The Gweagal (also spelt Gwiyagal) are a clan of the Dharawal people of Aboriginal Australians.[a] Their descendants are traditional custodians of the southern geographic areas of Sydney, New South Wales, Australia.
The Gweagal lived on the area of the southern side of the Georges River and Botany Bay stretching towards the Kurnell Peninsula. Although not clearly defined, their traditional lands are thought to have possibly extended over much of the Cronulla-Sutherland area as far west as Liverpool.
The Gweagal are the traditional owners of the white clay pits in their territory, which are considered sacred. Historically clay was used to line the base of their canoes so they could light fires, and also as a white body paint, (as witnessed by Captain James Cook). Colour was added to the clay using berries, which produced a brightly coloured paint that was used in ceremonies. It was also eaten as a medicine, an antacid. Geebungs and other local berries were mixed in the clay.
Aboriginal rock shelters
Naturally forming and human-modified caves or hanging rock shelters were regularly utilised by the first Australians during walkabout – seasonally guided maintenance of land and the vast natural gardens routinely tended by the Aboriginal people.
In the Royal National Park some of the caves were used as burial sites. In tribal lands and Dreamtime places this cultural practice continues. Charles Sturt documented large stone dwellings consisting of four rooms or more, along the banks of the Murray River and the shores of Lake Victoria, New South Wales. These buildings were re-purposed by settlers in the early years of colonisation, and the foundations of many such buildings can be seen in archaeological sites around Australia.
Caves and shelters are located in various places along the Georges River, which over the years have eroded into the sandstone cliffs. There is a large cave located in Peakhurst with its ceiling blackened from smoke. There are caves located around Evatt Park, Lugarno with oyster shells ground into the cave floor. A cave has also been discovered near a Baptist church in Lugarno, and another near Margaret Crescent, Lugarno (now destroyed by development), which was found to contain ochre and a spearhead on the floor of the cave when it was excavated. Another cave exists on Mickey's Point, Padstow, which was named after a local Gweagal man.
Australia's First Nation people decorated their caves and homes with carvings, sculpture, beads, paintings, drawings and etchings using white, red and other coloured earth, clay or charcoal. Symbols such as "water well" with a red ochre hand directed newcomers to wells and water storage. Footprints on a line signalled that there were stairs or steps in the area. The dwellings boasted thermal mass unlike modern day housing, which kept an even temperature year-round. Rugs, furs and woven mats provided further warmth and comfort. Fire was used to cook, produce materials and keep their shelters warm.
The territory of the Gweagal had much to offer. The Georges River provided fish and oysters. Various small creeks, most of which are now covered drains, provided fresh water. Men and women fished in canoes or from the shore using barbed spears and fishing lines with hooks that were crafted from crescent-shaped pieces of shell. Waterfowl could be caught in the swamplands near Towra Point and the variety of soils supported a variety of edible and medicinal plants. Birds and their eggs, possums, wallabies and goannas were also a part of their staple diet. The abundant food source meant that these natives were less nomadic than those of Outback Australia.
Middens have been found all the way along tidal sections of the Georges River where shells, fish bones, and other waste products have been thrown into heaps. These, as well as environmental modifications such as dams, building foundations, large earthen excavations and wells, gives evidence of where the Gweagal established villages for long periods, and are found where oysters, fresh water, and strategic views come together. Middens have been found in Oatley, and Oatley Point was known as a feasting ground. In Lugarno a midden is still existent and may be found in Lime Kiln Bay.
First contact with Europeans
The Gweagal first made visual contact with Cook and other Europeans on the 29 April 1770 in the area which is now known as "Captain Cook's Landing Place", in the Kurnell area of Kamay Botany Bay National Park. It was the first attempt made, on Cook's first voyage, in the Endeavour, to make contact with the Aboriginal people of Australia.
In sailing into the bay they had noted two Gweagal men posted on the rocks, brandishing spears and fighting sticks, and a group of four too intent on fishing to pay much attention to the ship's passage. Using a telescope as they lay offshore, approximately a kilometre from an encampment consisting of 6–8 gunyahs, Joseph Banks recorded observing an elderly woman come out of the bush, with at first three children in tow, then another three, and light a fire. While busying herself, she looked at the ship at anchor without showing any perplexity. She was joined by the four fishermen, who brought their catch to be cooked.
After an hour and a half, Cook, Banks, Daniel Solander and Tupaia, together with 30 of the crew, made for the beach, only to be threatened by two warriors. They threw some gifts on shore, trying to get over the idea they had come to seek fresh water, but the Gweagal men reacted with hostile diffidence. Cook felt it necessary to encourage a change of attitude by shooting one of the men in the leg with light shot. Unperturbed, the wounded man retrieved a shield from a gunyah before returning. By that time the crew had already beached their boat.
The sailors then proceeded to walk onto the beach and up to an encampment. Both Cook and Banks tried, with great difficulty, to make contact with the local people but without success due to the Gweagal avoiding further contact after the first encounter. They simply went about their daily affairs, seeming to ignore the strangers; they fished from canoes, cooked shellfish on the shore and walked along the beach, but at the same time, watched Cook's crew with caution.
The Gweagal Spears and Shield
In 1770, after returning to England from their voyage in the South Pacific, Cook and Banks brought with them a large collection of flora and fauna, along with cultural artefacts from their most recent venture. The find included a collection of roughly fifty Aboriginal spears that belonged to the Gweagal people. Banks was convinced the spears were abandoned (on the shores of Kurnell) and "thought it no improper measure to take with them all the lances which they could find, somewhere between 40 or 50".
According to Peter Turbet, four of these spears still exist: two bone-tipped three-pronged spears (mooting), one bone-tipped four-pronged spear (calarr) and a shaft with a single hardwood head – the only material reminder of this first contact. Cook gave the spears to his patron, John Montagu, First Lord of the Admiralty and Fourth Earl of Sandwich, who then gave them, to his alma mater Trinity College at the University of Cambridge in England. Archaeologists quote them as being priceless, as the spears are among the few remaining artefacts that can be traced back to Cook's first voyage. Although the Gweagal Spears remain in the ownership of Trinity College, they are now on display at the Museum of Archaeology and Anthropology at the University of Cambridge.
An Aboriginal shield held by the British Museum had until 2018 been described by the Museum as most likely the bark shield dropped by an Aboriginal warrior (identified in Gweagal tradition as Cooman), who was shot in the leg by Cook's landing party on 29 April 1770. The shield was lent to the National Museum of Australia in Canberra for an exhibition called Encounters: Revealing stories of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander objects from the British Museum, from November 2015 to March 2016. Rodney Kelly, sixth-generation descendant of Cooman, went to see the exhibition and immediately started a campaign for the return of the shield, along with the spears in held in Cambridge. Regarded as stolen objects of cultural significance, Kelly said that "the shield is the most significant and potent symbol of imperial aggression – and subsequent Indigenous self-protection and resistance – in existence".
In April 2016, the British Museum offered to display the shield in Australia on a loan, but its permanent return was the only acceptable outcome for the Gweagal people. In 2016 the NSW Legislative Council and the Australian Senate passed motions supporting Kelly's claims. Kelly made several crowdfunded trips to the UK, and included a trip to Germany in 2016. On this trip, Kelly discovered that the Ethnological Museum of Berlin holds another shield also said to be connected to Cook's 1770 visit to Botany Bay.
In November 2016, the British Museum began investigating the provenance of the shield held by them. They held a workshop involving various experts, including curators from both the British and Australian Museums, academics from the Royal Armouries, Cambridge and the Australian National University, and two Aboriginal representatives from La Perouse (the location of Cook's landing site). The participants examined the species of wood, other shields held by the British Museum, museum records and catalogue, and old colonial shipping records. The results of the workshop were reported by Maria Nugent and Gaye Sculthorpe, an Aboriginal curator at the museum, and published in Australian Historical Studies in 2018. The study discussed the origin of the shield, concluding that its history may never be completely settled.[b] Nicholas Thomas, director and curator of the Museum of Archaeology and Anthropology at Cambridge, in his article in the same issue of AHS, also examined the provenance of the shield, concluding that it is not the shield taken from Botany Bay in April 1770. Testing of the shield found that its wood is red mangrove, which can only be obtained at least 400 kilometres (250 mi) north of Botany Bay. The hole in the shield was "inspected by a firearms specialist and examined for traces of lead", with the conclusion that it was not caused by a bullet.
Historian and archivist Mike Jones of the eScholarship Research Centre of the University of Melbourne and ANU School of History, while not disputing the outcome of the workshop or Thomas' claim, has challenged the use of purely European sources and perspectives to provide the provenance Indigenous artefacts, saying that the shield has become a "cultural touchstone". Sarah Keenan, Leverhulme Fellow and senior lecturer at Birkbeck College Law School in London, said that Indigenous perspectives and methodologies were not used in the workshop, and a different conclusion may have been reached, or other knowledge gained about its significance, had such methods been applied. Thomas himself said that the fact that the shield is not the one represented in the story of the Gweagal Shield does not mean that it should not be repatriated, and its symbolism to all Indigenous Australians should not lose its power. The discussion around the shield is part of a growing movement for the decolonisation of museums in the UK and around the world.
Return of spears
Three of the spears were sent from Cambridge to the National Museum of Australia for the exhibition entitled Endeavour Voyage: The Untold Stories of Cook and the First Australians, from 2 June 2020 to 26 April 2021. The La Perouse Local Aboriginal Land Council and La Perouse Aboriginal Community Alliance worked with the Cambridge museum towards repatriation of the three spears, and on 30 April 2021 it was announced that plans had been made to return the spears to Country.
- Biddy Giles, or Biyarrung, (b.1820-died ca 1890s) was a Gweagal woman who lived throughout her life on traditional Gweagal land, and frequently impressed whites who employed her as a guide by her profound knowledge of the botany and landscape. She was a fluent Dharawal speaker.
- Rodney Kelly (born 1977) is a Gweagal activist campaigning for the return of a shield held by the British Museum, as well as other Indigenous Australian artefacts in museums across Europe and Australia.
- Lawrence 1999, p. 2.
- Goodall & Cadzow 2009, p. 31.
- Goodall & Cadzow 2009, p. 87.
- McGuinness n.d.
- Captain Cook's Landing Place.
- Turbet 2011, p. 9.
- Turbet 2011, pp. 9–10.
- Banks 1770.
- Turbet 2011, p. 10.
- SMH 2002.
- Thomas 2018, pp. 4–27.
- Keenan 2018.
- NMA Botany Bay.
- NMA Encounters.
- Daley 2016.
- Keenan 2016.
- Voon 2017.
- MAA: Nicholas Thomas.
- Lauder 2018.
- Fennell & Wiggins 2021.
- ANU School of History 2019.
- Jones 2019, pp. 884–897.
- UoTS: Keenan 2017.
- Miller 2019.
- Brennan 2019.
- Google Scholar.
- Silva 2021.
- NMoA: Endeavour 2020.
- Goodall & Cadzow 2009, pp. 80–108.
- Malvern 2018.
- "Aboriginal History". Sutherland Shire.
- Banks, Sir Joseph (28 April 1770). "Banks's Journal: Daily Entries". National Library of Australia, South Seas Collection. Retrieved 18 September 2020.
- "Botany Bay, New South Wales: Gweagal and Bidjigal country". National Museum of Australia. Retrieved 3 May 2019.
- Brennan, Bridget (10 May 2019). "The battle at the British Museum for a 'stolen' shield that could tell the story of Captain Cook's landing". ABC News (Australian Broadcasting Corporation). Retrieved 14 September 2020.
- "Captain Cook's Landing Place". NSW National Parks and Wildlife Service. Retrieved 9 June 2019.
- Daley, Paul (25 September 2016). "The Gweagal shield and the fight to change the British Museum's attitude to seized artefacts". The Guardian. Retrieved 3 May 2019.
- "Decolonisation of museums". Google Scholar. Retrieved 14 September 2020.
- "Encounters". National Museum of Australia. Retrieved 3 May 2019.
- "Endeavour Voyage". National Museum of Australia. 8 April 2020. Retrieved 7 May 2021.
- Fennell, Marc; Wiggins, Nick (25 January 2021). "A shield, some spears, and the symbolism people find in the stuff the British stole". ABC News. Retrieved 26 January 2021.
- Goodall, Heather; Cadzow, Allison (2009). Rivers and Resilience: Aboriginal People on Sydney's Georges River. University of New South Wales Press. ISBN 978-1-921-41074-1.
- Jones, Michael (14 March 2019). "Collections in the Expanded Field: Relationality and the Provenance of Artefacts and Archives". Heritage. 2 (1): 884–897. doi:10.3390/heritage2010059.
- Keenan, Sarah (11 November 2016). "Give back the Gweagal shield". Critical Legal Thinking. Interview with Rodney Kelly, Vincent Forrester and Roxley Foley. Retrieved 3 May 2019.
- Keenan, Sarah (18 May 2018). "How the British Museum Changed its Story About the Gweagal Shield". Australian Critical Race and Whiteness Studies Association. Archived from the original on 27 September 2020. Retrieved 14 September 2020.
- Lauder, Simon (23 July 2018). "No evidence Aboriginal shield taken by Captain Cook: British Museum". ABC Radio. Retrieved 3 May 2019.
- Lawrence, Joan (1999). A Pictorial History of Canterbury Bankstown. Kingsclear Books. ISBN 978-0-908-27255-6.
- Malvern, Jack (8 December 2018). "250 years on, Captain James Cook's foes want their shield back". The Times. ISSN 0140-0460. Retrieved 29 March 2019.
- McGuinness, Tim (n.d.). "Aussie People – Aborigines – Use of Caves". McGuinnessPublishing. Archived from the original on 29 August 2008.[self-published source]
- McKenna, Mark (2018). Moment of Truth: History and Australia's Future. Quarterly Essay 69. Black. ISBN 978-1-743-82037-7.
- "Michael Jones". ANU School of History. 15 July 2019. Retrieved 14 September 2020.
- Miller, Nick (11 May 2019). "The gripping story of the Gweagal Shield". The Sydney Morning Herald. Retrieved 14 September 2020.
- Nugent, Maria; Sculthorpe, Gaye (2018). "A Shield Loaded with History: Encounters, Objects and Exhibitions". Australian Historical Studies. 49 (1): 28–43. doi:10.1080/1031461X.2017.1408663. S2CID 149036662.
- "Once were warriors". The Sydney Morning Herald. 11 November 2002. Retrieved 3 May 2019.
- "Professor Nicholas Thomas: Director & Curator". The Museum of Archaeology and Anthropology, Cambridge. Retrieved 14 September 2020.
- Shoebridge, David (3 November 2016). "Supporting the repatriation of the Gweagal Shield". Retrieved 3 May 2019.[self-published source?]
- Silva, Nadine (29 April 2021). "Historic Gweagal spears stolen at First Contact are repatriated back to Eora-Sydney". NITV. Retrieved 7 May 2021.
- Thomas, Nicholas (2018). "A Case of Identity: The Artefacts of the 1770 Kamay (Botany Bay) Encounter". Australian Historical Studies. 49:1: 4–27. doi:10.1080/1031461X.2017.1414862. S2CID 149069484 – via ResearchGate.
- Tindale, Norman Barnett (1974). "Eora (NSW)". Aboriginal Tribes of Australia: Their Terrain, Environmental Controls, Distribution, Limits, and Proper Names. Australian National University.
- Turbet, Peter (2011). The First Frontier. Rosenberg Publishing. ISBN 978-1-922-01300-2.
- "Visiting Academic Research Seminar: Dr Sarah Keenan". University of Technology Sydney. 25 September 2017. Retrieved 14 September 2020.
- Voon, Claire (19 June 2017). "Why an Indigenous Australian Wants the British Museum to Return His Ancestor's Shield". Hyperallergic. Retrieved 3 May 2019.
- Keenan, Sarah (7 November 2017). Special issue: The Pop-Up Museum of Legal Objects. "Northern Ireland Legal Quarterly". Northern Ireland Legal Quarterly. 68 (3): 283–290. Article by Keenan here.
- Kohen, J. L. (1993). The Darug and their neighbours: The traditional Aboriginal owners of the Sydney region. Darug Link in association with the Blacktown and District Historical Society. ISBN 978-0-646-13619-6. (Trove and Worldcat entries)