Jump to content

Alexander Cartellieri

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This is an old revision of this page, as edited by Graeme Bartlett (talk | contribs) at 02:53, 27 January 2021 (clean up, replaced: “ → " (5), „ → " (5), … → ..., typo(s) fixed: On the other hand → On the other hand,, longer term → longer-term, four week → four-week (2), eminant → eminent, signficant → significant). The present address (URL) is a permanent link to this revision, which may differ significantly from the current revision.

Alexander Cartellieri
1913
Born
Alexander Maximilian Georg Cartellieri

19 June 1867 (1867-06-19)
Odessa, Novorossiya, Russia
Died16 January 1955 (1955-01-17)
Jena, German Democratic Republic (East Germany)
Alma materTübingen
Leipzig
Berlin
Occupation(s)Archivist (Karlsruhe)
Historian (medievalist)
Writer
University professor and prorector (Jena)
SpouseMargarete Arnold (1870-1931)
ChildrenWalther Cartellieri
Wolfgang Cartellieri
Ilse Cartellieri/Prange
and two others
Parent(s)Leopold Cartellieri (1828-1903)
German consul
Cölestine Manger (1831–1918)

Alexander Cartellieri (19 June 1867 - 16 January 1955) was a German historian, principally of the High Middle Ages. Between 1904 and 1934 he held a full professorship for Medieval and Modern History at the University of Jena. After his retirement in 1934, he continued to live in Jena through the National Socialist years, the war, Soviet occupation and the early years of German partition.[1][2]

Life

Provenance and early years

Alexander Maximilian Georg Cartellieri was born in Odessa, a cosmopolitan and commercially vibrant Black Sea port which had been part of the Russian empire since 1789. He was the third of his parents' five recorded children. Leopold Cartellieri (1828-1903), his father, was a businessman who at the time of Alexander's birth was serving as German consul in the city.[2] On his father's side the family could trace their ancestry back to Eighteenth century Milan, where a number of Cartellieris had been professional musicians.[3] Alexander Cartellieri's great grandfather Antonio Cartellieri (1772 - 1807), a composer of church music who made his career Germany, had himself been the son of two opera singers, respectively from Milan and Riga, who were also living and working, at the time of his birth, in northern Germany. Antonio Cartellieri had in 1786 been relocated with his mother to Königsberg in East Prussia, following his parents' divorce.[4] Alexander Cartellieri's more recent Cartellieri ancestors had made their way in life not as musicians but as businessmen. His grandfather, Julius Friedrich Leopold Cartellieri (1795–1873), was a city councillor and at one stage the treasurer in the port city of Pillau (which after 1945 became part of the Soviet Union and was renamed Baltiysk/Балтийск).[5] Alexander Cartellieri's mother, born Cölestine Manger (1831–1918), was the daughter of a mine owner, originally from Kassel. In 1872 the Cartellieris relocated from Odessa to Paris where the children grew up. The move was undertaken in connection with Leopold Cartellieri's work for the international "Ephrussi & Co." bank. Alexander Cartellieri was unusual among German university history professors in having been born and grown up abroad.[6][7] A few months before they moved to Paris the Franco-Prussian War had ended in French defeat. The traumatic Siege of Paris, the emperor's proclamation of 18 January 1871 in the Palace of Versailles and the loss of Alsace-Lorraine were all fresh and raw in the minds of Parisians. The family's social contacts were accordingly restricted to the very small number of German families living in the city.[7]

Cartellieri's father was a huge admirer of Chancellor Bismarck and an enthusiastic backer of unification. The father's linguistic talents and his patriotism influenced the son. Cartellieri was baptised as a Protestant. It was also important for his father that his birth be registered in the army register in 1867. While he was still young his parents arranged for tutors to come to the house to teach him French. He quickly became fascinated by the stalls of the book sellers, lined up alongside the left bank of the Seine. An entry in his diary dated June 1882 recalls his decision "gradually to assemble [his] own collection of the most important classics, especially those that dealt with [his particular passion, which was already the study of] ... history".[7] He was particularly fascinated by Leopold von Ranke, for many twentieth century historians an iconic figure, who had done much to redefine the study of History in Europe and North America. Cartellieri would much later describe Ranke as "the greatest historian of all peoples and times"[a][8][9] Another early focus of his historical passions, triggered by frequent walks in the Tuileries and to the royal tombs at Saint-Denis involved the French monarchy.[10]

In April 1883 Cartellieri was removed to the provincial German town of Gütersloh (between Dortmund and Hanover), which at that time had a population of fewer than 10,000.[11] His father was keen that he should spend his later school years at a Gymnasium (secondary school) in Germany in order that he might complete the German school curriculum and gain admission to a German university. His father's longer-term ambition for him was that he should be able to enter government service in the new Germany.[12] In addition to preparing him for university admission, three years in Gütersloh was an irresistible book-buying opportunity. He expanded his collection to above 400 volumes.[13] These included von Ranke's already six volume "World History" series. His reading of the books inspired his decision, noted in his diary in November 1886, to become a university history professor.[11] In February 1887 he passed his "Abitur" (school final exams), obtaining the highest marks in that year's cohort of candidates. He was quickly retired from completing his voluntary period of military service on account of the extent of his short-sightedness.[7][11]

Student years in Tübingen, Leipzig and Berlin

At the start of the 1887 summer term Cartellieri enrolled at the University of Tübingen,[11] where he studied History with Bernhard von Kugler. Away from the lectures and tutorials, during his time at Tübingen the nearby castle of the Hohenzollerns and the remaining ruins of Hohenstaufen Castle made a lasting impression on him. Subjects that particularly interested him at university, in addition to History, were Philosophy, Archaeology and Literature. He also continued to expand his personal collection of books, which by the time of his graduation had grown to become a personal history library. His parents were providing him with a generous 1,500 Mark annual allowance, and he shunned the dissolute life-style sometimes associated with well-funded students of the period, which left him with substantial funds for buying books.[7] An important early acquisition was a book by the influential historian (and one-time home tutor to Felix Mendelssohn) Johann Gustav Droysen. After a year at Tübingen, armed with a letter of recommendation from his tutor, Bernhard von Kugler, Cartellieri transferred to the University of Leipzig. At Leipzig it was the Medievalist palaeographer Wilhelm Arndt who awakened Cartellieri's interest in Philip II ("Philippe Auguste") of France. He became a regular presence at Wilhelm Maurenbrecher's lectures on eighteenth century history. In another part of the university, he was also able to attend, as a student, Wilhelm Wundt's "Laboratory of Popular and Experimental Psychology". In 1889 Cartellieri transferred again, this time to the Friedrich Wilhelm University (as it was known at that time).[11] His principal tutor here was Paul Scheffer-Boichorst, a man known for the rigour of his methodology in respect of historical sources. Having studied with Scheffer-Boichorst during the 1880s and 1890s would confer valuable professional cachet throughout the careers of those, such as Cartellieri, who went on to become university professors themselves.[14] The lectures of Heinrich von Treitschke covering the principal topical themes of the day, such as the "Jewish question", the church-state rivalries known collectively to historians as the "Kulturkampf" and education reform, also made a lasting impression on him. It was, according to his own diaries, from von Treitschke that he acquired his defining "belief in the German nation and in the Prussian state".[15] Alongside Heinrich von Treitschke, Otto von Bismarck was always a defining figure in German and world history, from Cartellieri's perspective.[7]

At the end of 1890 Cartellieri completed his doctoral dissertation on the early life of King Philippe Auguste of France. It was published in Revue historique in 1893.[16]

It was also in 1890 that Alexander Cartellieri met Margarete Arnold (1870-1931)[17] the daughter of a prosperous Berlin lawyer. They married on 23 July 1894.[2] Had he anticipated the posthumous publication of his diaries, he might or might not have confided to their pages his explanation that marriage seemed to him to be "still the best way to satisfy certain feelings .... [and] to get hold of a good cook, house keeper and carer"[b][7][18] According to at least one source, Cartellieri was able to benefit from "material support" from his Margarete's father for the rest of his life.[11] The couple's five children included the jurist-historian Wolfgang Cartellieri (1901-1969),[19] whose own children include the bank director Ulrich Cartellieri.[20] Margarete Cartellieri did indeed look after the household, but she also helped him with his work, proof reading and correcting his books ahead of publication.[7]

Archivist in Karlsruhe

After receiving his doctorate, with the backing of Scheffer-Boichorst, Cartellieri obtained a research post at the Baden Commission for Historical Studies, based in Karlsruhe. There, in 1892, the focus of his work became the "Regesta" (manuscript archives) of the Bishops of Konstanz ("Regesta episcoporum Constantiensium"). Some sort of basic indexing was already in place, but he was called upon to come up with descriptive entries in order to make the index more usable for researchers.[21] This principally involved parchment records from the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries. He also had frequent recourse to source records not held in Karlsruhe, and there were regular "archive trips" south, to Lucerne, Konstanz, Bregenz, Lindau and Freiburg. He also visited the Vatican Archive to view source material on the Bishops of Konstanz between 1351 and 1383. While in Karlsruhe he was also preparing for the government teaching exams. In the end he seems to have suffered some sort of fainting attack, caused by overwork, and was instructed to take a four-week break.[7]

He found it impossible to become very inspired by the "Regesta": "The wines extracted from the files and records are sleeping potions", he complained in his diary in September 1895.[22] By simply combing through the archival source records, he was not acquiring any sort of contextual overview or understanding of the place of these documents in world history in respect of the period from which they came.[7] On 6 April 1895 he passed his exams for qualification as an "Archivassessor" ("senior archivist").[2] Later, looking back, he would nevertheless recall his processing of the old "Regesta" as "exploitation" ("Ausbeutung") and "dull" ("stumpfsinnig").[22] (Despite Alexander Cartellieri's increasingly negative perception of the work, Otto Cartellieri (1872-1930), his younger brother who had also studied at Berlin under Paul Scheffer-Boichorst, and who would never be offered a full university professorship, would make archive work his life-long career, achieving a significant level of academic notability in the process.[23]) Underwhelmed by the "Regesta" work he turned, when he could, to questions involving historical theory and historical philosophy, and preoccupied himself with the structure and classifications of world history. He became interested in Marx's ideas on "Historical materialism", Arthur de Gobineau's work on "Race" and Darwin's endlessly current "Theories of Evolution".[10][22]

During his Karlsruhe years Cartellieri authored many reviews of new French publications and established a network of contacts with colleagues, both in Germany and abroad. His more notable contacts included Léopold Victor Delisle, Director of the French National Library, and the medievalist historians Denis Jean Achille Luchaire and Charles Petit-Dutaillis. On 1894 he attended the Deutscher Historikertag (historians' convention) in Leipzig. Here he met Henri Pirenne, which was the start of a lasting professional and personal friendship between the two men.[7][24]

He also engaged energetically in networking closer to home, participating in city life socially and becoming a member of a number of civic associations in Karlsruhe. He learned how to swim and to ride a bicycle in the Upper Rhine countryside. These activities, along with hiking and reading, became his favourite leisure pursuits as a young man.[7]

Tutor at Heidelberg

In January 1898, Cartellieri left Karlsruhe. It is not clear whether his absence was intended as a brief sabbatical, or a permanent move, but as matters turned out he never returned to the "Regesta" cataloguing work. He pursued, with enhanced depth, his researches on King Philippe Auguste. The French king had already provided him with material for a doctorate, and he was encouraged in his further researches by Bernhard Erdmannsdörffer and Dietrich Schäfer who at this time were both employed as professors at nearby Heidelberg. There was agreement that the subject offered scope for a habilitation (higher academic degree) using, at least in part, research notes that Cartellieri had already accumulated while researching Philippe Auguste for no openly defined goal beyond his own pleasure and satisfaction. During 1898 he moved to Heidelberg where he started work as a research assistant with Dietrich Schäfer. He duly produced his habilitation dissertation, which was unambiguously a sequel to his 1891 doctoral dissertation, and in August 1899 received the degree.[25][26] During the summer term, still at Heidelberg, he conducted his first tutorials on Latin Palaeography and delivered a lecture on France in the Middle Ages.[7]

He continued to sustain close contacts with academic colleagues who, like him, had closer connections to foreign cultures than was typical for university history tutors in Germany. These included the Romanistics historian Karl Vossler who had a particular interest in contemporary philosophy and was a great admirer of Benedetto Croce. Another scholar to whom he was particularly close was the professor of ancient history, Alfred von Domaszewski, whose ancestors were mainly Polish and French rather than German.[27] There were also frequent stimulating exchanges of ideas with the art historian Carl Neumann and the polymath-jurist Georg Jellinek. Neumann brought him closer to the work of Jacob Burckhardt, while Jellinek was able to guide him in respect of the differing constitutional structures of different foreign countries. Cartellieri would retain fond memories of his years Heidelberg for the rest of his life, later describing the period as "the conclusion to a wonderful adolescence".[7]

Jena (1904-1935)

The young professor (1904-1913)

In 1902, Cartellieri was appointed to an administrative associate professorship for Medieval and Modern History at the University of Jena. At the start of the Winter 1904/05 term he succeeded Ottokar Lorenz, who had died that May,[28] as University Professor for History.[29] He had already established a name as a knowledgeable practitioner of French Medieval History. But he did not feel at home in Jena as he had in Heidelberg. He confided to his diary on 24 August 1913 that he still found the place cold and unfriendly (...ein "Popel-Nest").[30][31] From the same source it is clear that in 1904 he had intended the Jena appointment to his first full professorship as a stepping stone. But the hoped for offer of a full professorship at Heidelberg, Munich Berlin never materialised. When a suitable vacancy arose at Heidelberg the post was offered to Karl Hampe: Hampe accepted. For Cartellieri this was a source of "piercing hurt". Three years later, when he actually met the man who had been his rival for the job, he was so stressed by the encounter that he had great difficulty in "speaking clearly and slowly".[32]

The house which Cartellieri and his wife rented (and later purchased outright for 50,000 Marks) was one of the first in a new development of so-called "noble houses" ("executive homes") on the western side of Jena. It remained his home till his death in 1955.[7] As a university professor in a still small city where industrialisation had arrived relatively late, and economic prosperity remained heavily dependent on the university, he occupied a privileged social position. The Cartellieri household included children's nannies, a cook and a parlour maid.[7]

His full professorship having been confirmed, Cartellieri delivered his inaugural lecture (subsequently published as a 32-page booklet) on 12 November 1904. He took as his subject "the essence and structure of the study of history".[33] Between 1904 and 1945 he supervised 144 doctoral dissertations and four habilitation dissertations. No fewer than fifty-five of those dissertations incorporated a strong focus on regional history, an academic discipline virtually never touched upon by scholars in more centralised states such as England and France.[7] Among Cartellieri's more noteworthy students were the historians Ulrich Crämer, Willy Flach, Friedrich Schneider and Hans Tümmler. There were, however, only two - Friedrich Schneider and Helmut Tiedemann - who were supervised both for their doctorates and for their habilitations by Cartellieri.[34]

Among university colleagues, Cartellieri was viewed as one who sided with the moderniser-reformers. As early as 1903, while sill only an associate professor, he put pen to paper in order to complain to the University Curator about the poorly equipped seminar rooms. He asked for more funding, especially for the library.[35] Later, despite privately deploring the opening up of university facilities to female students in his diary, he was generally seen to be supportive of female students at Jena.[7] By 1919 no fewer than ten of his doctoral students had been women, which in the context of the times was a remarkably high number. Several of his female doctoral students indeed received from his a coveted "cum laude" commendation for their dissertation. Käthe Nikolai was a doctoral student who received her degree from him in 1921, and thereafter became his long-standing research assistant. As his influence with the university administrators increased he was able to secure improvements both with respect to the seminar facilities and with regard to the books in the library, by stipulating a clear set of rules.[7]

Cartellieri was the only History Professor at Jena whose lectures and examinations covered the entire chronological spectrum from late antiquity to contemporary history.[27] He delivered a series of lectures on the French Revolution and Napoleonic era every year till his retirement in 1935, basing them on French sources and francophone historiography.[10] Several times a week he also managed to take time out for strenuous walks in the nearby forest with fellow scholars, which became an integral feature of academic culture among colleagues.[36]

War years

In common with many historians, Cartellieri's underlying beliefs were much affected by the First World War. By the start of 1914 his career was clearly on an upward trajectory. He had received the (probably largely honorary) title Hofrat in 1913. During Easter 1914 he accepted an appointment as university prorector which conferred certain administrative responsibilities and considerable status.[11] He sustained more international contacts than ever, representing the university abroad. During 1913 he had also addressed a historians' congress in London at the start of the year and another in Vienna towards its ends. On both occasions his theme concerned his further researches on the French king, Philippe Auguste.[11] He was also part of the new working group coming together to create a new Cambridge Medieval History series. His international networking may have been seen as excessive among one or two colleagues in Germany, however. Among university historians of the period he was on occasion identified simply as "the Frenchman".[36]

On 28 June 1914, as Crown Prince Franz Ferdinand and his wife were being assassinated at Sarajevo, Cartellieri was on an international train, en route to a conference of university rectors in Groningen, at which he would represent the University of Jena.[11] Cartellieri enjoyed international conferences, and garbled newspaper reports of a killing at the other end of the Austrian empire found little resonance either with the conference delegates or in the Dutch press. Of greater importance, as it seemed at the time, was the message he received that permission had finally been granted to start work on building an extension to the University Library in Jena later that year. The building work had been a constantly postponed item on the university's agenda for more than twenty years, and the library extension would provide researchers with access to an additional 250,000 books.[11] Even after the details of the assassination became known and the international crisis began to accelerate towards the precipice of war, he was not conscious of any reluctance on the part of foreign academic colleagues to engage with the Germans.[7] He was not unaffected, however: completion of the fourth and final volume of his great work on King Philippe Auguste was delayed, both by his prorectoral appointment and by the war. Cartellieri had been following a strictly chronological approach to his exposition, and had reached 1214 and the Battle of Bouvines just before the war broke out. Now, however, he faced the likelihood that his work would lose all its readers. Among Germans, the outbreak of war transformed King Philippe Auguste into a totem of French nationalism, and as such a wholly inappropriate research topic for a conventionally patriotic German historian. As Cartellieri's diaries reveal, the inopportune timing of a magnum opus dealing with the (French) King Philippe Auguste's victory over the (German) Emperor Otto IV at Bovines was only made worse by the battle's seven hundredth anniversary, in May 1914.[7] In October 1914 he complained in his diary that, because of this, he "bore the suffering of that year of warfare like few other colleagues!"[c] Despite doubts about the topic and the prospect of much diminished readership among scholars in Germany, he nevertheless continued his research for his lengthy study of the French king, the final volume of which was eventually published in 1922.[37]

In the end the First World War lasted for more than four years. During that time "war journalism" became a major media growth sector in Germany. It was a sector to which, in the judgement of one twenty-first century historian, roughly half of Germany's Medievalist professors contributed.[6] Alexander Cartellieri was one of those historians whose underlying attitudes were transformed permanently by war and by the crisis-strewn early years of the republican government which followed. According to Matthias Steinbach, Cartellieri underwent an "interior change into an embittered nationalist, content to squander intellectual and heuristic energies in the fight against the enemy and, later, against the Versailles peace treaty".[15] Steinbach also highlights a hardening and militarization of the diary entries during the first months of the war.[7] Each reported victory by German troops is celebrated in the diaries. Cartellieri seems to be dreaming of a return to the pre-1806 Holy Roman Empire.[38] Steinbach finds that this contrasts starkly with a speech Cartellieri had delivered in June 1914 in his capacity as university prorector, in which he had characterised France and Germany as "siblings at odds over an inheritance" and urged students to "recognise no frontier-posts in the intellectual struggle, but to set out boldly in order to conquer the non-destructive realm of knowledge". He had stressed back in 1914 that it had "never been the German way [to] transfer harsh political differences into the spiritual and personal spheres".[39] That approach had changed by October 1914, when in an address to a student audience he asserted that military and economic armaments were not sufficient: intellectual Germany must also work for victory: "The victory of German arms shall open up new paths for the triumph of German ideas".[7] Even though he had steeped himself in French culture for decades, in November 1916 he was writing of "France's thirst for revenge [over 1871]" which the neighbouring superpower wanted to quench at Germany's expense.[40]

Using the pseudonym "Konrad", Cartellieri contributed, during 1914/15 to Eugen Diederichs's monthly magazine Die Tat, a publication produced in Jena which was devoted to the arts and politics, and which during the war became strikingly nationalistic. He used his "Konrad" pieces to try and recreate medieval imperialism for the twentieth century and, as he expressed it, "to preach and speak of emperor and empire".[36] He presented medieval German kings and emperors as precursors for a powerful monarchy, of the kind that Germany should hope for in her present situation.[6] It is unclear why Cartellieri ended his contributions to Die Tat in 1915: possibly he was uncomfortable with an editorial line that repeatedly stressed the contrast between German culture and the culture of western Europe more broadly.[36] Apart from those "Konrad" articles, Cartellieri kept away from "war journalism". He wrote that he had no wish to "try and unveil the secrets of the General Staff, or to give them marks out of ten, using a few cards and newspaper headlines".[36] On the other hand, he also did not engage politically, as might have been expected, in Dietrich Schäfer's "Non-aligned Committee for a German Peace" ("Unabhängige Ausschuss für einen deutschen Frieden") or in the ultra-conservative "Fatherland Party" ("Deutsche Vaterlandspartei").[36]

Although university professors were relatively well remunerated during the first decades of the twentieth century, even for prosperous families such as the Cartellieris, the war years involved significant privation. Cartellieri was obliged to survive without a housekeeper and without a gardener, and was no longer to take the regular trips to the south of Europe to which he had become accustomed before 1914. He tried to keep in touch with those of his former students who had been sent to fight on the frontline, sending letters, sweets/candies and short papers.[36] In 1915 his eldest son, Walther and his younger brother, Otto went off to join in the fighting. Between 1915 and 1918 Alexander Cartellieri increasingly withdrew from the present, and immersed himself in the Medieval world of knights and tales of the orient.[41]

Following the German invasion of Belgium in August 1914, and in the context of the ensuing military occupation, Cartellieri's, the distinguished Wallon medievalist Henri Pirenne was questioned by the military authorities and then taken into custody, held successively in Krefeld, a hut in the camp on the edge of Holzminden, Jena (1916) and Creuzburg (from 1917 till the war ended). Shortly after his arrival in Jena, in August 1916 Pirenne met up with Cartellieri. The two men were at this time professional and personal friends of longstanding, but their views on the invasion of Belgium and the impact on each of them of subsequent events were understandably very different. Although Pirenne was detained, far from his family and against his will, the German authorities had recently relaxed the conditions of his detention. He was now required to report to the authorities only twice per week, and was otherwise left at large in Jena, though there is no mention in German-language sources of any relaxation of the condition imposed - according to French-language sources - in 1914, whereby he was prohibited from accessing any books. He devoted much of his time to authorship (from memory) and also took the opportunity to master the Russian language through oral instruction received from fellow detainees. While he was detained in Jena, Alexander Cartellieri was the only person whose company Pirenne sought out. After a long walk that the two men took together in January 1917, Cartellieri confided to his diary that he thought Pirenne "an exceptionally clever man, unfailingly obliging in discussion, but of course subject to the limitations to be expected of any Frenchman".[42][43][d] At the end of 1917 Pirenne was moved again, this time to Creuzburg, a small town with a large fortress, nestling in the countryside to the west of Erfurt. It quickly became clear that the former friendship between the two eminent scholars had cooled. They no longer met up or exchanged letters. In 1920 Henri Pirenne published a memoire of his German captivity covering the period from March 1916 till November 1918. He characterised Alexander Cartellieri as one of those German professors, hooked on conquest, who shared in the blame for the World War.[36]

Right up till the end of September 1918, Cartellieri continued to believe that the war might deliver a happy outcome for Germany. As a result of the Russian revolution, the country had been "liberated for ever from the dangerous threat in the east". To the west, he continued to hope for an Anglo-American falling out.[36] He held on to his "belief in Germany" throughout the war. On 8 November 1918 he noted, that "the firm belief in the German real, in the fatherland, cannot be shaken".[36]

By the end of the war Cartellieri had built his library beyond 18,000 volumes: he would never own more books. According to Matthias Steinbach, who has made a study of the matter, there were only three other men in Germany with comparable book collections: the sociologist Werner Sombart, the international economist Joseph Schumpeter and the polymath-sociologist Max Weber. Abroad there were, at the time, perhaps two other men with comparable private book collections: the philosophers Benedetto Croce in Naples and Henri Bergson in Paris.[44]

Peace and the republic

The rolling revolutions of 1918/19 came as a great shock to Cartellieri. The tone of his diary entries sharpens. The Abdication of Wilhelm II on 9 November 1918 created a "day of irreversible shame for Germany": that shame could "only be washed away by blood".[45][46] The armistice terms imposed on 11 November 1918 were "terrible".[45] On 13 November he wrote, "Who could be so dumb as to believe in the League of Nations, if we permanently loose Elsaß-Lothringen? Wolf [his son] says at once 'we'll take it back!' Bravo, that's how the young people have to think, and I look forward to experiencing that retribution."[45] Cartellieri wanted to use his speeches on the creation of the empire and his lectures on supposed "war guilt" to support an enhanced sense of nationhood. His lectures nevertheless tended to avoid an overtly political commitment. He insisted that he did not wish "to pour anger into the past".[47][e]

Like many of those who had been appalled by the emperor's enforced abdication, Cartellieri completely rejected the republican regime which during the 1930s became known (in a term originated by Adolf Hitler in a speech of snarling contempt) as the Weimar republic.[48] Cartellieri had no great respect for "parliamentary principles", and adhered uncompromisingly to the view that no legitimate state authority can be based on a lot of slips of paper (i.e. ballot papers).[49] The general election held on 19 January 1919 was Germany's first general election to use Proportional representation. It was the first time women were permitted to vote. The minimum voting age was reduced from 25 to 20.[50] Despite Cartellieri's loathing of the rapidly emerging post-imperial constitutional arrangements, he and his entire family turned out and voted with more than 30 Million others. (In the previous general election, held in 1912, a little over 12 million people had voted.[50]) Unanimously (it was recorded by Cartellieri), they "voted nationalist", "mainly to bring Clemens von Delbrück in [and] create some dams against the storm surge of democratic ideas".[36] Cartellieri would continue conscientiously to record every election in his diary right up till the Adenauer years.[15] He despised social democracy and distanced himself from the Labour movement. He took a close interest in political developments in Italy and the 1922 Fascist take-over. For Cartellieri, the March on Rome represented "the first significant anto-socialist movement since the French revolution".[51] When the Catholic centrist politician Matthias Erzberger was murdered by right-wing terrorists in August 1921, Cartellieri's diary entry was lacking in human empathy: it characterised the late Erzberger as one of the "fatherland's worst pests".[52] In view of his antiparliamentary stancein post-imperial Germany, Cartellieri cannot be identified as one of the so-called "Vernunftrepublikaner" (loosely, "republicans by pragmatism"): yet he conducted himself with unremarkable "constitutional loyalty". The biographer Matthias Steinbach places him closer to those who acknowledged the Weimar constitution from a sense of what was reasonable under the circumstances than to the die-hard "national-conservative" professors such as Dietrich Schäfer, Johannes Haller and Max Lenz.[7][32] The unity of the state was his top priority, and he accordingly put up with the new republican state structure. He might have seen his university lectures as an opportunity to speak out against the government, but he did not. In this and other respects, he was not untypical of the people who supported the "National People's Party" ("Deutschnationale Volkspartei" / DNVP). During the later 1920s and early 1930s, which was a period of intensifying political gridlock in the parliament ("Reichstag") and polarisation on the streets, Cartellieri generally voted for the DNVP or, latterly, for the conservative-liberal "People's Party" ("Deutsche Volkspartei" / DVP).[15]

Throughout the years of the republic, Alexander Cartellieri was one of many for whom the consequences of punitive terms imposed at Versailles continued to rankle. He rejected the "war guilt" hypothesis. He stressed, instead, "the love of peace and self-restraint ... which Germany [had demonstrated] under all sorts of circumstances before the war".[36] The need to repudiate the "war guilt" hypothesis led him to engage actively with the working groups and committees of the "Vereinigte Vaterländische Verbände Deutschlands" (loosely, "United German Patriotic Associations") and to join in defending the "war guilt lie" hypothesis.[36][53] Cartellieri was also a propagator of the (subsequently) infamous Stab-in-the-back legend.[54] It is evident from his diaries that he longed for a Hohenzollern restoration. In 1922, writing that he could now track his diary entriesd all the way back to 1915, he noted with wonder in 1922, the mood of optimistic pride and good cheer that had still prevailed back then.[55]

The next year Ilse Cartellieri, daughter of Alexander Cartellieri, married the Eutin geographer Max Prange (1891–1979). The marriage was followed by the births of their three recorded children. These included the historian Wolfgang Prange (1932–2018).[56]

The hyperinflation of 1922/23 took its toll on university salaries, and after 1922 the Cartellieris wee no longer able to enjoy the standard of living that they would have taken for granted before 1914. Alexander Cartellieri sold part of his library in order to be able to buy groceries, and magazine subscriptions were cancelled. Although university salaraies were increased with increasing frequency in order to try and match price rises, for much of the time Carellieri's salary was virtually worthless. After currency stabilisation began to take effect, he was earning an annual salary of 3,500 Marks, which was approximately twice that of an unskilled worker.[36][57]

The diaries contain several indications that during the 1920s Cartellieri became frustrated over the extent of his professional achievements. As early as 21 December 1921 he wrote in his diary, "My passionate yearning somehow to influence my times and the future, will perhaps never be fulfilled ... I would have loved to have been able to be of service to great men, I would have servf them loyally in the old German manner, [but] the opportunity never came: I was unloved!".[58][f] That mood was with him on 28 November 1928 when he wrote, "What will be left of me? A cold obituary in the HZ?" [g][59]

Alongside his work at the university, Cartellieri served as deputy chair of the "Association for Thuringian History and Antiquity". He sat on the advisory board of the "Society of Friends of the University" and was also a member of the exclusive inner-circle at the Weimar-based German Dante Sciety. In February 1933, a few weeks after the Hitler government took power in Berlin, Alexander Cartellieri was accepted as a member of the Saxon Academy of Sciences and Humanities.[36][60]

During the crtisis years that preceded the toppling of republican democracy, Cartellieri's diaries become increasingly preoccupied with his private life. His younger brother, Otto Cartellieri, died suddenly and unexpectedly while vacationing in Switzerland in April 1930.[61] Tragedy came even closer to home with the death of his wife in March 1931. Plunged intyo deep personal crisis, for the next couple of years Cartellieri found little space in his diaries for current events. After Margarete died, he tried several times to form new partnerships, hoping to marry again, but in this aspiration he was unsuccessful.[62]

Notes

  1. ^ ... der "grösste Geschichtsschreiber aller Völker und Zeiten".[8][9]
  2. ^ "Die Ehe ist immer noch das anständigste Mittel, gewisse Gefühle zu befriedigen ... gute Köchin, Haushälterin und Pflegerin [zu] bekommen".[7]
  3. ^ ... als "Leidtragender des Kriegsjahres wie wenig andere Kollegen!"[7]
  4. ^ "... ein ausnehmend kluger und in der Erörterung verbindlicher Mann, freilich in den Grenzen, die einem Franzosen gesteck".[43]
  5. ^ "... keinen Zorn in die Vergangenheit hineinzugiessen."[47]
  6. ^ "Mein heisses Verlangen, irgendwie einzuwirken auf meine Zeit, auf eine spätere Zeit, wird vielleicht nie erfüllt werden [...] Gerne hätte ich grossen Männern gedient, ich wäre ihnen nach altgermanischer Art treu gewesen, es fand sich dazu keine Gelegenheit, geliebt hat mich auch keiner".[58]
  7. ^ "Was wird von mir bleiben? Ein frostiger Nekrolog in der HZ?"[59]

References

  1. ^ "Alexander Cartellieri deutscher Historiker; Prof.; Dr. phil". Munzinger Archiv GmbH, Ravensburg. 26 February 1962. Retrieved 24 November 2020.
  2. ^ a b c d Dagmar Drüll (7 March 2013). Cartellieri, Alexander Georg Maximilian. Springer-Verlag. p. 36. ISBN 978-3-642-70760-5. {{cite book}}: |work= ignored (help)
  3. ^ Barbara Boisits (6 May 2001). "Cartellieri, Casimir Anton". Oesterreichisches Musiklexikon online. Österreichische Akademie der Wissenschaften, Wien. Retrieved 24 November 2020.
  4. ^ Christoph Spering (compiler of programme notes) (25 December 2003). "Antonio Cartellieris Weihnachtsoratorium: Eine Spurensuche". Antonio Cartellieri, Weihnachtsoratorium (concert programme). musik+konzept e.V., Maria Spering, Köln. Retrieved 24 November 2020.
  5. ^ Königsberg (Regierungsbezirk) (December 1834). Amtsblatt der Preussischen Regierung zu Königsberg No.49. Regierung zu Königsberg. p. 323.
  6. ^ a b c Rudolf Schieffer (2005). "Weltgeltung und nationale Verführung: Die deutschsprachige Mediävistik vom ausgehenden 19. Jahrhundert bis 1918". Konstanz Working Circle for Middle Ages History. pp. 39–61, 47. ISSN 0452-490X. Retrieved 24 November 2020.
  7. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s t u v w x y z Matthias Steinbach [in German] (2001). "Des Konigs Biograph. Alexander Cartellieri (1867-1955). Historiker zwischen Frankreich und Deutschland". Zeitschrift für Geschichtswissenschaft. pp. 15–18, 19, 21, 32, 36, 41–43, 53–54, 61, 66, 97, 105–109, 116, 125, 130, 140–141, 162. ISSN 0044-2828. Retrieved 24 November 2020.
  8. ^ a b Alexander Cartellieri: diary entry 2 January 1949, in: Matthias Steinbach & Uwe Dathe (compilers): "Alexander Cartellieri. Tagebücher eines deutschen Historikers. Vom Kaiserreich bis in die Zweistaatlichkeit (1899–1953)". München 2014, p. 889.
  9. ^ a b Gerhard A. Ritter. "A. Cartellieri: Tagebücher eines deutschen Historikers". Deutsche Geschichtsquellen des 19. und 20. Jahrhunderts (review). Historisches Fachinformationssystem e.V. nc/o Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin. ISBN 978-3486718881. Retrieved 24 November 2020.
  10. ^ a b c Matthias Steinbach [in German] (1999). "Zwischen Königsgräbern und Revolutionsfeiertagen". Paris Erfahrung, Identität und Geschichte. Deutsches Historisches Institut Paris. pp. 143–159. Retrieved 24 November 2020.
  11. ^ a b c d e f g h i j Tillmann Bendikowski (24 February 2014). Alexander Cartellieri: Ein Historiker in seiner Welt. C. Bertelsmann Verlag. pp. 24–36, 99–115. ISBN 978-3-641-12298-0. {{cite book}}: |work= ignored (help)
  12. ^ Mario Keßler (2014). "Matthias Steinbach / Uwe Dathe (eds.): Alexander Cartellieri. Tagebücher eines deutschen Historikers. Vom Kaiserreich bis in die Zweistaatlichkeit (1899-1953)". review. Retrieved 24 November 2020.
  13. ^ Matthias Steinbach: "Die Welt Cartellieris. Von einem Geschichtsprofessor und seinen Büchern", in: "Zeitschrift des Vereins für thüringische Geschichte" vol. 52, 1998, pp. 247–269, here: p. 250
  14. ^ Johannes Haller: Lebenserinnerungen. Gesehenes, Gehörtes, Gedachtes. Stuttgart 1960, p. 99.
  15. ^ a b c d Diary entry of 10 November 1890, quoted by Matthias Steinbach: "Alexander Cartellieri (1867–1955) – biographical introduction", in Matthias Steinbach, Uwe Dathe (compiler-editors): "Alexander Cartellieri. Tagebücher eines deutschen Historikers. Vom Kaiserreich bis in die Zweistaatlichkeit (1899–1953)". München 2014, pp. 7–30, here: pp. 11, 16, 21.
  16. ^ Cartellieri, Alexander (1894). "L'avènement de Philippe-Auguste (1179-1180)". 54. Revue historique, Paris: 1–33. {{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires |journal= (help)
  17. ^ Sonja Häder; Ulrich Wiegmann (2012). "Vorwort. In addition to giving Margarete's dates and sharing the authors' views on the roles of professors wives in Germany a hundred years ago, this source also includes on its front cover a portrait of Alexander and Margarete Cartellieri sitting together at a table strewn with papers in the garden of their home at Jena" (PDF). An der Seite gelehrter Männer: Frauen zwischen Emanzipation und Tradition. Verlag Julius Klinkhardt, Bad Heilbrunn. p. 12. ISBN 978-3-7815-2205-3. Retrieved 30 November 2020.
  18. ^ "Alexander Cartellieri. Tagebücher eines deutschen Historikers. Vom Kaiserreich bis in die Zweistaatlichkeit (1899-1953), hg. Matthias Steinbach, Uwe Dathe. München: Oldenbourg Verlag 2014". Mitteilungen des Historischen Vereins der Pfalz online. Academia. 2014. p. 519. Retrieved 25 November 2020.
  19. ^ "Wolfgang Cartellieri". fr. Staatssekretär. Munzinger-Archiv GmbH, Ravensburg. 28 July 1969. Retrieved 25 November 2020.
  20. ^ "Ulrich Cartellieri". deutscher Jurist; fr. Bankmanager; CDU-Bundesschatzmeister (2000-2001); Dr. jur. utr. Munzinger-Archiv GmbH, Ravensburg. 12 February 2005. Retrieved 25 November 2020.
  21. ^ "Einführung .... Vorwort". Findbuch C .... Privaturkunden vor 1200. Landesarchiv Baden-Württemberg, Stuttgart. Retrieved 25 November 2020.
  22. ^ a b c Diary entres 1895 quoted by Matthias Steinbach: "Die aus Urkunden und Akten gekelterten Weine sind Schlaftrunke", Alexander Cartellieri as Karlsruhe ardhivist, in: "Zeitschrift für die Geschichte des Oberrheins". vol. 160, 2012, pp. 493–560, here: p. 502, 532
  23. ^ Joachim Leuschner [in German] (1957). "Cartellieri, Otto Ernst Wilhelm, Historiker, * 23.1.1872 Odessa, † 13.4.1930 Basel. (evangelisch)". Neue Deutsche Biographie. Historische Kommission bei der Bayerischen Akademie der Wissenschaften (HiKo), München. pp. 160–161. Retrieved 26 November 2020.
  24. ^ Geneviève Warland (author); Hubert Roland (compiler-editor); Marnix Beyen (compiler-editor); Greet Draye (compiler-editor) (2011). Rezeption und Wahrnehmung der deutschen Geschichtswissenschaft. Waxmann Verlag. pp. 219–261. ISBN 978-3-8309-6687-6. {{cite book}}: |author1= has generic name (help); |work= ignored (help)
  25. ^ Hermann Jakobs (author); Jürgen Miethke (compiler-editor) (1 December 2013). Die Mediävistik bis zum Ende der Weimarer Republik. Springer-Verlag. pp. 39–68. ISBN 978-3-642-76669-5. {{cite book}}: |author1= has generic name (help); |work= ignored (help)
  26. ^ Wilhelm Dilthey (3 December 2018). page note (linked with previous page) 2. Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht. p. 121. ISBN 978-3-647-37074-3. {{cite book}}: |work= ignored (help)
  27. ^ a b Heribert Müller: "Aber das menschliche Herz bleibt, und darum können wir historisch kongenial verstehen. Anmerkungen zu einer Biographie des Jenaer Historikers Alexander Cartellieri", in: "Zeitschrift des Vereins für Thüringische Geschichte". vol.55, 2001, pp. 337–352, here: p. 341.
  28. ^ Silvia Backs (1987). "Lorenz, Ottokar: Historiker, * 17.9.1832 Iglau (Mähren), † 13.5.1904 Jena. (katholisch, dann evangelisch)". Neue Deutsche Biographie. Historische Kommission bei der Bayerischen Akademie der Wissenschaften (HiKo), München. pp. 170–172. Retrieved 30 November 2020.
  29. ^ Friedhilde Krause; Felicitas Marwinski. Jena 1c .... 1.3. Georg Olms Verlag. p. 168. ISBN 978-3-487-41815-5. {{cite book}}: |work= ignored (help)
  30. ^ Diary entry 24 August 1913, reproduced in: Matthias Steinbach & Uwe Dathe (compiler-editors): Alexander Cartellieri. "Tagebücher eines deutschen Historikers. Vom Kaiserreich bis in die Zweistaatlichkeit (1899–1953)", München 2014, p. 146.
  31. ^ Julian Führer (2014). "Rezension: Alexander Cartellieri: Tagebücher eines deutschen Historikers:Vom Kaiserreich bis in die Zweistaatlichkeit (1899-1953), hg. Matthias STEINBACH, Uwe DATHE, München: Oldenbourg Verlag 2014 (Deutsche Geschichtsquellen des 19. und 20. Jahrhunderts 69)" (PDF). review. Zurich Open Repository and Archive, University of Zurich. Retrieved 30 November 2020.
  32. ^ a b Folker Reichert: Gelehrtes Leben. Karl Hampe, das Mittelalter und die Geschichte der Deutschen. Göttingen 2009, pp. 78, 148
  33. ^ Cartellieri, A. (1905). Über wesen und gliederung der geschichtswissenschaft: Akademische antrittsrede gehalten am 12. november 1904. Leipzig: Dyksche buchhandlung.[1]
  34. ^ Herbert Gottwald: "Die Jenaer Geschichtswissenschaft in der Zeit des Nationalsozialismus", in: Uwe Hoßfeld, Jürgen John, Jürgen, Oliver Lemuth (co-producer-compilers.): ""Kämpferische Wissenschaft". Studien zur Universität Jena im Nationalsozialismus". Köln 2003, pp. 913–942, here: p. 929.
  35. ^ Matthias Werner: "Stationen Jenaer Geschichtswissenschaft", in : "Identität und Geschichte". Weimar 1997, pp. 9–26, here: p. 11.
  36. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o Matthias Steinbach: Des Königs Biograph. Alexander Cartellieri (1867–1955). Historiker zwischen Frankreich und Deutschland. Frankfurt am Main. 2001, pp. 110–114, 123, 125, 130, 132, 136, 149, 159, 163, 175-176, 200, 208, 231, 344.
  37. ^ Cartellieri, Alexander (1922). Philipp II. August König von Frankreich / Bd. 4, 2. Bouvines u. d. Ende d. Regierung. Dyksche Buchhandlung in Leipzig & Le Soudier in Paris.
  38. ^ Diary entry of 7 March 1915, reproduced in Matthias Steinbach, Uwe Dathe (editors): "Alexander Cartellieri. Tagebücher eines deutschen Historikers. Vom Kaiserreich bis in die Zweistaatlichkeit (1899–1953)". München 2014, p. 187
  39. ^ Quoted by Mathhias Steinbach in " Des Königs Biograph. Alexander Cartellieri (1867–1955). Historiker zwischen Frankreich und Deutschland. Frankfurt am Main u. a. 2001, p. 121"
  40. ^ Uwe Hoßfeld, Jürgen John, Jürgen, Rüdiger Stutz: ""Kämpferische Wissenschaft": Zum Profilwandel der Jenaer Universität im Nationalsozialismus", in: Uwe Hoßfeld, Jürgen John, Jürgen, Oliver Lemuth (compiler-editors): ""Kämpferische Wissenschaft". Studien zur Universität Jena im Nationalsozialismus", Köln 2003, pp. 23–121, here: p. 38. "Alexander Cartellieri: Frankreichs politische Beziehungen zu Deutschland vom Frankfurter Frieden bis zum Ausbruch des Weltkrieges".
  41. ^ Matthias Steinbach: "Alexander Cartellieri (1867–1955) – biografische Einführung", in: Matthias Steinbach, Uwe Dathe (editor-compilers): "Alexander Cartellieri. Tagebücher eines deutschen Historikers. Vom Kaiserreich bis in die Zweistaatlichkeit (1899–1953)". München 2014, pp. 7–30, here: p. 25.
  42. ^ Tagebucheintrag vom 7. Januar 1917. In: Matthias Steinbach, Uwe Dathe (compiler-editors.): Alexander Cartellieri. Tagebücher eines deutschen Historikers. Vom Kaiserreich bis in die Zweistaatlichkeit (1899–1953). München 2014, S. 257
  43. ^ a b Peter Schöttler. "review of: Matthias Steinbach / Uwe Dathe (eds.),Alexander Cartellieri. Tagebücher eines deutschen Historikers. Vom Kaiserreich bis in die Zweistaatlichkeit (1899-1953), München: DeGruyter Oldenbourg, 2014, in: Francia-Recensio, 2015-2, 19./20.Jahrhundert". Histoire contemporaine (recensio.net). ISBN 978-3-486-71888-1. Retrieved 22 January 2021.
  44. ^ Matthias Steinbach: Die Welt Cartellieris. Von einem Geschichtsprofessor und seinen Büchern. In: Zeitschrift des Vereins für thüringische Geschichte. 52, 1998, pp. 247–269, here: p. 261.
  45. ^ a b c Diary entry for 9 November 1918, in Matthias Steinbach, Uwe Dathe (compiler-editors): "Alexander Cartellieri. Tagebücher eines deutschen Historikers. Vom Kaiserreich bis in die Zweistaatlichkeit (1899–1953)". München 2014, p. 346-347, 389.
  46. ^ Gerhard A. Ritter (5 September 2014). "Cartellieri, Alexander : Tagebücher eines deutschen Historikers. Vom Kaiserreich bis in die Zweistaatlichkeit 1899–1953, hrsg. v. Matthias Steinbach u. Uwe Dathe (Deutsche Geschichtsquellen des 19. und 20. Jahrhunderts)". review ("Rezensiert für H-Soz-Kult"). Historisches Fachinformationssystem e.V. c/o Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin. ISBN 978-3486718881. Retrieved 22 January 2021.
  47. ^ a b Matthias Steinbach: "Des Königs Biograph. Alexander Cartellieri (1867–1955). Historiker zwischen Frankreich und Deutschland". Frankfurt am Main, 2001, p. 158 f. Diary entry for 20 January 1929, in: Matthias Steinbach, Uwe Dathe (compiler-editors): "Alexander Cartellieri. Tagebücher eines deutschen Historikers. Vom Kaiserreich bis in die Zweistaatlichkeit (1899–1953)". München 2014, p. 594.
  48. ^ Schnurr, Eva-Maria (30 September 2014). "Der Name des Feindes: Warum heißt die erste deutsche Demokratie eigentlich 'Weimarer Republik?' ". Der Spiegel (in German). Retrieved 21 January 2021.
  49. ^ Folker Reichert (2009). Herzensmonarchisten und Venrunftrepublikaner. Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht. pp. 141–169, here 148. ISBN 978-3-525-36072-9. {{cite book}}: |work= ignored (help)
  50. ^ a b Dieter Nohlen & Philip Stöver (2010) Elections in Europe: A data handbook, pp 746-762 ISBN 978-3-8329-5609-7
  51. ^ Diary entry for 29 October 1922, in: Matthias Steinbach, Uwe Dathe (compiler-editors.): "Alexander Cartellieri. Tagebücher eines deutschen Historikers. Vom Kaiserreich bis in die Zweistaatlichkeit (1899–1953)". München 2014, p. 466.
  52. ^ Diary entry for 29 December 1922, in: Matthias Steinbach, Uwe Dathe (editor-compilers): "Alexander Cartellieri. Tagebücher eines deutschen Historikers. Vom Kaiserreich bis in die Zweistaatlichkeit (1899–1953)". München 2014, p. 435
  53. ^ Herbert Gottwald (author); Uwe Hoßfeld (editor-compiler) [in German]; Jürgen John (editor-compiler) [in German]; Oliver Lemuth (2003). "Die Jenaer Geschichtswissenschaft in der Zeit des Nationalsozialismus". "Kämpferische Wissenschaft". Studien zur Universität Jena im Nationalsozialismus. Böhlau, Köln. pp. 913–942, here p. 912. ISBN 9783412041021. Retrieved 23 January 2021. {{cite web}}: |author1= has generic name (help)
  54. ^ Gerhard A. Ritter (September 2014). "Alexander Cartellieri. Tagebücher eines deutschen Historikers: Vom Kaiserreich bisin die Zweistaatlichkeit 1899–1953, hrsg. v. Matthias Steinbach u. Uwe Dathe. München: Oldenbourg Verlag, 2014. 980 S. ISBN 978-3-486-71888-1". book review. H-Soz-u-Kult. Retrieved 23 January 2021.
  55. ^ Diary entry for 29 December 1922, in: Matthias Steinbach, Uwe Dathe (compiler-editors): "Alexander Cartellieri. Tagebücher eines deutschen Historikers. Vom Kaiserreich bis in die Zweistaatlichkeit (1899–1953)", München 2014, p. 473
  56. ^ Enno Bünz: "Wolfgang Prange (1932–2018)", in: "Blätter für deutsche Landesgeschichte. vol. 154, 2018, pp. 807–815, here: p. 807.
  57. ^ Dr. Günter Hamer (verantwortlicher als Vizepräsident des Statistischen Bundesamtes) (May 1987). "Verdienste und Kostender Lebenshaltung". Von den zwanziger zu denachtziger Jahren: Ein Vergleich der Lebensverhältnisse der Menschen. Statistisches Bundesamt, Wiesbaden & Verlag W. Kohlhammer GmbH, Mainz. pp. 33–38. ISBN 978-3-82460002-1. Retrieved 23 January 2021.
  58. ^ a b Diary entry for 20 December 1921, in: Matthias Steinbach, Uwe Dathe (compiler-editors): "Alexander Cartellieri. Tagebücher eines deutschen Historikers. Vom Kaiserreich bis in die Zweistaatlichkeit (1899–1953)", München 2014, p. 445
  59. ^ a b Diary entry for 25 November 1928, in: Matthias Steinbach, Uwe Dathe (compiler-editors): "Alexander Cartellieri. Tagebücher eines deutschen Historikers. Vom Kaiserreich bis in die Zweistaatlichkeit (1899–1953)". München 2014, p. 589.
  60. ^ Saskia Paul. "Wiedergutmachung und Entnazifizierung an der Sächsischen Akademie der Wissenschaften zu Leipzig von 1945 bis zur Wiedereröffnung am 1. Juli 1948". Denkströme: Journal der Sächsischen Akademie der Wissenschaften zu Leipzig. Sächsischen Akademie der Wissenschaften zu Leipzig. ISSN 1867-7061. Retrieved 23 January 2021.
  61. ^ Fritz Quicke (1930). "Nécrologie: Otto Cartellieri". Revue belge de Philologie et d'Histoire. Poirtail Persée, École Normale Supérieure de Lyon. pp. 1249–1251. Retrieved 23 January 2021.
  62. ^ Matthias Steinbach, Uwe Dathe (editor-compilers): "Alexander Cartellieri. Tagebücher eines deutschen Historikers. Vom Kaiserreich bis in die Zweistaatlichkeit (1899–1953)". München 2014, p. 37.
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Alexander_Cartellieri&oldid=1003024011"