Tufts began his professional career in 1973, playing for the GCL Indians. In 51 games with them, he batted .194. He missed all of 1974 following a car accident, and in 1975 he hit .270 in 102 games for the San Jose Bees. He split the 1976 season between the Bees and Williamsport Tomahawks, hitting a combined .249 in 62 games. 1977 ended up being his final professional season playing baseball. In 84 games for the Waterloo Indians and Jersey City Indians, he hit only .234.
Overall, Tufts hit .240 in 299 minor league games, over four seasons.
Post playing career
From 1986 to 1993, he was the head coach for Bridgewater State College. He was hired as a minor league instructor by the Giants in 1994, coaching the Clinton LumberKings. He managed for three seasons, from 1995 to 1997, and in 1997 he became a scout as well.
Year-By-Year Minor League Managerial Record
|1995||Bellingham Giants||Northwest League||43-33||2nd||San Francisco Giants||Lost League Finals|
|1996||Burlington Bees||Midwest League||65-73||11th||San Francisco Giants|
|1997||Bakersfield Blaze||California League||33-43||--||San Francisco Giants||replaced by Keith Bodie on June 25|