Jump to content

Wiktionary: Difference between revisions

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Content deleted Content added
rvv
Adding criticism section
Line 174: Line 174:


See [[wiktionary: Help: Creating a Wikisaurus entry|"Creating a Wikisaurus entry"]] for the structure of Wikisaurus entries. An example of a well-formatted entry would be the "[[wiktionary:Wikisaurus:insane]]" page.
See [[wiktionary: Help: Creating a Wikisaurus entry|"Creating a Wikisaurus entry"]] for the structure of Wikisaurus entries. An example of a well-formatted entry would be the "[[wiktionary:Wikisaurus:insane]]" page.

==Criticism==
As of early November, 2006, Wiktionary had over 300,000 entries. However, 7 of the 18 bots registered on Wiktionary<sup>[http://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/Special:Listusers]</sup> created 163,000 of them.<sup>[http://tools.wikimedia.de/~interiot/cgi-bin/count_edits?user=TheDaveBot&dbname=enwiktionary_p], [http://tools.wikimedia.de/~interiot/cgi-bin/count_edits?user=TheCheatBot&dbname=enwiktionary_p], [http://tools.wikimedia.de/~interiot/cgi-bin/count_edits?user=Websterbot&dbname=enwiktionary_p], [http://tools.wikimedia.de/~interiot/cgi-bin/count_edits?user=PastBot&dbname=enwiktionary_p], [http://tools.wikimedia.de/~interiot/cgi-bin/count_edits?user=NanshuBot&dbname=enwiktionary_p]</sup> Most of the entries created are not found in other dictionaries. For example, the [http://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/User:ThirdPersBot ThirdPersBot] adds the third-person form for terms. For ''smoulder'' it created "smoulders," which reads, "Third-person singular simple present form of smoulder." If these 163,000 entries were excluded, Wiktionary would have 137,000 entries, making it smaller than most printed dictionaries. This number would be even smaller if terms unique to other languages were excluded. The ''Oxford English Dictionary'' has 615,000 headwords, while ''Merriam-Webster's Third New International Dictionary of the English Language, Unabridged'' has 475,000 entries (with many additional embedded headwords).

Unlike Wikipedia, Wiktionary has many competitors, who offer larger works online for free. Many users also prefer to post definitions on Wikipedia, instead of Wiktionary. On Wikipedia, they are called ''stubs''. Indeed, the difference between a dictionary and an encyclopedia is non-existant for many. Encyclopedia articles begin with a definition. Many large works with mostly in-depth prose treatises are called "dictionaries" (e.g., the 29-volume ''Grove'' Dictionary ''of Music''). On the other hand, many works called "encyclopedias" contain dictionary definitions. And even the larger articles within these works are organized as long dictionary entries (cf. ''Enciclopedia Unversal Larousse'').


== See also==
== See also==

Revision as of 04:08, 12 November 2006

Wiktionary
Detail of the English Wiktionary main page. All major wiktionaries are listed by number of articles.
Type of site
Online dictionary
OwnerWikimedia Foundation
Created byJimmy Wales
URLhttp://www.wiktionary.org/
CommercialNo
RegistrationOptional

Wiktionary is a Wikimedia Foundation project intended to be a free wiki dictionary (hence: Wiktionary) (including thesaurus and lexicon) in every language. It is a sister project to Wikipedia. It is located at wiktionary.org.

Mission

Wiktionary serves to:

History

Growth of the largest eight Wiktionaries, as of May 2006.

Wiktionary was brought online on December 12, 2002 following a proposal by Daniel Alston. On March 29, 2004 the first non-English Wiktionaries were initiated in French and Polish. Wiktionaries in numerous other languages have since been started. Wiktionary was hosted on a temporary URL (wiktionary.wikipedia.org) until May 1, 2004 when it switched to the current full URL.[1] As of September 2006, the English Wiktionary has more than 200,000 entries, although in early 2006 it was surpassed by the French Wiktionary, only to regain the top position in September 2006. Seven languages now have Wiktionaries containing at least 50,000 entries.

Top ten Wiktionaries

No. Language Language (local) Wiki Entries Total Edits Admins Users Images Updated
1 English English en 298425 410294 1610838 45 23312 137 2006-10-31 00:10:35
2 Vietnamese Tiếng Việt vi 208527 212538 386716 3 433 7 2006-10-31 00:11:08
3 French Français fr 208214 237747 1453533 11 2471 16 2006-10-31 00:10:35
4 Chinese 中文 zh 91327 106390 366163 6 1591 108 2006-10-31 00:10:37
5 Ido Ido io 86826 124025 309174 1 86 3 2006-10-31 00:10:37
6 Greek Ελληνικά el 72228 82359 128125 3 189 16 2006-10-31 00:10:59
7 Russian Русский ru 63961 75207 151272 1 444 69 2006-10-31 00:11:01
8 Polish Polski pl 48428 89348 288867 12 1027 102 2006-10-31 00:10:36
9 Italian Italiano it 45031 51987 177835 6 997 95 2006-10-31 00:10:36
10 German Deutsch de 38563 53618 434911 14 5395 40 2006-10-31 00:10:39

Comparison to other sister projects

The current Wiktionary logo

One difference between Wiktionary and Wikipedia is that pages beginning with upper- and lowercase letters can refer to different things. For example, the entries on lowercase "i" and uppercase "I" are distinct. All of the existing entries in the English Wiktionary were converted to lowercase automatically in mid-2005; manual intervention was used to move pages to uppercase (or split entries) as necessary. Links from Wikipedia to Wiktionary must be made with care, as it may be relevant to link to a lowercase entry, link to an uppercase entry, link to an entry with diacritics or link to multiple entries.

Wikisaurus

Wikisaurus is a category in the English Wiktionary whose purpose is to serve as a thesaurus, including a thesaurus of slang words.

See "Creating a Wikisaurus entry" for the structure of Wikisaurus entries. An example of a well-formatted entry would be the "wiktionary:Wikisaurus:insane" page.

Criticism

As of early November, 2006, Wiktionary had over 300,000 entries. However, 7 of the 18 bots registered on Wiktionary[1] created 163,000 of them.[2], [3], [4], [5], [6] Most of the entries created are not found in other dictionaries. For example, the ThirdPersBot adds the third-person form for terms. For smoulder it created "smoulders," which reads, "Third-person singular simple present form of smoulder." If these 163,000 entries were excluded, Wiktionary would have 137,000 entries, making it smaller than most printed dictionaries. This number would be even smaller if terms unique to other languages were excluded. The Oxford English Dictionary has 615,000 headwords, while Merriam-Webster's Third New International Dictionary of the English Language, Unabridged has 475,000 entries (with many additional embedded headwords).

Unlike Wikipedia, Wiktionary has many competitors, who offer larger works online for free. Many users also prefer to post definitions on Wikipedia, instead of Wiktionary. On Wikipedia, they are called stubs. Indeed, the difference between a dictionary and an encyclopedia is non-existant for many. Encyclopedia articles begin with a definition. Many large works with mostly in-depth prose treatises are called "dictionaries" (e.g., the 29-volume Grove Dictionary of Music). On the other hand, many works called "encyclopedias" contain dictionary definitions. And even the larger articles within these works are organized as long dictionary entries (cf. Enciclopedia Unversal Larousse).

See also

References

  1. ^ Wiktionary's current URL is www.wiktionary.org.
  • "Wiktionary article". Top 101 Web Sites. PC Magazine. Retrieved 2005-12-16.