Jump to content

Balhae: Difference between revisions

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Content deleted Content added
Deiaemeth (talk | contribs)
No edit summary
Appleby (talk | contribs)
No edit summary
Line 31: Line 31:


== Characterization and political interpretation==
== Characterization and political interpretation==
Controversy rests over the ethnic makeup of the people of Balhae. That Balhae was founded by a former general from Goguryeo is undisputed, but his ethnicity is, due to ambiguous wording in historical sources. In addition, no known historical records from Balhae survive to this day, further complicating the issue. This issue is an important subject in modern Korean nationalism, because later Korean states claim succession from Balhae as well as its heritage and history. Thus, claims that the people of Balhae were not Korean would hold serious repercussions for this worldview.
Controversy rests over the ethnic makeup of the people of Balhae. That Balhae was founded by a former general from Goguryeo is undisputed, but some Chinese scholars dispute his ethnicity. No historical records from Balhae survive.


In modern North and South Korea, Balhae is regarded as a Korean state and is positioned in the "North-South Period" (with Silla) today, although such a view has had proponents in the past. They emphasize its connection with Goguryeo and minimize that with the Mohe. While South Korean historians think the ethnicity ruling class was of Goguryeo and the commoners were [[Mohe]], North Korean historians think Balhae ethnography was mostly Goguryeo.
In modern North and South Korea, Balhae is regarded as a Korean state and is positioned in the "North-South Period" (with Silla) today, although such a view has had proponents in the past. They emphasize its connection with Goguryeo and minimize that with the Mohe. While South Korean historians think the ethnicity ruling class was of Goguryeo and the commoners were [[Mohe]], North Korean historians think Balhae ethnography was mostly Goguryeo.


Chinese historians consider Balhae a vassal of the Tang Dynasty: the succession of Balhae kings had to be sanctioned by the Tang Dynasty, and a heir who lacks this sanction can only be known as 知國務 ("State Affairs Leader"), not king; also, every king was also simultaneously the Prefect of Huhan Prefecture (忽汗州都督府都督). Chinese historians consider Balhae to be composed of the Balhae ethnic group, which was mostly based on the Mohe. Historically, the Jurchens (later renamed the [[Manchus]], considered themselves as sharing ancestry with the Mohe (Malgal), and the [[People's Republic of China]] continues to consider Balhae as part of the history of its ethnic Manchus. [http://www.china.org.cn/e-groups/shaoshu/shao-2-manchu.htm]
Chinese historians consider Balhae a vassal of the Tang Dynasty: the succession of Balhae kings had to be sanctioned by the Tang Dynasty, and a heir who lacks this sanction can only be known as 知國務 ("State Affairs Leader"), not king; also, every king was also simultaneously the Prefect of Huhan Prefecture (忽汗州都督府都督). Chinese historians consider Balhae to be composed of the Balhae ethnic group, which was mostly based on the Mohe. Historically, the Jurchens (later renamed the [[Manchus]], considered themselves as sharing ancestry with the Mohe (Malgal), and the [[People's Republic of China]] continues to consider Balhae as part of the history of its ethnic Manchus. [http://www.china.org.cn/e-groups/shaoshu/shao-2-manchu.htm] [http://books.google.com/books?ie=UTF-8&hl=en&vid=ISBN0631235914&id=0KHLEvqvET8C&pg=PA18&lpg=PA18&dq=Bohai&vq=Parhae&prev=http://books.google.com/books%3Flr%3D%26q%3DBohai%26start%3D40&sig=LaPiOw3_z7I-f5uddLq5ibxFVlw] [http://www.chinaknowledge.de/History/Altera/bohai.html]


Chinese and Russian archaelogists and scholars think of Balhae as an independent Mohe state, with Central Asian and Chinese influence. Japanese scholars also view Balhae as an independent state, likening to [[Manchukuo]] for its friendly relationship with Japan.[http://books.google.com/books?ie=UTF-8&hl=en&vid=ISBN0465084133&id=1yU6nMPALMwC&dq=Parhae&prev=http://books.google.com/books%3Fq%3DParhae&lpg=PA198&pg=PA198&sig=dLmVoLkjFhFfA9wuGfOAlVgupeo]
Chinese scholars think of Balhae as an independent Mohe state, with Central Asian and Chinese influence. Japanese historical records indicate that the [[Wae (Japan)|Wa]] of Japan welcomed diplomacy and trade with Balhae, explicitly considering the latter a revival of Goguryeo. However, some modern Japanese scholars view Balhae as an independent state, likening to [[Manchukuo]] for its friendly relationship with Japan.[http://books.google.com/books?ie=UTF-8&hl=en&vid=ISBN0465084133&id=1yU6nMPALMwC&dq=Parhae&prev=http://books.google.com/books%3Fq%3DParhae&lpg=PA198&pg=PA198&sig=dLmVoLkjFhFfA9wuGfOAlVgupeo]


Koreans and traditional Chinese historians believe the founder Dae Joyŏng was of Goguryeo stock. The ''[[Book of Tang]]'' says that Dae Joyŏng was of [Goguryeo] kind (高麗別種), and the ''[[New Book of Tang]]'' states that he is "from the [[Sumo Mohe]] of the former realm of Goguryeo." Some argue that Sumo Mohe is not a region, but an ethnic non-Korean tribe.
Koreans and traditional Chinese historians believe the founder Dae Joyeong was of Goguryeo stock. The ''[[Book of Tang]]'' says that Dae Joyeong was of Goguryeo kind (高麗別種), and the ''[[New Book of Tang]]'' states that he is "from the [[Sumo Mohe]] of the former realm of Goguryeo." Some argue that Sumo Mohe is not a region, but an ethnic non-Korean tribe.

Western reference publications generally characterize Balhae as a Korean and Malgal state, with its founder and the ruling class consisting largely of the former aristocrats of Goguryo [http://www.britannica.com/eb/article-9058453?query=Parhae&ct=] [http://www.britannica.com/ebc/article-9374564?query=Parhae&ct=][http://books.google.com/books?ie=UTF-8&hl=en&vid=ISBN0813328888&id=cybVUOkIw1kC&pg=PA296&lpg=PA296&dq=Parhae&prev=http://books.google.com/books%3Fq%3DParhae%26lr%3D%26start%3D30&sig=gW-I_IXkj2L8wI85hzvA-p8hVcA](''Also see external links, below''), but acknowledge its mixed ethnic composition. Some scholars believe [[Dae Jo-yong]] was of Goguryeo ethnicity, while others believe he was an ethnic Malgal from Koguryeo. [http://books.google.com/books?ie=UTF-8&hl=en&vid=ISBN0631235914&id=0KHLEvqvET8C&pg=PA18&lpg=PA18&dq=Bohai&vq=Parhae&prev=http://books.google.com/books%3Flr%3D%26q%3DBohai%26start%3D40&sig=LaPiOw3_z7I-f5uddLq5ibxFVlw] [http://www.chinaknowledge.de/History/Altera/bohai.html]


Western reference publications generally characterize Balhae as a part of Korean history, with its founder and the ruling class consisting largely of the former aristocrats of Goguryo [http://www.britannica.com/eb/article-9058453?query=Parhae&ct=] [http://www.britannica.com/ebc/article-9374564?query=Parhae&ct=] ''Also see external links, below''.
==See also==
==See also==
* [[History of Korea]]
* [[History of Korea]]

Revision as of 05:37, 28 January 2006

Template:Koreanname Chinesename

Alternate meaning: Bohai Sea

Balhae, (called Bohai by Chinese) (698 - 926), also known as Jin (진국, 振國), was a Korean kingdom occupying the northern Korean peninsula and parts of Manchuria and the Russian Far East. After Goguryeo's capital and southern territories fell to Unified Silla, Dae Jo-young, the leader of Goguryeo remnants, established what he considered the successor to Goguryeo. Balhae was conquered by the Khitans in 926.

History

Founding

The earliest known recorded mention of Balhae come from the Book of Tang, which was compiled between 941 to 945. Manchuria and northern Korea was previously the territory of the Goguryeo, one of the Three Kingdoms of Korea. Goguryeo fell to the allied forces of Silla and the Tang Dynasty in 668. The Tang annexed much of western Manchuria, while Silla unified the Korean peninsula south of the Taedong River. In the aftermath of the destruction caused by invasion and war, Goguryeo refugees fled to the east or south to Silla.

Expansion and foreign relations

In the confusion of a Khitan attack against the Tang in 696, Goguryeo remnants, led by Geolgeol Jungsang and Sumo Mohe tribe, led by Qisi Piyu, escaped eastward to their homeland. The two leaders died but Dae Jo-young, the son of Geolgeol Jungsang, established the State of Jin, claiming to be successors of Goguryeo. Dae Jo-young established his capital at Dongmu Mountain in the south of today's Jilin province. Since it gained power under protection of the northern nomadic empire of Gokturk, Tang called Dae Joyoung "Prefecture King of Bohai (Balhae)" in 713. China had considered Bohai a Chinese prefecture, but since then referred to it as a kingdom. The title was upgraded to "State King of Balhae" in 762.

The second king Mu, who felt encircled by Tang, Silla and Black Water Mohe along the Amur River, attacked Tang and his navy briefly occupied a port on the Shandong Peninsula in 732. Later, a compromise was forged between Tang and Balhae, which resumed tributary missions to Tang. He also sent a mission to Japan in 728 to threaten Silla from the rear. Balhae kept diplomatic and commercial contacts with Japan until the end of the kingdom. Because of its proximity to many powerful states, Balhae became a buffer zone for the region.

The third king Mun expanded its territory into the Amur valley in the north and the Liaodong Peninsula in the west. He also established the permanent capital near Lake Jingpo in the south of today's Heilongjiang province around 755.

By the 8th century, Balhae controlled northern Korea, all of Northeastern Manchuria, and the Liaodong peninsula. Its strength was such that Silla was forced to build a northern wall in 721 as well as maintain active defences along the common border.

Fall and legacy

However, by the early 10th century, ethnic differences between the Goguryeo and the Mohe (Malgal) people weakened the state. Eventually, Balhae would succumb to the Khitans, a new emerging power in Manchuria which founded the Liao Dynasty. After destroying Balhae in 926, the Khitan established the puppet Dongdan Kingdom, which was soon followed by the annexation by Liao in 936. Balhae aristocrats were moved to Liaoyang but small fragments of the state remained semi-independent. Some Balhae people, including a son of the last king, fled southward to Goryeo, successor to Unified Silla. Some descendants of the royal family lived in Korea, changing their family name to Tae (太). Balhae was the last state in Korean history to hold any significant territory in Manchuria, although later Korean dynasties would continue to regard themselves as successors of Balhae.

The Khitans themselves would eventually succumb to the Jurchen people, which founded the Jin Dynasty. The Jin dynasty favored the Balhae people as well as the Khitans. The fourth, fifth and seventh emperors of Jin were mothered by Balhae concubines. The 13th century census of Northern China by the Mongols distinguished Balhae from other ethnic groups such as Goryeo, Khitan and Jurchen. This suggests that the Balhae people still preserved their identity even after the conquest of the kingdom.

Government and culture

The people of Balhae were made up of former Goguryeo elements and of several Tungustic peoples present in Manchuria, of which the Mohe (Malgal) made up the largest element.

Its culture and government was heavily influenced by Tang China. It modeled its system of government upon that of Tang China, to an even greater extent than Silla. The government operated three chancelleries and six ministries, and its capital, Sanggyong, was modeled after Chang'an, the capital of the Tang Dynasty. In addition, Balhae sent many students to Tang China to study, and many went on to take and pass the Chinese civil service examinations.([1][2])

An important source of cultural information on Balhae was discovered at the end of the 20th century at the Ancient Tombs at Longtou Mountain, especially the Mausoleum of Princess Jeong-Hyo.

Characterization and political interpretation

Controversy rests over the ethnic makeup of the people of Balhae. That Balhae was founded by a former general from Goguryeo is undisputed, but some Chinese scholars dispute his ethnicity. No historical records from Balhae survive.

In modern North and South Korea, Balhae is regarded as a Korean state and is positioned in the "North-South Period" (with Silla) today, although such a view has had proponents in the past. They emphasize its connection with Goguryeo and minimize that with the Mohe. While South Korean historians think the ethnicity ruling class was of Goguryeo and the commoners were Mohe, North Korean historians think Balhae ethnography was mostly Goguryeo.

Chinese historians consider Balhae a vassal of the Tang Dynasty: the succession of Balhae kings had to be sanctioned by the Tang Dynasty, and a heir who lacks this sanction can only be known as 知國務 ("State Affairs Leader"), not king; also, every king was also simultaneously the Prefect of Huhan Prefecture (忽汗州都督府都督). Chinese historians consider Balhae to be composed of the Balhae ethnic group, which was mostly based on the Mohe. Historically, the Jurchens (later renamed the Manchus, considered themselves as sharing ancestry with the Mohe (Malgal), and the People's Republic of China continues to consider Balhae as part of the history of its ethnic Manchus. [3] [4] [5]

Chinese scholars think of Balhae as an independent Mohe state, with Central Asian and Chinese influence. Japanese historical records indicate that the Wa of Japan welcomed diplomacy and trade with Balhae, explicitly considering the latter a revival of Goguryeo. However, some modern Japanese scholars view Balhae as an independent state, likening to Manchukuo for its friendly relationship with Japan.[6]

Koreans and traditional Chinese historians believe the founder Dae Joyeong was of Goguryeo stock. The Book of Tang says that Dae Joyeong was of Goguryeo kind (高麗別種), and the New Book of Tang states that he is "from the Sumo Mohe of the former realm of Goguryeo." Some argue that Sumo Mohe is not a region, but an ethnic non-Korean tribe.

Western reference publications generally characterize Balhae as a part of Korean history, with its founder and the ruling class consisting largely of the former aristocrats of Goguryo [7] [8] Also see external links, below.

See also