Jump to content

Dendera zodiac: Difference between revisions

Coordinates: 26°8′30″N 32°40′13″E / 26.14167°N 32.67028°E / 26.14167; 32.67028
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Browse history interactively
← Previous editNext edit →
Content deleted Content added
VisualWikitext
→Further reading: description
m Some additional information so as not to give the impression that Wikipedia grants exclusivity to Eric Aubourg, who has not practiced astronomy for more than 20 years and has never published anything officially elsewhere than in within the IFAO.
Tag: Reverted
Line 29: Line 29:
The solar eclipse indicates the date of March 7, 51 BC: it is represented by a circle containing the goddess Isis holding a baboon (the god Thoth) by the tail.
The solar eclipse indicates the date of March 7, 51 BC: it is represented by a circle containing the goddess Isis holding a baboon (the god Thoth) by the tail.
The lunar eclipse indicates the date of September 25, 52 BC: it is represented by an [[Eye of Horus]] locked into a circle.
The lunar eclipse indicates the date of September 25, 52 BC: it is represented by an [[Eye of Horus]] locked into a circle.

But since the creation of astronomical software created by astronomer Xavier Jubier<ref>https://www.iau.org/administration/membership/individual/15159/</ref>, member of the IAU and partner of NASA<ref>https://eclipse.gsfc.nasa.gov/SEsearch/SEsearchmap.php?Ecl=19470520</ref>, it has been shown that the solar eclipse indicated by Eric Aubourg could never be observed in Egypt.<ref>http://xjubier.free.fr/site_pages/solar_eclipses/xSE_GoogleMap3.php?Ecl=-00500307&Acc=2&Umb=1&Lmt=1&Mag=0</ref> Moreover, it was not a total solar eclipse, but an annular one.

Regarding the lunar eclipse, it did not take place on September 25, but on September 26<ref>https://eclipse.gsfc.nasa.gov/5MCLEmap/-0099-0000/LE-0051-09-26T.gif</ref> as indicated by NASA. Depending on the position of this eye, since there isn't a circular shape exactly opposite this eye, so there can be a schematic representation of a lunar eclipse, and there can't be two suns on this sandstone. It is not one representation of an eclipse, it is rather the oldest representation of the Andromeda Galaxy, also named M31.

The right ascension of this galaxy corresponds to the position of this eye if we present the Zodiac of Dendera in the right direction<ref>https://gallica.bnf.fr/ark:/12148/bpt6k9621728m/f370.texteImage</ref> determined by the French astronomer [[Jean-Baptiste Biot]] (1774-1862), author of the book titled "Research on several points of Egyptian astronomy applied to astronomical monuments found in Egypt"<ref>https://books.google.be/books?id=MfleAAAAcAAJ&printsec=frontcover&hl=fr&source=gbs_ge_summary_r&cad=0#v=onepage&q&f=false</ref> published in 1823,, by Firmin Didot editions. Based on astronomical calculations, he determined that this Egyptian artifact displays the sky of the year 716 BCE<ref>https://gallica.bnf.fr/ark:/12148/bpt6k9621728m/f100.item.r=716.zoom</ref> according to the position of the star Sirius.

Eric Aubourg was published exclusively internally within the IFAO (French Institute of Oriental Archaeology). His theory was never submitted to a committee of readers, nor published in an astronomy magazine.
It is therefore recommended to rely on the career of a true astronomer such as Jean-Baptiste Biot, also renowned for his mastery of physics and mathematics.


==Notes==
==Notes==

Revision as of 04:38, 22 May 2023

26°8′30″N 32°40′13″E / 26.14167°N 32.67028°E / 26.14167; 32.67028

The Dendera zodiac as displayed at the Louvre
Denderah zodiac with original colors (reconstructed)

The sculptured Dendera zodiac (or Denderah zodiac) is a widely known Egyptian bas-relief from the ceiling of the pronaos (or portico) of a chapel dedicated to Osiris in the Hathor temple at Dendera, containing images of Taurus (the bull) and Libra (the scales). This chapel was begun in the late Ptolemaic period; its pronaos was added by the emperor Tiberius. This led Jean-François Champollion to date the relief to the Greco-Roman period, but most of his contemporaries believed it to be of the New Kingdom.

The relief, which John H. Rogers characterised as "the only complete map that we have of an ancient sky",[1] has been conjectured to represent the basis on which later astronomy systems were based.[2] It is now on display at the Musée du Louvre, Paris.

Description

The sky disc is centered on the north pole star, with Ursa Minor depicted as a jackal.[3] An inner disc is composed of constellations showing the signs of the zodiac.[a] Some of these are represented in the same Greco-Roman iconographic forms as their familiar counterparts (e.g. the Ram, Taurus, Scorpio, and Capricorn),[b] whilst others are shown in a more Egyptian form: Aquarius is represented as the flood god Hapy, holding two vases which gush water.[citation needed] Rogers noted the similarities of unfamiliar iconology with the three surviving tablets of a Seleucid zodiac and both relating to kudurru ('boundary stone') representations: in short, Rogers sees the Dendera zodiac as "a complete copy of the Mesopotamian zodiac".[4]

Four women and four pairs of falcon-headed figures, arranged 45° from one another, hold up the sky disc, the outermost ring of which features 36 figures representing the 36 asterisms used to track both the 36 forty-minute "hours" that divided the Egyptian night, as well as the 36 ten-day "weeks" (decans) of the Egyptian year (with 5 days excluded). The square of the overall sculpture is oriented to the walls of the temple.[3]

This sculptural representation of the zodiac in circular form is unique in ancient Egyptian art.[citation needed] More typical are the rectangular zodiacs which decorate the same temple's pronaos.

Zodiaque de Denderah with the 48 constellations of Claudius Ptolemaus clearly identified among the present 72 constellations on this Zodiac.

History

During the Napoleonic campaign in Egypt, Vivant Denon drew the circular zodiac, the more widely known one, and the rectangular zodiacs.[clarification needed] In 1802, after the Napoleonic expedition, Denon published engravings of the temple ceiling in his Voyage dans la Basse et la Haute Egypte.[5] These elicited a controversy as to the age of the zodiac representation, ranging from tens of thousands to a thousand years to a few hundred, and whether the zodiac was a planisphere or an astrological chart.[6] Sébastien Louis Saulnier, an antique dealer, commissioned Claude Lelorrain to remove the circular zodiac with saws, jacks, scissors and gunpowder.[7] The zodiac ceiling was moved in 1821 to Restoration Paris and, by 1822, was installed by Louis XVIII in the Royal Library (later called the National Library of France). In 1922, the zodiac moved from there to the Louvre. In 2022, egyptologist Zahi Hawass started a petition to bring the ancient work back to Egypt, along with the Rosetta Stone and other artifacts.[8]

Dating

The controversy around the zodiac's dating, known as the "Dendera Affair", involved people of the likes of Joseph Fourier (who estimated that the age was 2500 BC).[9] Champollion, among others, believed that it was a religious zodiac. Champollion placed the zodiac in fourth century AD.[10] Georges Cuvier placed the date 123 AD to 147 AD.[11] His discussion of the dating summarizes the reasoning as he understood it in the 1820s.

Solar eclipse on 7 March 51 BC
Lunar eclipse on 25 September 52 BC

Sylvie Cauville of the Centre for Computer-aided Egyptological Research at Utrecht University and Éric Aubourg dated it to 50 BC through an examination of the configuration it shows of the five planets known to the Egyptians, a configuration that occurs once every thousand years, and the identification of two eclipses.[12] The solar eclipse indicates the date of March 7, 51 BC: it is represented by a circle containing the goddess Isis holding a baboon (the god Thoth) by the tail. The lunar eclipse indicates the date of September 25, 52 BC: it is represented by an Eye of Horus locked into a circle.

But since the creation of astronomical software created by astronomer Xavier Jubier[13], member of the IAU and partner of NASA[14], it has been shown that the solar eclipse indicated by Eric Aubourg could never be observed in Egypt.[15] Moreover, it was not a total solar eclipse, but an annular one.

Regarding the lunar eclipse, it did not take place on September 25, but on September 26[16] as indicated by NASA. Depending on the position of this eye, since there isn't a circular shape exactly opposite this eye, so there can be a schematic representation of a lunar eclipse, and there can't be two suns on this sandstone. It is not one representation of an eclipse, it is rather the oldest representation of the Andromeda Galaxy, also named M31.

The right ascension of this galaxy corresponds to the position of this eye if we present the Zodiac of Dendera in the right direction[17] determined by the French astronomer Jean-Baptiste Biot (1774-1862), author of the book titled "Research on several points of Egyptian astronomy applied to astronomical monuments found in Egypt"[18] published in 1823,, by Firmin Didot editions. Based on astronomical calculations, he determined that this Egyptian artifact displays the sky of the year 716 BCE[19] according to the position of the star Sirius.

Eric Aubourg was published exclusively internally within the IFAO (French Institute of Oriental Archaeology). His theory was never submitted to a committee of readers, nor published in an astronomy magazine. It is therefore recommended to rely on the career of a true astronomer such as Jean-Baptiste Biot, also renowned for his mastery of physics and mathematics.

Notes

  1. ^ The zodiac is a planisphere or map of the stars on a plane projection, showing the 12 constellations of the zodiacal band forming 36 decans of ten days each, and the planets. These decans are groups of first-magnitude stars. These were used in the ancient Egyptian calendar, which was based on lunar cycles of around 30 days and on the heliacal rising of the star Sothis (Sirius).
  2. ^ Albeit most in odd orientations in comparison to the conventions of ancient Greece, as shown for instance in the Almagest and later Arabic-Western developments

References

  1. ^ John H. Rogers, "Origins of the ancient constellations: I. The Mesopotamian traditions", Journal of the British Astronomical Association 108 (1998) 9–28
  2. ^ Zodiac of Dendera, epitome. (Exhibition, Leic. square). J. Haddon, 1825.
  3. ^ a b Tompkins, Peter (1978). Secrets of the Great Pyramid. Harper & Row. pp. 172–73. ISBN 0-06-090631-6.
  4. ^ Rogers (1998) p. 10.
  5. ^ Abigail Harrison Moore, "Voyage: Dominique-Vivant Denon and the transference of images of Egypt", Art History 25.4 (2002:531–549).
  6. ^ Zodiac of Dendera, epitome. (Exhib., Leicester Square). J. Haddon, 1825.
  7. ^ Saulnier, Sébastien L. (1822). Notice sur le voyage de M. Lelorrain en Egypte: et observations sur le zodiaque circulaire de Denderah. Chez l'auteur – via Internet Archive.
  8. ^ Romo, Vanessa (October 12, 2022). "Egyptians call for the return of the Rosetta Stone and other ancient artifacts". NPR. Retrieved 2023-05-10.
  9. ^ Francis Lister Hawks, The monuments of Egypt: Or, Egypt a witness for the Bible. John Murray, 1850. 256 pages. Page 158
  10. ^ "YouTube". www.youtube.com.[dead YouTube link]
  11. ^ Georges Cuvier A Discourse on the Revolutions of the Surface of the Globe (1825) Archived 2016-03-03 at the Wayback Machine in the chapter entitled "The astronomical monuments of the Ancients.", pp. 170 Archived 2011-07-24 at the Wayback Machine and 172 Archived 2011-07-24 at the Wayback Machine.
  12. ^ Marchant, Jo (5 July 2010). "Decoding the ancient Egyptians' stone sky map". New Scientist.
  13. ^ https://www.iau.org/administration/membership/individual/15159/
  14. ^ https://eclipse.gsfc.nasa.gov/SEsearch/SEsearchmap.php?Ecl=19470520
  15. ^ http://xjubier.free.fr/site_pages/solar_eclipses/xSE_GoogleMap3.php?Ecl=-00500307&Acc=2&Umb=1&Lmt=1&Mag=0
  16. ^ https://eclipse.gsfc.nasa.gov/5MCLEmap/-0099-0000/LE-0051-09-26T.gif
  17. ^ https://gallica.bnf.fr/ark:/12148/bpt6k9621728m/f370.texteImage
  18. ^ https://books.google.be/books?id=MfleAAAAcAAJ&printsec=frontcover&hl=fr&source=gbs_ge_summary_r&cad=0#v=onepage&q&f=false
  19. ^ https://gallica.bnf.fr/ark:/12148/bpt6k9621728m/f100.item.r=716.zoom

Further reading

Wikimedia Commons has media related to Dendera zodiac.
  1. ^ The online book is an edition from 1839.
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Dendera_zodiac&oldid=1156289716"