People United Means Action
||This article needs to be updated. (May 2009)|
U.S. Secretary of State
U.S. Senator from New York
First Lady of the United States
"People United Means Action" (or PUMA) was a political action committee in the United States that opposed the Democratic Party leadership and the nomination of Senator Barack Obama as the Democratic candidate for President in the 2008 presidential election. PUMA began as an effort by supporters of Senator Hillary Rodham Clinton who believed that Clinton should have been the Democratic nominee. According to PUMA, "We [were] protesting the 2008 Presidential election because we refuse to support a nominee who was selected by the leadership rather than elected by the voters."
On May 11, 2011, the PUMA PAC was stripped of its status as a recognized Political Action Committee for failure to meet reporting requirements.
The PUMA PAC registered as a non-affiliated political action committee (PAC) with the Federal Election Commission and organized as a 527 Organization with the IRS in June 2008.[better source needed] PUMA's founders state that the group originated out of online comments of a group of Clinton supporters on a pro-Clinton blog, The Confluence, which was created by New Jersey biochemist and former John Edwards supporter Riverdaughter, who had been recently banned from a pro-Obama liberal blog. The website ClintonsForMcCain.com was, however, registered by the Republican National Committee on May 15, 2008, well in advance of Clinton's concession speech.
PUMA is also part of a coalition of online activists with similar goals, the JustSayNoDeal coalition. The PUMA acronym as originally coined stood for "Party Unity My Ass", but the PAC was registered as "People United Means Action," a backronym. Executive Director Darragh Murphy estimates that PUMA PAC proper had gathered over 10,000 members and the organization's official site had received more than a million hits between its founding in June through August 2008. Dianne Mantouvalos, founder of the larger JustSayNoDeal coalition, estimates the coalition comprises over 100 groups, and accounted for more than 10% of the 18,000,000 votes Clinton received in the primaries.
Will Bower, a media spokesperson for PUMA and JustSayNoDeal, summarized many of PUMA's objections to the actions of the Democratic Party during the 2008 presidential primaries. PUMA's stated beliefs were that Obama was selected undemocratically by the party leadership rather than by Democratic voters, and that Obama was unfairly advantaged by the ruling by the Rules and Bylaws Committee on seating Florida and Michigan delegates.
PUMA members pointed to charges that the media directed sexism and misogyny at Clinton during the primary campaign and expressed anger at Democratic Party leaders' failure to speak out against that or otherwise respond appropriately. After the primaries, while focusing none of his comments on Obama, DNC Chairman Howard Dean did criticize the media, saying, "The media took a very sexist approach to Senator Clinton's campaign" in response to hearing objections from what he described as a "cross-section of women, from individual voters to powerful politicians and chief executives."
Some media and online commentators used the term PUMA to describe any Clinton primary voter who did not support Obama's nomination or the Democratic Party leadership, regardless of PAC affiliation.
PUMA's protest actions during the 2008 election took several forms, including encouraging a Clinton write-in campaign for the general election, voting for no presidential candidate, or supporting other candidates such as U.S. Senator John McCain (R–AZ). Some hoped that enough superdelegates would change their minds to give Clinton the nomination at the Democratic National Convention in August. Other expressed desires were to help defeat Obama in the general election by electing McCain president in order to set up another run for Clinton in 2012, or that Clinton run as an independent candidate in the election. Some have noted that the Internet fostered the organization. Many PUMA advocates are part of the blogosphere and use it for organization, advocacy and viral communication.
PUMA advocated for an open convention in which Clinton's name would be placed in nomination and her delegates allowed to vote for her, The allied organization The Denver Group spearheaded an ad-based media campaign advocating for an open nomination convention including placing Clinton's name in nomination, allowing speeches in support and a roll-call vote. The campaign emphasized a connection between historical events and the 2008 convention, calling on DNC Chairman Howard Dean and Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi to "follow fair and honest application of the democratic process and according to democratic principles" and resist turning "the convention into a coronation."
PAC members were among the groups protesting the 2008 Democratic National Convention.
Organizers, co-founders and associated movements
Darragh Murphy, Executive Director of PUMA PAC, created the organization in June 2008, saying that her website's immediate goal was "to let the party know, let the leadership know that millions and millions of us are not going to support Obama, that we believe the nomination process was flawed beyond belief, that it was unfair and biased."[not in citation given] According to one reporter who interviewed her, "Murphy ... believes that the only way to save the Democratic Party at this point was to destroy it. Mr. Obama must lose, and his supporters must be purged." But Murphy had characterized PUMA PAC's goals as "not an organized effort to leave the Democratic Party, but to get it back, to bring real unity to the party. Millions of voters are still very unhappy. We're going to still be here on November 5."
Diane Mantouvalos, who also founded HireHeels.com, a website trying to involve women in politics, founded “Just Say No Deal.com” along with Peter Boykin (creator of the slogan for the domain name), Will Bower, Cristi Adkins, Amy Goldman, Anne Franklin, Robin Carlson, and Thuc Ngyuen after Hillary Clinton announced the suspension of her campaign. Just Say No Deal was a coalition of groups, including PUMA, advocating against Obama as the nominee.
Christi Adkins, along with Anne Franklin, Peter Boykin and other Clinton supporters, created Clintons4McCain.com.
Clintons4McCain's group membership intended to vote for McCain in November 2008, and believed that he would be a tolerable president. Adkins and Franklin were interviewed on Third Rail Radio, Fox News on multiple occasions about PUMA's mission. Adkins and Bowers and other PUMAs appeared on The Daily Show with Jon Stewart during the convention.
PUMA has been criticized for its support of Republican candidates John McCain and Sarah Palin, especially considering the sharp policy differences between the Republican ticket and Hillary Clinton; this left the organization open to charges that it supported the McCain campaign solely out of spite, with no concern for whether a McCain victory would actually advance Hillary's policy agenda.
Some Democrats argued that the organization's goals contradicted Clinton's stated views, and PUMA's lack of support from Clinton herself undermined its credibility. On CNN's Situation Room, Clinton said, "I'm going to do everything I can to make sure that anyone who supported me... understands what a grave error it would be not to vote for Senator Obama." PUMA suggested that Clinton was not sincere in endorsing Obama, but was simply trying to avoid damage to her position in the party. One Democratic state committeewoman who said she supported Clinton, and whose attitude was "Enough with this PUMA stuff," said: "It's not like it's 'Rah rah Obama'. No. But he was our candidate...."
Patti Higgins, the Chair of the Alaska Democratic Party, wrote to a PUMA supporter: "Having Senator Clinton’s name on a roll call without having the votes would just embarrass her, waste time, and make people agonize over nothing. I find it difficult to believe that this organization was not an undercover McCain operation." On August 14, 2008, Clinton and Obama issued a joint news release stating that Clinton's name would be put into nomination and a roll-call vote held at the convention, in response to calls from Clinton supporters. Clinton previously stated at a fundraiser: "[I] believe that we will come out stronger if people feel that their voices were heard and their views were respected. I think that was a very big part of how we actually come out unified."
Amanda Marcotte of Pandagon had accused PUMA of being a front for McCain advocacy, pointing to Darragh Murphy's financial support of McCain in February 2000. Murphy admitted having donated to McCain, stating that the donation was to help defeat George W. Bush in the primary. She said she voted for Al Gore in the general election, although she did not donate to his campaign, and said she was "devastated when Bush stole the election". According to the Huffington Post's Fundrace 2008, Murphy had donated $850 to Clinton's presidential campaign through Q3 2008. Marcotte's accusation omits Murphy's campaign contributions to Clinton. FEC records show a $200 donation to WomenCount PAC by Murphy in June 2008. Bower rejects the claims of Marcotte and others: "People have been trying to paint this as a Trojan horse, you know, as though I'm a Republican, that this was a Republican strategy... No, that's not it at all. From dog-catcher to president, I've voted Democrat."
Clinton supporter Representative Debbie Wasserman Schultz (D-FL) argued that while she saw why many subscribed to the "PUMA attitude", she argued that for "reproductive rights, the economy and a range of other issues, the only choice was Obama", and that voting for McCain, or letting him win by default, was worse than not having Clinton as the nominee. Speaker of the U.S. House of Representatives Nancy Pelosi stated that PUMAs and other Clinton supporters "have been less than gracious" for their continuing refusal to support Obama.
DNC Rules and Bylaws Committee co-chairman James Roosevelt disputed the claim that the Michigan–Florida delegate decision was in any way preordained to favor Obama. He argued that Party rules and regulations were "followed and interpreted fairly," saying that there were allegations of impropriety in the Texas caucuses, but only one complaint was filed with a delegate.
After McCain's defeat in the general election many commentators from both sides of the political spectrum accused PUMA of essentially misrepresenting their influence or numbers, as exit polls showed that Obama won over 90% of the Democratic vote, a larger percentage than the previous Democratic nominee, John Kerry.
Among the anti-PUMA blogs, StupidPumas! was easily the least restrained, accusing the group of both overt and covert racism, duplicity, and even fraud. StupidPumas! posted copies of official letters sent to PUMA-PAC from the Federal Election Commission, demanding the filing of long-overdue financial reports.
In 2009, Los Angeles filmmakers Brad Mays and Lorenda Starfelt finished work on their feature-length political documentary The Audacity of Democracy, which followed the 2008 race for the Democratic presidential nomination and focused in particular on PUMA. Shot from June through September 2008, Mays and Starfelt filmed interviews and political activity in Los Angeles, Princeton, Dallas, Austin, Washington, D.C., Chicago, New York City and at the 2008 Democratic National Convention in Denver, Colorado. Mays came under almost immediate fire from pro-Obama groups, citing conflict of interest due to the production having been financed by PUMA-PAC itself. Mays acknowledged these concerns but maintained that his film would be an objective account of what he saw and heard during the primary. About a week before the convention, all of Mays's camera equipment was stolen en route to Chicago. Most of the gear was eventually replaced, but the crucial Chicago shoot was seriously compromised. When Mays decided to film interviews with Internet journalist Tommy Christopher, an outspoken PUMA critic, the rank and file of the PUMA movement quickly denounced the filmmaker, distancing themselves from the entire project.
In multiple subsequent Blog-Radio interviews, Mays has expressed extreme dissatisfaction with the finished film, revealing that he had not been allowed to complete shooting in the manner originally agreed to, and adding that many of the PUMA members who had decided to switch their support from Clinton to McCain did not care for the way their newfound Republican leanings played onscreen.
- Abrahams, Tom (2008-07-14). "What'a P.U.M.A.?". ABC 13 VOTE08. Retrieved 2008-07-20.
- Preston, Mark (2008-07-23). "Preston on Politics: PUMAs Stalking Obama". CNN Political Ticker. Retrieved 2008-08-16.
- King, Allison (2008-06-24). "Obama, Clinton might not find united party". NECN. Retrieved 2008-07-01.
- Archer, Lincoln (2008-06-10). "Party Unity, My Ass group shows Obama's fight ahead". News.com.au.
- Federal Election Commission (2011-05-11). "FEC Campaign Finance reports and data". Federal Election Commission. Retrieved 2011-06-07.
- PUMA PAC.
- Riverdaughter. "Monday: PUMA Power". Retrieved 2008-07-20.
- Riverdaughter. "Ladies and Gentlemen, You Are Looking Fine Today!". Retrieved 2008-08-02.
- Stirland (2008-06-05). "In Appeal to Angry Clinton Voters, Republicans Prep ClintonsForMcCain.com". Wired. Retrieved 2010-02-28.
- Merida, Kevin (June 27, 2008). "Hill, Yes! O., No!". Washington Post. Retrieved 2008-07-01.
- Burkeman, Oliver (June 7, 2008). "'Party Unity, My Ass' - what the Pumas really stand for". The Guardian. London. Retrieved 2008-07-01.
- Costa, Robert (2008-08-17). "Political Diary: Darragh vs. the Obamabots". The Wall Street Journal. Retrieved 2008-08-17.
- "Party Unity, My Ass". Fox News. June 9, 2008.
- Cocco, Marie (2008-05-15). "Misogyny I Won't Miss". Washington Post. Retrieved 2008-07-29.
- Stephen, Andrew (2008-05-22). "Hating Hillary". New Statesman. Retrieved 2008-07-29.
- Erbe, Bonnie (2008-06-09). "Obama and the Democrats Owe Hillary Clinton and Her Supporters a Formal Apology for the Campaign's Sexism". US News & World Report. Retrieved 2008-07-29.
- Katherine Q. Seelye & Julie Bosman (2008-06-13). "Media Charged with Sexism in Clinton Coverage". New York Times. Retrieved 2008-08-06.
- Traister, Rebecca (2008-06-23). "Why Clinton Voters Say They Won't Support Obama". Salon. Retrieved 2008-08-31.
- "WriteinHillary". Retrieved 2008-07-29.
- "McCain Dem/Clinton Republican". Retrieved 2008-07-29.
- "Clintons4McCain". Retrieved 2008-07-29.
- Saul, Michael (June 12, 2008). "Hillary Clinton fanatics keep fight alive". New York Daily News.
- Niedowski, Erika (June 7, 2008). "Clinton supporters vow to fight on". The National. Retrieved 2008-07-01.
- Democratic National Committee (2006-08-19). "Delegate Selection Rules for the 2008 Democratic National Convention" (PDF). Democratic National Committee. p. 16. Retrieved 2008-01-21.
- Wheaton, Sarah (2008-07-23). "The Caucus: Clinton Supporters Try One More Tack". The New York Times. Retrieved 2008-08-18.
- "The Denver Group". Retrieved 2008-08-18.
- Horowitz, Jason (2008-08-12). "Defiant Clinton Women Refuse to Support Obama". The News York Observer. Retrieved 2008-08-16.
- "Will Howard Dean and the DNC turn the Democratic Party into the Boston Tea Party?". The Denver Group. Retrieved 2008-08-28.
- Chozick, Amy (2008-08-12). "Pro-Clinton Force Plans Protest in Denver". The Wall Street Journal. Washington Times. Retrieved 2008-08-15.
- Horowitz, Jason (August 12, 2008). "Defiant Clinton Women Refuse To Support Obama". The New York Observer.
- Parker, Jennifer (2008-06-26). "Clinton Supporters Protest Outside Obama Finance Meeting in DC". ABC News, Political Radar. Retrieved 2008-08-16.
- Clintons4McCain.com About us
- Member of Clintons for Cristi Adkins, Speaks. Fox News, June 11, 2008.
- Daum, Meghan (2008-08-30). "A few PUMAs on the loose". Los Angeles Times.
- "Visible Vote '08". Visiblevote08.logoonline.com. Retrieved 2012-01-05.
- Clinton: It'd be 'terrible mistake' to pick McCain over Obama May 14, 2008 CNN
- Benjamin, Elizabeth (August 24, 2008). "The Anti-Pumas". Daily News.
- "Why Are These People In Charge?". PUMAPac.org. July 28, 2008. Retrieved 2008-07-29.
- Kate Snow; Jake Tapper; Jennifer Parker (2008-08-14). "Dem's Deal: Hillary Gets Convention Vote". ABC News. Retrieved 2008-08-16.
- "Clinton, Obama Deal Could Let Supporters Disrupt Convention". Fox News. 2008-08-14. Retrieved 2008-08-16.
- "Donor Lookup". OpenSecrets.org. Retrieved 2008-07-01.
- "pandagon.net". pandagon.net. Retrieved 2012-01-05.
- Abrahams, Tom (2008-06-23). "P.U.M.A. Passion". ABC 13 VOTE08. Retrieved 2008-07-29.
- Huffington Post Donations Search Fundrace 2008
- "Official FEC Search". Retrieved 2010-10-06.
- Tomasic, John (2008-07-18). "Hell No: P.U.M.A. Spokesman Will Bower on Post-Clinton Party Unity". Huffington Post. Retrieved 2008-07-20.
- Mooney, Alexander (2008-08-14). "Pelosi Not Happy with Some Clinton Backers". CNN Political Ticker. Retrieved 2008-08-16.
- "Defining PUMA for the few who are interested". Stupid Pumas. Retrieved 2012-01-05.
- "Federal Election Commission official letter to PUMA-Pac". Retrieved 2012-01-05.
- "Brad Mays". Internet Movie Database. Retrieved 2008-08-06.
- Powers, Kirsten (2008-08-27). "HILLARY'S HELLIONS". New York Post.
- Horowitz, Jason (2011-12-30). "Clinton's Wishes Don't Spoil PUMA's Fun | The New York Observer". Observer.com. Retrieved 2012-01-05.
- Drake, Bruce. "Politics Daily online article, written by Tommy Christopher, discussing Brad Mays' film ''The Audacity of Democracy". Politicsdaily.com. Retrieved 2012-01-05.
- "Independence Day in Philadelphia the Cradle of Independence". Blog Talk Radio. 2009-07-05. Retrieved 2012-01-05.
- "Central Presents The Audacity of Democracy 01/24 by TheDameTruth". Blog Talk Radio. 2009-01-25. Retrieved 2012-01-05.