Jump to content

Assuwa

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Assuwa
𒀸𒋗𒉿
aš-šu-wa
unknown-1430 BC
Common languagesLuwian[1]
GovernmentConfederation
Members 
• legible
Kispuwa, Unaliya, Dura, Halluwa, Huwallusiya, Karakisa, Dunda, Adadura, Parista, Warsiya, Kuruppiya, Alatra, Pasuhalta, Mount Pahurina, Wilusiya, Taruisa
• obliterated
[—]lugga, [—], [—],
[—]waa, [—]luissa, [—]
Historical eraBronze Age

Assuwa (Hittite: 𒀸𒋗𒉿, romanized: aš-šu-wa) was a region of Bronze Age Anatolia located west of the Kızılırmak River. It was mentioned in Aegean, Anatolian and Egyptian inscriptions but is best known from Hittite records describing a league of 22 towns or states that rebelled against Hittite authority. It disappears from history during the thirteenth century BC.

Etymology

[edit]

The name appears in different scripts over the course of a few hundred years. The individual etymologies are unknown,[2] but scholarship has come to accept that the Ancient Greek: Ᾰ̓σῐ́ᾱ, romanizedAsia is cognate to the Mycenaean Greek: 𐀀𐀯𐀹𐀊, romanized: a-si-wi-ja).[3]

Geography

[edit]

Assuwa was located somewhere in western Anatolia. Linear B texts from Mycenaean Greece identified it as a region within reach of Pylos associated with levies of rowers,[16] suggesting a location separated by water from the Peloponnese. While the extent of its geography is a matter of debate, recent scholarship has argued that much of its territory was located in the western part of classical Phrygia.[17][18][19] This same region was designated by the Hittite laws as part of the land of Luwiya, according to modern researchers.[20][21][17] It was likewise mentioned in a contemporary Egyptian poetical stela along with Keftiu as one of the lands to the west of Egypt.[9][22]

History

[edit]

The earliest mention of a-šu-wi(ya)[15] is from an Anatolian royal seal dating to the eighteenth/seventeenth centuries BC,[23][24] contemporary to the first and only mention of the land of Luwiya of the Hittite texts.[25] The name a-su-ja[7] in Minoan Linear A texts of the sixteenth century BC is also acknowledged to be a likely reference to Assuwa,[3][26] though with no clear understanding of the context.

Egyptian records mention a region called isy[15] and an Assuwan "chief" and "prince" providing supplies to Thutmose III from 1445-1439 BC during his military campaigns against Nuhašše in modern Syria, including copper, lead, lapis lazuli, ivory, wood and horses.[10] It has been suggested these references predate Egypt's direct contacts with the Hittites and refer to a trade relationship mediated by Alashiya[9] and initiated by an Assuwan power with access to the Mediterranean.[10]

Assuwa is likewise mentioned in six surviving Hittite documents,[27] with all texts either dated to or referring to events occurring during the reign of Tudhaliya I/II.[3] Most of our knowledge comes from the Annals of Tudḫaliya, which gives a detailed account of a rebellion by a league of towns in the aftermath of a Hittite campaign against Arzawan controlled territories west of the Maraššantiya.[10][28][12]

But when I turned back to Hattusa, then against me these lands declared war: [—]lugga, Kispuwa, Unaliya, [—], Dura, Halluwa, Huwallusiya, Karakisa, Dunda, Adadura, Parista, [—], [—]waa, Warsiya, Kuruppiya, [—]luissa, Alatra, Mount Pahurina, Pasuhalta, [—], Wilusiya, Taruisa. [These lands] with their warriors assembled themselves...and drew up their army opposite me...I, Tudḫaliya, brought up my forces at night, and surrounded the army of the enemy. The gods handed their army over to me, the Sun Goddess of Arinna, the Storm God of Heaven, the Protective Genius of Hatti, Zamama, Istar, Sin, Lelwani. I defeated the army of the enemy and entered their country. And from whatever country an army had come (out) to battle, the gods went before me, and the countries which I have mentioned, which declared war, the gods delivered them to me. All these countries I carried off. The conquered population, oxen, sheep, the possessions of the land, I brought away to Hattusa. Now when I had destroyed the land of Assuwa, I came back home to Hattusa. As a booty 10,000 foot soldiers and 600 teams of horses for chariots together with the 'lords of the bridle' I brought to Hattusa, and I settled them in Hattusa."[29]

Cline dates this rebellion to circa 1430 BC[10] and Bryce describes it as "the first major [Hittite] venture to the west" which was "not carried out with the aim to impose authority on the western border, but just to secure it."[30] The annals further detail the capture of an Assuwan king named Piyama-dKAL,[31] the establishment of a client state under his son Kukkuli[32] and a second rebellion[33]after which "the coalition of Assuwa was destroyed".[3]

Analysis

[edit]
1st Millenium BC

Iron AgeMycenaean GreeceHattusaSea PeoplesBattle of KadeshAchaeans (Homer)Tudḫaliya IMiletusMitanniMinoan eruptionHattusaPurushandaKültepeAssyriaMinoan chronologyKarum (trade post)Purushanda

The Land of Luwiya

[edit]

It is possible that Asuwiya ("our good land") was simply the native name for territory occupied by Luwic speakers.[34][35][4] Linguistic models suggest the existence of a common Luwian-speaking state circa 2000 BC, stretching from the central Anatolian plateau (modern Konya) northward to the western bend of the Maraššantiya (where modern Ankara, Kırıkkale and Kırşehir provinces meet).[36][37] The region was dominated by the kingdom of Purushanda,[21][36] the etymology of which suggests a takeover of Hattic lands by Luwian elites[38][39] and a kingdom made up of an eclectic mix of Luwian-speaking Luwians, Hattic-speaking Luwians, Luwian-speaking Hattians and Hattic-speaking Hattians.[40] Archaeology at Acemhöyük has confirmed the remains of central Anatolian, Mesopotamian and north Syrian pottery - as well as traces of monumental structures - dated 2659 to 2157 BC,[41] providing a plausible terminus a quo for the Luwian takeover of the region.[42]

In the eighteenth century BC the Hittites conquered the Assyrian karum at Kanesh[29] and ultimately moved south to Purushanda,[43] establishing Hittite rule over ikkuwaniya - the Lower land.[29][44] By 1650 BC everything west of Purushanda was regarded as the unconquered (and not worth conquering) land of Luwiya,[45][46] "an Old Hittite ethno-linguistic term referring to the area where Luwian was spoken."[47] While it is still an open question whether the border between the Hittites and the Luwians ever extended as far west as the Sangarious,[13] in the 1600s BC that border was clearly the Maraššantiya.[48]

Arzawa

[edit]

Within a generation "Arzawiya" is first mentioned in the Hittite records, located somewhere beyond the Hittite sphere of influence in the Lower land.[49] This suggests an extensive colonization of the land of Luwiya by a non-Luwian peoples by the turn of the sixteenth century BC - Gander focuses on Hurrian[49] Yakubovich says Carian[50] and Cline implies Ahhiyawan[3] - in the wake of prior Luwian westward migration.[13][46][51] There are historical traces of this migration - the Leleges[52] and the Lukka[29] - but it is clear the Luwians came into contact with the Mycenaeans,[53][54][55] whose strongholds in the Argolis[56] lay directly across the Aegean Sea from modern İzmir and who seem to have at first called the Luwian territory ru-wa-ni-jo ("land where Luwian is spoken").[57] With time bred by familiarity the Luwian name a-šu-wi-ya was transliterated into Mycenaean as a-si-wi-ja.[15]

As a result of this contact the Luwian language and culture went through a profound metamorphosis,[58][15] - and spread inland along the Hermos and Maeander river valleys into classical Pisidia and beyond:[29][59][60] "Extension of the Lower land further to the southwest would have brought Hittite territory in close proximity to the region which came to be called Arzawa, thus creating the potential for border disputes and cross border raids of the kind allied to in a number of treaties which Hittite kings subsequently drew up with their immediate neighbors."[46]

By the 1430s BC the Hittites perceived a threat from this unfamiliar mixture of different political, social, cultural and linguistic groups amongst the small entities and independent polities[61][62][63] in the land of Luwiya and launched a preemptive strike.[29] The campaigns against the Assuwa coalition are listed after the Lusa campaign[64] south of Lake Beyşehir.[65]

Towns of the Assuwa League

[edit]

The confederacy appears to have been a rather short-lived affair, and there is thus far no consensus as to identification of the towns of the Assuwa league listed in the Annals of Tudḫaliya:

  • Assuwa

‣"Now, the Assuwan League consisted of a coalition of forces running from Lukka in the southwest to Wilusiya in the northwest, and hence comprised western Anatolia in its entirety."[15]
‣"The group of states making up this confederacy probably lay in the far west of Anatolia, covering at least part of the Aegean coast."[29]
‣"...the province of Assuwa...is located in the Hermos valley, as much as four toponyms featuring in the list with bearing on the blanket term Assuwian League can positively be situated in the realm of Arzawa."[15]
"Starke...connects...the Land of Assuwa...with classical Assos.[46]
‣"Assuwa" was merely a city or town "somewhere in the region of the upper stretches of the Sangarius and the Tembris" and "located in the immediate proximity of the region in which the coalition was apparently active, just to the (south)east of Huwalusiya and Masa."[66]

  • Kispuwa

‣"...not attested anywhere else."[49]

  • Unaliya

...not attested anywhere else."[49]

  • Dura

"For the identification of Dura with classical Tyrrha and modern Tire(h) along the southern bank of the river late called Kaystros, see Freu (208)b...[15]

  • Halluwa

...not attested anywhere else."[49]

  • Huwallusiya

‣"...it can hardly be separated from the town of Huwalusa, which is mentioned in another small fragment probably dating from the reign of Mursillis II."[67]
"Many of the towns mentioned alongside [it] have convincingly been localized in western Phrygia by M. Forlanini."[49]
‣Woudhuizen associated it with the town of Honaz near the ancient Lycus river in Phrygia.[15]

  • Karakisa

‣"...can only be the well attested country of Karkisa..."[67]
‣"...was apparently situated close to the Seha River Land..."[68]

  • Dunda

‣"is to be localized in Kizzuwatna..."[49]

  • Adadura

‣"...not attested anywhere else."[49]

...not attested anywhere else."[49]

  • Warsiya

‣"[S]uggests some close connection with the country of Warsiyalla mentioned in §14 of the Alaksandus treaty together with the Lukka lands, Masa and Karkisa, in a context which...probably serves only to locate these countries somewhere in the west of Asia Minor".[67]

  • Kuruppiya

‣The name is identified with Karatepe on the Cilician plain,[69] far removed from traditional locations of Assuwa.
‣Woudhuizen associated it with a mountain near İzmir.[15]

...not attested anywhere else."[49]
‣"...only mentioned in a fragmentary ritual text without determinative and lacking any geographical context."[49]
‣Woudhuizen noted the correspondence with the Luwian name for Kaunos, Kwalatarna (“army camp”).[70]

...not attested anywhere else."[49]

  • Mount Pahurina

...not attested anywhere else."[49]

  • Wilusiya

‣"...[it] can be equated Ilios by way of a hypothetical form Wiluwa."[67]
‣...an alternative location at the Byzantine site of Iluza was proposed by Vangelis Pantazis...[15][71]

  • Taruisa

"The possibility that [it] might be identified with Greek Troia, i.e. the city of Troy, was observed in 1924 by E. Forrer, and after much controversy philologists have agreed that the equation is possible by way of the hypothetical form Tauriya."[67]
"A silver bowl whose hieroglyphic inscription mentions the name of Taruisa (ta-r-wi-za) might be evidence of the same Tudhaliya's campaign against Assuwa."[72][73]

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]
  1. ^ Teffeeller, Annette. (2013). Singers of Lapza: Reconstructing Identities on Bronze Age Lesbos. Luwian Identities: Culture, Language and Religion Between Anatolia and the Aegean. Netherlands: Brill. Google Books
  2. ^ Woudhuizen translated a-šu as a Luwic adverb meaning "good." See Bomhard, A. R. (1984). Toward proto-Nostratic : a new approach to the comparison of proto-Indo-European and proto-Afroasiatic, p. 112. Netherlands: North-Holland. Google Books
  3. ^ a b c d e f g Cline, Eric H. (1996). Assuwa and the Achaeans: The Mycenaean Sword at Hattusas and Its Possible Implications. The Annual at the British School at Athens, Vol. 91, pp. 137–151. ResearchGate
  4. ^ a b Achterberg, W. (2004). The Phaistos Disc: A Luwian Letter to Nestor, p. 99. Netherlands: Dutch Archaeological and Historical Society. Academic.edu
  5. ^ Best, Jan and Woudhuizen, Fred. (1988). Ancient Scripts from Crete and Cyprus, p. 83. Germany: Brill. Google Books
  6. ^ Best Jan and Woudhuizen, Fred. (2023). Lost Languages from the Mediterranean, pp. 18, 69-70. Germany: Brill. Google Books
  7. ^ a b Packard, David W. (2023). Minoan Linear A, p. 4, 43, 95. Germany: University of California Press. Google Books
  8. ^ Emanuel, Jeffrey P.. Black Ships and Sea Raiders: The Late Bronze and Early Iron Age Context of Odysseus’ Second Cretan Lie, p. 53. United Kingdom: Lexington Books (2017). Google Books
  9. ^ a b c Strange, John. (2023). Caphtor/Keftiu: A New Investigation, p. 19. Germany: Brill. Google Books
  10. ^ a b c d e f Cline, E. H. (2015). 1177 B.C.: The Year Civilization Collapsed, p. 28–41. United Kingdom: Princeton University Press. Google Books
  11. ^ Rose, C. B. (2014). The Archaeology of Greek and Roman Troy pp. 108-109. United Kingdom: Cambridge University Press. Google Books.
  12. ^ a b Cline, Eric H. (1997). Achilles in Anatolia: Myth, History, and the Assuwa Rebellion. Crossing Boundaries and Linking Horizons: Studies in Honor of Michael Astour on His 80th Birthday, pp. 189–210. Eds. Gordon D. Young, Mark W. Chavalas, and Richard E. Averbeck. (Bethesda, MD: CDL Press), Academia.edu
  13. ^ a b c Collins, B. J., Bachvarova, M. R., Rutherford, I. (2010). Anatolian Interfaces: Hittites, Greeks and Their Neighbours. United Kingdom: Oxbow Books. Google Books
  14. ^ Latacz, J. (2004). Troy and Homer: towards a solution of an old mystery. United Kingdom: OUP Oxford. Google Books
  15. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k Woudhuizen, Fred. (2023), The Luwians of Western Anatolia: Their Neighbours and Predecessors, pp. 23, 26, 34-66, 71-72, 119, 123, 134. United Kingdom: Archaeopress Publishing Limited. Academia.edu
  16. ^ Palima, Thomas G. (1991). Maritime Matters in the Linear B tablets, p. 279, 302-304. Austin: University of Texas. (University of Texas Files)
  17. ^ a b Forlanini, Massimo. (2008). The Historical Geography of Anatolia and the Transition From the Karum-Period to the Early Hittite Empire. Anatolia and the Jazira during the Old Assyrian Period, p. 58, 67 Academic.edu.
  18. ^ Schachner, Andreas. (2022). Hattusa and Its Environs: Archaeology, p. 37-49. Hittite Landscape and Geography. (2022). Eds. Lee Z. Ullmann and Mark Weeden. Netherlands: Leiden, Boston: Brill. Google Books
  19. ^ Wouduizen, Fred (2021). "Arzawa, Assuwa and Mira: Three Names For the Same Country in Western Anatolia" (video). European Association of Archaeologists.
  20. ^ Yukabovich, Ilya. (2011). Luwian and the Luwians. The Oxford Handbook of Ancient Anatolia: (10,000-323 BCE), p. 534-545. Spain: OUP USA. Google Books
  21. ^ a b Blasweiler, Joost. (2016). The kingdom of Purušhanda in the land Luwiya, pp. 31-38. Arnhem, Arnhem (NL) Bronze Age. Academia.edu
  22. ^ Nederhof, Mark-Jan. (2006). Transliteration and translation for "The 'poetical' stela of Tuthmosis III, p. 4. Laurinburg, NC: St. Andrews University. St. Andrews University archives.
  23. ^ Ambos, Clause and Krauskopf, Ingrid. (2008). The curved staff in the Ancient Near East as a predecessor of the Etruscan lituus, p. 132. Bouke van der Meer, L. (Hrsg.), Material Aspects of Etruscan Religion. Proceedings of the International Colloquium Leiden, May 29 and 30, 2008, Babesch Suppl. 16, 2010, S. 127-153. University of Heidelberg Archives.
  24. ^ Wouduizen characterizes the three hieroglyphs that comprise the name as (1) man's head in profile, (2) a triangle and (3) and a vine tendril.
  25. ^ Giusfredi, Federico., Pisaniello, Valerio, Matessi,  Alvise. (2023). Contacts of Languages and Peoples in the Hittite and Post-Hittite World: Volume 1, The Bronze Age and Hatti, p. 288. Netherlands: Brill. Google Books
  26. ^ Emanuel, Jeffrey, (2017). Ships and Sea Raiders: The Late Bronze and Early Iron Age Context of Odysseus’ Second Cretan Lie, p. 53. United Kingdom: Lexington Books. Google Books
  27. ^ KUB xxiii 11 þ 12 (CTH 142), KUB xxiii 14 (CTH 211.5), KUB xxvi 91 (CTH 183), KUB xxxiv 43 (CTH 824), KUB xl 62 þ KUB xiii 9 (CTH 258)
  28. ^ Rose, Charles Brian. (2014). The Archaeology of Greek and Roman Troy, pp. 108-109. United Kingdom: Cambridge University Press. Google Books
  29. ^ a b c d e f g Bryce, Trevor. (1999). The Kingdom of the Hittites, p. 35-40, 54-55, 124-125. 136. United Kingdom, Oxford University Press. Google Books.
  30. ^ Nostoi: Indigenous Culture, Migration + Integration in the Aegean Islands + Western Anatolia During the Late Bronze + Early Iron Ages, p. 134. Eds. Konstantinos Kopanias, Nikolaos Chr Stampolidēs, Çiğdem Maner. United Kingdom: Koç University Press, 2015.
  31. ^ The name has been identified as Luwian in origin. Greenberg, Joseph H. (2000). Indo-European and Its Closest Relatives: The Eurasiatic Language Family, Volume 1, p. 171. United States: Stanford University Press. Google Books
  32. ^ The name has been identified as Hurrian in origin. See Nyland. Ann. (2009) The Kikkuli Method of Horse Fitness Training, Revised Edition, p. 9. Maryannu Press, Sydney."
  33. ^ Unal, Ahmet. (1991). Two Peoples on Both Sides of the Aegean Sea. Officials and Administration in the Hittite World, pp. 16-44. Germany: O. Harrassowitz. Google Books
  34. ^ Rutherford, I. (2020). Hittite Texts and Greek Religion: Contact, Interaction, and Comparison, p. 113. United Kingdom: OUP Oxford. Google Books
  35. ^ Bomhard, A. R. (1984). Toward proto-Nostratic : a new approach to the comparison of proto-Indo-European and proto-Afroasiatic, p. 112. Netherlands: North-Holland. Google Books
  36. ^ a b Yakubovich, Ilya. (2011). Luwian and the Luwians. The Oxford Handbook of Ancient Anatolia: (10,000-323 BCE), p. 364, 535. Spain: OUP USA. Google Books.
  37. ^ Yakubovich, Ilya. (2011). In Search of Luwiya, the Original Luwian-speaking Area. Journal of Ancient History, Vol. 4, p. 295. http://vdi.igh.ru
  38. ^ Hecker, Karl. (1980). Zur Beurkundung V011 Kauf und Verkauf im Altassyrischen, Die Welt des Orients 11; RIA band 11, Purušhatum, 119.
  39. ^ History of Humanity: From the third millennium to the seventh century B.C., p. 549. United Kingdom: Routledge, 1994.
  40. ^ Giusfredi, F., Pisaniello, V., Matessi, A. (2023). Contacts of Languages and Peoples in the Hittite and Post-Hittite World: Volume 1, The Bronze Age and Hatti. Netherlands: Brill. Google Books
  41. ^ Yakar, Jak. (2003). Towards an absolute chronology for middle and late bronze age Anatolia, Studies. Presented A.M. Mansel, 562. Academia.edu
  42. ^ Boutet, Michel Gérald, (2000). Time Line of Indo-European Peoples and Cultures (after Cyril Babaev with modifications by MichelGérald Boutet and David Frawley), p. 5. Academia.edu.
  43. ^ Kuhrt, A. (1995). The Ancient Near East, C. 3000-330 BC, p. 227. United Kingdom: Routledge. Google Books
  44. ^ Forlanini, Massimo (2017). "South Central: The Lower Land and Tarḫuntašša". In Weeden, Mark; Ullmann, Lee (eds.). Hittite Landscape and Geography. Brill. p. 244. doi:10.1163/9789004349391_022. ISBN 978-90-04-34939-1.
  45. ^ Burney, C. (2018). Historical Dictionary of the Hittites p. 262. United States: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers. Google Books
  46. ^ a b c d Melchert, Craig. (2003). The Luwians, pp. 1-2, 7, 11 54-70. Netherlands: Brill. Google Books
  47. ^ Hawkins, David J. (2013). Luwians vs. Hittites. Luwian Identities: Culture, Language and Religion Between Anatolia and the Aegean, p. 31-35. Netherlands: Brill.
  48. ^ Seeher, Jurgen. (2011). The Plateau: The Hittites. The Oxford Handbook of Ancient Anatolia: (10,000-323 BCE), p. 376-392. (2011). Spain: OUP USA.
  49. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m Gander, Max. (2022). The West: Philology, p. 264-266. Hittite Landscape and Geography, Netherlands: Brill. Academia.edu
  50. ^ Yakubovich, Ilya (2013). Anatolian Names in -wiya and the Structure of Empire Luwian Omnastics. Luwian Identities: Culture, Language and Religion Between Anatolia and the Aegean, p. 31-35. Netherlands: Brill.
  51. ^ Bryce, T. (2018). Warriors of Anatolia: A Concise History of the Hittites. United Kingdom: Bloomsbury Publishing. Google Books
  52. ^ Herda, Alexander. (2013). Greek (and our) Views on the Karians, pp. Aegean. Netherlands: Brill. Google Books
  53. ^ Feuer, B. (2004). Mycenaean civilization : an annotated bibliography through 2002, p. 138. United Kingdom: McFarland, Incorporated, Publishers. Google Books
  54. ^ Eds. Joseph, Brian, Klein, Jared, Wenthe, Mark and Fritz, Matthias. (2018). Graeco-Anatolian Contacts in the Mycenaean Period. Handbook of Comparative and Historical Indo-European Linguistics, p. 2039. Germany: De Gruyter. Ancient Ports Antiques
  55. ^ Greaves, A. M. (2005). Miletos: Archaeology and History. United Kingdom: Taylor & Francis Google Books
  56. ^ Castleden, R. (2005). The Mycenaeans p. 37. United Kingdom: Taylor & Francis. https://www.google.com/books/edition/The_Mycenaeans/pLR-AgAAQBAJ?hl=en&gbpv=0 Google Books]
  57. ^ Widmer, P. (2006). Mykenisch ru-wa-ni-jo, Luwierı. Kadmos 45, pp. 82-84. Zurich Open Repository and Archive)
  58. ^ Billigmeier, J. C. (1970). An Inquiry into the Non-Greek Names on the Linear B Tablets from Knossos and their Relationship to Languages of Asia Minor. Minos 10, 177–83.
  59. ^ Waelkens, Marc. (2000). Sagalassos and Pisidia During the Late Bronze Age. Sagalassos V: Report on the Survey and Excavation Campaigns of 1996 and 1997, p. 473-508. Eds. Marc Waelkens and L. Loots. Belgium: Leuven University Press.Google Books
  60. ^ Price, S., Thonemann, P. (2011). The Birth of Classical Europe: A History from Troy to Augustine. United States: Penguin Publishing Group.
  61. ^ Mac Sweeney, Naoíse. (2016). Anatolian-Aegean Interactions in the Early Iron Age: Migration, Mobility, and the Movement of People. Of Odysseys and Oddities: Scales and Modes of Interaction between Prehistoric Aegean Societies and Their Neighbors, pp. 411-433. Ed. B. Molloym. Oxford. Philadelphia.
  62. ^ Bryce, Trevor. (2003). History. Vol. I/68, in Handbuch der Orientalistik, by The Luwians, p. 35-40. Eds. H. C. Melchert. Boston: Brill, Leyde.
  63. ^ Meriç, Recep. (2020). The Arzawa lands. The historical geography of İzmir and its environs during late bronze age in the light of new archaeological research. TÜBA-AR Türkiye Bilimler Akademisi Arkeoloji Dergisi, no. 27 : 151-177.
  64. ^ Houwink ten Cate, Philo H. J. (1970). The Records of the Early Hittite Empire (c. 1450-1380 B.C.), p. 58. Archive.org
  65. ^ Gurney, O. R. (2016). The Hittites. (Fig. 1): Hauraki Publishing. Google Books
  66. ^ Oreshko, Rostislav. (2013). Geography of the Western Fringes: Gar(a)giša/Gargiya and the Lands of the Late Bronze Age Caria, p. 153. Centre for Hellenic Studies (Harvard University). Academic.edu.
  67. ^ a b c d e Garstang, J. (2017). The Geography of the Hittite Empire, 105-106. United Kingdom: British Institute at Ankara. Google Books
  68. ^ Unwin, Naomi Carless. (2017). Caria and Crete in Antiquity: Cultural Interaction Between Anatolia and the Aegean, pp. 57, 115-118. United Kingdom: Cambridge University Press. Google Books.
  69. ^ Hawkins, J. D., Weeden, M. (2024). Corpus of Hieroglyphic Luwian Inscriptions: Volume III, p. 187: Inscriptions of the Hettite Empire and New Inscriptions of the Iron Age. Germany: De Gruyter. Google Books
  70. ^ Etruscan as a Colonial Luwian Language, Linguistica Tyrrhenica III. Innsbrucker Beiträge zur Kulturwissenschaft, Sonderheft 128. Innsbruck: Innsbrucker Beiträge zur Kulturwissenschaft. Talanta
  71. ^ Pantazis (Nikaea), "Wilusa: Reconsidering the Evidence", KLIO, 91 (2009), σ. 305-307. Web Archive
  72. ^ Taracha, Piotr. (2003). Is Tuthaliya's Sword really Aegean? Hittite Studies in Honor of Harry A. Hoffner, Jr: On the Occasion of His 65th Birthday, p. 367. Eds. Gary Beckman, Richard Beal and Gregory MaMahon. United States: Eisenbrauns. Google Books
  73. ^ Bryce, T. (2006). The Trojans and Their Neighbours, pp. 33-35, 81. Kiribati: Routledge. Google Books