At the Feet of the Master: Difference between revisions
→References: Resolving Category:Harv and Sfn no-target errors. This causes multiple referencing errors |
→References: repl. online ed. |
||
| Line 95: | Line 95: | ||
* {{cite book|author-link=Rom Landau|last=Landau|first=Rom|year=1943|orig-year=originally published 1935. London: I. Nicholson and Watson|url=https://archive.org/details/godismyadventure032951mbp|title=God is my adventure: a book on modern mystics, masters, and teachers|type=[[hardcover]]|publisher=[[Faber and Faber]]|location=London |oclc=561790498|via=[[Internet Archive]]}} |
* {{cite book|author-link=Rom Landau|last=Landau|first=Rom|year=1943|orig-year=originally published 1935. London: I. Nicholson and Watson|url=https://archive.org/details/godismyadventure032951mbp|title=God is my adventure: a book on modern mystics, masters, and teachers|type=[[hardcover]]|publisher=[[Faber and Faber]]|location=London |oclc=561790498|via=[[Internet Archive]]}} |
||
* {{cite book|author-link=Charles Webster Leadbeater|last=Leadbeater|first=C. W.|year=2007|orig-year=originally published 1925. Chicago: Theosophical Press|title=The masters and the path|type=[[paperback]]|edition=reprint|publisher=Cosimo Classics|location=New York|isbn=978-1-60206-333-4}} |
* {{cite book|author-link=Charles Webster Leadbeater|last=Leadbeater|first=C. W.|year=2007|orig-year=originally published 1925. Chicago: Theosophical Press|title=The masters and the path|type=[[paperback]]|edition=reprint|publisher=Cosimo Classics|location=New York|isbn=978-1-60206-333-4}} |
||
* {{cite book |author-last=Lutyens|author-first=Mary|author-link=Mary Lutyens|year=1975|title=Krishnamurti: the years of awakening|url=https://archive.org/details/ |
* {{cite book |author-last=Lutyens|author-first=Mary|author-link=Mary Lutyens|year=1975|title=Krishnamurti: the years of awakening|url=https://archive.org/details/krishnamurtiyear0000unse_n4b0|url-access=registration|type=[[hardcover]]|publisher=[[Farrar, Straus and Giroux]]|location=New York|edition=1st US|isbn=978-0-374-18222-9|via=[[Internet Archive]]}} |
||
* {{cite book|last=Michel|first=Peter|year=1995|orig-year=originally published 1992 in [[German language|German]] as ''Krishnamurti - liebe und freiheit annäherung an ein geheimnis''. [[Grafing]]: Aquamarin Verlag|title=Krishnamurti: love and freedom: approaching a mystery|type=[[paperback]]|translator-last=Michel|translator-first=Petra|location=Woodside, California|publisher=Bluestar Communications|isbn=978-18-853-9400-2}} |
* {{cite book|last=Michel|first=Peter|year=1995|orig-year=originally published 1992 in [[German language|German]] as ''Krishnamurti - liebe und freiheit annäherung an ein geheimnis''. [[Grafing]]: Aquamarin Verlag|title=Krishnamurti: love and freedom: approaching a mystery|type=[[paperback]]|translator-last=Michel|translator-first=Petra|location=Woodside, California|publisher=Bluestar Communications|isbn=978-18-853-9400-2}} |
||
* {{cite book|last=Rodrigues|first=Hillary|editor-last=Sasson|editor-first=Vanessa R.|year=2012|chapter=Chapter 19: Young Lord Maitreya: The Curious Case of Jiddu Krishnamurti|title=Little Buddhas: children and childhoods in Buddhist texts and traditions|type=[[hardcover]]|pages=453{{en dash}}482|publisher=[[Oxford University Press]]|location=New York|via=Oxford Scholarship Online|isbn=978-0-19986-026-5|doi=10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199860265.003.0019}} |
* {{cite book|last=Rodrigues|first=Hillary|editor-last=Sasson|editor-first=Vanessa R.|year=2012|chapter=Chapter 19: Young Lord Maitreya: The Curious Case of Jiddu Krishnamurti|title=Little Buddhas: children and childhoods in Buddhist texts and traditions|type=[[hardcover]]|pages=453{{en dash}}482|publisher=[[Oxford University Press]]|location=New York|via=Oxford Scholarship Online|isbn=978-0-19986-026-5|doi=10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199860265.003.0019}} |
||
Revision as of 19:41, 24 August 2023
 1911 edition | |
| Author | Alcyone (Jiddu Krishnamurti) |
|---|---|
| Language | English |
| Subject | Religious text, Theosophy |
| Published | December 1910 by Theosophist Office (1st edition) |
| Publication place | India |
| Media type | Print (cloth) |
| Pages | 84 |
| OCLC | 465903996 |
| Text | At the Feet of the Master at Wikisource |
| Wikisource has the 1911 US edition | |
At the Feet of the Master is a book attributed to Jiddu Krishnamurti (1895–1986), authored when he was 14 years old. Written under the name Alcyone, it was first published in 1910. The work was closely related to the World Teacher Project, a contemporary messianic endeavor launched by the Theosophical Society. The book is considered a spiritual classic and was still in print in 2012. By that time it had been published in dozens of editions and had been translated in many languages; by 2004 early editions were in the public domain. Throughout its publication history the work has also generated controversy, regarding the author's identity.
Background
| Part of a series on |
| Theosophy |
|---|
The work was an important early milestone of the World Teacher Project, a worldwide enterprise launched by the Theosophical Society in early 20th century. This endeavor, which received widespread publicity, proclaimed the imminent arrival of the World Teacher, a new messiah.[1] Jiddu Krishnamurti, an adolescent Brahmin from South India, and the presumed author of At the Feet of the Master, was considered the likely "vehicle" for the World Teacher.[2] As a result, the book was seen as being closely related to Krishnamurti's expected mission, an early indication of his spiritual and worldly destiny.[3]
About the work
The title was reputedly chosen by Annie Besant,[4] then–President of the Theosophical Society, who was also Krishnamurti's legal guardian.[5] The author was listed as Alcyone, a pseudonym assigned to Krishnamurti by one of his mentors, the prominent and controversial Theosophist Charles Webster Leadbeater.[6]
The original edition's front cover features an illustration (in gold on blue background), of a path leading to an Egyptian-style gateway; in the frontispiece there is a contemporary photograph of Alcyone.[7] The book includes a preface by Besant, and a dedication page with the inscription, "To those who knock". Following, is an additional full-page photograph of Alcyone (uncaptioned), a page with a short, unattributed quote in Sanskrit and English, and a foreword by Alcyone. The body of the work is then laid out in four parts, corresponding to its proclaimed requirements for disciples on the spiritual path: [8]
- Discrimination
- Desirelessness
- Good conduct
- Love
The book closes with an unsigned, two-verse devotional poem.
The following is stated in the book's foreword: "These are not my words; they are the words of the Master who taught me."[9] This is related to Leadbeater's statement that over a period of about five months during 1909–10, Master Kuthumi (or Koot Hoomi) – a postulated embodied spiritual entity – was releasing to Krishnamurti, through a mystical process and while the boy was asleep, the spiritual instruction that makes up the work.[10] Upon waking, Krishnamurti "with great laboriousness" put the instructions into notes; afterwards, the notes were checked for spelling and grammar, and then arranged and typed by Leadbeater. The resulting typescript formed the basis for the book's original edition; Krishnamurti's handwritten notes were lost sometime after the book's publication.[11]
Publication history
The original edition was published at Adyar, India, through the facilities of The Theosophist, the Society's main organ; the publisher is listed as "Theosophist Office, Adyar". The book, introduced during the December 1910 Theosophical Convention at Adyar,[12] was bound in blue cloth, with a limited number of copies bound in blue leather.[7]
This edition quickly sold out; within a year the book had been published in twenty-seven editions, and by 1925 there were at least forty.[12] In the ensuing decades, dozens of editions in many languages and formats were published by Theosophical and non-Theosophical publishers,[13] including the Star Publishing Trust (SPT), publishing arm of the World Teacher Project. Following its founding in 1926, the SPT had assumed the copyright to the work. This entity became the official publisher of Krishnamurti's work after he effectively ended the World Teacher Project by rejecting his messianic role and leaving the Theosophical Society in 1929–30;[14] however, the SPT still held the rights to At the Feet of the Master as of 1946. Meanwhile, according to one source, the original edition of the book may have never been legally copyrighted.[15]
The book is considered a spiritual classic,[16] and was still in print in 2012.[17] Around that time, early editions of the work had been in the public domain within several jurisdictions.[18]
Select editions
Later editions may list the author as both Alcyone and Jiddu Krishnamurti, or solely as Jiddu Krishnamurti.[19] They may also omit material, or add new material.
- Alcyone (Jiddu Krishnamurti) (1911). At the feet of the master (hardcover). Preface by Besant, Annie (American ed.). Chicago: Rajput Press. 84 pp. OCLC 560831417 – edition is in the public domain ().
- Jiddu, Krishnamurti (1990). At the feet of the master (hardcover). Preface by Besant, Annie; illustrated by Eedle, Alfred. London: Rider. 128 pp. ISBN 978-0-7126-3615-5. Back cover:
An illustrated text of the teachings given to the spiritual teacher, Krishnamurti, by his own guru [publisher's annotation].
- Jiddu, Krishnamurti (Alcyone) (2001). At the feet of the master and towards discipleship (paperback). Preface by Besant, Annie; additional material by Algeo, John (1st Quest ed.). Wheaton, Illinois: Quest Books. 112 pp. ISBN 978-0-8356-0803-9 – expanded edition includes "Towards Discipleship", a previously published private transcript of informal 1924 talks by Krishnamurti, and background material by John Algeo, past president of the Theosophical Society in America.
Reception
![original sheet music cover of the 1925 Leevi Madetoja composition at the feeth [sic] of the Master (Alcyone)](/wiki/File:At_The_Feet_of_The_Master.jpg)
The book was enthusiastically received by Theosophists and members of the Order of the Star in the East, a worldwide organization established by the Theosophical leadership to promote the World Teacher Project.[20] According to a Krishnamurti biographer, "[n]othing, since Blavatsky, carried the sort of authority soon ascribed to Alcyone's document";[21] contemporary press reports described it as "a holy book to his [Alcyone-Krishnamurti] disciples".[22] In 1925 the Finnish Section of the Theosophical Society published "At the feeth [sic] of the Master (Alcyone)" – a work for voice and piano by the composer Leevi Madetoja (Op. 71/2); the composition, whose lyrics include the book's closing poem, was commissioned by the Section for the 50th anniversary of the parent organization's founding. It was republished as "The Word of the Master" (Finnish: Mestarin käsky) in 1929.[23]
The extraordinary publicity surrounding Krishnamurti and the World Teacher Project brought increased attention to the book. Favorable early press coverage[24] was complemented by more neutral or strict assessments, which included the tentative characterization of Krishnamurti's writing style as "artless".[25]
Others have found the book "simple ... though not platitudinous ... draws on the pious morality that underlies ... all [religions]".[12] It has also been pointed out that the main body's themes, and four-part layout, bear close resemblance to Advaita Vedanta treatises by, or attributed to, the 8th century Indian philosopher and theologian Adi Shankara.[26]
Despite the demise of the World Teacher Project in 1929, and the subsequent dismantling of the infrastructure supporting it (which included the book),[14] millions of copies have been sold.[27] Soon after its original publication, commentaries and detailed analyses by prominent Theosophists started to appear, "in which every line of Alcyone's original is weighed, analyzed, laboriously expanded upon"; in addition, the book became a frequent subject of lectures, a practice that continued past the Project's ending, and into the early 21st century.[28] The work reputedly also played a role in later occult endeavors by Leadbeater.[29]
Authorship debate
The identity of the author has been the subject of debate, starting with the appearance of the first edition.[30] It has been proposed that Leadbeater was the actual producer of the work; this proposition has had opponents as well as supporters.[31] Shortly after the original publication, the matter found its way to court in India. It was brought up during a custody battle over Krishnamurti between Besant and Jiddu Narayaniah, Krishnamurti's father. Narayaniah believed the book was "fathered" on Krishnamurti in order to promote his messianic credentials, citing as one proof the boy's poor prior knowledge of English.[32] In related litigation, Besant alleged The Hindu newspaper was in contempt over the "publication of certain correspondence ... relating to the authorship of the book 'At the feet of the Master'".[33]
Since the original publication, statements reputedly made by Krishnamurti have appeared in a variety of sources, implying he accepted or rejected authorship; his own recorded statements on the matter have been subject to interpretation.[34] Decades after the original publication, he stated that he had no memory of writing it, although he did not discount the possibility.[35]
As the original notes by Krishnamurti are missing, the extent of any differences with Leadbeater's typescript and with the original published edition is not clear.[36] The debate regarding the role of Krishnamurti in the production and promotion of this work persisted, a century after its original publication.[37]
See also
Notes
- ^ Vernon 2001, pp. 10, 22, 38.
- ^ Lutyens 1975, pp. 12, 21.
- ^ Vernon 2001, p. 61. "Besant described the notes [compiled as the work] as Alcyone's 'first gift to the world'"; Leadbeater 2007, ch. "III: § At the Feet of the Master" pp. 51–53; see also § Reception.
- ^ Wood 1964, p. 289.
- ^ Lutyens 1975, p. 40.
- ^ Lutyens 1975, p. 23. Alcyone is the name of a star in the Pleiades star cluster and of characters from Greek mythology.
- ^ a b Lutyens 1975, p. 44n.
- ^ Alcyone (Jiddu Krishnamurti) 1911, p. 3.
- ^ Alcyone (Jiddu Krishnamurti) 1911, p. [1].
- ^ Lutyens 1975, pp. 10–11, 28, 43; Vernon 2001, p. 61.
- ^ Lutyens 1975, pp. 28, 44; Wood 1964, p. 289.
- ^ a b c Vernon 2001, p. 61.
- ^ Lutyens 1975, p. 28; Vernon 2001, p. 61; see also WorldCat search link for editions and formats of the original (OCLC 465903996). Retrieved 2015-11-04.
- ^ a b Lutyens 1975, pp. 246, 272–276.
- ^ C. V. Williams 2004, p. 528n50; Vernon 2001, p. 199. Krishnamurti biographer Roland Vernon considers the inclusion of the book in SPT's post-World Teacher Project sales catalog a shrewd business decision, and notes it was offered in three different bindings, "cloth, paper and 'deluxe'."
- ^ C. V. Williams 2004, p. 27.
- ^ Rodrigues 2012, p. 462.
- ^ C. V. Williams 2004, pp. 196–197, 528n50.
- ^ C. V. Williams 2004, pp. 26, 28.
- ^ C. V. Williams 2004, pp. 25–26.
- ^ Vernon 2001, pp. 61–62. Helena Blavatsky (1831–1891), was a founder of modern Theosophy and the Theosophical Society (pp. 2, 7–8).
- ^ Davis 1926, p. SM1.
- ^ Djupsjöbacka 2002, "[Track:] 30 The Word of the Master (Alcyone)" pp. 31–32 [from a 2002 recording]; Eskola 2015.
- ^ Detroit Free Press 1913. "It is declared that no one ... can read this strangely simple, lucid and beautiful exposition ... without realizing its vital significance".
- ^ Davis 1926, p. SM1. In this comprehensive report the book is described as a "boyish testament ... the messiah dwells upon ... all of the stock spiritual soothsayings of all the redeemers and yogi since Christ"; Scott 1930. The book, and "certain public utterances" by Krishnamurti, "if a trifle trite, were entirely unobjectionable."
- ^ C. V. Williams 2004, p. 26. "[T]he book is ... in the style of Shankaracharya's 'four qualifications', expounded as Advaita philosophy in about 800 CE"; Rodrigues 2012, p. 462. "[P]arallels between the contents of At the Feet of the Master and the Vivekac ū ḍ ā ma ṇ i [Vivekachudamani], attributed to Śaṅkara."
- ^ C. V. Williams 2004, p. 26; The Star 1928. By January 1928, the book's "Million Edition" was advertised in World Teacher Project-related magazines.
- ^ Vernon 2001, pp. 61, 62. "[The work] enjoyed a long and lucrative history in Theosophical circles"; see for example, Guideposts for Living: At the Feet of the Master (2007, OCLC 258382667) a 2003 lecture published on DVD-Video, and the early print commentaries Thoughts on "At the Feet of the Master" (1918, OCLC 556990948), and Talks on At the feet of the Master (1922, OCLC 22467665). The latter commentary was one of the books requested by Robert F. Kennedy killer Sirhan Sirhan while in jail awaiting trial (Christian Science Monitor 1968).
- ^ Tillett 2012, p. 43.
- ^ Michel 1995, pp. 2–3; Vernon 2001, p. 61.
- ^ Lutyens 1975, p. 44; C. V. Williams 2004, pp. 24–29, 476n93–478n100.
- ^ Lutyens 1975, pp. 62, 82, 84, ch. "8: The Lawsuit" pp. 64–71. Narayaniah had previously granted guardianship of Krishnamurti to Besant; Vernon 2001, pp. 62–63, 71.
- ^ The Times of India 1912; Vernon 2001, p. 62.
- ^ Michel 1995, p. 20; Vernon 2001, pp. 61–63.
- ^ Landau 1943, pp. 262–263; C. V. Williams 2004, pp. 196–197, 294, 534n35.
- ^ Lutyens 1975, p. 44.
- ^ S. L. Williams 2010. This author maintains the work is rightly attributable to Krishnamurti.
References
- "Alleged Contempt of Court". The Times of India. New Delhi: Bennett, Coleman & Company. 19 December 1912. p. 7. OCLC 23379369. ProQuest 346190847.
- "At the Feet of the Master" (PDF). [Advertisements]. The Star. Vol. 1, no. 1. Los Angeles: Star Publishing Trust. January 1928. p. 67. OCLC 10990552 – via IAPSOP (International Association for the Preservation of Spiritualist and Occult Periodicals).
- Davis, Forrest (15 August 1926). "A New Deity Comes in Plus Fours: Krishnamurti Sponsored by Theosophists as 'A Messiah From India' Brings No Disturbing or Difficult Doctrine to Jazz-Ridden America". Magazine. New York Herald Tribune. Krishnamurti portrait by McBride, Hubbell. Ogden Mills Reid. pp. SM1–3. ISSN 1941-0646. ProQuest 1112612876.
- Djupsjöbacka, Gustav (1 January 2002). Madetoja: Complete Lieder Vol. 1 (PDF) (Media notes) (in Finnish and English). Translated by Mäntyjärvi, Jaakko. Gabriel Suovanen. Helsinki: Ondine. ODE996-2. UPC 761195099629. Archived from the original (PDF) on 2015-11-17. Retrieved 2021-12-18 – via Wayback Machine.
- Eskola, Jari, ed. (2015). "Vocal and Choral Works with Accompaniment, Solo Songs". Leevi Madetoja. Source material by Music Finland. Helsinki: Madetoja Foundation. ¶ "Mestarin käsky Op. 71/2". Archived from the original on 2015-11-17. Retrieved 2015-10-31.
- "Hailed by Mystics as Divine". Detroit Free Press. Detroit, Michigan: Gannett Company. 12 January 1913. p. D7. ISSN 1055-2758. ProQuest 565163150.
- Landau, Rom (1943) [originally published 1935. London: I. Nicholson and Watson]. God is my adventure: a book on modern mystics, masters, and teachers (hardcover). London: Faber and Faber. OCLC 561790498 – via Internet Archive.
- Leadbeater, C. W. (2007) [originally published 1925. Chicago: Theosophical Press]. The masters and the path (paperback) (reprint ed.). New York: Cosimo Classics. ISBN 978-1-60206-333-4.
- Lutyens, Mary (1975). Krishnamurti: the years of awakening (hardcover) (1st US ed.). New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux. ISBN 978-0-374-18222-9 – via Internet Archive.
- Michel, Peter (1995) [originally published 1992 in German as Krishnamurti - liebe und freiheit annäherung an ein geheimnis. Grafing: Aquamarin Verlag]. Krishnamurti: love and freedom: approaching a mystery (paperback). Translated by Michel, Petra. Woodside, California: Bluestar Communications. ISBN 978-18-853-9400-2.
- Rodrigues, Hillary (2012). "Chapter 19: Young Lord Maitreya: The Curious Case of Jiddu Krishnamurti". In Sasson, Vanessa R. (ed.). Little Buddhas: children and childhoods in Buddhist texts and traditions (hardcover). New York: Oxford University Press. pp. 453–482. doi:10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199860265.003.0019. ISBN 978-0-19986-026-5 – via Oxford Scholarship Online.
- Scott, Ted, ed. (7 August 1930). "Krishnamurti". Editorials. The Manchester Guardian. Guardian News and Media. p. 8. ISSN 0261-3077. ProQuest 478105584.
- "Sirhan asks books on theosophy". The Christian Science Monitor. Boston, Massachusetts: Christian Science Publishing Society. Associated Press. 8 June 1968. p. 7. ISSN 0882-7729. ProQuest 511045808.
- Tillett, Gregory (January 2012). "Modern Western Magic and Theosophy". Aries. 12 (1). European Society for the Study of Western Esotericism; Brill Academic Publishers: 17–51. doi:10.1163/147783512X614821. ISSN 1567-9896 – via Brill Online.
- Vernon, Roland (2001). Star in the east: Krishnamurti: the invention of a messiah (hardcover). New York: Palgrave. ISBN 978-0-312-23825-4 – via Internet Archive.
- Williams, Christine V. (2004). Jiddu Krishnamurti: world philosopher (1895–1986): his life and thoughts (hardcover) (1st ed.). Delhi: Motilal Banarsidass. ISBN 978-81-208-2032-6.
- Williams, S. Lloyd (July–October 2010). "Did J. Krishnamurti write At the Feet of the Master?". Theosophical History (double issue). XIV (3–4). Fullerton, California: Theosophical History Foundation: 11–114. ISSN 0951-497X. Retrieved 2015-10-06.
- Wood, Ernest (December 1964). "No Religion Higher than Truth". The American Theosophist. Vol. 52, no. 12. Wheaton, Illinois: Theosophical Society in America. pp. 287–290. ISSN 0003-1402. Archived from the original on 2004-02-16. Retrieved 2010-08-14 – via KatinkaHesselink.net.
External links
The full text of At the Feet of the Master (1911 US edition) at Wikisource.
