Amendments to the Constitution of Iraq
This article needs to be updated.(January 2023) |
The government of Iraq has established a committee to consider a proposed amendment to the Constitution of Iraq.
Current constitution
[edit]The current Constitution of Iraq was drafted by a committee of the Iraqi Transitional Government. The agreed text was put to a referendum in October 2005. It was approved by 79% of voters and 15 out of 18 governorates.
Agreement to consider amendments
[edit]In an agreement prior to the referendum, the largest Sunni Arab majority party, the Iraqi Islamic Party agreed to support a "Yes" vote as long as the first parliament elected under the constitution agreed to consider amendments. This agreement was written into Article 142 of the constitution.
Procedure
[edit]Article 142 of the constitution states that the Council of Representatives shall form a committee from its members "representing the principal components of the Iraqi society", which should present proposed amendments to the Council within four months.[1] The amendment package shall be voted on as a whole by the council, and if it is passed, put to a referendum, which shall pass if approved by a majority of voters and is not rejected by a two-thirds majority in three or more governorates. The conditions for this referendum are the same as the conditions for the original ratification referendum.
The constitution can also be amended by a general procedure, laid down in Article 126, which requires a two-thirds approval in the Council of Ministers, followed by approval by a simple majority in a referendum.
Committee appointment
[edit]The committee of 27 was appointed on 2006-09-25, chaired by Iraqi Accord Front member Ayad al-Samarrai. The committee comprised 27 members [2][3] drawn from senior politicians across the political spectrum in rough proportions to the Council of Representatives of Iraq that was elected in the Iraqi legislative election of December 2005:
- United Iraqi Alliance (Shiite): 12
- SCIRI and allies:[4]
- Islamic Dawa Party - Iraq Organisation
- Islamic Dawa Party
- Islamic Virtue Party
- independent
- unknown
- Kurdistani Alliance (Kurdish): 5
- Iraqi Accord Front (Sunni Arab): 4
- Iraqi National List (secular): 2
- Iraqi National Dialogue Front: 1
In addition, the representatives of the Turkmen, Mandaeans, and Yazidis were invited to nominate a member each to join the committee [6]
The Iraqi National Dialogue Front has rejected the deal that led to the formation of the committee and has refused to participate.
Amendments proposed
[edit]Seven areas have been identified as areas where one or more of the political forces in Iraq would like to change:[7]
- The ability of constitutional changes to be vetoed by three out of the 19 governorates
- Iraq's Arab identity
- The shape of the federal system
- The status of Kirkuk
- The split of oil revenues between national and regional governments
- The role of Islam
- De-Baathification
Positions
[edit]The main proposed amendments have come from the Sunni Arab majority parties who want to make it more difficult to establish an oil-rich Shiite "super-region" in the south of Iraq[8][9]
However, SCIRI has insisted that the "essence" of the constitution should be maintained and has pushed for the creation of a Shiite Region covering the nine southern governorates. On March 16 Abdul Aziz al-Hakim, the leader of SCIRI proposed a compromise whereby two Regions are created - one in the far South near Basra and one for the middle Euphrates region.[10] The Islamic Virtue Party governor of Basra has expressed support for a Region covering Basrah and its only its two neighbouring governorates of Maysan and Dhiqar.[11] The Sadrist Movement supports a stronger central government, saying that federalism should not be applied to the south "while Iraq is still under occupation".[12]
The National Dialogue Front has asked that the de-Baathification provisions be reworded to "be fair to those that have suffered under this article".[13]
Some Shiite leaders had proposed changing the country's official name to the Islamic Republic of Iraq, a move opposed by Iraq's secularists.[14]
Iraq Study Group
[edit]The Iraq Study Group of senior American politicians recommended that the constitution be amended as follows:[15]
- Oil revenue should accrue wholly to the central government and not split with the regions
- The referendum on Kirkuk joining the Iraqi Kurdistan region should be delayed
Kurdistani Alliance
[edit]The Kurdistani Alliance submitted a working paper in April 2007 with the following proposed changes:
- Iraq to be renamed the "Federal Republic of Iraq"
- Iraqi Kurdistan to have its own representative at the United Nations[16]
Iraqi Accord Front
[edit]The Iraqi Accord Front was reported in July 2007 as seeking the following changes:[17]
- Whilst now accepting the establishment of new Regions of Iraq, it wants the powers of these to be limited
- Deleting references to the religious Hawza of Najaf
- Remove the de-Baathification clauses
- Bringing existing as well as future crude oil fields into the law on oil
- Postponing the Kirkuk status referendum
References
[edit]- ^ Iraqi Constitution, UNESCO
- ^ Iraq Forms Panel on Constitution Changes, The Guardian, 2006-09-25
- ^ Iraqis Reach Temporary Compromise on Federalism, Threats Watch, 2006-09-27
- ^ The Draft Law for the Formation of Regions: A Recipe for Permanent Instability in Iraq?, Historiae, 2006-09-27
- ^ constitution amendments committee formed Archived 2007-09-27 at the Wayback Machine, Niqash, 2006-09-27
- ^ constitution amendments committee formed Archived 2007-09-27 at the Wayback Machine, Niqash, 2006-09-28
- ^ Intractable positions on the constitution Archived 2011-07-19 at the Wayback Machine, Niqash, 2007-09-23, accessed on 2007-10-02
- ^ Iraq forms panel on Constitution Changes, The Guardian, 2006-09-25
- ^ Sunnis back govt talks but say demands must be met, Malaysian Star, 2006-01-22
- ^ US/Iraqi Attack on Samarra Region Parliament Sworn In, Informed Comment, 2006-03-17
- ^ Proposal to divide Iraq into semi-autonomous states gains ground Archived 2006-06-26 at the Wayback Machine, Kurdish Media, 2005-05-25
- ^ Iraq's Federalism Debate Rages On Archived 2006-10-12 at the Wayback Machine, Institute for War and Peace Reporting, 2006-09-26
- ^ the constitutional amendments committee: "crises" at the beginning of the road Archived 2007-07-11 at the Wayback Machine, Niqash, 2006-10-11
- ^ Otterman, Sharon; Beehner, Lionel (27 April 2005). "Iraq: Drafting the Constitution". Council on Foreign Relations. Retrieved 28 December 2019.
- ^ Panel offers recommendations to tackle Iraq's 'dire' plight Archived 2007-09-30 at the Wayback Machine, Turkish Daily News, 2006-12-08
- ^ Security position grabs Iraqi media attention, Al-Mashriq via Iraq Updates, 2007-04-08, accessed on 2007-07-02
- ^ Sectarian disputes delay constitution, Gulf News, 2007-07-09, accessed on 2007-07-09