LNER Peppercorn Class A1 60163 Tornado
LNER Class A1 Peppercorn 60163 Tornado | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
![]() Tornado, 14 December 2008 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
60163 Tornado is a main-line steam locomotive built in Darlington, England. Completed in 2008, Tornado was the first such locomotive built in the United Kingdom since Evening Star, the last steam locomotive built by British Railways, in 1960. Designed to meet modern safety and certification standards, Tornado runs on the UK rail network and on mainline-connected heritage railways. The locomotive is named after the Panavia Tornado military jet.
Overview
The locomotive was built by the A1 Steam Locomotive Trust, a charitable trust founded in 1990 to build Tornado and possibly further locomotives. Tornado was conceived as an evolution of the LNER Peppercorn Class A1 class, incorporating improvements likely had steam continued, and changes for cost, safety, manufacturing and operational benefits, while replicating the original design's sound and appearance. Tornado, completely new-built, is considered the 50th Peppercorn A1, numbered next in the class after 60162, Saint Johnstoun, built in 1949.
The 49 original Peppercorn A1s were built in Doncaster and Darlington for the London and North Eastern Railway (LNER). Tornado was built in the trust's Darlington works. The original 49 locomotives were scrapped by 1966 after an average service of 15 years. None survived into preservation, and Tornado fills a gap in the classes of restored steam locomotives that used to operate on the East Coast Main Line.
Tornado moved under her own power for the first time on 29 July 2008 at Darlington, and then spent two months at the preserved Great Central Railway double-track tourist railway in Loughborough, where she was tested up to 60 mph (97 km/h) and operated her first passenger train. Tornado then moved to the National Railway Museum (NRM) in York for three test runs on the main line up to 75 mph (121 km/h). After repainting into LNER Apple Green, Tornado was approved for main-line passenger operation. On 31 January 2009 she hauled her first passenger trip on the main line, The Peppercorn Pioneer, from York to Newcastle and back. By hauling various A1 Trust railtours, charters and other activities, Tornado will begin to recoup the estimated £800,000 debt from the project, which cost around £3 million.
With a shorter rake of eleven coaches compared with the original Peppercorn A1's usage, Tornado is expected to achieve contemporary mainline speeds. Theoretically capable of 100 miles per hour (160 km/h), Tornado may in the future gain permission to run at 90 miles per hour (140 km/h),[3] making her the fastest steam locomotive on the British main line. Once on the main line, Tornado is not expected to leave it again until its ten-year fire-tube boiler re-certification in late 2018.
On 21 June 2009, Tornado featured in the Top Gear Race to the North, coming second to a car in a three-way race from London to Edinburgh, against a 1949 Jaguar XK120 sports car and a 1949 Vincent Black Shadow motorbike.
Background
![](http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/0/00/Gateshead_locomotive_sheds.jpg/220px-Gateshead_locomotive_sheds.jpg)
The original Peppercorn A1 series was ordered by the LNER, but the 49 locomotives were built at Doncaster and Darlington for British Railways (BR) in 1948–49, after the nationalisation of the railways in the United Kingdom. Following the modernisation and dieselisation plans of the 1950s, the A1 Peppercorn class was eventually scrapped at a comparatively early age of just 14 years.
Other famous East Coast Mainline steam locomotives have been preserved, for example several Gresley LNER Class A4 and one LNER Class A3, 4472 Flying Scotsman, but all 49 LNER Peppercorn Class A1 locomotives were scrapped. The last was 60145 St Mungo, which survived until September 1966. An effort was made to preserve 60145, but it failed due to a lack of funds.
The Peppercorn A1s were designed to cope with the heaviest regular post-war East Coast trains. These were frequently 15 coaches or 550 tons. The locomotives were capable of 60-70 mph (95-110 km/h) on level track. Tornado will be able to haul 10-11 coach trains at higher speeds, to fit modern faster main lines.
The A1 Trust intended Tornado to be built from scratch, designed and built as the next locomotive in the A1 Peppercorn class, not as a replica or restoration project,[4][5][6] but an evolution of the class incorporating design improvements that would have occurred had steam motive power continued on the mainline railway.[7]
Name, number and liveries
![](http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/4/43/60163_Tornado_Nameplate_York_16.05.09R.jpg/220px-60163_Tornado_Nameplate_York_16.05.09R.jpg)
![](http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/6/6f/Ruth_Tornado_Nameplate_09.11_edited-2.jpg/220px-Ruth_Tornado_Nameplate_09.11_edited-2.jpg)
![](http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/6/66/60163_Tornado_cab_number_and_plate.jpg/220px-60163_Tornado_cab_number_and_plate.jpg)
![](http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/0/08/Ruth_Tornado_naming_plate_09.11_edited-2.jpg/220px-Ruth_Tornado_naming_plate_09.11_edited-2.jpg)
The name Tornado was chosen in honour of the Royal Air Force Tornado air crews flying at the time in the Gulf War.[8] The honour of choosing the name was given to a £50,000 sponsor of the project.[8] In 1995, officers of the Royal Air Force presented the Tornado nameplates to the trust at Tyseley Locomotive Works[9] at the frame laying ceremony in January.[10]
Tornado is numbered 60163, as the 50th Peppercorn A1.[4][5][6] Tornado's smokebox door also carries the identification plate "51 A", the code for Darlington shed. The cab side carries the builder's plate "No. 2195 Darlington 2008". The front buffer beam carries the designation "A1", applied in the paint detailing phase for launch in Apple Green.[11]
On 7 August 2008, Tornado was entered onto the Total Operations Processing System (TOPS).[12] Although the painted number is 60163, on the British mainline Tornado is designated 98863 in TOPS,[13] where 98 describes a steam engine, the 8 stems from the power classification of 8P,[1] and 63 comes from her 60163 number.[13]
![](http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/f/fa/60163_Tornado_side_on.jpg/220px-60163_Tornado_side_on.jpg)
![](http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/e/ee/60163_Tornado_at_Newcastle_31_Jan_09_pic_6.jpg/220px-60163_Tornado_at_Newcastle_31_Jan_09_pic_6.jpg)
![](http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/3/32/60163_Tornado_Tender_at_the_NRM_24_Jan_09.jpg/220px-60163_Tornado_Tender_at_the_NRM_24_Jan_09.jpg)
Tornado was in grey undercoat[14] until final testing was completed, as a precaution against the need to remove the boiler cladding.[15] The livery was described as "works grey”[14][16] in a ”satin finish”.[17] While in this undercoat, Tornado wore the web address of the A1 Trust on the side of the tender, and the mark RA9 (denoting route availability[1]) on the locomotive cab. On her third main line test run to Newcastle, the web address was replaced with the National Express logo.[18]
The first full livery is LNER-style express passenger apple green, with 'British Railways' on the tender, as worn by the original locomotives in 1948.[14][16] The first 30 Peppercorn A1s delivered wore this colour[19] This was applied by the NRM paint shop after completion of mainline trials at the NRM in York.[20] Painting was behind closed doors, with the finished article unveiled (without nameplates) on 13 December 2008, in front of 500 supporters of the A1 Trust.[19] The green livery was applied in the traditional way, brush painted by hand.[11] Tornado was unveiled on the turntable with the NRM North Eastern Railway (NER) dynamometer car.[21] Due to time constraints, detailing had been completed only on one side of the locomotive at the launch, and Tornado re-entered the paintshop after the launch before going back on display.[21]
Prior to Tornado, LNER Thompson Class B1 1306 Mayflower and LNER Class D49 46 Morayshire were the only two operational steam locomotives in Britain wearing LNER green.[22] LNER Class V2 4771 Green Arrow was withdrawn from mainline operations on 26 April 2008.[22] LNER green was also the last livery worn by LNER Class A3 4472 Flying Scotsman prior to withdrawal in December 2005.
Over the life of her first ten-year boiler certificate, it is expected Tornado will also wear BR Blue, BR Brunswick Green (pre-1957) and Brunswick Green post-1957.[15][16]
Although the name Tornado was chosen and nameplates manufactured long before the locomotive was completed, during commissioning and test running the nameplates were not attached.[23] By railway convention, the locomotive is officially known by her number until the name plates are affixed.
Tornado was named by HRH The Prince of Wales, accompanied by the Duchess of Cornwall and Dorothy Mather (widow of designer Arthur Peppercorn), at York railway station on 19 February 2009. The ceremony is marked by a plaque located below the nameplate. Tornado then pulled the Royal Train to Leeds.[24]
Project milestones
This section needs additional citations for verification. (July 2010) |
![](http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/1/15/60163_Tornado_1.jpg/220px-60163_Tornado_1.jpg)
- 1990 – A1 Steam Locomotive Trust formally launched, 11 November[25]
- 1994 – First and last components ceremonially presented (a bogie swivel pin and a regulator nut)[9]
- 1994 – Construction starts (frame plates rolled at Scunthorpe), 22 April[10]
- 1995 – Nameplates presented[9] at the frame laying ceremony, January[10]
- 1995 – First wheel cast[10]
- 1996 – Three cylinder castings unveiled at Tyseley, 25 May[9][10]
- 1997 – Frame displayed at the Great Hall at the National Railway Museum, March[10]
- 1997 – Tornado unveiled at Darlington Locomotive Works
- 1999 – Smokebox door complete, Tornado's symbolic 'face'
- 2000 – Construction over 50% complete (Summer)[26]
- 2000 – Wheelset added[10] (Autumn)[26]
- 2004 – The book value of Tornado components reaches 1 million pounds[27]
- 2004 – First synchronous smooth wheel motion, 25 August[27]
- 2007 – Boiler/firebox assembly fitted to frame, June[28][29]
- 2008 – First static steaming, January[29][30]
- 2008 – Tender completed, February[15]
- 2008 – Tornado publicly launched, Darlington Locomotive Works, 1 August 2008
- 2008 – First passenger train hauled, preserved Great Central Railway. Loughborough, 21 September
- 2008 – Main line testing begins, National Railway Museum, York, 4 November[31]
- 2008 – Third and final main line test run completed, York, 19 November[32]
- 2008 – First full livery unveiled (minus nameplates), LNER Apple Green, York, 13 December[33]
- 2009 – The Peppercorn Pioneer, the first passenger journey on the UK Main Line, 31 January 2009[34]
- 2009 – Hauls her first Talisman from Darlington to Kings Cross, 7 February[35]
- 2009 - First London departures Waterloo and Victoria, 14 February
- 2009 - First A1 to run on the Southern Region, 14 February
- 2009 - Tornado was officially named by The Prince of Wales and The Duchess of Cornwall, 19 February
- 2009 - Becomes only the 3rd steam locomotive to haul the Royal Train behind 6233 Duchess of Sutherland and 6024 King Edward 1st, 19 February
- 2009 - Tornado made her first journey into Scotland with "The Auld Reekie Express" from York to Edinburgh, 28 February
- 2009 - Tornado becomes the first A1 out of Edinburgh for 40 years with the North Briton from Edinburgh to York, 7 March
- 2009 - First A1 out of Kings Cross for 40 years, 18 April
- 2009 - Hauls VSOE stock for the first time, 18 April
- 2009 - BBC Top Gear Race filmed, 25 April 2009
- 2009 - Suffers first mechanical failure at the North Yorkshire Moors Railway, 2 May 2009
- 2009 - Institution of Mechanical Engineers present Tornado with Engineering Heritage Award at York, 23 May 2009
- 2009 - First A1 on the Great Western, 30 May
- 2009 - Top Gear Race to the North broadcast on BBC 2, 21 June
- 2009 - First A1 and LNER/BR locomotive to run in Kent, 21 June
- 2009 - Returns to Tyseley Works for Tyseley 101 Gala, 27/28 June
- 2009 - Reaches 10,000 miles (16,000 km) on Torbay Express, 5 July
- 2009 - Tornado made her first journey to Plymouth on 8 August hauling The Tamar Tornado.
- 2009 - Hauls the British leg of the Winton Train from Harwich to London Liverpool Street, 4 September
- 2009 - Hauls first train along the LSWR main line, 13 September
- 2009 - Hauls first trains over the Settle and Carlisle line, 3/4 October
- 2009 - Hauls first train over Shap, 10 October
- 2009 - Rescues Stranded commuters after Kent's Railways Shut down after heavy snow fall
- 2010 - Hauls the Royal Train with TRH the Prince of Wales and the Duchess of Cornwall for the second time in a year to the Manchester Museum Of Science and Industry, 4 February
- 2010 - First time at Paddington Station Valentine Special, 14 February
- 2010 - First visit to the Mid-Hants Railway (Watercress Line) for their Spring Steam Gala
- 2010 - First mainline failure on "The Canterbury Tornado" railtour, 31 May
- 2010 - Hauls Mallard in tow to Shildon Locomotion Museum from the National Railway Museum, with a support coach and 44798 also in tow
- 2010 - Beats previous record for fastest steam hauled railtour over Shap summit by 19 seconds, 24 June
- 2010 - Failed at Rugby on "The Christmas Coronation" (Day 3) with low steam pressure after several problems en route, mainly due to poor quality coal from Russia. Tornado could barely reach 100 psi (700 kPa) 20 November
- 2010 - Returns to York NRM for maintenance and to be repainted to lined "Brunswick Green" December
- 2011 - Boiler returned to DB Meiningen for repairs January[36]
- 2011 - Boiler refitted and passes steam test April.
- 2011 - Unveiled at NRM in lined Brunswick Green with initial BR 'Lion and wheel' symbol (9th February)
- 2011 - Hauls the longest public steam day excursion since 1968 - 505 miles from Crewe via Manchester, Shap and Beattock to Glasgow and return via Wigan (21 September)
Design
Livio Dante Porta
![](http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/a/a0/60163_Tornado_valve_gear_right_hand_side.jpg/220px-60163_Tornado_valve_gear_right_hand_side.jpg)
On hearing of the project in October 1991, the Argentinian locomotive engineer Livio Dante Porta contacted the trust,[8] hailing the project as the start of a "renaissance of steam technology".[8] In 1992, he submitted A proposal for the Tornado project.[37] In it, he proposed to the trust several design improvements that could be made to Tornado that, while preserving the outer form, would make Tornado a second-generation steam locomotive.
Since the trust was not creating a replica of a Peppercorn A1,[4] but the next in class, the proposals were duly considered. However, the trust decided it could only adopt some of the proposals, and improved Tornado remains strictly a first-generation locomotive. The trust felt there were too many risks in adopting all of the untried proposals, and in Porta's own words, it would have taken 20,000 test miles to iron out his improvements, something the trust probably could not finance.[38] The expense of testing the heavily modified preserved Duke of Gloucester was also cited as a factor.
Ironically, in 2003, it was decided to make Tornado oil-fired, for cost and operational reasons,[39] following earlier dual-fuelled coal-and-oil-fired proposals in 1998, when boiler design commenced.[40] This was later abandoned in favour of the original design of coal firing, due to the large increase in global fuel prices, and to save the certification costs of this design difference.[27]
Draughting
![](http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/7/75/60163_Tornado_tender_body.jpg/220px-60163_Tornado_tender_body.jpg)
Rough engineering dimensions for Tornado were obtained from measuring Blue Peter at the National Railway Museum (NRM).[8] Due to there being no general arrangement drawing of a Peppercorn A1, one from an A2 was used.[8]
Many of the drawings originally used at Doncaster Works for the A1 Peppercorn class had been preserved at the NRM,[8] and a team of volunteers spent three days collating these in the autumn of 1991.[8] The original drawings were India ink drawings on linen;[2] these had to be scanned into a Computer Aided Design (CAD) software program, as the microfilm NRM copies were not suitable for manufacturing purposes, and direct dyeline copies could not be made.[9] About 95 percent of the original drawings were found, with 1,100 scanned by 1993, and a further 140 in 2001.[9] A few poor-quality originals required re-drawing.[9]
Updated specifications were required to be drawn up to account for out of date material specifications and drawing notes whose original meaning could not be determined.[9] Other design details were also obtained through interviews with Arthur Peppercorn's former assistant, J.F. Harrison.[9]
Changes from original
![](http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/c/cf/60163_Tornado_cab_electrics.jpg/220px-60163_Tornado_cab_electrics.jpg)
The design was modified where necessary to better suit modern manufacturing techniques,[25] and to fit in with the modern high speed railway,[25] while retaining the greater part of the original design.[25] As an evolution of the Peppercorn A1 class, Tornado would also incorporate improvements that would have been made to the class had steam continued, such as correction of the rough riding faults of the original 49 Peppercorn A1s.[7]
The whistle is not an A1, it is an A4 whistle, procured from the scrapped loco "Golden Eagle"
The following design changes were made for cost or operational reasons:
- All welded boiler[9] (i.e. not riveted[39])
- Steel firebox[9] (not copper[39])
- One-piece frames[9]
- Roller bearings
- Improved front bogie[9]
- Improved steam circuit[9]
- Altered tender coal/water balance (more water)[9]
- Overall weight reduction[9]
Additionally, to meet current safety and operation standards, Tornado includes:
- Up-rated electrical supplies
- Primary air (not steam) brakes[9]
- LED cluster based head-tail lamps
- Vacuum brakes[9] (for heritage railway stock)
- 1 inch (2.5 cm) reduction in overall height[39] (for overhead line equipment (OLE) regulations[39])
- Automatic Warning System (AWS),
- Train Protection & Warning System (TPWS).
- Data recorder
- European Rail Traffic Management System (ERTMS) compatible GSM-Railway (GSM-R) cab radio[23]
With advances in manufacturing, as opposed to the original Peppercorn A1, which had two-piece frames riveted together, Tornado's 48-foot-6-inch (14.78 m) long steel plates were electronically cut from one piece of steel.[2][10] These are probably the most accurate steam locomotive frames ever produced.[10]
![](http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/5/5d/60163_Tornado_Cartazzi_axle.jpg/220px-60163_Tornado_Cartazzi_axle.jpg)
Despite their higher costs, roller bearings were used[9] owing to the reliability they had demonstrated after a trial of some of the original Peppercorn A1s. This caused an unforeseen problem in 2003 since the modifications made to the tender in the original fitting of roller bearings as an experiment to some Peppercorn A1s had not been properly drawn for the Cartazzi axle of the trailing wheels.[39]
The tender was redesigned internally, removing the water scoop, increasing the water capacity from 5,000 to 6,000 gallons, and reducing coal capacity from 9 to 7.5 tons.[29]
A 1-inch (25 mm) reduction in height from the original 13-foot-1-inch (3.99 m) height was required by the Network Rail OLE regulations, and was achieved by a redesign of the dome and safety valve mountings on the boiler,[39] and by reprofiling of the cab roof and chimney.
Testing was planned to occur with a lipped chimney, and on receipt of the first full livery, Tornado would be fitted with an authentic rimless chimney,[15] described as the original non-capped version.[16] The fluted chimney intended for Apple Green running was still not fitted at the time of the green livery launch on 13 December,[21] due to it still being machined at the manufacturer.[11] It was completed and fitted in time for the inaugural main line passenger run. The locomotive chimney would also be fitted with a spark arrestor.[16] The locomotive number on the smokebox door may be moved higher up as was "once the norm" (requiring the moving of the lamp-bracket).[16] Moving the number plate above the smokebox door hand-rail was confirmed as being intended at the time of Tornado's unveiling at the NRM.[21] Tornado would also be fitted with a chime whistle from an A4 class locomotive.[16]
Tender
![](http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/d/d6/60163_Tornado_at_the_GCR_2.jpg/220px-60163_Tornado_at_the_GCR_2.jpg)
In 1991, a preference for a 'Doncaster pattern' riveted tender was expressed,[8] as per the Doncaster-built Peppercorn A1s.[39] The redundant tender of Flying Scotsman was acquired, although later returned unused, allowing Tornado to remain a completely originally manufactured locomotive.
By 2002, it was agreed that a flush sided (all welded) boiler and tender was appropriate for a Darlington-built Peppercorn A1,[39] making construction and maintenance easier.[39] In 2003 the need for a second tender for Tornado was discounted.[39] The tender features spoked wheels as per at least three historical LNER Peppercorn A1s.
Boiler
Consideration of the boiler began in late 1998.[40] No standard gauge boiler had been built in Britain since the 1960s,[39] at least not for such a large engine. It was required to be based on the original LNER Diagram 118 design but had to meet modern safety standards.[39] Design changes included the cheaper modern-day fabrication method of a welded rather than a riveted firebox and boiler tube,[39] the use of steel rather than copper for the firebox,[39] and the height reduction for OLE regulations.
While manufacturing facilities still existed in Britain to manufacture such a large component,[41] because of the design differences from the originals the trust required a supplier with specific experience of designing, building and certification of steam engine boilers to modern safety regulations,[39] as required by the European Union's Pressure Equipment Directive.[42]
![](http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/f/f0/Dampflokwerk03.jpg/220px-Dampflokwerk03.jpg)
In early 2002, the Deutsche Bahn Meiningen Steam Locomotive Works in the former East Germany was identified as a supplier.[39] They possessed the required knowledge as mainline steam operation had continued in East Germany until the mid-1980s,[27] 70% of their work still involved steam, and they still possessed the powerful plate roller machines. The trust did not have funding to place the order until January 2005.[27]
On 16 July 2006 the boiler arrived by sea and was unloaded at Darlington with a 200-ton crane, having taken just nine months to build.[29] The fitting of the 21-ton firebox and boiler unit to the wheeled locomotive frame was said to have been a perfect fit, requiring no grinding at all, a tribute to the accuracy of the design and construction by the Meiningen works.[41] The fitting was not without incident though, as the extra weight caused some compaction of the track bed, and assistance was required to move the locomotive back into the works, being winched, towed by a forklift truck and pushed with Land Rovers.[41]
A further modification to the boiler design has been the use of hollow stays. Stays support and separate the outer boiler and inner firebox. The hollow stays act as an indicator of any cracks in the otherwise inaccessible stays, such cracks being revealed by water leaks. Leaks have in fact been detected and have led to the locomotive being unavailable for service. In July 2010 while replacement stays were fitted, Mark Allatt, chairman, The A1 Steam Locomotive Trust, commented "Although the problems with Tornado’s boiler are part of learning about the locomotive in today’s operational environment, they are a source of great disappointment to all of Tornado's supporters and customers and our customers' passengers. We are working as hard as we can to bring Tornado back to full health as soon as possible and back onto the main line where she belongs." [43]
Motion and wheelset
The motion components cost £150,000: taking £50,000 to forge (and requiring three years to complete[40]) and £100,000 to machine.[40] The first mainline steam locomotive wheelset manufacture in Britain since 1960 took five years, involved nine suppliers and cost £100,000, even with generous sponsorship.[26] The wheels were so smooth that the complete locomotive could easily be pushed out of the works by human power alone, as seen the locomotive was moved outside in preparation for the first steam-powered moves.[41] If the locomotive were to be suspended, the entire wheel and motion arrangement could be turned by hand.[41]
Manufacture
![](http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/2/22/60163_Tornado_outside_Hopetown_Carriage_works.jpg/220px-60163_Tornado_outside_Hopetown_Carriage_works.jpg)
The assembly of Tornado has mostly taken place at the A1 Trust's Darlington Locomotive Works,[10] bringing together components manufactured around the country, and some from overseas.
1995–2000
Actual manufacture and construction had started in 1994, before the Darlington works opened, with casting of the cylinders (late 1994[10]) and wheels, cutting of the frames and construction of the cab. The locomotive frames were assembled at Tyseley Locomotive Works, Birmingham,[9] being ceremonially laid there on 5 January 1995,[10] and completed by October 1996.[9]
In March 1997, Tornado, as a completed frame and inside cylinder, was displayed at the Great Hall at the NRM for several weeks, transported from Tyseley by an EWS freight wagon.[10] She returned to Tyseley to await completion of the Darlington works.[10] The elements of Tornado were brought together with the opening of Darlington Locomotive Works in 1997, and the opening ceremony saw the unveiled locomotive, now consisting of the frame with its three cylinders and cab attached.[40] Spring 1998 saw the smokebox construction started[40] and the tyres fitted,[40] and by 1999 forging of the motion components started,[40] the first delivery of components commencing in January 2000.[44]
2000–05
![](http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/9/9f/2002-00186wm.jpg/220px-2002-00186wm.jpg)
By September 1999, the last wheel had been pressed onto the wheelset,[40] which was delivered to Darlington by July 2000.[26] By January 2000, the front bogie had been assembled.[44] With the fitting of these parts, the mounting of the frame onto the wheelset,[10][26] and fitting of the smokebox,[26] by the end of 2000, the most visible missing parts of Tornado were the boiler and tender.
Post-2000, assembly and setting of the motion proceeded, and attention turned to the design of the boiler; a £250,000 appeal was launched.[40] Tornado became a rolling chassis by October 2002,[39] and achieved the first synchronous movement of the motion and all wheels in August 2004.[27]
2005–08
2005 also saw construction of the boiler in Germany, with construction begun on 16 October,[45] and completed in time for delivery on 16 July 2006.[29] By June 2007 Tornado's internal construction was sufficiently complete to allow fitting of the boiler to the frame, using a 100-ton crane.[29] The most complex casting, the superheater header, was started in 2007, and after defeating two foundries the complex shape was cast by a third supplier.[29][40]
Owing to space constraints at Darlington works, the Tornado tender frames and body were built off-site, with the body being significantly built locally in Darlington.[45] The tender wheelsets were assembled by an East Lancs Railway-based company.[29] The tender frame and wheel set were united by December 2007,[29] and the tank attached to it by February 2008.[15]
Commissioning
Components and boiler
![](http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/7/78/Boiler_safety_valve_of_60163_Tornado.jpg/220px-Boiler_safety_valve_of_60163_Tornado.jpg)
A computer simulation was used to assist in the setting up of the valves and motion.[27] The boiler safety valves were tested on LNER Class A4 60009 Union of South Africa at the Severn Valley Railway before their delivery to Meiningen for fitting to the boiler.
On 10 July 2006, the boiler was hydraulically tested at the manufacturer's at one-and-a-half times working pressure[29] and was passed safe.[29] On 11 January 2008 the boiler passed its first steam test,[29] in tests carried out by an external boiler inspector.[41] The boiler was noted by the inspector to be a very rapid boiler, boding well for use on the main line.[15] As also noted by the inspector, being brand new Tornado's boiler exhibited no leaks of any kind during the test, in contrast to heritage restorations.[41]
For the test, the fire was lit and the boiler was allowed to warm up over 48 hours[41] before being then taken up to 260psi,[29] just over the maximum working pressure. During the test, the boiler safety valves were set to the correct pressure.[41]
At that time the tender body was not yet finished, so the test was conducted using a water bowser. The boiler was creating steam so efficiently that the water supply was being used faster than it could be replenished by the mains water supply to the works.[41] In order to complete the test and not prematurely damp down the fire, an emergency call for water was made to the local fire brigade, who responded with a fire engine to supply more water.[41] This was sensationally but inaccurately reported in one local newspaper as "fire brigade called to prevent boiler explosion".[41]
Launch of steam trials
Low speed trials of Tornado as a steaming locomotive first occurred on the 500-foot (150 m) long Darlington works track.[15] After a series of private tests in the days beforehand,[41][46] in which Tornado made her first in-steam moves on 29 July,[22] Tornado was launched on 1 August 2008,[16][46] moving up and down the test siding in front of the press.
The 1 August launch was timely, as it coincided with the 40th anniversary of the end of steam on British Railways, on 4 August 1968, and with the 60th anniversary of the entry into traffic of No. 60114 W.P. Allen, the first Peppercorn A1 class locomotive.
Great Central Railway
From Darlington works, Tornado was moved by road on two articulated lorries to the 60 miles per hour (97 km/h) preserved Great Central Railway, where she would perform mileage accumulation and testing,[13] before hauling her first passenger trains.
After being transported to the GCR on 19 August 2008,[47] Tornado was unloaded at Quorn and Woodhouse station the following day, and towed to the GCR Loughborough shed.
Tornado performed her first non-stop mile run at the GCR on 21 August,[22] and hauled her first empty trains on 22 August.[47] For the GCR Thomas the Tank Engine themed bank holiday weekend (23–25 August), Tornado wore a small Thomas face for light runs during the days.[47]
![](http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/5/55/60163_Tornado_at_the_GCR.jpg/220px-60163_Tornado_at_the_GCR.jpg)
It was anticipated that Tornado would need around 2,000 miles (3,200 km) of running to bed in, before moving to the main line proper.[14] Following HM Railway Inspectorate (HMRI) approval, 60 mph (97 km/h) running was achieved by the end of September 2008.[14] Prior to mid-October 2008, Tornado had achieved 1,000 miles (1,600 km) of fault-free running.[16] By the end of October, Tornado had run 1,500 miles (2,400 km).[48]
While at the GCR, Tornado hauled empty passenger trains at speeds up to 60 mph (97 km/h),[23] and load test trains of up to around 500 tons.[23] One load test in September involved the hauling of a rake of 11 empty coaches and a dead Class 45 diesel locomotive.[14] Also in one load test, over 2,000edhp (Effective Drawbar Horsepower) was recorded.[23] On 10 September Tornado was officially timed for the first time, hauling 518 tons up the 1 in 176 gradient south from Rothley railway station.[17]
According to the preserved railway's president, Tornado achieved a "smooth debut" while at the GCR.[20] Tornado was also described to have performed in the testing and passenger runs "effortlessly"[23] and "faultlessly".[14][41]
National Railway Museum
![](http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/b/b1/Tornado_apple_green_livery_-_2008-12-13.jpg/220px-Tornado_apple_green_livery_-_2008-12-13.jpg)
On 21 October 2008, Tornado arrived at the National Rail Museum in York,[20] and was first put on display in the Great Hall for a few days,[20] where she was given pride of place on the NRM turntable for the annual railway industry dinner on 23 October 2008.[48] Tornado then remained operationally based at the NRM behind the scenes for final preparations and testing on the main line, reaching speeds of up to 75 mph (121 km/h), before an expected main line debut in February 2009.[20] The acceptance testing based out of York would be conducted by EWS.[48]
Three test runs on the main line were planned, for the 4, 6 and 18 November 2008, involving out and back journeys departing from York in the evenings.[31] The first would be to Scarborough.[31] Two further runs would occur to Barrow Hill, Chesterfield,[31] and to Newcastle.[31]
The Scarborough run would be a round trip of 84 miles (135 km)[49] with a support coach only.[31] The Barrow Hill run would see Tornado haul a 500-ton load, consisting of a rake of 12 coaches and a Class 67 diesel locomotive, at up to 60 mph (97 km/h),[50] on a 142-mile (229 km) round trip.[49] The Newcastle run would be a 176-mile (283 km) round trip at up to 75 mph (121 km/h),[49] with a rake of empty coaches.[31]
The first test run ran successfully on 4 November 2008 "with no discernible problems".[49] The second test also ran on 6 November. The morning of 19 November 2008 marked the successful completion of the third and final test run.[32]
Following the completion of the mainline test tuns, Tornado entered the NRM paintshop to receive her first proper livery, and was unveiled in a launch ceremony on 13 December 2008. After some brief further work behind the scenes, Tornado returned to the NRM turntable on 22 December and was displayed there over the Christmas period until 11 January 2009, whereupon she was moved back into the workshops to undergo preparation for her main line passenger debut.[21]
![](http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/b/b7/4472_Flying_Scotsman_and_60163_Tornado_at_the_NRM.jpg/220px-4472_Flying_Scotsman_and_60163_Tornado_at_the_NRM.jpg)
A further test run was announced, the first in her green livery, with a run for Tornado and support coach from York to Leeds and back, to be run on 28 January 2009, in preparation for the inaugural main line passenger trains.[51] This was duly completed, allowing passenger trains to begin.[52]
While Tornado was based at the NRM, on 21 January 2009 a £250,000 funding appeal, Save Our Scotsman,[53] was launched for completion of the restoration of LNER Class A3 4472 Flying Scotsman, a long-term resident of the NRM workshops since being taken out of service for overhaul in December 2005.[54] Inevitable comparisons were drawn with the Tornado project, with it being highlighted that as of the end of 2008 the cost to the NRM since 2004 of restoring Flying Scotsman (£2.2m purchasing and £742,000 overhauling) was almost the exact cost of building Tornado from scratch.[55] In particular, as of January 2008, the believed cost of £800,000 for Tornado's brand new boiler from Germany was less than the latest NRM budget of £850,000 for restoring Flying Scotsman's A3 boiler,[54] which had risen from earlier estimates due to the boiler's poor condition and the rising cost of copper.[53]
Certification
External image | |
---|---|
![]() Key: |
As a new build locomotive, certification is more complex than for a restoration,[28] and requires liaison with Network Rail, HMRI and a vehicle acceptance body (VAB),[28] with the origin of all construction materials needing to be documented[28] and every aspect of the manufacture recorded.[29] Following manufacture, a technical file and Notified Body certificate will be obtained on completion of a manufacturing and maintenance procedures review.[29]
Tornado is required to pass the 2006 European Interoperability of the conventional rail system Directive,[29] achieved through compliance with the National Notified Technical Rules (formerly the Railway Group Standards).[29] Certification of Tornado is being managed by the trust's UK Notified Body, DeltaRail Group Ltd.[29] Tornado is exempted from portions of the regulations, as are many main line steam locomotives, such as from the need for a yellow warning panel, or crumple zones.[29]
In liaison with Network Rail, a route acceptance strategy will be agreed.[29] Approval for Tornado to enter service will be granted by the Office of Rail Regulation (ORR).[29] This will be in two stages, approval under the 'Railway and Other Transport Systems regulations, for use on the Great Central Railway (GCR) and other preserved lines, and then as an 'interoperable' locomotive for use on the British main line network.[29]
Testing of the On-Train Monitoring Recorder (OTMR), Train Protection & Warning System (TPWS), Automatic Warning System (AWS), and air brakes was done at the GCR.[16] These tests are standard for all steam locomotives requiring certification for the main line.[13] Regulator position and locomotive speed are both recorded by the on-train recording equipment, stored under the driver's seat.[2]
![](http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/9/91/60163_Tornado_at_Newcastle_Central_Station.jpg/220px-60163_Tornado_at_Newcastle_Central_Station.jpg)
As well as standard tests, as technically a new design of locomotive Tornado was required to undergo specific extra tests to examine ride quality and track force, to assess the effect the locomotive would have on the main line track.[13] The details of these tests are laid down by the Network Rail Safety Review Panel. It was agreed in advance between the trust and the authorities that these could be done in part at the GCR.[13] Accordingly, on 25 September 2008, the tests were performed by running Tornado through the Kinchley Curve at speeds of 10, 20, 30, 40, 50 and 60 mph (97 km/h), with a trailing saloon car fitted with monitoring equipment, including a Global Positioning System (GPS) unit to measure the precise speed and distance travelled every metre.[13] Measurements were taken on board by 21 sensors attached to the locomotive, measuring pitch and roll, and acceleration and deceleration. Measurements were also taken through the use of track-side sensors measuring side forces exerted on the track, augmented with freeze-frame footage of the position of the wheels as they passed.[13] The results were compared with control readings taken at the same site using Oliver Cromwell, two weeks later.[13] The preliminary results were described as producing "no untoward signals".[13]
![](http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/5/51/60163_Tornado_at_Newcastle_31_Jan_09_pic_13.jpg/220px-60163_Tornado_at_Newcastle_31_Jan_09_pic_13.jpg)
Tornado was granted an Engineering Acceptance (EA) certificate on 31 October by DeltaRail and a Route Acceptance certificate on 3 November by Network Rail, allowing testing on the main line to begin.[31] Further tests were performed at Network Rail facilities located between York and Darlington, at a testing facility known as a wheelchex. This consists of track fitted with sensors to measure vertical force effects such as hammer blow.[13] Completion of a test run between York and Leeds on 28 January 2009 signalled the gaining of certification to haul passengers on the Network Rail main line.[52][57]
In January 2009, the railway press reported that a discrepancy had emerged in the 18 November 2008 75 mph (121 km/h) test, whereby the OTMR recording equipment on the Class 67 being towed had recorded a top speed of around 100 mph (160 km/h), while the A1 data recorder measured speeds "nearer the 75 mph (121 km/h)" mark.[3] It was stated that while a 10% overspeed is allowed (and may be required) in such new equipment test runs (A4 Class 4464 Bittern reached 83 mph (134 km/h) in 2007,[58]) Tornado had not been planned or authorised to do so on this test. It was suggested that the discrepancy might been down to the equipment on the Class 67[58] having had its gearing altered but not having been recalibrated.
Passenger operation
![]() | This section needs to be updated.(March 2011) |
![](http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/e/e6/60163_Tornado_in_steam_5.jpg/220px-60163_Tornado_in_steam_5.jpg)
After leaving the GCR, it is intended that Tornado will, as much as possible, not be transported by road; therefore she will only see service on the main line, or on heritage lines with a main line connection.[15][30] Exceptions have been made to this: the locomotive revisited the GCR in spring 2010, and is set to visit the Bluebell Railway in August 2010. It will be put onto a low loader again to be transported back to Darlington for overhaul, after five years' service.[15]
It was expected that the first phase of main line operational running would be limited to trips of 200 to 250 miles (400 km).[14] The expanded water capacity of the tender allows legs of over 100 miles (160 km) between water stops,[52] 25 miles (40 km) further than the original Peppercorn A1s.[2]
To assist in passenger operation, in 2008 the Trust purchased their own support coach, a British Railways Mark 1 Brake Composite Corridor type, No. 21249,[16] which as of spring 2010 is still not in use. Tornado has a route availability of 9.[1]
Inaugural trains on the Great Central Railway
Following the gaining of HMRI approval the previous week,[14] Tornado made her passenger train debut on 21 September 2008 at the GCR.[1][14][23]
The inaugural train was formed of a rake of eight carriages,[14] formed (from the front) of three 'blood and custard' liveried coaches, four green liveried coaches, and a special rear coach.[1] This rear coach was a restored LNER beavertail observation car.[14] This train departed at 10.15 am from Quorn and Woodhouse station,[14][23] and ran non-stop to Leicester North station, back to Loughborough, and then to Quorn.[14] Five trains in all ran on this first day, with all special services being restricted to those involved with the Trust,[14][23] with Tornado running around in a non-platform passing loop at Loughborough Central.[23] On this day, 1,000–2,000 covenantors,[16] donors and guests[14] travelled on the service.
The first public trains for fare-paying passengers began the next day on 22 September 2008,[14][23] limited to the normal line speed.[23] On this day, over 1,000 passengers were carried on the three sold-out trips.[16]
Heritage railways
![](http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/3/3f/60163_Tornado_at_the_GCR_3.jpg/220px-60163_Tornado_at_the_GCR_3.jpg)
While at the GCR for the first time, Tornado also took part in the 125th anniversary of the Boys' Brigade wearing a special headboard on 4 October 2008, and hauled the preserved GCR Travelling Post Office rake.[59]
The last passenger operation at the GCR was on Sunday 12 October 2008,[14][16] the culmination of a three-day gala weekend event. Tornado operated over the weekend alongside Leander, Oliver Cromwell and Lord Nelson,[16] which was to have an "end of steam" theme.[60] The first announced heritage event for Tornado was an appearance at the 2009 Spring gala at the North Yorkshire Moors Railway, 1–10 May.[59][61]
Following a servicing visit on her 6 November 2008 test run, Tornado returned to the Barrow Hill roundhouse on the weekend of 4–5 April, arriving on 30 March.[61] As well as Tornado, the LNER themed event featured, among others, the LNER locomotives A2 Class 60532 Blue Peter, and the A4 Classes 4498 Sir Nigel Gresley and 4488 Union of South Africa.[62] At this event, Tornado was posed alongside narrow gauge (15 inches (38 cm)*) locomotive No.7 Typhoon of the Romney, Hythe and Dymchurch Railway, recreating an LNER publicity shot held previously with Typhoon and LNER Class A3 4472 Flying Scotsman.[62] 60532 Blue Peter, which is a semi-permanent resident of Barrow Hill, was repainted in apple green for display alongside Tornado.[61] The 6 November meeting of Tornado and 60532 Blue Peter in the Barrow Hill roundhouse re-created a scene not witnessed for nearly 50 years.[22] From 16 August 2009 to 2 September 2009, Tornado visited Didcot Railway Centre. From 24 October 2009 to 7 November, Tornado visited the Severn Valley Railway for October half term, where it ran with the SVR's LNER set of teak carriages. [1]
In August 2010, Tornado will be visiting the Bluebell Railway for its 50th anniversary of operation celebrations. It may arrive via low loader if its East Grinstead extension is not completed despite the fact that the A1 Trust said all movements would be by rail.[2] [3]
Inaugural main line trains
![](http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/c/c3/60163_Tornado_at_Newcastle_31_Jan_09_pic_1.jpg/350px-60163_Tornado_at_Newcastle_31_Jan_09_pic_1.jpg)
Tornado completed her first passenger trip on the main line on 31 January 2009, a return trip from York to Newcastle, via Darlington and Durham.[34] As with the trains at the GCR, the first two official passenger trips on the mainline were to be for covenanters only.[63] These trips were provisionally announced as two specials from York to Newcastle and back, making one trip on 31 January 2009, with the same trip repeated the next day.[64] This would see Tornado repeating the route of the last tour hauled by the last surviving original Peppercorn A1, 60145 St Mungo, 42 years previously.[63] These trains were announced as The Peppercorn Pioneers on 18 January 2009.[51] The first train would be carrying 500 passengers in a rake of 13 carriages.[52] On 23 January, on advice from the British Transport Police and Network Rail, due to concerns over crowd safety at Newcastle station due to the 1 February Tyne-Wear football derby match between Newcastle United F.C. and Sunderland A.F.C., the second Peppercorn Pioneer was re-arranged into a return trip from Doncaster to Durham, with Tornado hauling the train for the outbound leg and part of the return leg.[65][66]
![](http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/8/80/60163_Tornado_7_Feb_2009_Tallington.jpg/220px-60163_Tornado_7_Feb_2009_Tallington.jpg)
Tornado's first publicly available train, and also her first trip to London, was hauling an A1 Trust Talisman railtour on 7 February 2009 from Darlington to King's Cross.[63][67] Tornado's first trains out of London were two Valentine's Day Cathedrals Express excursions from London Victoria on 14 February 2009, a lunch tour and a dinner tour.[68][69] The lunch tour was later modified to leave from London Waterloo station, making Waterloo as Tornado's first London departure point.[70] Tornado's first Pullman class train was expected to be a Yorkshire Pullman on 26 February 2009, hauling the British Venice-Simplon Orient Express (VSOE) coaching stock from King's Cross to York.[71] This was later postponed to 18 April 2009.[72] The new date also saw Tornado scheduled to run a return journey back to King's Cross on the same day.[61][73] This was still expected to be Tornado's first passenger departure from King's Cross.[61] Tornado's first trip to Scotland was The Auld Reekie Express on 28 February 2009, with steam traction one way from York to Edinburgh. With Following Saturday 7 March making her first journey from Scotland.[58][74] As of January 2009, the Trust planned to run their own excursions with Tornado over the Settle-Carlisle Line on 3 October 2009 and 4 October 2009.[61]
On 21 December 2009, Tornado rescued about 100 people who were stranded by bad weather at London Victoria station. On that day, a number of electric trains, which picked up their power from the third rail, were unable to run because of snow and ice on the line. Tornado was to haul a 'Cathedrals Express' lunchtime special service from Victoria; a number of booked passengers had been unable to get there due to the conditions, and so there were spare seats; the train's operators decided to offer these seats to commuters whose trains had been cancelled. Tornado also had an evening 'Cathedrals Express' dining train, and the same offer was again made.[75][76][77][78]
Operational top speed
![](http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/2/27/60163_Tornado_Peterborough_7_Feb_2009.jpg/350px-60163_Tornado_Peterborough_7_Feb_2009.jpg)
In 2004, approval was sought for 90 mph (140 km/h) running,[27] however this has not yet been achieved. If approved at some time in the future it would make Tornado the fastest present-day steam locomotive in Britain.[27] This approach is required to run at speeds comparable to contemporary rail traffic,[29] involving full certification of Tornado.[29] While older preserved steam locomotives are subject to speed and safety restrictions, approval for 90 mph (140 km/h) running is possible for Tornado due to her new condition.[2] Like her predecessors, the original Peppercorn A1 class, Tornado could reach 100 mph (160 km/h).[2]
It was expected that Tornado would achieve certification to be allowed to run at 90 mph (140 km/h) on the main line, although it was believed this might not occur until 2009.[16] As of January 2009, having gained approval for running at 75 mph (121 km/h), "active discussion" was said to be taking place about testing Tornado to "a higher speed".[58]
If 90 mph (140 km/h) running is achieved, Tornado would also become the second fastest in the world.[16] Regular 90 mph (140 km/h) steam operation was last seen in Britain in 1967 with the Merchant Navy class Pacific locomotives operating on the Waterloo to Bournemouth route.[16] The fastest operational steam locomotive in the world is Deutsche Reichsbahn 18.201, allowed to run in Germany up to 180 km/h (110 mph).[16]
While Tornado will be limited to 75 mph (121 km/h) on the UK main line, there is a possibility that she could reach higher speeds if transported to Germany. If she was towed through the Channel Tunnel, according to the Trust, Deutsche Bahn had informed the Trust that Tornado would be allowed to run "as fast as [they] like".[56]
Funding
Tornado carries a plaque bearing the following message:[11]
This locomotive was built and paid for by people who shared a vision and were determined to turn it into reality
Fundraising
![](http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/b/b6/60163_Tornado_being_prepared.jpg/220px-60163_Tornado_being_prepared.jpg)
Tornado was built by the Locomotive Construction Co Ltd,[9] a wholly owned subsidiary of the A1 Steam Locomotive Trust. At 1990s prices, the projected cost of the project was £1.6 million.[1]
The trust has used Deeds of Covenant since the start of the project in 1990,[25] marketed under the slogan 'build a main line loco for the price of a pint of beer a week!'.[8] Covenantors can wear a special A1 Trust tie[8] and pay a fixed amount monthly by standing order, and for this they receive honour roll recognition, event and viewing priority, regular trust publications and the right to attend the annual conventions.[15]
In September 1996, the concept of dedicated covenants was launched.[10] Now renamed dedicated donations, these were one-off payments of £25 to £25,000 to sponsor a particular part.[10] As with regular covenantors, dedicated donors receive recognition, and an engineering drawing of the component they sponsored.[15]
In October 1999 a £250,000 appeal was launched to fund the boiler, whose absence was now noticeable with Tornado now comprising a wheeled frame with completed cab and smokebox.[40] As Tornado began to look like a locomotive with the mating of the frame with the wheelset in the Autumn of 2000, fundraising progress increased, breaking previous records by recruiting 100 new covenantors in two months.[26] By 2005, the trust had raised over £1.5m.[29]
Completion of the boiler was achieved through a half million pound bond issue.[45] Following securing the boiler funding, the last major part, the tender, was achieved with a £200,000 single sponsor donation.[45]
As of May 2008, £2.5m had been raised and spent, and the gap to the required £3m had been raised to complete Tornado[15] However, due to the Chinese economic boom causing raw material cost increases, and increased certification costs, a further £50,000 appeal had to be launched if main line running was to be achieved by September.[15]
As of the end of September 2008, the Trust still needed to raise £66,000 to pay for tests and trials to allow main line operation.[14][20][23][79] While at the GCR, the project costs were running at the rate of £10,000 a month,[16] rising to "six-figure bills" for certification in the months up to January 2009.[21]
Launched in 2004, as of January 2009 £100,000 of the Trust's half million pound bond issue offering 4% returns remained unsubscribed.[61]
Sponsorship
![](http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/f/f6/60163_Tornado_smokebox_door.jpg/220px-60163_Tornado_smokebox_door.jpg)
In 1994 the A1 trust gained its first major sponsor, a major steel company.[9] In 1997, Great North Eastern Railway (GNER), the then operator on the East Coast Main Line, became a sponsor, and decorated Darlington station for the event, as well as offering free travel for trust workers.[40] The trust gained Rolls-Royce as a sponsor in Spring 1998.[40] The trust's principal sponsor is a metal casting company, which initially cast the driving wheels on "very advantageous terms",[10] and later assisted with all the wheels and almost all other steel castings.[10] As with GNER, Tornado's links to the East Coast Main Line brought with it support from the next incumbent operator, National Express, with sponsorship of the third main line test run to Newcastle. Significant savings were made through industrial sponsorship; by 1998 this was keeping costs at 40% of normal.[40] Some components, such as the smokebox door, were even obtained free of charge.[26]
Other
Cost savings of a third of the original were possible in some manufacturing cases, where the building of one locomotive allowed for cheaper construction methods, such as using one-off polystyrene cast patterns.[10] Several other events and fund-raising drives have assisted in funding the project, including a Land's End to John O'Groats bike ride.
The Trust also received proceeds from the sale of limited edition models of Tornado in works grey livery. The model was a customised product from The Model Centre (TMC), based on the Bachmann OO scale models of the Peppercorn A1 class.[14][80][81]
Another grey works Tornado was to be made by TMC but with National Express on her tender from her 18 November mainline test run.
Bachmann released another Tornado model in her BR Apple Green livery just before Christmas 2009. Unlike the TMC models, which featured standard Bachmann A1s repainted in Tornado's then grey livery, and unlike the original Bachmann limited edition model of Tornado which had the locomotive in BR Brunswick Green livery with the late BR crest, the apple-green 2009 release was of a new model, with most (though not all) of the detail differences applied. This is particularly evident on the tender, which features the enlarged water capacity and reduced coal storage of Tornado as compared to the 49 original A1s. The model proved extremely popular, to the extent that 10 weeks after going on sale Bachmann stocks were exhausted and more models had to be ordered.[82]
On 25 December 2010 Hornby announced their 2011 range of models, which includes three versions of Tornado: a budget 'Railroad' version in BR Apple Green with simplified printing and lining details;[83] a more detailed BR Apple Green version for the main range;[84] and a version in BR Brunswick Green (with early crest) available as part of a train pack with three maroon coaches.[85]
To recoup the cost of the project and service the debt, once operational Tornado would take over haulage duties on the Trust’s own Talisman railtours,[86] and be offered for hire to heritage railways and other railtour and charter train operators.[87] Whilst at heritage railways, the Trust would also offer driver courses at the controls of Tornado.[87]
A new book on the story of Tornado called Tornado 21st Century Steam, written by The Guardian's Jonathan Glacey, was released on 15 October 2010.
Media
A BBC film crew filmed the project at certain points on the journey, up to and including arrival and operation of Tornado running at the GCR. The resulting film was used to make a 30 minute documentary film, Absolutely Chuffed: The Men Who Built a Steam Engine. It was first broadcast on BBC Four on 16 October 2008, as part of their Golden Age of Steam season.[41] The film was released on region 2 DVD on 28 December 2009 with unseen material and DVD extras.[88]
Tornado and the Tornado project was also partly featured in the BBC Four documentary episode The Last Days of Steam[46] (series 8 of the Time Shift documentaries), and also on How Do They Do It? (channel Five version, season 3 episode 3).[89] The project also featured on BBC 2's magazine programme Working Lunch broadcast on 3 December 2007.[90]
Top Gear Race to the North
![](http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/a/a1/60163_Tornado_Private_Charter_Cathedrals_Express_Top_Gear_Race_25_April_2009_Newcastle_pic_7.jpg/220px-60163_Tornado_Private_Charter_Cathedrals_Express_Top_Gear_Race_25_April_2009_Newcastle_pic_7.jpg)
On 25 April 2009, Tornado hauled a 10-coach Cathedrals Express charter from London King's Cross to Edinburgh Waverley. This private train was filmed by the BBC for a Top Gear Race, in which Jeremy Clarkson on the train raced James May in a Jaguar XK120 and Richard Hammond on a Vincent Black Shadow motorbike. Tornado was booked to complete the 390.2-mile (628.0 km) journey in 8 hours 2 minutes, without any passenger stops in stations, but with four water stops en route at Grantham, York, Tyne Yard and Berwick, totalling 95 minutes booked stoppage time.[91] May and Hammond were restricted to using A-roads, The Tornado came second beating the bike. The train was formed from the maroon support coach and a uniform rake of nine Royal Scot blood and custard coaches. The race featured in the first episode of the show's 13th series, airing on 21 June 2009.
Models
Bachmann Branchline produce a model in OO gauge. Other suppliers have produced detailed drawings.
Hornby Railways have announced that they will be producing a OO gauge Tornado in 2 different liveries. There will be one highly detailed version in the main range and one in the railroad range appealing to the younger modeller. There will also be a Tornado in BR Brunswick green with the early BR Totem as part of a set.
Graham Farish (By Bachmann) have produce a model in N gauge in its British Railway Apple Green.
See also
References
- ^ a b c d e f g The Railway Magazine, 50 Great British Locomotives, Autumn/Winter 2008 special, p98, A bonus 51st entry: The 21st century steam miracle
- ^ a b c d e f g Michael Binyon (9 October 2008). "The steam train returns: caught up by the Tornado". London: The Times. Retrieved 17 December 2008.
Soon it will begin trials at 60mph and faster on the main line. It will then be free to it's full energy potential and haul chartered trains on Britain's rail network at speeds of up to 90mph. Like its forebears that worked along the East Coast line from King's Cross to the North East, Tornado could theoretically run at up to 100mph
- ^ a b [The Railway Magazine, February 2009, page 57]
- ^ a b c "The Tornado Story". The Railway Magazine: 15. 2008.
the new loco would carry the running number 60163 - next in sequence after St Johnstoun ... From its earliest days, the A1 Trust regarded 60163 not as a replica or copy of any one of the 49 Peppercorn A1's, but as the 50th member of the class
{{cite journal}}
: Unknown parameter|month=
ignored (help) - ^ a b "Presentation 'Tornado - the first 6 months of operation'". Events, Technical Lecture, 18 February 2009. IMechE. Retrieved 22November2008.
This lecture will cover the history of the Peppercorn Class A1s, the design and manufacturing of the 50th A1 Tornado and its first 6 months of operation in main line service.
{{cite web}}
: Check date values in:|accessdate=
(help) - ^ a b "£300,000 in grants awarded". News archive. A1 Steam Locomotive Trust. 1996. Retrieved 22 November 2008.
Tornado will be a completely new steam locomotive, built from the original 1940s drawings and is therefore neither a restoration project nor a replica, but the next in the original series, the 50th Peppercorn Class A1.
- ^ a b "Latest Computer Technology used at NRM". News archive. A1 Steam Locomotive Trust. 1993. Retrieved 22 November 2008.
The A1 Project is [using CAD] in making modifications to correct A1 faults such as rough-riding just as the LNER/Eastern Region would have done if steam had continued
- ^ a b c d e f g h i j k The Railway Magazine, The Tornado Story Part 1, April 2008, page 16
- ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s t u v w The Railway Magazine, The Tornado Story Part 1, April 2008, page 17
- ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s t The Railway Magazine, The Tornado Story Part 1, April 2008, page 18
- ^ a b c d "Tornado unveiled at York (video)". Railway Herald website, Video Section. Retrieved 31 January 2009. [dead link]
- ^ A1 Steam Official Site Certification, accessed 24 October 2008
- ^ a b c d e f g h i j k Steam Railway magazine, Issue 355, 17 October - 13 November 2008, pages 60 and 61
- ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s t Heritage Railway magazine, Issue 116, 2–29 October 2008
- ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m The Railway Magazine, The Tornado Story Part 2, May 2008, page 35
- ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s t Steam Railway magazine, Issue 355, 17 October - 13 November 2008
- ^ a b Steam Railway magazine, Issue 355, 17 October - 13 November 2008, page 73
- ^ "National Express sponsors final test train on main line for new £3m steam locomotive Tornado". www.a1steam.com. 18 November 2008. Retrieved 8 October 2009.
- ^ a b Mark Branagan (11 December 2008). "Golden age of steam comes back to life in newly-built loco". Yorkshire Post. Retrieved 12 December 2008.
She will be unveiled in the eye-catching apple green livery of the LNER – the London & North Eastern Railway – at the National Railway Museum (NRM) in York on Saturday in front of 500 people who funded the construction of the locomotive. Apple green was the original colour carried by the first 30 of the 49 Peppercorn class A1s
- ^ a b c d e f Tornado steams into town Darlington and Stockton Times, 22 October 2008, accessed 24 October 2008
- ^ a b c d e f Steam Railway magazine, Issue 358, January 9 - February 5, 2009, page 6-7
- ^ a b c d e Steam Railway magazine, Issue 358, January 9 - February 5, 2009, page 44-46
- ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m The Railway Magazine, November 2008, p63
- ^ [http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/north_yorkshire/7898633.stm Royal couple name new steam train, 19 February 2009, BBC News. Retrieved on 20 February 2009.
- ^ a b c d e The Railway Magazine, The Tornado Story Part 1, April 2008, page 15
- ^ a b c d e f g h The Railway Magazine, The Tornado Story Part 2, May 2008, page 29
- ^ a b c d e f g h i The Railway Magazine, The Tornado Story Part 2, May 2008, page 32
- ^ a b c d The Railway Magazine, The Tornado Story Part 2, May 2008, page 30
- ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s t u v w x y The Railway Magazine, The Tornado Story Part 2, May 2008, page 34
- ^ a b The Railway Magazine, The Tornado Story Part 1, April 2008, page 14
- ^ a b c d e f g h A1 Steam Official Site Latest News - New £3m steam locomotive Tornado takes first steps on the main line, accessed 4 November 2008
- ^ a b "New steam loco ready for service". BBC News. 19 November 2008. Retrieved 19 November 2008.
[Tornado] is ready for service after successfully completing all its trial runs. Tornado completed its third and final test run between York and Newcastle.
- ^ "Public unveiling for steam train". BBC News. 13 December 2008. Retrieved 13 December 2008.
She was unveiled in apple green, the colour carried by the first 30 Peppercorn class A1s.
- ^ a b "First passenger trip for new loco". BBC News. 31 January 2009. Retrieved 31 January 2009.
The first new mainline steam engine to be built in Britain for nearly 50 years has made its maiden voyage carrying fare-paying passengers. It travelled from York, calling at Darlington and Durham before stopping in Newcastle ahead of its return trip. Seats on the first journey have been reserved for supporters of the A1 Steam Locomotive Trust
- ^ "New steam train makes London trip". BBC News. 7 February 2009. Retrieved 7 February 2009.
- ^ "The Tornado Telegraph January 2011" (pdf). A1 Steam Locomotive Trust. 2011. Retrieved 2011-04-17.
- ^ Trainweb Publication list of L.D.Porta
- ^ MartyBane.co.uk Transcript of an October 1993 Steam Railway publication]
- ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r The Railway Magazine, The Tornado Story Part 2, May 2008, page 31
- ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o The Railway Magazine, The Tornado Story Part 1, April 2008, page 19
- ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o Absolutely Chuffed: The Men Who Built a Steam Engine BBC Four, accessed 16 October 2008
- ^
Logan, Helen (24 September 2007). "Tornado team steams into future with new locomotive". nebusiness. Retrieved 18 November 2008.
"A steam locomotive boiler built nowadays has to comply with the Pressure Equipment Directive," Mr Boyle explains.
- ^ "Tornado update - 24th July 2010".
- ^ a b The Railway Magazine, The Tornado Story Part 2, May 2008, page 28
- ^ a b c d The Railway Magazine, The Tornado Story Part 2, May 2008, page 33
- ^ a b c The Last Days of Steam BBC Four, accessed 18 October 2008
- ^ a b c A1 Steam Official Site Tornado hauls first trains on Great Central Railway, Monday, 25 August 2008 13:54, accessed 24 October 2008
- ^ a b c The Railway Magazine, December 2008, page 7
- ^ a b c d It's full steam ahead for new locomotive The Scotsman, 6 November 2008, accessed 10 November 2008
- ^ A1 Steam Official Site Latest News - First train on main line for new £3m steam locomotive Tornado, 6 November 2008, accessed 10 November 2008
- ^ a b "Test run on main line as Tornado prepares for main line passenger début". Latest News. A1 Steam Locomotive Trust. 25 January 2009. Retrieved 29 January 2009.
Tornado...will be conducting an additional test run on Wednesday 28th January 2009 from York to Leeds and return...the first time that...on the Network Rail main line wearing her new apple green livery...The timings for the test run of 60163 Tornado and Support Coach are:
Cite error: The named reference "A1STNews18Jan09Pioneer" was defined multiple times with different content (see the help page). - ^ a b c d John Ingham (29 January 2009). "A blast from the past as new Tornado puffs back". Daily Express. Retrieved 29 January 2009.
...took to the main railway line yesterday...first test run on a main line since getting her new apple green livery...four-hour round trip from York's National Railway Museum to Leeds...now set to take her first paying passengers when she pulls out of York for the return trip to Newcastle on Saturday at 12.07 carrying 500 passengers in 13 carriages each way...[Trust Chairman] Mark Allatt, said: "Today means we have completed our mission. We have got the certification to pull passengers. It is a fantastic feeling."...tender's water capacity has been increased from 5,000 gallons to 6,200 gallons, giving her a range of more than 100 miles between refills.
- ^ a b Carole Green (23 January 2009). "Save our Scotsman". BBC North Yorkshire Local history. BBC. Retrieved 29 January 2009.
- ^ a b [Heritage Railway magazine, Issue 120, 21 January - 18 February 2009, pages 8-9]
- ^ Steam Railway magazine, Issue 358, January 9 - February 5, 2009, page 62
- ^ a b Full steam ahead: Our science editor takes the controls of the first giant locomotive built for 50 years Daily Mail online, last updated 20 October 2008, accessed 24 October 2008
- ^ "All Aboard For Tornado's Debut". Sky News. 31 January 2009. Retrieved 31 January 2009.
Tornado made a successful test run on Wednesday and was given the go-ahead to haul a passenger train on the Network Rail main line.
- ^ a b c d [The Railway Magazine, February 2009, pages 6 - 7]
- ^ a b A1 Steam Official Site Preserved Railways, accessed 24 October 2008
- ^ Heritage Railway magazine, Issue 116, 2–29 October 2008, p28
- ^ a b c d e f g [Heritage Railway magazine, Issue 120, 21 January - 18 February 2009, pages 6-7]
- ^ a b Steam Railway magazine, Issue 358, January 9 - February 5, 2009, page 35
- ^ a b c "Where to travel". Travel with Tornado. A1 Steam Locomotive Trust. undated. Retrieved 22 November 2008.
The locomotive will operate her first tours exclusively for our covenantors who have paid for the locomotive on Saturday 31 January and Sunday 1 February 2009. On each day Tornado will haul a train between York and Newcastle replicating the final tour of the last original class A1 60145 St Mungo 42 years ago. On 7 February the locomotive will venture further onto the East Coast Main Line when Tornado will head for Kings Cross and a date with destiny, and carrying The Talisman headboard, the A1SLT's tour trademark. This tour will first be open to covenantors and then to the wider public.
{{cite web}}
: Check date values in:|date=
(help) - ^ "Mainline Steam Tour Programme 2009". www.uksteam.info. 17 November 2008. Retrieved 22 November 2008.
Sat 31-Jan Private Charter (Provisional) (updated 13/11) York-Newcastle 60163: York-Newcastle-York [Tornado inaugural train] Sun 01-Feb Private Charter (Provisional) (updated 13/11) York-Newcastle 60163: York-Newcastle-York
- '^ "Changes to Sunday 1st February train 'The Peppercorn Pioneer'". Latest News. A1 Steam Locomotive Trust. 23 January 2009. Retrieved 29 January 2009.
The A1 Steam Locomotive Trust has been advised by Network Rail and the British Transport Police that due to significant concerns regarding crowd control at Newcastle Central station on Sunday 1 February,
Tornados second train cannot operate through to Newcastle....alter the destination to be the University City of Durham...will now start from Doncaster with 60163 Tornado hauling the train from there...The return journey will be steam hauled from Durham to York with a modern diesel returning the train to Doncaster. - ^ "Mainline Steam Tour Programme 2009". www.uksteam.info. 29 January 2009. Retrieved 29 January 2009.
Sun 01-Feb The Peppercorn Pioneer [Times] (updated 23/01)
York-NewcastleDoncaster-Durham [dbs] 60163:York-Newcastle-YorkDoncaster-Durham-York [Revised itinerary due to crowd control/security issues at Newcastle] - ^ "Mainline Steam Tour Programme 2009". www.uksteam.info. 17 November 2008. Retrieved 22 November 2008.
Sat 07-Feb The Talsiman (Provisional) (updated 13/11) York-London Kings Cross 60163: York-Kings Cross
- ^ "Mainline Steam Tour Programme 2009". www.uksteam.info. 17 November 2008. Retrieved 22 November 2008.
Sat 14-Feb Valentine Dining Excursions (updated 10/11) London Victoria-TBA [wcrc]60163: Victoria-TBA-Victoria (lunch tour) 60163:Victoria-Guildford-Victoria (dinner tour)
- ^ "Valentine's Day Tours - 14th February 2009". www.steamdreams.com. undated. Retrieved 22 November 2008.
Valentine's Day brings a very special occasion to the Cathedrals Express as we welcome the brand new A1 locomotive Tornado on its first departure from London.
{{cite web}}
: Check date values in:|date=
(help) [dead link] - ^ "Mainline Steam Tour Programme 2009". www.uksteam.info. 29 January 2009. Retrieved 29 January 2009.
Sat 14-Feb Valentine Dining Excursion (am) - London Victoria-Trowbridge London Waterloo-Andover [dbs] 60163: Victoria-Staines-Newbury-Trowbridge- Swindon-Staines-Victoria (lunch tour) Waterloo-Staines-Andover-Eastleigh-Staines-Waterloo [Revised route now from Waterloo not Victoria]
- ^ "Mainline Steam Tour Programme 2009". www.uksteam.info. 9 December 2008. Retrieved 9 December 2008.
Thu 26-Feb The Yorkshire Pullman (update 08/12) London Kings Cross-York (VSOE) [ews] 60163: Kings Cross-York
- ^ "Mainline Steam Tour Programme 2009". www.uksteam.info. 29 January 2009. Retrieved 29 January 2009.
Thu 26-Feb The Yorkshire Pullman [POSTPONED to 18-Apr] London Kings Cross-York (VSOE) [dbs] 60163: Kings Cross-York
- ^ "Mainline Steam Tour Programme 2009". www.uksteam.info. 29 January 2009. Retrieved 29 January 2009.
Sat 18-Apr The Yorkshire Pullman London Kings Cross-York (VSOE) [dbs]60163: Kings Cross-York-Kings Cross [Postponed from 26-Feb, steam now both ways]
- ^ "Mainline Steam Tour Programme 2009". www.uksteam.info. 29 January 2009. Retrieved 29 January 2009.
Sat 28-Feb The Auld Reekie Express Peterborough-Edinburgh [dbs] 60163: York-Edinburgh
- ^ "Steam train's snow rescue 'glory'". BBC News Online. 23 December 2009. Retrieved 23 December 2009.
- ^ "Steam engine Tornado shows up its electric friends as it races through Kent". Kent Online. KM Group. 21 December 2009. Retrieved 24 December 2009.
- ^ White, James (24 December 2009). "All aboard the polar express: Steam locomotive takes home passengers stranded by snow-delayed modern trains". The Daily Mail. Retrieved 28 December 2009.
- ^ Pigott, Nick, ed. (2010). "Steam to the rescue as bad weather hits". The Railway Magazine. 156 (1307). London: IPC Media: 6. ISSN 0033-8923.
{{cite journal}}
: Unknown parameter|month=
ignored (help) - ^ 60163 Tornado is on the go! BBC Tees - Industry, last updated 22 September 2008, accessed 24 October 2008
- ^ TMC celebrates Tornado’s first move with limited edition Hornby Magazine News, accessed 27 October 2008
- ^ Limited edition model of Tornado in her launch livery of works grey from TMC Official site news, 14 September 2008, accessed 27 October 2008
- ^ Bachmann stock page, accessed 12 March 2010
- ^ Tornado in the Hornby 2011 Railroad Range
- ^ Tornado in the Hornby 2011 Main Range
- ^ Tornado as part of a Hornby 2011 Train Pack
- ^ A1 Steam Official Site Tornado Steam Traction Tours, accessed 24 October 2008
- ^ a b A1 Steam Official Site Hiring Tornado, accessed 4 November 2008
- ^ http://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B002VENATQ
- ^ How Do They Do It? Episode 3 demand.five.tv, accessed 18 October 2008
- ^ "Monday 3rd December 2007, segment "Locomotive Gift"". Working Lunch. BBC News. Monday 3 December 2007. Retrieved 22 November 2008.
What about giving your loved one some brass nuts or a part for a steam boiler? Rob meets a bunch of enterprising rail enthusiasts who hope you will consider it.
{{cite news}}
: Check date values in:|date=
(help) - ^ "Private Charter Saturday 25 April 2009 LNER A1 Class 4-6-2 no 60163 Tornado". UKSteam info. undated. Retrieved 25 April 2009.
Steam hauled: Kings Cross-Edinburgh Load: 10 coaches 1Z63 0.0 London Kings Cross d 07.25 60163...105.5 Grantham a 09.07 water 105.5 d 09.20...188.5 York a 10.33 water 188.5 d 11.08...264.6 Tyne Yard a 12.25 water 264.6 d 12.59...335.9 Berwick DGL a 14.12 water 335.9 d 14.25...390.2 Edinburgh Waverley a 15.27
{{cite web}}
: Check date values in:|date=
(help); External link in
(help)|publisher=
Further reading
- Glancey, Jonathan (2010). Tornado: 21st Century Steam. Books on Track. ISBN 978-0-9566770-0-6.
- Townend, Peter (1982). East Coast Pacifics at Work. Ian Allan. ISBN 0-7110-1170-2.
- Nock, O. S. (1984). British Locomotives of the 20th Century, Volume 2: 1930-1960. Patrick Stephens.
- Allatt, Mark (2008 18 Jan.-14 Feb.). "Tornado: countdown to steaming!". Heritage Railway. 107: 24–31.
{{cite journal}}
: Check date values in:|date=
(help) - The Tornado Story, by Tony Streeter. The official Trust book, up to the Great Central Railway
External links
![](http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/thumb/4/4a/Commons-logo.svg/30px-Commons-logo.svg.png)
- Official site
- General information
- LNER encyclopedia
- News editor gets Tornado driving lesson The Daily Mail science section
- Funding model BBC News
- Images
- Preview images of Tornado in LNER Apple Green
- Modified image showing Tornado in BR Apple Green (Steam Railway Magazine)
- Pictures at Newcastle, 18 November 2008 (BBC Tyne)
- Tornado and support coach leaving York on her first mainline test to Scarborough BBC News
- Photo-Library of the A1 Steam Locomotive Trust, with pictures of 'historic A1s' and 'Building Tornado'
- Photo-Library of the A1 Steam Locomotive Trust, with pictures of other types of locomotive, and other railway scenes
- A Flickr group for Tornado photos
- Tornado being loaded at Darlington works for transport to the GCR BBC Tees
- Pictures at Darlington, 1 August 2008 (The Times)
- Audio
- Interview with Ian Howitt of the trust about the construction of Tornado BBC Tees
- Sound clip of the Locomotive hauling The Talisman
- Videos
- Tornado arriving at Newcastle Central Station (BBC Tyne)
- Tornado being offloaded at the NRM on arrival from the GCR The Northern Echo
- Interviews and tour outside the shed at the GCR on arrival, BBC News
- Interview with driver and static tour at Darlington Locomotive Works during first move weekend
- Tour of Tornado half built at Darlington works BBC Tees
- A1 Trust appearance on Working Lunch, 3 December 2007 BBC 2
- Other
- Short editorial on Tornado and Britains love of steam Guardian, 2008
- Long editorial on the project Guardian, 2001