This article has multiple issues. Please help improve it or discuss these issues on the talk page. (Learn how and when to remove these template messages)(Learn how and when to remove this template message)
|Birth name||Iona Emmanuilovich Yakir|
August 3, 1896|
Kishinev, Bessarabia, Russian Empire
|Died||June 12, 1937
Moscow, Soviet Union
|Allegiance|| Russian SFSR
|Years of service||1918–37|
|Rank||Komandarm 1st rank|
|Unit||45th Rifle Division, 58th Rifle Division, Ukrainian Military District, Kiev Military District, Leningrad Military District|
|Commands held||Ukrainian Military District, Kiev Military District, Leningrad Military District|
|Battles/wars||Russian Civil War, Polish-Soviet War|
|Awards||Order of the Red Banner (three times)|
Iona Emmanuilovich Yakir (Russian: Иона Эммануилович Якир; August 3, 1896 – June 12, 1937) was a Red Army commander and one of the world's major military reformers between World War I and World War II. He was an early and major military victim of the Great Purge, alongside Mikhail Tukhachevsky. He was rehabilitated in 1957 by Nikita Khrushchev.
Yakir was born in Kishinev, Bessarabia, Russian Empire, into the prosperous family of a Jewish pharmacist. He graduated from the local secondary school in 1914. Because of governmental restrictions on Jewish access to higher education, Yakir studied abroad at the University of Basel in Switzerland, in the field of chemistry. During World War I, he returned to the Russian Empire and worked as a turner in a military factory in Odessa, Ukraine (he was a reservist). From 1915 to 1917, he attended the Kharkiv Technological Institute. He was affected by the war and became a follower of Vladimir Lenin. In 1917, he returned to Kishinev, and in April became a member of the Bolshevik Party. He also became a member of the Bessarabian Governorate's Council, the Governorate's Committee and the Revolutionary Committee. From January 1918, he took active part in the Bolshevik seizure of power in Bessarabia. When Romania intervened to recapture Bessarabia, Yakir led Bolshevik resistance but his small force was overwhelmed by the regular Romanian army.
In the Civil War
Yakir retreated to Ukraine and fought against Austro-Hungarian occupation forces as a commander of a Chinese regiment of the Red Army. He was severely wounded in March 1918 near Ekaterinoslav. At the beginning of the Russian Civil War between Bolshevik forces, the White Army and various other anti-Bolshevik movements, Yakir was a member of the Bolshevik Party in Voronezh Province and started his service in the Red Army as a commissar. He showed military talent and was assigned as a field commander. In October 1918, he served as a member of the Revolutionary Council of the 8th Army in the Southern Front and simultaneously commanded the Southern Front's several key formations in operations against the Don Cossacks of Pyotr Krasnov. He carried out Lenin's order of persecution against the Cossack civilians and the extermination of almost half of the male Cossack population. The war against armed combatants plus the terror against the civilians were coming together in the Russian Civil War. Encouraged by the Bolshevik theory of class struggle, Yakir, like other members of the Communist party, took part in terror. For his services, he became the second individual (after Vasily Blyukher) to receive the highest Soviet military award of that time, the Order of the Red Banner (engraved as No. 2).
In the summer of 1919, Yakir was sent to Ukraine to command the 45th Rifle Division, and in August 1919, he became the commander of the Southern Group of the 12th Army, which included the 45th and 58th Rifle Divisions. Both divisions were surrounded in Odessa by the White forces. Yakir undertook one of the most unusual Civil War military operations. He breached the encirclement and led his forces through the enemy rear for a distance of 400 kilometres (250 mi) to join the Red Army in Zhitomir. Like other Bolshevik commanders who did not have military education he was assisted in this operation by former tsarist army officers on his staff but this fact does not negate his own role in planning and leading the campaign. For this campaign he received his second Order of the Red Banner, and both of his divisions received Red Banners of Honor. Yakir took part in actions against the White forces of Nikolai Yudenich in defense of Petrograd, in suppression of Ukrainian anarchist guerrilla forces of Nestor Makhno, and in the Polish-Soviet War. He was awarded the Order of the Red Banner three times (twice in 1919 and once in 1930), and he became one of the most-decorated Red Army commanders.
After the war, Yakir commanded army formations in Ukraine. Yakir was a close associate of Mikhail Frunze and belonged to his inner circle of innovative Red Army officers who assisted Frunze in starting far-reaching military reforms. Among these reformers was Mikhail Tukhachevsky who became Yakir's friend. In April 1924 Yakir was appointed a head of Main Directorate of Military Academies of the Red Army and simultaneously editor of a major military periodical devoted to development of military theory, Voennyi Vestnik.
In November 1925, after Frunze's death, Yakir was appointed commander of the most powerful territorial formations of the Red Army, the newly reorganized Ukrainian Military District (see: Kiev Military District). Yakir, in close coordination with Tukhachevsky and other reformers, made his district into a laboratory of wide-ranging experiments in strategy, tactical and operational techniques, army formations and equipment. In training his troops, Yakir encouraged his officers' initiative and ability to make their own judgments. In 1928 and 1929, Yakir studied at the Higher Military Academy in Berlin. This was possible because of the intensive military cooperation between the Soviet Union and Germany. Yakir's innovative approaches to the military art impressed his German colleagues. German Field Marshal of World War I fame, Paul von Hindenburg, praised him as one of the most-talented military commanders of the post-World War I era. Upon repeated requests from German officers, Yakir gave special lectures on the Russian Civil War.
After returning to his district, Yakir continued military reform. He was one of the creators of the first large tank and air force formations in the world. Not a military theorist in his own right, Yakir strongly supported Tukhachevsky's endeavor in developing the theory of deep operations. Military historians across the world still consider this theory an outstanding theoretical innovation. In 1934 Yakir requested that Tukhachevsky would be appointed to conduct advanced courses on operational theory for high-ranking officers of the Red Army General Staff and commanders of military districts. He did it even though he knew about Joseph Stalin's dislike of Tukhachevsky. In retribution, Stalin instructed Kliment Voroshilov, the Peoples Commissar of Defense, to bar Yakir from membership in the prestigious Advisory Council of the Defense Commissariat. In 1935, in order to diminish Yakir's power, the Ukrainian Military District was divided into two new districts: Kiev, under Yakir's command, and Kharkov.
In September 1935, Yakir conducted major military maneuvers in Kiev, with the Kiev and Kharkov Military Districts' forces. The event resulted in several cover page articles in the Defense Comissariat's official journal, Krasnaya Zvezda (Red Star). The major aim of these maneuvers was to test the theory of deep operations and the latest technology. A total of 65,000 troops, including 1,888 paratroopers, 1,200 tanks and 600 aircraft participated in these maneuvers. These were first maneuvers in the world that used combined operations of large tank, air force and airborne formations. The troops acted along a front of 250 kilometres (160 mi) and a depth of 200 kilometres (120 mi). The representatives of major world armies attended the maneuvers. French general Lucien Loizeau made very favorable comments about the technical and moral readiness of the Red Army. The German Wehrmacht copied Soviet innovations in preparation for World War II. The reform started by Frunze, and continued by Yakir, Tukhachevsky and many other commanders, made the Red Army into one of the most advanced armies in the world. During these years, Yakir regularly gave lectures to the Red Army General Staff Academy, informing the students about the newest developments in military affairs; his students considered him both an excellent speaker and tutor. In 1935 he was promoted to Comandarm, first rank, the second-highest military rank in the Soviet Union at the time.
Stalin, who was consolidating his power over the country, approved Yakir's appointment to the Ukrainian Military District in 1925. However, he did not trust him fully and instructed his political ally Lazar Kaganovich to become friends with Yakir and to report about his activities. Yakir, who was a firm believer in the Communist cause, was actively involved in internal politics. He was member of the party Central Committee in Moscow and member of the Politburo of the Communist Party of Ukraine. While ingenious and independent in his thinking as a military commander, in Soviet politics he was a docile party member and followed the Stalinist line. As a party member, he lacked the power of conviction and independent thinking to defy Stalin.
His blind obedience did not spare him. Stalin would not allow to his military commanders any independent thinking – he was aware of the constant risk of a coup. While Stalin's attitude toward Yakir was apparently friendly, the leader could not tolerate him. Starting with the Great Purge in 1936, the NKVD arrested many close associates and subordinates of Yakir. (This method became an NKVD routine in the course of the purges: this way they were able to create a professional and private vacuum around the target person.) Yakir was one of few top Soviet commanders who appealed to Stalin, even traveled to Moscow and tried to convince Voroshilov in person, claiming the innocence of these officers. However, Yakir's appeals (and his other reactions) were a clear sign of his disagreement with the ongoing purges which alienated Stalin even more.
Arrest, trial and death
On 10 and 11 May 1937, the Red Army was shaken up by several major personal changes. Marshal Tukhachevsky was discharged from his position as a deputy commissar and was sent to command the Volga Military District which had little military importance. At the same time Yakir was also sent to a different post: from Kiev to Leningrad. Unlike Tukhachevsky, it wasn't an obvious demotion. Tukhachevsky was arrested on the way to his new post on 22 May. Yakir attended a conference in the Kiev Military District when he heard the news. His mood changed dramatically afterwards – normally he was cheerful, friendly, making jokes. This shift was attributed to his transfer to Leningrad.
On 31 May 1937, the NKVD arrested Yakir, and transported him to the Lubyanka prison in Moscow. He and seven other major military commanders (Robert Eideman, Boris Feldman, Avgust Kork, Vitaly Primakov, Vitovt Putna, Mikhail Tukhachevsky and Ieronim Uborevich) were accused of being members of the alleged Trotskyist Anti-Soviet Military Organization and of being Nazi agents. Except for Feldman, who was cooperative, all of them got brutally tortured. Yakir (until they broke him) maintained his innocence, both in correspondence to Joseph Stalin and at his trial on 11 July. Although he generally admitted taking part in a conspiracy, he denied being a spy. During the trial he was asked to provide further details about his written confession but he stated that he couldn't add anything more. One of his last letters to Stalin is really moving. Stalin and other members of the Politburo made a following cynical comments on this, creating a written conversation: "Rascal and prostitute" (Stalin). Kliment Voroshilov and Vyacheslav Molotov added: "A perfectly accurate definition". Lazar Kaganovich finally wrote: "The only punishment for the scoundrel, riffraff and whore is death penalty".
Yakir and the other seven commanders were executed in Moscow, virtually right after their trial at the dawn of 12 June 1937, without even reading their appeals. The man who performed their execution was Vasily Blokhin, the chief executioner of NKVD. The corpses were cremated on site, and the ashes were thrown into a mass grave dug at the Donskoye Cemetery. Members of the Yakir family were either immediately executed, like his younger brother, Moris Emmanuilovich (1902–1937), or sent to Gulag labor camps: Yakir's younger sister, Isabella Emmanuilovna (1900–1986) served there 10 years while his wife, Sarra Lazarevna (1900–1971) and his then-14-year-old son, Pyotr Ionovich (1923–1982), spent almost 20 years there. Yakir's military writings were banned. Plus, to morally finish the generals, newspapers dubbed them "treasonous", and published articles approving their execution, with the signatures of well-known Soviet artists – no matter if they in fact signed these articles or not (among those that refused was Boris Pasternak).
Opinions on Yakir are mixed, even today. As a young Civil War commander, he used excessive force and violence (flamethrowers, machine guns) against the civilian members of resistance and the Cossack population, and was also involved in requisition. Later, during the years of agricultural collectivization, he led punitive raids against the starving peasants. Many think that he was personally liable for the great famine in the Ukraine between 1932 and 1933. On the top of this, he was of Jewish origin, and he supported the loathed Trotsky during and even after the Civil War (Trotsky was a family friend of the Yakirs). He also had other characteristics translated as vices by the puritan Stalin: Yakir never made a secret of his luxurious Kiev lifestyle (he lived in one of the palaces of the Mezhyhirya Residence), and he also lent dachas for profit and never ceased his involvement in trading.
But as a military reformer, he was absolutely remarkable. He worked on the improvement of the Red Army until his last breath. On 10 June 1937, 2 days before his execution, he wrote a long letter to Nikolay Yezhov, head of the NKVD, about his observations and the important duties in the field of military. After his death, the purge wiped out large number of the officers who had served under him. Many tasks of Yakir's work, including his reforms and preparations for guerrilla activities in the event of an invasion of Ukraine, were dismantled. When Germany invaded the Soviet Union in June 1941, the Red Army was incapable of modern warfare and unprepared to face an enemy who used military art which Yakir and other Soviet innovators were greatly familiar with. The Soviets suffered terrible defeats and huge human and territorial losses before remastering modern operational approaches and tactics. Yakir's disciples who survived the purge used the experiences which they had gained under Yakir to make a vital contribution to Soviet victory over Germany. Among them were Chief of the General Staff of the Red Army Aleksei Antonov, Front commanders Andrei Yeremenko and Ivan Chernyakhovsky, and Army commander Alexander Gorbatov.
- Командарм Якир. Воспоминания друзей и соратников (edited by P. I. Yakir and I. A. Geller; 1963)
- Stalin's Generals (edited by Harold Shukman; 1993)
- Victor Alexandrov, The Tukhachevsky Affair (1964)
- Thos. G. Butson, The Tsar's Lieutenant: The Soviet Marshal (1984)
- Robert Conquest, The Great Terror (2008)
- John Erickson, The Soviet High Command: A Military-Political History 1918–1941 (2006)
- Alexander Gorbatov, Years off My Life: The Memoirs of a General of the Soviet Army (New York, 1964)
- Anna Larina, This I Cannot Forget: The Memoirs of Nikolai Bukharin's Widow (1993)
- Donald Rayfield, Stalin and His Hangmen: The Tyrant and Those Who Killed for Him (2004)
- Simon Sebag Montefiore, Stalin: The Court of the Red Tsar (2005)
- Brian D. Taylor, Politics in the Russian Army: Civil–Military Relations, 1689–2000 (2003)
- Pyotr Yakir, A Childhood In Prison (1973)
- Earl F. Ziemke, The Red Army 1918–1941: From Vanguard of World Revolution to US Ally (2006)
- Film about Yakir (he's on the left of Voroshilov)
- Film about Yakir (in the company of Budyonny and Tukhachevsky)
- Five short biographies about Yakir (all in Russian)
- Yakir's short biography (in Russian)
- John Erickson, The Soviet High Command. A Military-Political History 1918–1941, page 80.
- Donald Rayfield, Stalin and His Hangmen: The Tyrant and Those Who Killed for Him, page 79.
- Earl F. Ziemke, The Red Army 1918–1941. From Vanguard of World Revolution to US Ally, page 104.
- The Soviet High Command. A Military-Political History 1918–1941, page 178.
- "Voennyi Vestnik".
- The Soviet High Command. A Military-Political History 1918–1941, pages 202, 367.
- And not just him: historians of posterity also consider Yakir as one of the most promising talents of the Red Army. See: John Erickson, The Soviet High Command. A Military-Political History 1918–1941, page 482.
- At the end of the course Hindenburg handled of a copy of Cannae, the famous military treatise of Alfred von Schlieffen to Yakir with the following written dedication: "To Herr Yakir, one of the most talented commanders present". See: 10 мифов о 1941 годе.
- The Soviet High Command. A Military-Political History 1918–1941, page 394.
- "Voroshilov, Gamarnik and Yakir: The Troika".
- Peter Gosztony, Die rote Armee: Machtfaktor der Weltpolitik.
- Alexander Gorbatov, Years off My Life: The Memoirs of a General of the Soviet Army.
- Simon Sebag Montefiore, Stalin: The Court of the Red Tsar, page 223.
- Robert Conquest, The Great Terror, page 201.
- Otto Preston Chaney, Zhukov, page 36-37.
- Thos. G. Butson, The Tsar's Lieutenant: The Soviet Marshal, page 227.
- The Soviet High Command. A Military-Political History 1918–1941, page 426.
- Yakir – alongside Stalin, Yezhov and Krupskaya – was the member of a special committee established after the arrest of Nikolai Bukharin and before the Trial of the Twenty-One. They gathered together to decide upon the fate of the accused ones, including Rykov and Bukharin. Yezhov suggested to exclude them from the Central Committee and execute them, following a short trial. Postyshev agreed on the trial but rejected against the idea of execution. Stalin himself made a third suggestion (which only delayed the solution): to further investigate therefore pushing the case back to NKVD. Members of the special committee were to vote for each of the three suggestions one by one, in alphabetical order. According to some people present Yakir was the only person refraining. Given the circumstances, it was a heroic act. Others said though that Yakir (whose name starts with the last letter of the Russian alphabet) took advantage of his position and voted for the suggestion of Stalin as the most convenient option. See: Anna Larina, This I Cannot Forget: The Memoirs of Nikolai Bukharin's Widow, page 241–242. and Jörg Baberowski, Verbrannte Erde. Stalins Herrschaft der Gewalt.
- This is how Khrushchev remembers: "Previously Stalin had greatly respected Yakir. Yakir kept in his possession a memorandum in which Stalin had praised Yakir's personal qualities, and, you know, Stalin was very miserly about putting any praise in writing." See: Memoirs of Nikita Khrushchev: Commissar, 1918–1945. Penn State University Press.