Jump to content

Kilclooney More: Difference between revisions

Coordinates: 54°49′04″N 8°25′59″W / 54.817718°N 8.4331537°W / 54.817718; -8.4331537
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Content deleted Content added
link
m task, replaced: Proceedings of the Royal Irish Academy. Section C: Archaeology, Celtic Studies, History, Linguistics, Literature → Proceedings of the Royal Irish Academy, Section C (2) using AWB
Line 1: Line 1:
[[File:Kilclooney More Portal Tomb Dg. 70 North-Eastern Chamber SE II 2016 08 30.jpg|thumb|Larger chamber of the eastern portal tomb in Kilclooney More with a capstone that has been described as ‘birdlike’ or ‘Concorde-like’ ({{italics correction|''Dg. 70''}})<ref name="Lacey">{{cite encyclopedia |last1=Lacey |first1=Brian |title=Prehistoric Archaeology of Donegal: c. 7000 BC to c. AD 500 |pages=101–106 |encyclopedia=An Historical, Environmental and Cultural Atlas of County Donegal |editor1-last=Mac Laughlin |editor1-first=Jim |editor2-last=Beattie |editor2-first=Seán |publisher=Cork University Press |location=Cork |date=2013 |isbn=978-1-85918-494-3 |quote=One of the most striking Neolithic monuments in Donegal is the portal tomb at Kilclooney More, near Ardara. Its 4.2- metre long ‘birdlike’ capstone is only one of the unusual features of this magnificent structure.}}</ref><ref>{{cite journal |last=Lacy |first=Brian |title=Donegal |journal=Archaeology Ireland |volume=2 |number=2 |date=1988 |pages=48–52 |quote=Among the most impressive is the well-known Kilclooney More tomb with its famous ‘Concorde-like’ capstone.}}</ref>]]
{{about|Kilclooney More in County Donegal|the townland in County Galway|Kilclooney}}
{{about|Kilclooney More in County Donegal|the townland in County Galway|Kilclooney}}
[[File:Kilclooney More Portal Tomb Dg. 70 North-Eastern Chamber SE II 2016 08 30.jpg|thumb|Larger chamber of the eastern portal tomb in Kilclooney More with a capstone that has been described as ‘birdlike’ or ‘Concorde-like’ ({{italics correction|''Dg. 70''}})<ref name="Lacey">{{cite encyclopedia |last1=Lacey |first1=Brian |title=Prehistoric Archaeology of Donegal: c. 7000 BC to c. AD 500 |pages=101–106 |encyclopedia=An Historical, Environmental and Cultural Atlas of County Donegal |editor1-last=Mac Laughlin |editor1-first=Jim |editor2-last=Beattie |editor2-first=Seán |publisher=Cork University Press |location=Cork |date=2013 |isbn=978-1-85918-494-3 |quote=One of the most striking Neolithic monuments in Donegal is the portal tomb at Kilclooney More, near Ardara. Its 4.2- metre long ‘birdlike’ capstone is only one of the unusual features of this magnificent structure.}}</ref><ref>{{cite journal |last=Lacy |first=Brian |title=Donegal |journal=Archaeology Ireland |volume=2 |number=2 |date=1988 |pages=48–52 |quote=Among the most impressive is the well-known Kilclooney More tomb with its famous ‘Concorde-like’ capstone.}}</ref>]]
'''Kilclooney More''' ({{lang-ga|Cill Chluanadh Mhór}},<ref>{{cite web |url=https://www.logainm.ie/en/14599 |title=Cill Chluanadh Mhór |access-date=2 March 2017}}</ref> meaning church of the pasture)<ref>{{cite book |last1=Flanagan |first1=Deirdre |last2=Flanagan |first2=Laurence |date=1994 |title=Irish Place Names |publisher=Gill & Macmillan |location=Dublin |page=223 |isbn=0-7171-2066-X}}</ref> is a [[townland]] in the northwest of [[Ireland]] in coastal [[County Donegal]]. It is situated halfway between [[Narin, County Donegal|Narin]] and [[Ardara, County Donegal|Ardara]] at the [[R261 road (Ireland)|R261]] on the Loughrea Peninsula.
'''Kilclooney More''' ({{lang-ga|Cill Chluanadh Mhór}},<ref>{{cite web |url=https://www.logainm.ie/en/14599 |title=Cill Chluanadh Mhór |access-date=2 March 2017}}</ref> meaning church of the pasture)<ref>{{cite book |last1=Flanagan |first1=Deirdre |last2=Flanagan |first2=Laurence |date=1994 |title=Irish Place Names |publisher=Gill & Macmillan |location=Dublin |page=223 |isbn=0-7171-2066-X}}</ref> is a [[townland]] in the northwest of [[Ireland]] in coastal [[County Donegal]]. It is situated halfway between [[Narin, County Donegal|Narin]] and [[Ardara, County Donegal|Ardara]] at the [[R261 road (Ireland)|R261]] on the Loughrea Peninsula.


Line 12: Line 12:
=== Court tomb ''Dg. 69'' ===
=== Court tomb ''Dg. 69'' ===
[[File:Cromlech on the lands of Kilcluny, Co. Donegal by Rev. Joseph Turner 1799.png|thumb|18th-century drawing of the court tomb of Kilclooney More when the lintel was still in its original place ({{italics correction|''Dg. 69''}})]]
[[File:Cromlech on the lands of Kilcluny, Co. Donegal by Rev. Joseph Turner 1799.png|thumb|18th-century drawing of the court tomb of Kilclooney More when the lintel was still in its original place ({{italics correction|''Dg. 69''}})]]
The court tomb {{italics correction|''Dg. 69''}} is located north of the portal tomb {{italics correction|''Dg. 68''}} and likewise west of the R261 on flat moorland above the basin on a small hill that provides a commanding outlook in all directions. The gallery of the monument has a length of c. 6{{nbsp}}m and a width of 2.0 to 2.5{{nbsp}}m with three [[orthostat]]s on each side. There are no surviving traces of a segmentation into chambers but de Valera assumes that the tomb consisted of two chambers. A heavy [[lintel]] that still resides on the side stones appears to be displaced and reversed in consideration of an 18th-century drawing that shows the lintel above the front of the gallery. Another lintel appears to be fallen and rests in front.<ref>entry 15 on p. 107: {{cite journal |last=de Valera |first=R. |title=The Court Cairns of Ireland |journal=Proceedings of the Royal Irish Academy. Section C: Archaeology, Celtic Studies, History, Linguistics, Literature |volume=60 |date=1959 |pages=9–140 |jstor=25505085}}</ref><ref>{{cite book |editor-last=Lacy |editor-first=Brian |title=Archaeological Survey of County Donegal |page=22 |publisher=Donegal County Council |location=Lifford |date=1983 |isbn=0-9508407-0-X}}</ref><ref>{{cite book |last=Cody |first=Eamon |title=Survey of the Megalithic tombs of Ireland, Volume VI, County Donegal |publisher=Stationery Office |location=Dublin |date=2002 |isbn=0-7557-1248-X |pages=94–96}}</ref>
The court tomb {{italics correction|''Dg. 69''}} is located north of the portal tomb {{italics correction|''Dg. 68''}} and likewise west of the R261 on flat moorland above the basin on a small hill that provides a commanding outlook in all directions. The gallery of the monument has a length of c. 6{{nbsp}}m and a width of 2.0 to 2.5{{nbsp}}m with three [[orthostat]]s on each side. There are no surviving traces of a segmentation into chambers but de Valera assumes that the tomb consisted of two chambers. A heavy [[lintel]] that still resides on the side stones appears to be displaced and reversed in consideration of an 18th-century drawing that shows the lintel above the front of the gallery. Another lintel appears to be fallen and rests in front.<ref>entry 15 on p. 107: {{cite journal |last=de Valera |first=R. |title=The Court Cairns of Ireland |journal=Proceedings of the Royal Irish Academy, Section C |volume=60 |date=1959 |pages=9–140 |jstor=25505085}}</ref><ref>{{cite book |editor-last=Lacy |editor-first=Brian |title=Archaeological Survey of County Donegal |page=22 |publisher=Donegal County Council |location=Lifford |date=1983 |isbn=0-9508407-0-X}}</ref><ref>{{cite book |last=Cody |first=Eamon |title=Survey of the Megalithic tombs of Ireland, Volume VI, County Donegal |publisher=Stationery Office |location=Dublin |date=2002 |isbn=0-7557-1248-X |pages=94–96}}</ref>


=== Portal tomb ''Dg. 70'' ===
=== Portal tomb ''Dg. 70'' ===
Line 20: Line 20:
The poorly-preserved [[cairn]] has a long shape with an NNE alignment that extends over 25{{nbsp}}m. The chambers are in the middle of the cairn with the north-eastern chamber 5{{nbsp}}m inside its northern end. The smaller chamber faces NNE, the larger chamber NE.<ref name="Cody" /><ref>{{cite journal |last=Ó Nualláin |first=Seán |title=Irish Portal Tombs: Topography, Siting and Distribution |journal=The Journal of the Royal Society of Antiquaries of Ireland |volume=113 |date=1983 |pages=75–105 |jstor=25508838}} The two portal tombs are listed as numbers 15 and 16 on p. 94. Ó Nualláin describes the smaller chamber to be aligned in NNW direction which appears to be wrong. Cody's survey gives an NNE alignment and provides a comparative chart with the alignments of all portal tombs in County Donegal in Fig. 94.</ref> Like almost all coastal portal tombs in Ireland it is oriented away from the sea with the backstone facing the coast.<ref>{{cite thesis |type=Ph.D. |last=Mercer |first=Phyllis |title=Ritual aspects of Irish portal tombs |date=2014 |publisher=[[NUI Galway]] |pages=128,130 |url=http://hdl.handle.net/10379/4809}}</ref> The combination of a long cairn with a minor chamber as in Kilclooney More and Ballyrennan in [[County Tyrone]] is seen by Ó Nualláin as an indication that portal tombs evolved from court tombs.<ref>{{cite journal |last=Ó Nualláin |first=Seán |title=The Megalithic Tombs of Ireland: Neolithic Tombs and their Art |journal=Expedition |volume=21 |number=3 |date=1979 |pages=6–15 |url=https://www.penn.museum/documents/publications/expedition/PDFs/21-3/Nuallain.pdf}}</ref>
The poorly-preserved [[cairn]] has a long shape with an NNE alignment that extends over 25{{nbsp}}m. The chambers are in the middle of the cairn with the north-eastern chamber 5{{nbsp}}m inside its northern end. The smaller chamber faces NNE, the larger chamber NE.<ref name="Cody" /><ref>{{cite journal |last=Ó Nualláin |first=Seán |title=Irish Portal Tombs: Topography, Siting and Distribution |journal=The Journal of the Royal Society of Antiquaries of Ireland |volume=113 |date=1983 |pages=75–105 |jstor=25508838}} The two portal tombs are listed as numbers 15 and 16 on p. 94. Ó Nualláin describes the smaller chamber to be aligned in NNW direction which appears to be wrong. Cody's survey gives an NNE alignment and provides a comparative chart with the alignments of all portal tombs in County Donegal in Fig. 94.</ref> Like almost all coastal portal tombs in Ireland it is oriented away from the sea with the backstone facing the coast.<ref>{{cite thesis |type=Ph.D. |last=Mercer |first=Phyllis |title=Ritual aspects of Irish portal tombs |date=2014 |publisher=[[NUI Galway]] |pages=128,130 |url=http://hdl.handle.net/10379/4809}}</ref> The combination of a long cairn with a minor chamber as in Kilclooney More and Ballyrennan in [[County Tyrone]] is seen by Ó Nualláin as an indication that portal tombs evolved from court tombs.<ref>{{cite journal |last=Ó Nualláin |first=Seán |title=The Megalithic Tombs of Ireland: Neolithic Tombs and their Art |journal=Expedition |volume=21 |number=3 |date=1979 |pages=6–15 |url=https://www.penn.museum/documents/publications/expedition/PDFs/21-3/Nuallain.pdf}}</ref>


Multiple sherds of Neolithic pottery, all belonging to one quartz-tempered vessel with fine textures, were found in the larger chamber and are now in the possession of the [[National Museum of Ireland]].<ref>Items 64–66 at p. 18 in: {{cite journal |last1=Lucas |first1=A. T. |last2=Raftery |first2=Joseph |last3=Prendergast |first3=Ellen |last4=Ó Ríordáin |first4=Breandán |last5=Rynne |first5=Etienne |title=National Museum of Ireland Archaeological Acquisitions in the Year 1958 |journal=The Journal of the Royal Society of Antiquaries of Ireland |volume=90 |number=1 |date=1960 |pages=1–40 |jstor=25509378}}</ref><ref>Item 9 at p. 138 in: {{cite journal |last=Herity |first=Michael |title=The Finds from the Irish Portal Dolmens |journal=The Journal of the Royal Society of Antiquaries of Ireland |volume=94 |number=2 |date=1964 |pages=123–144 |jstor=25509566}}</ref><ref>p. 319 in: {{cite journal |last=Herity |first=Michael |title=Irish Decorated Neolithic Pottery |journal=Proceedings of the Royal Irish Academy. Section C: Archaeology, Celtic Studies, History, Linguistics, Literature |volume=82C |date=1982 |pages=247–404 |jstor=25506090}}</ref> Dating of Irish portal tombs is difficult as no radiocarbon dates are available. However, the sherds are assumed to belong to the [[Grimston-Lyles Hill ware|''Lyles Hill'']] series of pottery which can be approximately dated as this kind of pottery has been found close to fireplaces at other sites. In consideration of this context, Arthur ApSimon estimates that portal tombs like those of Kilclooney More belong to a period from 5000 to 4800 [[Before Present|BP]], i.e. from ca. 3780 to ca. 3550 [[Anno Domini|BC]], which falls into the early Neolithic period.<ref>{{cite journal |last=ApSimon |first=Arthur |title=Chronological Contexts for Irish Megalithic Tombs |journal=The Journal of Irish Archaeology |volume=3 |date=1985 |pages=5–15 |jstor=30001633}}</ref>
Multiple sherds of Neolithic pottery, all belonging to one quartz-tempered vessel with fine textures, were found in the larger chamber and are now in the possession of the [[National Museum of Ireland]].<ref>Items 64–66 at p. 18 in: {{cite journal |last1=Lucas |first1=A. T. |last2=Raftery |first2=Joseph |last3=Prendergast |first3=Ellen |last4=Ó Ríordáin |first4=Breandán |last5=Rynne |first5=Etienne |title=National Museum of Ireland Archaeological Acquisitions in the Year 1958 |journal=The Journal of the Royal Society of Antiquaries of Ireland |volume=90 |number=1 |date=1960 |pages=1–40 |jstor=25509378}}</ref><ref>Item 9 at p. 138 in: {{cite journal |last=Herity |first=Michael |title=The Finds from the Irish Portal Dolmens |journal=The Journal of the Royal Society of Antiquaries of Ireland |volume=94 |number=2 |date=1964 |pages=123–144 |jstor=25509566}}</ref><ref>p. 319 in: {{cite journal |last=Herity |first=Michael |title=Irish Decorated Neolithic Pottery |journal=Proceedings of the Royal Irish Academy, Section C |volume=82C |date=1982 |pages=247–404 |jstor=25506090}}</ref> Dating of Irish portal tombs is difficult as no radiocarbon dates are available. However, the sherds are assumed to belong to the [[Grimston-Lyles Hill ware|''Lyles Hill'']] series of pottery which can be approximately dated as this kind of pottery has been found close to fireplaces at other sites. In consideration of this context, Arthur ApSimon estimates that portal tombs like those of Kilclooney More belong to a period from 5000 to 4800 [[Before Present|BP]], i.e. from ca. 3780 to ca. 3550 [[Anno Domini|BC]], which falls into the early Neolithic period.<ref>{{cite journal |last=ApSimon |first=Arthur |title=Chronological Contexts for Irish Megalithic Tombs |journal=The Journal of Irish Archaeology |volume=3 |date=1985 |pages=5–15 |jstor=30001633}}</ref>


== References ==
== References ==
Line 29: Line 29:


{{Coord|54.817718|-8.4331537|display=title}}<!-- coordinates of the portal tomb Dg. 70 which is the most prominent feature of this townland -->
{{Coord|54.817718|-8.4331537|display=title}}<!-- coordinates of the portal tomb Dg. 70 which is the most prominent feature of this townland -->

{{County Donegal}}


[[Category:Townlands of County Donegal]]
[[Category:Townlands of County Donegal]]
[[Category:Archaeological sites in County Donegal]]
[[Category:Archaeological sites in County Donegal]]

{{County Donegal}}

Revision as of 23:42, 27 February 2018

Larger chamber of the eastern portal tomb in Kilclooney More with a capstone that has been described as ‘birdlike’ or ‘Concorde-like’ (Dg. 70)[1][2]

Kilclooney More (Irish: Cill Chluanadh Mhór,[3] meaning church of the pasture)[4] is a townland in the northwest of Ireland in coastal County Donegal. It is situated halfway between Narin and Ardara at the R261 on the Loughrea Peninsula.

Megalithic tombs

Kilclooney More belongs to the low-lying land in the west of County Donegal that is prominent for its concentration of court and portal tombs. In the Neolithic period this land was fertile due to a warmer and drier climate, supporting farming communities who crafted ceramics and built tombs which are still described as ‘magnificent’.[1]

Portal tomb Dg. 68

Western portal tomb of Kilclooney More (Dg. 68)

The smaller portal tomb of Kilclooney More is located west of the R261, in a shallow basin north of the Abberachrin River. The eastern portal stone is missing but otherwise the tomb is well preserved. The chamber is comparatively small, measuring 1.45 m × 1.2 m, pointed in SSE direction. It is referred to as Dg. 68 by Eamon Cody.[5][6]

Court tomb Dg. 69

18th-century drawing of the court tomb of Kilclooney More when the lintel was still in its original place (Dg. 69)

The court tomb Dg. 69 is located north of the portal tomb Dg. 68 and likewise west of the R261 on flat moorland above the basin on a small hill that provides a commanding outlook in all directions. The gallery of the monument has a length of c. 6 m and a width of 2.0 to 2.5 m with three orthostats on each side. There are no surviving traces of a segmentation into chambers but de Valera assumes that the tomb consisted of two chambers. A heavy lintel that still resides on the side stones appears to be displaced and reversed in consideration of an 18th-century drawing that shows the lintel above the front of the gallery. Another lintel appears to be fallen and rests in front.[7][8][9]

Portal tomb Dg. 70

East of the R261 on rough moorland is the larger portal tomb Dg. 70 with two chambers, 9 m apart, and a modern field wall in-between. The north-eastern chamber has a roof stone with a length of 4.2 m which rests on two portal stones, both of 1.8 m height, and a very small pad-stone which in turn rests on the backstone of 1.3 m height. The smaller, south-western chamber has portal stones of 1 m height. The roof stone with a length of 1.9 m is partly dislodged.[5][10] The sill stone between the portal stones has a rectangular piece missing, a feature that is shared with the portal tombs of Poulnabrone, Ballybrittas, and Tawnatruffaun. Most of the stones are from grey granite outcrops in close vicinity to the tomb. The backstone in red Ardara granite stands in a stark contrast to the overall grey, it originates possibly from a cliffy extrusion 200 m south of the tomb.[11]

Dg. 70 with its NE-aligned larger chamber in front and its NNE-aligned smaller chamber in the background

The poorly-preserved cairn has a long shape with an NNE alignment that extends over 25 m. The chambers are in the middle of the cairn with the north-eastern chamber 5 m inside its northern end. The smaller chamber faces NNE, the larger chamber NE.[10][12] Like almost all coastal portal tombs in Ireland it is oriented away from the sea with the backstone facing the coast.[13] The combination of a long cairn with a minor chamber as in Kilclooney More and Ballyrennan in County Tyrone is seen by Ó Nualláin as an indication that portal tombs evolved from court tombs.[14]

Multiple sherds of Neolithic pottery, all belonging to one quartz-tempered vessel with fine textures, were found in the larger chamber and are now in the possession of the National Museum of Ireland.[15][16][17] Dating of Irish portal tombs is difficult as no radiocarbon dates are available. However, the sherds are assumed to belong to the Lyles Hill series of pottery which can be approximately dated as this kind of pottery has been found close to fireplaces at other sites. In consideration of this context, Arthur ApSimon estimates that portal tombs like those of Kilclooney More belong to a period from 5000 to 4800 BP, i.e. from ca. 3780 to ca. 3550 BC, which falls into the early Neolithic period.[18]

References

  1. ^ a b Lacey, Brian (2013). "Prehistoric Archaeology of Donegal: c. 7000 BC to c. AD 500". In Mac Laughlin, Jim; Beattie, Seán (eds.). An Historical, Environmental and Cultural Atlas of County Donegal. Cork: Cork University Press. pp. 101–106. ISBN 978-1-85918-494-3. One of the most striking Neolithic monuments in Donegal is the portal tomb at Kilclooney More, near Ardara. Its 4.2- metre long 'birdlike' capstone is only one of the unusual features of this magnificent structure.
  2. ^ Lacy, Brian (1988). "Donegal". Archaeology Ireland. 2 (2): 48–52. Among the most impressive is the well-known Kilclooney More tomb with its famous 'Concorde-like' capstone.
  3. ^ "Cill Chluanadh Mhór". Retrieved 2 March 2017.
  4. ^ Flanagan, Deirdre; Flanagan, Laurence (1994). Irish Place Names. Dublin: Gill & Macmillan. p. 223. ISBN 0-7171-2066-X.
  5. ^ a b Lacy, Brian, ed. (1983). Archaeological Survey of County Donegal. Lifford: Donegal County Council. p. 32. ISBN 0-9508407-0-X.
  6. ^ Cody, Eamon (2002). Survey of the Megalithic tombs of Ireland, Volume VI, County Donegal. Dublin: Stationery Office. pp. 93–94. ISBN 0-7557-1248-X.
  7. ^ entry 15 on p. 107: de Valera, R. (1959). "The Court Cairns of Ireland". Proceedings of the Royal Irish Academy, Section C. 60: 9–140. JSTOR 25505085.
  8. ^ Lacy, Brian, ed. (1983). Archaeological Survey of County Donegal. Lifford: Donegal County Council. p. 22. ISBN 0-9508407-0-X.
  9. ^ Cody, Eamon (2002). Survey of the Megalithic tombs of Ireland, Volume VI, County Donegal. Dublin: Stationery Office. pp. 94–96. ISBN 0-7557-1248-X.
  10. ^ a b Cody, Eamon (2002). Survey of the Megalithic tombs of Ireland, Volume VI, County Donegal. Dublin: Stationery Office. pp. 96–99. ISBN 0-7557-1248-X.
  11. ^ Mercer, Phyllis (2014). Ritual aspects of Irish portal tombs (Ph.D.). NUI Galway. pp. 110–111.
  12. ^ Ó Nualláin, Seán (1983). "Irish Portal Tombs: Topography, Siting and Distribution". The Journal of the Royal Society of Antiquaries of Ireland. 113: 75–105. JSTOR 25508838. The two portal tombs are listed as numbers 15 and 16 on p. 94. Ó Nualláin describes the smaller chamber to be aligned in NNW direction which appears to be wrong. Cody's survey gives an NNE alignment and provides a comparative chart with the alignments of all portal tombs in County Donegal in Fig. 94.
  13. ^ Mercer, Phyllis (2014). Ritual aspects of Irish portal tombs (Ph.D.). NUI Galway. pp. 128, 130.
  14. ^ Ó Nualláin, Seán (1979). "The Megalithic Tombs of Ireland: Neolithic Tombs and their Art" (PDF). Expedition. 21 (3): 6–15.
  15. ^ Items 64–66 at p. 18 in: Lucas, A. T.; Raftery, Joseph; Prendergast, Ellen; Ó Ríordáin, Breandán; Rynne, Etienne (1960). "National Museum of Ireland Archaeological Acquisitions in the Year 1958". The Journal of the Royal Society of Antiquaries of Ireland. 90 (1): 1–40. JSTOR 25509378.
  16. ^ Item 9 at p. 138 in: Herity, Michael (1964). "The Finds from the Irish Portal Dolmens". The Journal of the Royal Society of Antiquaries of Ireland. 94 (2): 123–144. JSTOR 25509566.
  17. ^ p. 319 in: Herity, Michael (1982). "Irish Decorated Neolithic Pottery". Proceedings of the Royal Irish Academy, Section C. 82C: 247–404. JSTOR 25506090.
  18. ^ ApSimon, Arthur (1985). "Chronological Contexts for Irish Megalithic Tombs". The Journal of Irish Archaeology. 3: 5–15. JSTOR 30001633.

54°49′04″N 8°25′59″W / 54.817718°N 8.4331537°W / 54.817718; -8.4331537