the brain, might suffer first in insanity, which consists essentially in reduction from a higher voluntary to a lower automatic sphere." James Crichton-Browne (1879) On The Weight of the Brain.
"We are not yet free from the dangers of disuse or lopsided use of the brain. In moments of optimism we may flatter ourselves with the thought that we are under some sort of evolutionary compulsion....but the truth is that we are as apt to dissolve as to evolve, to sink as to swim....Our fate is in our own hands. We should bear in mind that it is not through ease and indolence, but through toil and conflict that man's highest welfare is attained. It is in the sweat of his brow and the stress of his brain that he has come to be what he is. The story of the brain is an epitome of history...." James Crichton-Browne The Second Ramsay Henderson Bequest Lecture: The Story of the Brain delivered in Edinburgh on Friday, 29th February 1924.
Family Background and Education
"My [maternal] grandfather's house was a....specimen of Scottish domestic architecture of the conventional type of the middle of the eighteenth century. He had inherited it from his grand-uncle, a really great man, a vigorous and versatile genius, James Hutton, who may be styled the father of modern geology. It was at St John's Hill that he....wrote The Theory of the Earth, that geological classic, and many other dissertations which contain pregnant suggestions on the physical and philosophical problems which are being at present so earnestly discussed." James Crichton-Browne (1938) The Doctor Remembers, page 17.
"No vestige of a beginning, no prospect of an end...." James Hutton (1788) The Theory of the Earth.
"In all the ages of the world....theologians, philosophers, and legislators....have agreed as to the importance to be attached to the physical, mental and moral training of infancy and childhood." James Crichton-Browne Psychical Diseases of Early Life, a paper read before the Royal Medical Society, Edinburgh, Friday, 2nd December 1859.
Crichton-Browne was born in Edinburgh at the family home of his mother, Magdalene Howden Balfour. She was the daughter of Dr Andrew Balfour and belonged to one of Scotland's foremost scientific families - the home (at St John's Hill near Salisbury Crags) had been built in 1770 for the unmarried geologist James Hutton (1726–1797).
Crichton-Browne's father, the asylum reformer William A.F. Browne (1805–1885), was a prominent phrenologist. Crichton-Browne's younger brother, John Hutton Balfour-Browne K.C. (1845–1921), wrote a classic work on the legal relations of insanity and his first cousin, Sir Isaac Bayley Balfour (1853–1922), was Sherardian Professor at Oxford and, later, Professor of Botany at Edinburgh.
Crichton-Browne spent much of his childhood at the Crichton Royal asylum in Dumfries where his father was the first medical superintendent from 1838 to 1857. William A.F. Browne was a pioneering Victorian psychiatrist and an exponent of moral treatment with an interest in the psychological lives of his patients as illustrated by their group activities, symptoms, dreams and art-works. During his twenty years at the Crichton Royal, W.A.F. Browne hoarded a huge collection of patient art and this interest found a parallel in Crichton-Browne's later asylum photography. In his childhood, Crichton-Browne lost two siblings: an older brother, William (aged 11 years) in 1846 and a sister, Jessie (aged 10 years) in 1852. He went to school at Dumfries Academy and then, in line with his mother's episcopalian outlook, to Trinity College, Glenalmond. Shortly before his death, Crichton-Browne wrote a valuable account of his Dumfries childhood, including a description of the visit of the American asylum reformer Dorothea Lynde Dix, and this was published as a Foreword to Charles Easterbrook's Chronicle of the Crichton Royal in 1940.
"Dumfries thirty-five years ago seemed almost on the eve of becoming the seat of a university....and then, at the instance, it is believed, of Sir Andrew Halliday, the money was applied in establishing and partly endowing a model house for the treatment of the insane. About forty acres of ground, forming part of the estate of Mountainhall, were purchased...." William McDowall (1873) History of The Burgh of Dumfries, page 732.
"I was not in those days interested in asylum administration, but I remember overhearing at table Miss Dix's warmly approbatory remarks on much that she saw in the Crichton Royal Institution, and her inquiries as to the composition of some distinctly Scottish dishes, such as kale, shortbread, scones, oatcakes, and haggis, recipes for which she obtained and carried off with her to the United States." James Crichton-Browne (1940) Some Early Crichton Memories.
"I am a personal link with Burns, having as a boy often chatted with his eldest son Robert, as he fished in the Nith dressed in a black tailed coat and a tall hat in the years 1854-1855, some twenty years after his retirement from his appointment in the Stamp Office in London....he wrote a few songs and miscellaneous pieces not without merit. He never displayed any spark of his father's genius. Both in London and Dumfries, however, he supplemented his modest income by giving lessons in classics and mathematics." James Crichton-Browne (1931) The Doctor's Second Thoughts, page 79.
"The New Moon, or Crichton Royal Institution Literary Register was founded in 1844....so successful as a kind of moral treatment was the New Moon, that it was followed in 1845 by the Morningside Mirror...." James Crichton-Browne (1930) What the Doctor Thought, page 41.
Darwin, Ferrier and the Wakefield Reports 1866 - 1875
"...it occurred to me that the insane ought to be studied." Charles Darwin (1872) Introduction to The Expression of the Emotions in Man and Animals.
"Professor Laycock attached much importance to automatic writing as expressive of hidden mental states and cerebral reflexes....after a long meeting of the Senatus Academicus, he collected and docketed the blotting-pads of about forty members....the scribblings, scratchings and sketches proved very instructive...." James Crichton-Browne (1930) What the Doctor Thought, page 31.
Crichton-Browne studied medicine at Edinburgh University, where his uncle was Dean of the Faculty of Medicine; he qualified MRCS in 1861, and MD in 1862 with a thesis on hallucinations. Among his teachers was his father's friend Thomas Laycock (1812–1876) whose "magnum opus" Mind and Brain is an extended speculative essay on neurology and psychological life. Crichton-Browne also drew on the writings of the physicians Sir Andrew Halliday and Sir Henry Holland. Like his father, Crichton-Browne was elected one of the undergraduate Presidents of the Royal Medical Society and, in this capacity, he argued for the place of psychology in the medical curriculum. After working as assistant physician in asylums in Exeter (with John Charles Bucknill), Warwick and Derby, and a brief period on Tyneside, Crichton-Browne was appointed Physician-Superintendent of the West Riding Pauper Lunatic Asylum at Wakefield in 1866; this was the year in which his father served as the first President of the reconstituted Medico-Psychological Association (now the Royal College of Psychiatrists); and, in his Presidential address delivered at the Royal Society of Edinburgh, W.A.F. Browne gave a rather laborious account of the principles of medical psychology and recorded the deaths of John Conolly (1794–1866) and Sir Alexander Morison (1779–1866).
Crichton-Browne spent ten years at the West Riding Asylum. He believed that the asylum should be an educational as well as a therapeutic institution and set about a major research programme, bringing biological insights to bear on the causes of insanity. He supervised hundreds of post-mortem examinations of the brain and took a special interest in the clinical features of neurosyphilis. In 1872, Crichton-Browne invited the Scottish neurologist David Ferrier (1843–1928) to direct the asylum laboratories and to conduct electrical studies on the cortical localization of cerebral functions, a research initiative which echoed Duchenne de Boulogne's revival of Galvani's experiments and which developed the phrenological theories of Crichton-Browne's father. (In 1832-1834, William A.F. Browne had published a serial paper in the Phrenological Journal on the relationship of mental disorder to a neurological disturbance of language and in some of his later writings there is a reiterated emphasis on the relationships of brain injury, psychosis and language). On the more general confluence of Crichton-Browne's thinking with his father's phrenology, see the papers by Walmsley, 1993 and 2003. Ferrier summarised his scientific work at the Wakefield asylum in his neurological classic The Functions of the Brain (1876).
"One is tempted to believe phrenologists are right about habitual exercise of the mind altering form of head, and thus these qualities become hereditary." Charles Darwin (1838) The M Notebook.
"My father says there is perfect gradation between sound people and insane - that everybody is insane at some time. Mania is quite distinct....in Mania, all idea of decency & affection are lost.- Most delicate people do most indelicate actions, as if/ their emotions/acquired....my Grandfather thought the feeling of anger, which arises almost involuntarily when a person is tired is akin to insanity. (I know the feeling also of depression)...." Charles Darwin (1838) The M Notebook.
"As my present opportunities did not admit of my giving you satisfactory information....I sent the letter on to my friend Dr C. Browne, medical superintendent of the West Riding Asylum, who has upwards of 1000 insane patients under his constant observation, and whose acquirements are of a high order....I trust that you may find the results useful...." (Henry Maudsley to Charles Darwin, 20th May, 1869).
"I do not know how to thank you enough for your MS "observations on expression". They contain exactly and fully the information which I wanted, and.... are most interesting and so graphic as to be almost painful." (Charles Darwin to James Crichton-Browne, 22nd May 1869).
"The extraordinary condition of the hair in the insane is due not only to its erection, but to its dryness and harshness, consequent on the subcutaneous glands failing to act. Dr Bucknill has said that a lunatic "is a lunatic to his fingers' ends"; he might have added, "and often to the extremity of each particular hair." " Charles Darwin (1872) The Expression of the Emotions in Man and Animals, page 297.
"It seems that the physiology of the brain will soon be completely understood." (Charles Darwin to James Crichton-Browne, concerning David Ferrier's experiments at Wakefield, 17th April 1873).
At the instigation of Henry Maudsley (1835–1918), Crichton-Browne corresponded with Charles Darwin (1809–1882) from May 1869 until December 1875. The bulk of the correspondence occurred during the preparation of Crichton-Browne's famous West Riding Lunatic Asylum Medical Reports and also of Darwin's The Expression of the Emotions in Man and Animals. On 8 June 1869, Darwin sent Crichton-Browne his copy of Duchenne's Mechanism of Human Facial Expression, asking for his comments. Crichton-Browne seems to have mislaid the book for about a year at the Wakefield asylum; but, on 6 June 1870, he returned it (with some embarrassment) to Darwin, along with an illustration of a woman with occasionally erected hair from the Southern Counties Asylum at Dumfries. Darwin explored a huge range of subjects with Crichton-Browne, including references to Maudsley's Body and Mind, the psychology of blushing, the functions of the platysma muscle (Darwin's "bête noire"), and the clinical phenomena of bereavement and grief. Darwin's mysterious symptoms which included vomiting, sweating, sighing, and weeping, particularly troublesome in the early months of 1872, seem to have largely resolved around the time that he completed his work on the origins of the human emotions.
" [William A.F.] Browne and I often talk of you and the old Plinian Society days when as young naturalists we discussed many points of interest which have since occupied prominent places in Science." (Professor John Hutton Balfour to Charles Darwin, 14th January, 1862).
"Enclosed in Duchenne (at the beginning) you will find a few crude notes on expression. I promise you more, in a little time....I send you a photograph of a female patient in the Southern Counties Asylum, Dumfries, N.B., under the care of Dr Gilchrist....We are beginning to take large photographs here, the size of Duchenne's....I shall send you some." (Crichton-Browne to Charles Darwin, 6th June 1870).
"Blushing is generally a public performance, but I succeeded in satisfying Darwin that it may occur in solitude and in the dark....I explained to Darwin that the case which I described to him....was illustrative of the rapid extension, under increased emotional perturbation, of the vaso-motor paralysis in which blushing really consists." James Crichton-Browne (1930) What the Doctor Thought, pp 64-65.
"The Plinian Society was encouraged by Professor Jameson....I used regularly to attend and the meetings had a good effect on me....one evening a poor young man got up and after stammering for a prodigious length of time, blushing crimson, got out the words, "Mr President, I have forgotten what I was going to say." The poor fellow looked quite overwhelmed, and all the members were so surprised that no one could think of a word to say to cover his confusion.... " Charles Darwin (1876) Recollections of the Development of my Mind and Character.
"April 20th 1882 - Charles Darwin has passed away, and with him I have lost a friend, illustrious and kind. Recalling my delightful intercourse with him, I pick out of a sheaf of letters one showing, as indeed they all do, the scrupulous care with which his inquiries were conducted, his marvellous suggestiveness, and his generous acknowledgement of any help given to him." James Crichton-Browne (published in) What the Doctor Thought (1930), page 61.
Building on the early psychiatric photography of Hugh Welch Diamond (1809 -1886) at Brookwood Hospital (Surrey's second County Asylum), Crichton-Browne sent about forty photographs of patients to Charles Darwin during the composition of his The Expression of the Emotions; however, Darwin used only one of these in the book (Figure 19) and this (Darwin Correspondence Project Letter 7220) was of the patient (with occasional erection of her hair "like wire") (photographer unknown) - under the care of Dr James Gilchrist at the Southern Counties Asylum, the public wing of (Crichton Royal) at Dumfries. The complete correspondence between Crichton-Browne and Charles Darwin forms a remarkable contribution to the beginnings of behavioural science. Nevertheless, Crichton-Browne attached greater importance to his six volumes of West Riding Lunatic Asylum Medical Reports (1871–1876) (Jellinek, 2005) - sending Darwin a copy of Volume One on 18 August 1871 - and to the neurological journal Brain which developed from them, in which he was assisted by John Hughlings Jackson (1835-1911), David Ferrier (1843-1928) and John Charles Bucknill (1817-1897) . Interestingly, Crichton-Browne declined Henry Maudsley's invitation to review The Descent of Man for The Journal of Mental Science; and it is notable that Charles Darwin did not make a contribution to Crichton-Browne's Asylum Reports, nor did he visit the West Riding asylum when invited by Crichton-Browne in 1873.
"Of all the classifications of insanity with which we have been afflicted in recent times, none has been more diligently vaunted, or more frequently obtruded upon attention, than that of the late Dr David Skae." James Crichton-Browne (1875) The Journal of Mental Science.
In 1875, Crichton-Browne ridiculed the classification of mental disorders produced by the Edinburgh psychiatrist David Skae (1814–1873) which had been promoted by Skae's pupil Thomas Clouston (1840–1915); Skae had sought to associate specific forms of mental disorder with diseased states of various bodily organs. Crichton-Browne characterised it as
|“||philosophically unsound, scientifically inaccurate and practically useless.||”|
In 1879, Crichton-Browne published his own considerations of the neuropathology of insanity making some exact predictions about the morbid anatomy of the human brain in cases of severe psychiatric disorder: he proposed that in the insane the weight of the brain was reduced, that the lateral ventricles were enlarged and that the burden of damage fell on the left cerebral hemisphere. This involved an evolutionary view of cerebral localisation with an emphasis on the asymmetry of cerebral functions which he derived from the clinical research of the French neurologist Paul Broca (1824–1880) on language centres in the brain - originally published in 1861 - and presented by Broca to the British Association for the Advancement of Science at its 1868 meeting in Norwich (chaired by Joseph Dalton Hooker). The question of asymmetrical cerebral functions had been raised many years earlier by the Edinburgh phrenologist Hewett Cottrell Watson in the Phrenological Journal. Crichton-Browne summarised his own views on psychosis and cerebral asymmetry in his most important scientific paper: On The Weight of the Brain (1879); and the best achieved appraisals of this paper are by Crow, 1995 and Compston, 2007.
Lord Chancellor's Visitor in Lunacy 1875 - 1922
In 1875, Crichton-Browne was appointed as Lord Chancellor's Visitor in Lunacy, a position which involved the regular examination of wealthy Chancery patients throughout England and Wales. He held this post until his retirement in 1922 and he combined it with the development of an extensive London consulting practice, becoming a familiar figure on the metropolitan medical scene. In 1878, he followed his father as President of the Medico-Psychological Association; in 1883, he was elected a Fellow of the Royal Society; and he served as Treasurer and Vice-President of the Royal Institution from 1889 till 1926. Crichton-Browne also made friendships in the literary world with the idiosyncratic historian Thomas Carlyle (1795–1881) whose marital reputation he defended against the allegations of James Anthony Froude; and, less controversially, with his exact contemporary, the novelist Thomas Hardy (1840–1928) who consulted Crichton-Browne about the anatomical peculiarities of the female brain. Crichton-Browne informed Hardy that the brain/body ratio was much the same in women as in men; but it is not clear that he drew Hardy's attention to the greater symmetry of female nervous structure. In 1898, Hardy presented Crichton-Browne with an inscribed copy of his Wessex Poems.
"George Herbert was wrong when he said that man was all symmetry; it was woman to whom that remark applied....evolution is still going on, and the faces of men and women still altering.... The emotions are less violently expressed....our ancestors gave vent to their feelings in a way that we would be ashamed of, and their range of feeling seems to have been in some degree more limited. The language of the countenance, like that of the tongue, has been enriched in the process of the suns." James Crichton-Browne, On Emotional Expression, the Presidential Address, Dumfriesshire and Galloway Natural History and Antiquarian Society, delivered in Free St George's Hall, Dumfries on Thursday, 24th January 1895.
"All these sensations and innervations belong to the field of "the Expression of the Emotions" which, as Darwin has taught us, consists of actions which originally had a meaning and served a purpose. These may now for the most part have become so weakened that the expression of them in words seems to us to be only a figurative picture of them, whereas in all probability the description was once meant literally, and hysteria is right in restoring the original meaning of the words...." Josef Breuer and Sigmund Freud (1895) Studies on Hysteria.
Crichton-Browne was a notable stylist and orator and he often combined this with a kind of couthy vernacular evocative of the Dumfries of his childhood. He was proud to have served as President of the Dumfriesshire and Galloway Natural History and Antiquarian Society from 1892 to 1896 and, on 24 January 1895, he gave a remarkable and light-hearted Presidential lecture - in Dumfries - On Emotional Expression - in which he discussed some reservations about Darwin's views and touched on the role of the motor cortex in expression, on the relations of gender to expressive asymmetry and on the relationship of language to the physical expression of the emotions. A few months later, on 30 June 1895 in London, Crichton-Browne delivered his famous Cavendish Lecture on Dreamy Mental States, in which he explored the relationship of trauma in the uniquely vulnerable temporal lobes to déjà vu, hallucinatory and supernatural experiences; this caught the attention of William James (1842-1910) who referred - rather dismissively - to Crichton-Browne in his Gifford lectures on The Varieties of Religious Experience (delivered in Edinburgh in 1901-1902). In the early years of the twentieth century, Crichton-Browne delivered a number of lectures on the asymmetry of the human brain, publishing his conclusions in 1907.
"Sir James Crichton-Browne has given the technical name of "dreamy states" to these sudden invasions of vaguely reminiscent consciousness. They bring a sense of mystery and of the metaphysical duality of things, and the feeling of an enlargement of perception which seems imminent, but which never completes itself. In Dr Crichton-Browne's opinion they connect themselves with the perplexed and scared disturbances of self-consciousness which occasionally precede epileptic attacks. I think that this learned alienist takes a rather absurdly alarmist view of an intrinsically insignificant phenomenon. He follows it along the downward ladder, to insanity..." William James (1902) The Varieties of Religious Experience - The Gifford Lectures on Natural Religion: Lecture 16: Mysticism.
Elder Statesman of British Psychiatry 1920 - 1938
"Maudsley was revealed to me in a brilliant essay on Edgar Allan Poe, which was published in the Journal of Mental Science in April, 1860, and which, although too scathing, was so rich in insight....as to betoken "the lighting of another taper at Heaven," which was at that time Maudsley's way of describing the arrival of a new man of genius on the scene....Maudsley's pathway and mine diverged physically after these racy and roseate London days when my lot was cast in the provinces for a decade....but whatever differences of conviction and outlook separated us, our friendship remained unbroken to the end." James Crichton-Browne The First Maudsley Lecture, delivered at the Royal Society of Medicine, Wimpole Street, London, 20th May 1920.
In the early Summer of 1920, Crichton-Browne delivered the first Maudsley Lecture to the Royal Medico-Psychological Association at the Royal Society of Medicine in London, giving an affecting tribute to Henry Maudsley whose enthusiasm and energy in the 1860s had been a source of inspiration and encouragement to him. He spoke with some feeling of Maudsley the man, and of the divergence of their pathways in the later development of British psychiatry, regretting Maudsley's social withdrawal in the last thirty years of his life. Crichton-Browne, rather in awe of Maudsley's intellectual powers, seems to have flinched at the less forgiving aspects of Maudsley's emotional landscape.
"I can conceive of a man learned in all the wisdom of the psychologians who would be a less successful asylum medical officer than one with quick insight, wholesome imagination and vivid sympathy who altogether ignored Freud and Hegel. There is a tactus eruditus in handling the morbid mind that only personal practice can confer...." James Crichton-Browne (1920) The First Maudsley Lecture.
"I recollect Professor Balfour telling me that....in 1860, a year after the publication of On The Origin of Species, there was a sharp discussion on that subject, in which Chambers, although present, took no part. As they left the meeting, however, Chambers turned to Balfour and said, "I think the Vestiges still holds its own," on which Balfour, challenging him, said, "And you are the Vestiges ?" and he nodded his head." James Crichton-Browne (1930) What the Doctor Thought, page 40.
"Vestiges is highly readable, but not always easy to understand." James A. Secord (1994) Introduction to Vestiges of the Natural History of Creation, reprinted edition, page xi.
"One of the admirable things about Chambers is the way in which he moves so easily between what we now regard as the poetic and the scientific....In conducting his life Robert Chambers also came to be able to meld labour and leisure so the two might enhance each other....by this time he was well advanced with Vestiges of the Natural History of Creation and, excursing with friends through the countryside around St Andrews, manifestly recovered and happy." Robert Crawford (2011) The Beginning and the End of the World: St Andrews, Scandal and the Birth of Photography, page 120.
"The Constitution of Man on its first appearance was received in Edinburgh with an odium theologicum, analogous to that afterwards stirred up by the Vestiges of Creation and The Origin of Species.....Moved by early predilection, - my father, a phrenologist of the old school, was assistant to George Combe at his lectures for a time, and was also for some years one of the Henderson Trustees - I have dipped into that old controversy and....this I will say, the phrenologists, notwithstanding their egregious errors, had the best of it both in argument and temper." James Crichton-Browne, The Story of the Brain, the second Ramsay Henderson Lecture delivered in Edinburgh on Friday, 29th February 1924.
" While defending the fundamental principle that the brain is the organ of the mind....it was, of course, the [phrenologists'] craniological conclusions, their dissection of the mind into a number of component faculties....that was the main point of attack, and that, it must be allowed, readily leant itself to burlesque." James Crichton-Browne, The Story of the Brain, Friday, 29th February 1924.
Four years later, on 29 February 1924, Crichton-Browne gave the Ramsay Henderson Bequest Lecture in Edinburgh and this lecture forms a kind of peroration to his public career. His title was The Story of the Brain. In this, he gave a remarkable tribute to members of the Edinburgh Phrenological Society - to George Combe (1788–1858), author of The Constitution of Man (1828), to Andrew Combe (1797–1847) author of Observations on Mental Derangement (1831) - and to Robert Chambers (1802–1871) who had sought to combine phrenology with evolutionary Lamarckism in his Vestiges of the Natural History of Creation - written in St Andrews as Chambers recuperated from a depressive illness, published in 1844, - and inverting Hutton's aphorism "no vestige of a beginning". However, Crichton-Browne did not mention that his Henderson lecture was delivered a century (almost to the day) after his father had joined the Edinburgh Phrenological Society.
With increasing age, with the death of his first wife, and with the loss of two grandsons in the first world war, Crichton-Browne's rhetoric took on a more strident tone and this compromised his reputation in the last two decades of his life.
"My first visit to St Andrews was in 1857, when I had just entered as a student in the University of Edinburgh, and thanks to the fact that I was under the wing of my uncle, Professor Balfour, I was shown over the ancient buildings - the Culdee Tower, the Castle rock, the Cathedral wall - by Sir David Brewster, who was to Carlyle "a grand superficial man", but who was to me a bit of a magician, as the inventor of the kaleidoscope in which I had seen so many fantastic suggestions. Carlyle was a candidate for the Chair of Moral Philosophy at St Andrews in 1827 when Chalmers left for Edinburgh, and was greatly disappointed that he did not obtain it....St Andrews, in its grey monotone, has a singular charm for all beholders." James Crichton-Browne (1938) The Doctor Remembers, page 32.
"The Doctor's Case Book is locked in a drawer, but his Note Book is ever ready to receive the jottings of the passing thoughts of his professional life....it is, in my case, in an endeavour to save some of them, for a time, from the inevitable auto-da-fé, that they have been assembled...." James Crichton-Browne (1937) From The Doctor's Notebook The Preface, page 5.
Crichton-Browne usually described himself as a medical psychologist - but, in spite of the pervasive influence of his medical psychology, he remains a strangely neglected figure in the history of British psychiatry. His raffish - almost louche - demeanour, rather snobbish social attitudes, latterly idiosyncratic political views - and his elegant, but convoluted, Victorian prose - have doubtless contributed to this. To the modern eye, Crichton-Browne's life displays a familiarly formulaic Victorian father-son dynamic. However, his unusual longevity, taken together with his father's distinguished psychiatric career, brought the world of the Edinburgh phrenologists - George Combe, Robert Chambers, Hewett Watson and William Ballantyne Hodgson - into contact with developing neuroscience in the course of the twentieth century - and he did not ignore the mediating influences of French neurology - Duchenne de Boulogne and Pierre Paul Broca. In the medical world, he held out the promise of a continuum of neurological and psychiatric illness and in the narrower world of psychiatry he demonstrated a public role for the specialist in mental disorder. The phrenologists' concept of the brain was of a genetically determined, dynamic system vulnerable to environmental stress. Crichton-Browne's psychiatric thinking contained a remarkable blend of social and neurological concerns and his considerations of the cerebral basis of psychotic disorder were well ahead of their time.
"I don't know much about [Crichton-Browne], except that he had a fine line in trenchant phraseology.... I particularly like his observation that "We are still as far as ever from mounting a delusion in Canada balsam, or from detecting despondency in a test tube." " Robert E. Kendell, personal correspondence, 21st December 2000.
"Clerk Maxwell was a teleologist, and clearly accepted design in the universe. There was in him a mystic awareness akin to that of Faraday. "I have been thinking," he said, "how very gently I have been dealt with. I have never had a violent shove in all my life." His spiritual sensibility was never stifled by his physical researches....Einstein would place him first in his trinity of great men: Newton, Faraday, Clerk Maxwell." James Crichton-Browne (1930) What The Doctor Thought, page 165.
"Clerk Maxwell, a man of real genius, noble character, and loveable disposition, had porridge and milk for his breakfast every morning, all his life". James Crichton-Browne (1932) The Doctor's After Thoughts page 46.
"....The last scene of all, a passage-at-arms, I vividly recollect. Mr Myers, standing in front of the fireplace, said: "It must be allowed that this demonstration has been a failure, and I attribute this to the offensive incredulity of Dr Crichton-Browne." To which I rejoined: "I hope I always will show offensive incredulity when I find myself in the presence of imposture." " James Crichton-Browne (1899) The Westminster Gazette, and reprinted (1931) in The Doctor's Second Thoughts, pp 63-64.
"On the night on which my [paternal] grandfather was drowned, his father, then living in Plymouth, awaking suddenly in the middle of the night, saw his son standing at the foot of the bed in his uniform and dripping with water....the old gentleman continued to believe till his dying day that it was a veritable wraith that he had seen." James Crichton-Browne (1938) The Doctor Remembers page 11.
Very early in his career - a week after the publication of On the Origin of Species - Crichton-Browne stressed the importance of psychiatric disorders in childhood and, much later, he was to emphasise the distinction between organic and functional illness in the elderly. He was considered an expert in many aspects of psychological medicine, public health and social reform. He supported a campaign for the open-air treatment of tuberculosis, housing and sanitary reform for the working-classes, and a practical approach to sexually transmitted diseases. He condemned the corporal punishment of children. He stressed the importance of the asymmetric lateralization of brain function in the development of language and deplored the fads relating to ambidexterity advocated by (among others) Robert Baden-Powell. He was critical of public education systems for their repetitive and fact-bound character, warning of mental exhaustion in otherwise happy and healthy children. He was openly - even offensively - sceptical concerning the claims of psychic investigators (including Frederic William Henry Myers) and spiritualists (see The Times articles of 1897/1899 concerning the Ballechin House controversy) and of dietary faddists and vegetarians. He argued that the benefits of Freudian psychotherapy had been assessed with insufficient rigour. He advocated (in 1892) the fluoridation of human dietary intake and he worried about the consequences of mass transportation by motor vehicles.
"James Crichton-Browne is a difficult figure to place. Honoured by contemporaries, and described as one of the most distinguished psychiatrists of the late nineteenth century, his appearance in the literature of the history of psychiatry is erratic." Alison M. Pearn (2010) "This Excellent Observer..."
"Crichton-Browne was not prominently linked with the Colleges of Physicians, did not occupy a senior academic position, endowed no lectures or institutions, left no textbook of psychiatry and was "owned" neither by England nor Scotland....but, in his very long life and career, there is conspicuous lineage of early asylum medicine with contemporary ideas of the cerebral basis of psychotic disorder...." Tom Walmsley (2003) Crichton-Browne's Biological Psychiatry.
"There is no short cut to longevity. To win it is the work of a lifetime." James Crichton-Browne (1905) The Prevention of Senility.
"My Dear Sir James....Corresponding with you reminds me of a very ancient controversy about Peat Reek and Harris Tweed which I once had with a celebrated but anonymous "J.C.B." " Winston Churchill, personal correspondence to James Crichton-Browne, 3rd June 1935.
"I have been spared the worst thing that affects most people of my age - forgetfulness. There are two kinds of forgetfulness - you forget your friends, and they, as you grow older, forget you....I still have plenty of friends." James Crichton-Browne, The New York Times, interview on his ninety-fifth birthday.
In the last years of his life, from retirement at his home "Crindau" (37 Nunholm Road) by the River Nith in the Nunholm district of Dumfries, Sir James published a notable study of Robert Burns' medical problems and physical decline based on some articles he had contributed to the Glasgow Herald, and seven volumes of memoirs selected from his commonplace books, consisting of fragmentary essays ranging widely over medical, psychological, biographical and Scottish themes. Crichton-Browne was twice married and, like his mother, cherished a lifelong affection for the traditions of the Anglican liturgy; he was a loyal member of the congregation at the Church of St John the Evangelist, Dumfries. Through family connections he became friendly with the painter Hannah Gluckstein ("Gluck") (1895–1978) who executed an arresting portrait of Sir James in 1928, now in the National Portrait Gallery. (Another portrait - by Sir Oswald Birley, painted in 1934 - is in the Crichton Royal Collection in Dumfries). Crichton-Browne was elected a Fellow of The Royal Society in 1883 (with posthumous support from Charles Darwin) and he was knighted in 1886. He was a vigorous opponent of teetotalism, stating that "no writer has done much without alcohol". When he died on 31 January 1938, at the age of 97, Crichton-Browne - like Robert Burns, Thomas Carlyle and James Clerk Maxwell - was acclaimed as one of the greatest sons of Dumfries and Galloway in South-West Scotland; one of the last men in Britain to sport Dundreary whiskers - and as one of the last Victorians.
- Holmes, G. M. (1939). "Sir James Crichton-Browne. 1840-1938". Obituary Notices of Fellows of the Royal Society 2 (7): 518–526. doi:10.1098/rsbm.1939.0012.
- Repcheck, Jack (2003) The Man Who Found Time: James Hutton and the Discovery of the Earth's Antiquity London and New York: Pocket Books (Simon and Schuster), especially pp 124-125
- Buchan, James (2003) Capital of the Mind: How Edinburgh Changed The World London: John Murray, especially pp 272-299
- Herman, Arthur (2003) The Scottish Enlightenment: The Scots' Invention of the Modern World London: Fourth Estate, a division of HarperCollins, pp 313-314
- Kaufman, Matthew H. (2005) Edinburgh Phrenological Society: A History Edinburgh: The William Ramsay Henderson Trust
- Jenkinson, Jacqueline (1993) Scottish Medical Societies 1731 - 1939: Their History and Records Edinburgh University Press, especially pp. 72 - 77
- Balfour Browne, J.H. (1875) The Medical Jurisprudence of Insanity San Francisco: Sumner Whitney
- McDowall, William (1873) History of the Burgh of Dumfries with notices of Nithsdale, Annandale and the Western Border, 2nd Edition, Edinburgh: Adam and Charles Black, pp 732-734
- Comrie, John D. (1932) History of Scottish Medicine, 2 vols, London: Baillière, Tindall and Cox, for The Wellcome Historical Medical Museum, see especially pp 464 - 471
- Henderson, D.K. (1964) The Evolution of Psychiatry in Scotland Edinburgh and London: Livingstone, pp 72-74
- Scull, Andrew (1991) The Asylum as Utopia: W.A.F. Browne and the Mid-Nineteenth Century Consolidation of Psychiatry London and New York: Tavistock/Routledge (includes a reprint of Browne, William A. F. (1837) What Asylums Were, Are, and Ought To Be Edinburgh: Adam and Charles Black)
- Scull, Andrew, MacKenzie, Charlotte and Hervey, Nicholas (1996) Masters of Bedlam: The Transformation of the Mad-Doctoring Trade Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton University Press, especially pp. 84-122
- Walmsley, Tom (1991) Psychiatry in Scotland (in) 150 Years of British Psychiatry 1841-1991, edited by Berrios G.E. and Freeman, Hugh, London: Gaskell/ The Royal College of Psychiatrists, pp 294 - 305
- Porter, Roy (editor) (1991) The Faber Book of Madness London and Boston: Faber and Faber, pp 352 - 353
- Browne, W.A.F. (1864) The Moral Treatment of Insanity The Journal of Mental Science, 10, 309 - 337
- Cormack, Alexander Allan (1966) Susan Carnegie 1744-1821: Her Life of Service Aberdeen University Press for Dr Cormack, especially pp 297 - 305
- Prichard, James Cowles (1835) A Treatise on Insanity and Other Disorders Affecting the Mind London: Sherwood, Gilbert and Piper
- Walk, Alexander (1954) Some Aspects of the "Moral Treatment" of the Insane The Journal of Mental Science, 100, 807-837
- Jones, Kathleen (1993) Asylums and After London: The Athlone Press, especially pp 69-70
- Park, Maureen (2010) Art in Madness: Dr W.A.F. Browne's Collection of Patient Art at Crichton Royal Institution, Dumfries Dumfries and Galloway Health Board
- Crichton-Browne, James (1940) Some Early Crichton Memories (in) The Chronicle of Crichton Royal 1833-1936 (edited by C.C. Easterbrook) Dumfries: Courier Press, pp 1-6
- Laycock, Thomas (1860) Mind and Brain: or, The Correlations of Consciousness and Organization, 2 vols, Edinburgh: Sutherland and Knox; 2nd edn (1869) London: Simpkin and Marshall.
- Beveridge, Allan (1996) On The Origins of Psychiatric Thought: the contribution of Edinburgh, 1730 - 1850, (in) 150 Years of Psychiatry, Vol. 2. The Aftermath, edited by Freeman, Hugh and Berrios, German E., London: The Athlone Press, pp. 339 - 366
- Halliday, Sir Andrew (1828) A general view of the present state of lunatics, and lunatic asylums, in Great Britain and Ireland, and in some other kingdoms. London: Underwood
- Gray, James (1952) History of the Royal Medical Society 1737-1937 Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press
- Browne, W.A.F. (1866) On Medico-Psychology The Journal of Mental Science, 12, 309 - 327
- Todd, John and Ashworth, Lawrence E. (1991) The West Riding Asylum and James Crichton-Browne, 1818-1876, (in) 150 Years of British Psychiatry 1841 - 1991 edited by Berrios, G.E., and Freeman, Hugh, London: Gaskell/ The Royal College of Psychiatrists, pp 389 - 418
- Hustvedt, Asti (2011) Medical Muses: Hysteria in Nineteenth Century Paris London: Bloomsbury, especially pp 155 - 159
- Duchenne (de Boulogne), Guillaume-Benjamin Amand (1990) The Mechanism of Human Facial Expression, edited and translated by R. Andrew Cuthbertson, Cambridge University Press and Paris: Éditions de la Maison des Sciences de l'Homme, originally published (1862) as Mécanisme de la Physionomie Humaine Paris: Jules Renouard, Libraire
- Didi-Huberman, Georges (1982) Invention de l'hystérie: Charcot et l'iconographie photographique de la Salpêtrière Paris: Éditions Macula, english translation (2003) (by Alice Hartz) Invention of Hysteria Cambridge, Mass: The MIT Press
- Browne, W.A.F. (1832-1834) On Morbid Manifestations of the Organ of Language, as connected with insanity The Phrenological Journal and Miscellany, 8, pp 250-260, 308-316 and 414-423
- Browne, W.A.F. (1872) Impairment of Language, the Result of Cerebral Disease West Riding Lunatic Asylum Medical Reports, 2, 278 - 301
- Walmsley, Tom (1993) Psychiatry in Descent: Darwin and the Brownes Psychiatric Bulletin, 17, 748 - 751
- Walmsley, Tom (2003) Crichton-Browne's Biological Psychiatry Psychiatric Bulletin, 27, 20 - 22
- Ferrier, David (1876) The Functions of The Brain London: Smith, Elder
- Collie, Michael (1988) Henry Maudsley: Victorian Psychiatrist: A Bibliographical Study Winchester: St Pauls Bibliographies pp 25 - 26
- Pick, Daniel (1989) Faces of Degeneration: A European Disorder, c.1848 - c.1918 Cambridge University Press, especially pp 203-216
- Pearn, Alison M. (2010) "This Excellent Observer...": The Correspondence between Charles Darwin and James Crichton-Browne 1869 - 1875, History of Psychiatry, 21, 160 - 175
- Browne, E. Janet (1985) Darwin and the Face of Madness (in) The Anatomy of Madness: Essays in the History of Psychiatry, Vol 1, People and Ideas, edited by Bynum, W.F., Porter, Roy and Shepherd, Michael, London: Tavistock, pp 151 - 165
- Gilman, Sander L. (1982) Seeing the Insane Lincoln, Nebraska: University of Nebraska Press and reprinted (1996) New York: Bison Books, especially pp. 179-191
- Appignanesi, Lisa (2008) Mad, Bad and Sad: A History of Women and the Mind Doctors from 1800 to the Present London: Virago Press, especially page 110
- Prodger, Phillip (2009) Darwin's Camera: Art and Photography in the Theory of Evolution Oxford University Press, especially pp 92 - 101
- Darwin, Charles R. (1872) The Expression of the Emotions in Man and Animals London: John Murray
- Darwin, Charles, Ekman, Paul, and Prodger, Phillip (1998) The Expression of the Emotions in Man and Animals, 3rd edn, London: Harper Collins
- Maudsley, Henry (1870) Body and Mind: The Gulstonian Lectures for 1870 London: Macmillan and Co.
- Colp, Ralph (1977) To Be an Invalid: The Illness of Charles Darwin Chicago and London: Chicago University Press
- Gilman, Sander L. (1976) The Face of Madness: Hugh W. Diamond and the Origin of Psychiatric Photography New York: Brunner Mazel
- Smith, Jonathan (2006) Charles Darwin and Victorian Visual Culture Cambridge University Press
- Jellinek, E.H. (2005) Sir James Crichton-Browne (1840 - 1938): pioneer neurologist and scientific drop-out Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine, 98, 9, 428 - 430
- Rose, F. Clifford (1999) A Short History of Neurology: The British Contribution 1660 - 1910 Oxford, Auckland: Butterworth, Heinemann, especially pp 151 - 164
- Critchley, Macdonald (1998) John Hughlings Jackson: Father of English Neurology Oxford University Press
- Jackson, J. Hughlings (1884) Evolution and Dissolution of the Nervous System: The Croonian Lectures The Lancet, i, 555-558, 649-652, 739-744; reprinted (1931) in Selected Writings, vol. II, pp 45 - 75 London: Hodder and Stoughton
- Fish, Frank (1965) David Skae MD FRCS, Founder of the Edinburgh School of Psychiatry Medical History, 9 , 36 - 53
- Beveridge, Allan (1991) Thomas Clouston and the Edinburgh School of Psychiatry (in) 150 Years of British Psychiatry, 1841 - 1991, edited by Berrios, G.E. and Freeman, Hugh, London: Gaskell/The Royal College of Psychiatrists, pp 359 - 388
- Crichton-Browne, James (1875) Skae's Classification of Mental Diseases The Journal of Mental Science, 21, 339 - 365
- Crichton-Browne, James (1879) On The Weight of the Brain and its Component Parts in the Insane Brain, 1, 514 - 518, 2, 42 - 67
- Broca, Pierre Paul (1861) Remarques sur le Siège de la Faculté de Langage Articulé; suivis d'une observation d'aphémie (perte de la parole) Bulletin de la Societé de l'Anatomie de Paris, 36, pp 330 - 357
- McManus, Chris (2002) Right Hand, Left Hand: The Origins of Asymmetry in Brains, Bodies, Atoms and Cultures London: Weidenfeld and Nicolson
- Broca, Pierre Paul (1868) On the Seat of the Faculty of Articulate Language British Medical Journal, 2, 259
- Watson, Hewett Cottrell (1836) What is the Use of the Double Brain ? The Phrenological Journal and Miscellany, 9, 608-611
- Holland, Sir Henry (1840) On the Brain as a Double Organ. In Chapters on Mental Physiology London: Longmans et al
- Wigan, Arthur Ladbroke (1844) A New View of Insanity: The Duality of Mind proved by the structure, functions, and diseases of the brain, and by the phenomena of mental derangement. London: Longmans et al
- Harrington, Anne (1987) Medicine, Mind, and the Double Brain: a study in nineteenth century thought Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton University Press
- Crow, T.J. (1995) A Darwinian Approach to the Origins of Psychosis British Journal of Psychiatry, 167, 12 - 25
- Compston, Alastair (2007) Brain, 130, (3), 599 - 601
- Neve, Michael and Turner, Trevor (1995) What the Doctor Thought and Did: Sir James Crichton-Browne (1840-1938) Medical History, 39, 399-432
- Oppenheim, Janet (1991) Shattered Nerves: Doctors, Patients and Depression in Victorian England London and New York: Oxford University Press, especially Chapter 2
- Crichton-Browne, James with Alexander Carlyle (1903) The Nemesis of Froude: A Rejoinder to J.A.Froude's "My Relations with Carlyle" London and New York: John Lane, The Bodley Head
- [Crichton-Browne, James] (1895) Conversazione - and the Presidential Address: "On Emotional Expression" Transactions and the Journal of Proceedings of the Dumfriesshire and Galloway Natural History and Antiquarian Society, Series II, 11, 72 - 77, Dumfries: the Courier and Herald Offices
- Crichton-Browne, James (1895) Dreamy Mental States (reprinted in) Stray Leaves from a Physician's Portfolio (1927) London: Hodder and Stoughton, pp 1 - 42
- Crichton-Browne, James (1907) Dexterity and the Bend Sinister Proceedings of the Royal Institution of Great Britain, 18, 623-652
- Crichton-Browne, James (1920) The First Maudsley Lecture The Journal of Mental Science, 66, 199 - 225
- Crichton-Browne, James (1924) The Story of the Brain, Edinburgh: Oliver and Boyd
- [Chambers, Robert] (1844) Vestiges of the Natural History of Creation London: John Churchill, published anonymously, and reprinted (1994) (edited by James A. Secord) Chicago, Ill: University of Chicago Press
- Secord, James A. (2000) Victorian Sensation: The Extraordinary Publication, Reception and Secret Authorship of "Vestiges of the Natural History of Creation" Chicago, Ill: University of Chicago Press
- Crawford, Robert (2011) The Beginning and the End of the World: St Andrews, Scandal and the Birth of Photography Edinburgh: Birlinn
- Bourne Taylor, Jenny (2007) Psychology at the fin-de-siècle (in) The Cambridge Companion to the Fin-de-Siècle (edited by Gail Marshall) Cambridge University Press
- Clarke, Edwin and Jacyna, L.S. (1987) Nineteenth Century Origins of Neuroscientific Concepts Berkeley, Los Angeles and London: University of California Press
- Crichton Browne, James (1860) The Psychical Diseases of Early Life, The Journal of Mental Science, 6, 284 - 320
- Crichton-Browne, James (1874) Senile Dementia, British Medical Journal, i, 601-603, 640-643
- Berrios, German E. (1996) The History of Mental Symptoms: descriptive psychopathology since the nineteenth century Cambridge University Press, page 183
- Myers, F.W.H. (1903) Human Personality and its Survival of Bodily Death London: Longmans, Green & Co
- Luckhurst, Roger (2004) Knowledge, Belief and the Supernatural at the Imperial Margin (in) The Victorian Supernatural (edited by Nicola Bown, Carolyn Burdett and Pamela Thurschwell) Cambridge University Press, pp 197-216
- Campbell, John L. and Hall, Trevor H. (2006) Strange Things: The Story of Fr Allan McDonald, Ada Goodrich Freer and the Society for Psychical Research's Enquiry into Highland Second Sight Edinburgh: Birlinn, especially pp. 185 - 188
- Warner, Marina (2006) Phantasmagoria: Spirit Visions, Metaphors and Media into the Twenty-first Century Oxford University Press, especially pp 237 - 249
- Ring, Malvine E. (2007) A Scottish Physician Ahead of His Times: The Story of Sir James Crichton-Browne Dental History Magazine, Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Glasgow, 1, 1, pp 9 - 11
- Crichton-Browne, James (1925) Burns from a New Point of View London:Hodder and Stoughton
- Crichton-Browne, James (1926) Victorian Jottings London: Etchells and Macdonald
- Crichton-Browne, James (1927) Stray Leaves from a Physician's Portfolio London: Hodder and Stoughton
- Crichton-Browne, James (1930) What the Doctor Thought London: Ernest Benn
- Crichton-Browne, James (1931) The Doctor's Second Thoughts London: Ernest Benn
- Crichton-Browne, James (1932) The Doctor's After Thoughts London: Ernest Benn
- Crichton-Browne, James (1937) From The Doctor's Notebook London: Duckworth
- Crichton-Browne, James (1938) The Doctor Remembers London: Duckworth
- American Journal of Public Health Sir James Crichton-Browne: Victorian Psychiatrist and Public Health Reformer (biography)