William Low

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
William Low plc
Industry Retail
Fate Takeover
Successors Initially rebranded as Tesco Scotland, then again to be Tesco
Founded 1868
Defunct 2 September 1994
Headquarters Dundee, Scotland
Key people Chairman - James Millar
C.E.O - P.R Spicer
Company Secretary - H.L Findlay
Products Groceries
Employees 8981
Wm Low store in Whitehaven

William Low (popularly referred to as Willie Low's;[1] latterly marketed as Wm Low) was a chain of supermarkets based in Dundee, Scotland, until it was bought out by Tesco for £257m in 1994.

As a group it was smaller than most of its competitors and often served small towns, although it still had several large supermarkets, including two in Dundee, and two in Perth. Most towns in the Tayside region had at least one large William Low store and it had branches throughout Scotland, North East England, Cumbria and Yorkshire. Tesco had to compete with a rival takeover bid from competitor J Sainsbury for the chain and, following the takeover, 57 of the William Low stores were converted to the Tesco fascia. Prior to this, there were only around 17 Tesco branches in Scotland.

At one stage, the company also ran a chain of frozen food stores known as Lowfreeze.[2] Lowfreeze was sold in 1987 to Bejam, with Bejam being sold to rival Iceland in 1989.

History[edit]

Early years[edit]

The Company was founded by William Rettie and James Low in 1868 (The name consists of both the founder's names, one's first name and the other's surname). James's brother, William, joined the shop in 1870, taking over the business some years later.[3]

William Rettie's grandson, Philip, joined the company in 1948, becoming managing director in 1958 and chairman in 1980.[4]

1976-1984 Expansion[edit]

Logo used during the 1970s and early 1980s (black and white version)

Wm Low almost doubled in size between 1976 to 1984 with sustained expansion and increased store sizes. In 1976, Wm Low had a total of 205,000 sq ft (19,000 m2) of floor space which by 1984 had become 446,000 sq ft (41,400 m2). Wm Low also rose to be included as number 400 in the Times 1000, a list of top UK Companies in 1984, whereas in 1976 it was not even listed.[5]

Takeovers and Mergers[edit]

In 1984, Wm Low attempted but failed to take over Hintons, which later became part of Safeway. In 1985, Wm Low took over Laws Stores at a cost of £7.1 million.,[5] a group predominantly based in the north-east of England with a portfolio of smaller stores than Wm Low. Wm Low proceeded to close unprofitable Laws stores in 1986.[6]

In 1989. Wm Low attempted to take over Budgens, a move described by Budgens as a friendly merger and which had looked to be a done deal. This deal ultimately collapsed.[7]

Also in 1989, James Millar of Wm Low approached John Apthorp, owner of Bejam Freezer Centres to explore the possibility of merging the two brands. John Apthorp explains that he could not see the idea going ahead as Wm Low were losing market share and the store portfolio did not lend itself well to the possibility of conversions to freezer centre formats.[8] In 1987, Wm Low had sold its frozen food chain, Lowfreeze, to Bejam for £3.8 million.[5]

1993-1994 Expansion[edit]

It was Wm Low's aim to achieve a total of 61 stores and 959,000 sq ft (89,100 m2) of sales area by the end of the 1994 financial year.[9]

Expansion into the north and midlands of England was a priority, with the £12 million, 30,000 sq ft (2,800 m2) Loughborough store opening in 1993. Amid huge publicity for price cuts on over 500 items, customers took their sleeping bags to await the opening of the store and claim their hamper, champagne and flowers. This was the company's foray into direct competition with Sainsbury.

Market share[edit]

Wm Low was one of the market leaders in Scotland in terms of market share, which was 7.4% in 1981, rising to 10.4% in 1984 and then 12.7% in 1986. It then started to fall until the 1994 takeover by Tesco.[5]

History of the takeover[edit]

Competing bids[edit]

The takeover battle for William Low started on 14 July 1994, when Tesco announced its formal bid of £156 million for the company to dramatically improve its Scottish portfolio and an assurance it would not cherry pick the best stores. J Sainsbury launched a counter-bid of £210 million but this would have led to a break up of the Wm Low portfolio as they had intended to maintain the best stores and dispose of the rest.

The Scottish market leader at the time, The Argyll Group - Safeway - announced in July 1994 that it would not be making a bid for Wm Low.[10] Sainsbury was keen to gain a stronger foothold in Scotland, having only 3 stores in Scotland at the time of the bid.[11] Tesco reacted with an improved offer of £247 million and Sainsbury's withdrew from the battle.[11]

Tesco formally took over Wm Low on 2 September 1994 for a total sum of £257 million. Analysis at the time suggested that the Sainsbury bid was possibly a spoiler tactic as opposed to a serious takeover attempt.[12]

The company had been independent for 126 years, having been founded in 1868. The purchase of Wm Low doubled Tesco's Scottish market share from 7.6% to 15.3% in 1995.[13]

Financial performance: before and after[edit]

Prior to the take over, sales had been falling at a rate of 6%, a figure that Tesco reversed to a growth of 20% by February 1996 and the former Wm Low stores contributed £11 million profit to the Tesco group.[14]

Tesco quotes pre-tax profits prior to the takeover as being £17m in 1993 and £15m in 1994.[14] The Scottish Business Insider quotes similar yearly figures:[15]

  • 1991: £354 million turnover, £21 million profit
  • 1992: £394 million turnover, £23 million profit
  • 1993: £253 million turnover, £20 million profit
  • 1994: £446 million turnover, £21 million profit

Staff numbers prior to the takeover had been reasonably static, from 8799 employees in 1991 to 8981 in 1994.[15]

Conversion to Tesco-formatted stores[edit]

A re-fit programme followed and Tesco scanning tills were installed at every store by August 1995, with the refit being completed by the end of 1996 at a cost of £35 million.[14]

Although the vast majority of old Wm Low stores have now been replaced with all-new Tesco stores, as of December 2006 some branches retain some Wm Low format fixtures (e.g. open grid false ceilings and blue / pink tiling in toilets). This is evident in stores such as Inverness Metro, Campbeltown, Fort Willam, Helensburgh, St Andrews, Dalgety Bay, Rosyth, Monifeith and Haddington. This is despite the stores having undergone a couple of internal refits since the takeover. Tesco Banff is the last obvious Wm Low style store left in the portfolio, having not undergone any refit since immediately after the takeover in 1996. This store is due to be replaced by a new purpose built store in 2010. Dundee Lochee which was the last large Wm Low superstore closed on 7 February 2009, being replaced by Dundee South Rd which is now Scotland's largest Tesco store, spread out over 3 floors. Wishaw Tesco moved to a purpose built store in November 2007 across from its original Wm Low store.

The last Wm Low superstore in England is due to close in spring 2013. The store in Consett which opened in 1987 replacing the smaller town centre store acquired in the takeover of Laws Stores is to be replaced by a single floor Tesco Extra located on the former steelworks site. Construction commenced in August 2012.[citation needed]

Remaining stores[edit]

Most of the remaining Wm Low stores have been converted to the Tesco "Metro" format, in line with their smaller size. Such stores can be found in Grangemouth, St Andrews, Campbeltown, Monifieth, Inverness, Fort William, Helensburgh and Stranraer.

Planned Wm Low store expansion[edit]

At the time of the Tesco take over, a number of new Wm Low Stores were earmarked for development. These were ultimately launched as Tescos but had been planned by Wm Low. This included Aviemore,[16] Cupar, Falkirk and Dunblane, opened between 1995 and 1996.

Redundant stores[edit]

Some of the now redundant sites have gone on to find new owners after Tesco relocated in nearby areas. The former Wm Low Dingwall has now become a Lidl, Wm Low Blairgowrie became M & Co whilst Wm Low Elgin became TK Maxx. WM Low Keith became The Original Factory Shop, Wm Low Forres remains empty to this day.

Wm Low Bathgate West_Lothian became Tesco which relocated to a new purpose built store on the outskirts of Blackburn,_West_Lothian, the former Wm Low unit then became B Wise and Qs which both have since closed down. The site is currently as of December 2013, a fairly large charity shop.

Wm Low Dundee Lochee Site remains on the market since the store was closed and business relocated to Dundee South Road.

Wm Low in Perth (Victoria St branch) lay empty for almost a decade before half of the premises being refitted and operated as a Matalan Store and the other half (what used to be the supermarket warehouse) now a store selling floor coverings and livingroom furniture.

In 2007, the former Wm Low store in Forfar closed, with Tesco moving to a new site at the northern end of the town centre. The old site was subsequently sold to Focus DIY, whose store opened there in early 2008. The site has a garden centre, built on part of the old car park, and very little exists to suggest it was a former supermarket.

The former Wm Low store in Goole, East Yorkshire, was taken over by Tesco, but this was relocated to a larger site on Boothferry Road in the late 1990s. The store was split into four units and is now home to a branch of Lidl and Farmfoods with the other two units being empty. The store in Berwick-upon-Tweed became a Kwik Save, which in turn has closed now an empty store.

Distribution Centres[edit]

The Wm Low warehouse in Gateshead was closed in March 1995.[14] The head office and Distribution Centre at the Dryburgh Estate in Dundee became the Tesco Customer Service Centre and one of two Scottish Distribution Depots for Tesco.

Wm Low Dryburgh Distribution Centre was built in the mid 1970s by Wm Low with an expected 25 years life span. In 2006, Tesco announced the closure of the Dundee depot to create a brand new centre in Livingston on the site of the former NEC which would also replace the current distribution centre already based in Livingston ( now open as of October 2007). The customer service centre is unaffected by the closure. Residents of Dundee reacted furiously to the news of the depot closure.

Store portfolio[edit]

The following is a list of Wm Low stores in existence immediately prior to the takeover by Tesco.[17]

Scotland[edit]

Banff, Bathgate, Blairgowrie, Bo'ness, Campbeltown, Carnoustie, Coatbridge, Craigmarloch, Crieff, Cumbernauld, Dalgety Bay, Dalkeith, Dingwall, Dumfries, Dunbar, Dundee (two), Dunfermline, Edinburgh (two), Elgin, Forfar, Forres, Fort William, Galloway, Govan (Paisley Road West), Grangemouth, Greenock, Haddington, Helensburgh, Inverness, Inverurie, Keith, Kilmarnock, Kirkcaldy, Kirkintilloch, Kirriemuir, Lanark, Linlithgow, Milngavie, Monifieth, Montrose, Oban, Perth (two; one on Victoria Street in the city centre and one on the Crieff Road), Rosyth, St Andrews, Stranraer, and Wishaw.

In 1999, Tesco agreed to swap the Carnoustie, Dunbar and Kirriemuir stores with Lothian Borders & Angus Co-operative Society to gain a larger superstore in Galashiels.[18]

England[edit]

Consett, Driffield, Gateshead (Rowlands Gill), Goole, Ilkeston, Jesmond, Loughborough, Northallerton, Sleaford, Thirsk, Whitehaven, Workington.

Typhoid outbreak[edit]

On 6 and 7 May 1964, the Aberdeen branch delicatessen used a tin of Argentinian corned beef that had not been processed properly (and was infected with typhoid).[19] Due to the fact that the meat was sliced using a communal deli slicer, approximately 500 people were diagnosed in Aberdeen in 1964 with suspected typhoid. William Low was never successful in the city again with their branch closing in the city only 3 years later.

References and footnotes[edit]

  1. ^ The Scotsman
  2. ^ Evidence quotes: "Lowfreeze store network", "Does not include Lowfreeze freezer centres": Sparks, Leigh, "Restructuring Scottish grocery retailing: the rise and demise of Shoprite and Wm Low" (via Google cache of emerald-library.com), International Journal of Retail & Distribution Management, Volume 23, Number 10, 1995. Article retrieved 18 December 2006.
  3. ^ Sparks, L (1996-08-01), "Space wars: Wm Low and the 'auld enemy.'(British food retailer takes over Scottish firm Wm Low & Co.)", Environment & Planning A (Pion Ltd) v28 (n8): p1465(20), ISSN 0308-518X 
  4. ^ Burdge, Richard (2013-09-04). "Businessman and Ballindean farmer Philip Rettie dies aged 86". The Courier. DC Thomson & Co, Ltd. Retrieved 2014-01-17. 
  5. ^ a b c d [1] University of Stirling Working papers, 2005. Retailing in Scotland. Article retrieved 24 December 2007
  6. ^ Restructuring Scottish grocery retailing: the rise and demise of Shoprite and Wm Low Article retrieved 25 November 2007.
  7. ^ Budgens at Funding Universe Article retrieved 26 November 2007.
  8. ^ Majestic Return for 80's Star Management Today. Article retrieved 22 December 2007
  9. ^ Wm Low & Company Plc, Profile at business.com. Article retrieved 25 December 2006.
  10. ^ Grocer Magazine, July 1994
  11. ^ a b Calder, Colin. "Defeated Sainsbury to spend Pounds 100m". Sunday Times (Times Newspapers). 
  12. ^ BBC TV, Reporting Scotland, evening editions, transmitted 1994-07-14 and 3 August 1994.
  13. ^ Supply-side Changes in Food Retailing in Scotland, Healthscotland.Com, Document Retrieved 26 December 2006.
  14. ^ a b c d Five Year Record, Tesco Investor Information 1995, tesco.com. Article retrieved 2006-12-19. Contains information on (i) Growth figures (ii) Conversion expenditure, (iii) Fixed assets and (iv) Notice to Financial Statements respectively.
  15. ^ a b Data collated by Centre for the Study of Retailing in Scotland (csrs.ac.uk). Sourced from Scottish Business Insider, January editions 1991-1998 (inc) and 2000-2004 (inc). Document retrieved 25 December 2006.
  16. ^ JLP Development Consultancy Article retrieved 26 November 2007.
  17. ^ "List of Stores", Tesco Investor Information 1995, tesco.com. Article retrieved 19 December 2006.
  18. ^ Selected extracts from "UK Activity Report", UK Business Park. Article retrieved 19 December 2006.
  19. ^ Diack, Lesley and Smith, David, Sensationalism and Secrecy: The Aberdeen Typhoid Outbreak, 1964, History Scotland Magazine at historyscotland.com. Article retrieved 19 December 2006

External links[edit]