Curial response to Catholic sexual abuse cases

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search

The Curial response to Catholic sexual abuse cases was a significant part of the Church's response to Catholic sexual abuse cases.

Initial response[edit]

On April 30, 2001, Pope John Paul II issued a letter stating that "a sin against the Sixth Commandment of the Decalogue by a cleric with a minor under 18 years of age is to be considered a grave sin, or 'delictum gravius.'"[1]

John F. Allen Jr., Vatican correspondent for the National Catholic Reporter, has commented that many American Catholics saw the Vatican’s initial silence on the Boston Globe stories as showing a lack of concern or awareness about the issue. However, Allen said that, he doesn't know anyone in the Roman Curia, who was not, in the least, horrified "by the revelations that came out of the Globe and elsewhere" or "would defend Cardinal Law’s handling of the cases in Boston" or "would defend the rather shocking lack of oversight that revealed itself" though "they might have different analyses of what should have happened to him".[2] Allen described the Vatican's perspective as being somewhat skeptical of the media handling of the scandal.

In addition, he asserted that the Vatican viewed American cultural attitudes toward sexuality as being somewhat hysterical as well as exhibiting a lack of understanding of the Catholic Church;

No one [in the Vatican] thinks the sexual abuse of kids is unique to the States, but they do think that the reporting on it is uniquely American, fueled by anti-Catholicism and shyster lawyers hustling to tap the deep pockets of the church. And that thinking is tied to the larger perception about American culture, which is that there is a hysteria when it comes to anything sexual, and an incomprehension of the Catholic Church. What that means is that Vatican officials are slower to make the kinds of public statements that most American Catholics want, and when they do make them they are tentative and halfhearted. It's not that they don't feel bad for the victims, but they think the clamor for them to apologize is fed by other factors that they don't want to capitulate to.[2]

Crimen Sollicitationis controversy[edit]

In 2003, a 1962 document was discovered in the Vatican's archives,[3] titled "Crimen sollicitationis" (Instruction on the Manner of Proceeding in Cases of Solicitation) written by Cardinal Alfredo Ottaviani, the Secretary of the Holy Office, issued an instruction regarding the disciplinary procedures for dealing with solicitation by priests during the Sacrament of Penance.[4] The document dealt with any priest who "tempts a penitent... in the act of sacramental confession... towards impure or obscene matters." It directed that investigation of allegations of solicitation in the confessional and the trials of accused priests be conducted in secrecy.

Some parties interpreted the document to be a directive from the Vatican to keep all allegations of sexual abuse secret, leading to widespread media coverage of its contents.[5][6][7] Lawyers for some of those making abuse allegations claimed that the document demonstrated a systematic conspiracy to conceal such crimes.[8][9] The Vatican responded that the document was not only widely misinterpreted, but moreover had been superseded by more recent guidelines in the 1960s and 1970s, and especially the 1983 Code of Canon Law.[10][11]

2003 Vatican Conference on Sexual Abuse[edit]

In April 2003, the Pontifical Academy for Life organized a three-day conference, entitled "Abuse of Children and Young People by Catholic Priests and Religious", where eight non-Catholic psychiatric experts were invited to speak to near all Vatican dicasteries' representatives. The panel of experts identified the following factors contributing to the sexual abuse problem.[citation needed]

  • Failure by the hierarchy to grasp the seriousness of the problem.
  • Overemphasis on the need to avoid a scandal.
  • Use of unqualified treatment centers.
  • Misguided willingness to forgive.
  • Insufficient accountability.

Papal apologies[edit]

In 2003, Pope John Paul II stated that "there is no place in the priesthood and religious life for those who would harm the young".[12]

Pope Benedict XVI has apologized for the sexual abuse of minors by Catholic clergy.[13]

On July 19, 2008, the Pope made a historic full apology for child sexual abuse by priests and clergymen in Australia. Before a 3,400 congregation assembled in Sydney's St. Mary's Cathedral, Pope Benedict called for compensation and demanded punishment for those guilty of the "evil":

Here I would like to pause to acknowledge the shame which we have all felt as a result of the sexual abuse of minors by some clergy and religious in this country. I am deeply sorry for the pain and suffering the victims have endured and I assure them that, as their pastor, I too share in their suffering. ... Victims should receive compassion and care, and those responsible for these evils must be brought to justice. These misdeeds, which constitute so grave a betrayal of trust, deserve unequivocal condemnation. I ask all of you to support and assist your bishops, and to work together with them in combating this evil. It is an urgent priority to promote a safer and more wholesome environment, especially for young people.

On July 21, he met with two male and two female victims of sexual abuse by priests, listened to their stories and celebrated Mass with them.[14] The Premier of New South Wales Morris Iemma said "Hopefully it will be a sign of righting the wrongs of the past and of a better future and better treatment by the church of the victims and their families."[15][16] The victims' rights advocacy group Broken Rites welcomed the Pope's apology, but expressed disappointment that the Pope had not made his apology directly to sexual abuse victims[17] and criticized the selection of the victims as having been hand-picked to be cooperative.

I'm afraid that what they've done is selected victims who have agreed with what the Church's policies are. The Pope should have met with Anthony Foster, the father of two girls abused by a priest, who cut short a holiday in Britain to return to Australia in the hope of meeting the pontiff.[18][19][20]

In August 2018, Pope Francis apologized in a 2,000 word letter after the release of a grand jury report confirming that over 1,000 children were sexually abused by "predator priests" in Pennsylvania for decades, incidents often covered up by the Church.[21]

"With shame and repentance, we acknowledge as an ecclesial community that we were not where we should have been, that we did not act in a timely manner, realizing the magnitude and the gravity of the damage done to so many lives ... We showed no care for the little ones; we abandoned them ... The heart-wrenching pain of these victims, which cries out to heaven, was long ignored, kept quiet or silenced."

The Pope said the church was developing a "zero tolerance" policy on abuse (which he called "crimes") and cover-ups. Vatican spokesman Greg Burke emphasized that the Pope's apology is not specific to any geographic area. "Pope Francis has written to the people of God and that means everyone."[22]

New rules regarding ordination[edit]

Because a significant majority of victims were teenage boys, the Vatican instituted reforms to prevent future United States abuse by requiring background checks for Church employees[23] and issued new rules disallowing ordination of men with "deep-seated homosexual tendencies".[24][25] They now require dioceses faced with an allegation to alert the authorities, conduct an investigation and remove the accused from duty.[23][26]

UN human rights council in Geneva[edit]

In a statement, read out by Archbishop Silvano Maria Tomasi at a meeting of the UN human rights council in Geneva on 22 September 2009, the Holy See stated that the majority of Catholic clergy who had committed acts of sexual abuse against under 18 year olds should not be viewed as paedophiles but homosexuals who are attracted to sex with adolescent males.

The statement said that rather than pedophilia, it would "be more correct" to speak of ephebophilia; being a homosexual attraction to adolesant males ....... "Of all priests involved in the abuses, 80 to 90% belong to this sexual orientation minority which is sexually engaged with adolescent boys between the ages of 11 and 17."[27][28]

The move angered many gay rights organizations, who claimed it was an attempt by the Vatican to redefine the Church's past problems with pedophilia as problems with homosexuality.[29]

The 2019 Meeting on the Protection of Minors in the Church[edit]

From 21 to 24 February 2019, a four-day Catholic Church summit meeting was held in Vatican City, called the Meeting on the Protection of Minors in the Church (Italian: Incontro su “La Protezione dei Minori nella Chiesa”) with the participation of the presidents of all the episcopal conferences of the world to discuss preventing sexual abuse by Catholic Church clergy.[30]

2019 Vatican norms[edit]

On March 26, 2019, one month after the summit was held,[31] Pope Francis adopted:

According to Andrea Tornielli, these:

are very specific laws, norms and indications destined, first of all, for those to whom they are addressed: in fact, they concern only Vatican City State, where a large number of priests and religious work, but where there are very few children. Although they have been conceived and written for a unique reality, in which the highest religious authority is also the sovereign and legislator, these three documents contain exemplary indications that take into account the most advanced international parameters."[32]

Law No. CCXCVII requiries Vatican City officials, including those in the Roman Curia,[31] and diplomatic personnel of the Holy See, such as the Apostolic Nuncios, to report sex abuse.[33][34][35] Failure to do so can result in a fine of up to 5,000 euros (about $5,600) or, in the case of a Vatican gendarme, up to six months in prison.[33][36] In addition, all crimes related to child abuse, incluning mistreatment, are persecutable “ex officio”, even when the purported victim does not file an official report. The law also extends the statute of limitations to 20-year prescription that, in the case of and offence against a minor, begin to count from on his or her eighteenth birthday. In addition, the Governorate of the Vatican City State is required to set up, within the Vatican Department of Health and Welfare, service to support and assist the victims of abuse, providing them with medical and psychological assistance and informing them of their rights and of how to enforce them.[32]

The motu proprio extends the application of the Vatican law to the Roman Curia and its personnel. It requires that, when recruiting staff, the candidate's suitability to interact with minors must be ascertained.[32]

The Guidelines for the Vicariate of Vatican City are addressed to the canons, parish priests and coadjutors of the two parishes located withing the Vatican, as well as to the priests, deacons and educators of the Saint Pius X Pre-Seminary, to all the religious men and women who reside in the Vatican, and to all those who work within the ecclesial community of the Vicariate of Vatican City. The guidelines require that, in the course of pastoral activites, those persons must always be visible to others when they are in the presence of minors, and that it is strictly forbidden to establish a preferential relationship with a single minor, to address a minor in an offensive way or to engage in inappropriate or sexually allusive conduct, to ask a minor to keep a secret, to photograph or to film a minor without the written consent of his parents. The Vicar of Vatican City has also the obligation to report to the Promoter of Justice any news of abuse that is not manifestly unfounded, and to remove the alleged perpetrator of the abuse from pastoral activities as a precautionary measure. [32]

The Motu Proprio Vos estis lux mundi[edit]

On May 9, 2019, Pope Francis issued the Motu Proprio Vos estis lux mundi [37] requiring both clerics and religious brothers and sisters, including Bishops,[38] throughout the world to report sex abuse cases and sex abuse cover-ups by their superiors.[38][39][40] Under the new Motu Proprio, all Catholic dioceses throughout the world are required to establish stable mechanisms or systems through which people may submit reports of abuse or its cover-up by June 2020.[41] All metropolitan Archdioceses are also required to send reports to the Holy See on the progress of the investigation, whether in their Archdiocese or suffragan dioceses, every 30 days and to complete the investigation within 90 days unless granted an extension.[42] The law is effective for a 3-year experimental period with a vacatio legis of 1 June 2019. According to Canon law professor Kurt Martens:

This new law is without a doubt a rare gift to the entire church and sets, along with the companion Vatican law providing for jail time for any public official of the Vatican who fails to report abuse, an unmistakable new course. The painful, sometimes bitter, experience of the church in the United States and the voices of the faithful worldwide have helped bring about a change in attitude and a change in law. There is no turning back now, and the tone has been set for the future. [43]

Relations between the Vatican and American Catholics[edit]

According to John Allen Jr., Vatican correspondent for the National Catholic Reporter, cultural differences between the Vatican and American Catholics complicated the process of formulating a comprehensive response to the sexual abuse scandal. Allen asserted that the sexual abuse crisis illustrated that "there is a lot about the American culture and the American Church that puzzles people in the Vatican, and there is much about the Vatican that puzzles Americans and English speakers generally."[2]

See also[edit]

Church related:




  1. ^ Gallagher, Delia. "Vatican Study on Sex Abuse". Zenit. Archived from the original on 2012-03-16.
  2. ^ a b c "SCU Conference on the Crisis". Connections. 4 (=4). December 2003. Archived from the original on 2012-07-22.
  3. ^ Bowcott, Owen (18 August 2003). "Row over Vatican order to conceal priests' sex abuse" – via
  4. ^ Crimen sollicitationis (Instruction on the Manner of Proceeding in Cases of Solicitation)
  5. ^ "Hide sex abuse, secret Vatican paper instructs". The Age. 7 August 2003.
  6. ^ August 6, Dan Collins CBS; 2003; Pm, 2:52. "Sex Crimes Cover-Up By Vatican?".
  7. ^ "Manila Times". Archived from the original on 2009-02-10. Retrieved 2010-01-04.
  8. ^ The Guardian,"Row over Vatican order to conceal priests' sex abuse" [1]
  9. ^ "Vatican 'ordered abuse cover-up'". 17 August 2003 – via
  10. ^ America, "Vatican Official Says 1962 Norms on Solicitation No Longer Apply" [2]
  11. ^ Catholic Culture, "CBS news story distorts 1962 Vatican document"
  12. ^ Walsh, John Paul II: A Light for the World (2003), p. 62
  13. ^ Pullella, Philip; Golovnina, Maria (September 18, 2010). "Pope apologizes on abuse as thousands protest in London". Reuters. Retrieved June 29, 2012.
  14. ^ The Australian.2008 [online]. [Accessed 21 July 2008]. Available from World Wide Web:<,25197,24049778-601,00.html>
  15. ^ ", Pope's Australia sex abuse apology not enough -- critics". Archived from the original on 2012-07-29. Retrieved 2010-01-04.
  16. ^ McMahon, Barbara (2008-07-20). "Pope says he is 'deeply sorry' to Australian sexual abuse victims". The Guardian. London. Retrieved 2010-04-30.
  17. ^ "Sexual abuse apology welcomed".
  18. ^ "The Times & The Sunday Times".
  19. ^ Johnston, Tim (22 July 2008). "Pope Meets Australian Abuse Victims" – via
  20. ^ ", Pope meets sex abuse victims as Australia trip ends". Archived from the original on 2012-10-02. Retrieved 2010-01-04.
  21. ^ "Pope apologizes for priest sex abuse scandal with 'sorrow and shame'". NBC News. New York. 2018-08-20. Retrieved 2018-08-21.
  22. ^ "Pope apologizes for priest sex abuse scandal with 'sorrow and shame'". CNN. Atlanta. 2018-08-20. Retrieved 2018-08-21.
  23. ^ a b United States Conference of Catholic Bishops (2005). "Charter for the Protection of Children and Young People". United States Conference of Catholic Bishops. Retrieved 2007-10-08.
  24. ^ Filteau, Jerry (2004). "Report says clergy sexual abuse brought 'smoke of Satan' into church". Catholic News Service. Archived from the original on 2004-06-26. Retrieved 2008-03-10.
  25. ^ Pope Benedict XVI (2005). "Instruction Concerning the Criteria for the Discernment of Vocations with regard to Persons with Homosexual Tendencies in view of their Admission to the Seminary and to Holy Orders". Vatican. Archived from the original on 2008-02-25. Retrieved 2008-03-09.
  26. ^ "Scandals in the church: The Bishops' Decisions; The Bishops' Charter for the Protection of Children and Young People". The New York Times. 2002-06-15. Retrieved 2008-02-12.
  27. ^ Archived 2012-04-20 at the Wayback Machine
  28. ^ Butt, Riazat (2009-09-28). "Sex abuse rife in other religions, says Vatican". The Guardian. London. Retrieved 2010-04-30.
  29. ^ Editor, Editor (30 September 2009). "The Vatican Would Prefer You Refer To Its Molesting Priests as Gay Molesting Priests".
  30. ^ McElwee, Joshua J. (12 September 2018). "Francis summons world's bishop presidents to Rome for meeting on clergy abuse". National Catholic Reporter. Vatican City. Retrieved 24 February 2019.
  31. ^ a b
  32. ^ a b c d Tornielli, Andrea (2019-03-29). "State-of-the-art standards for the protection of minors". Retrieved 2019-05-31.
  33. ^ a b
  34. ^ "Pope Francis issues sexual abuse reporting laws for Vatican City and Holy See diplomats". 2019-03-29. Retrieved 2019-03-29.
  35. ^
  36. ^
  37. ^ FRANCIS. "Apostolic Letter in the form of "Motu Proprio" " "Vos estis lux mundi"". Retrieved 2019-05-11.
  38. ^ a b Telegraph, The Catholic. "President of U.S. Bishops' Conference Issues Statement on Pope Francis's Motu Proprio Ordering Worldwide Response to the Evil of Sexual Abuse".
  39. ^ "Pope Francis issues groundbreaking law requiring priests, nuns to report sex abuse, cover-up". NBC News.
  40. ^ "Pope Francis issues broad new Vatican law on reporting of sexual abuse and cover-up".
  41. ^ Brockhaus, Hannah. "Pope Francis issues norms for reports of abuse of minors, seminarians, and religious". Catholic News Agency.
  42. ^ Tornielli, Andrea (2019-05-09). "New norms for the whole Church against those who abuse or cover up - Vatican News". Retrieved 2019-05-11.
  43. ^ Martens, Kurt (2019-05-10). "Pope Francis' new sex abuse rules are a revolution for the Catholic Church". America Magazine. Retrieved 2019-05-11.