Jump to content

Talk:Wadi Murabba'at

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Pls add Wadi "Muraba'at" autodirect

[edit]

@Zero0000: Hi! Sorry for hurrying to conclusions. I see the spelling with one b is less common, but still it produces some 1200 hits. So - "Muraba'at", "Wadi Muraba'at", "Wadi Muraba'at Caves" as autodirects? Thanks, merry Xmas, and a happy New Year! Arminden (talk) 17:02, 27 December 2019 (UTC)[reply]

First two done, not sure about the third. Have a great 2020. Zerotalk 23:27, 27 December 2019 (UTC)[reply]

What wadi?

[edit]

@Zero0000: Hi. Cartography might solve the problem, so... :)

In Arabic, each section of a wadi/valley has a different name. Here we have at least three distinct Arabic names used in a careless manner, possibly for the same wadi, and a set of Hebrew names, maybe used for the entire valley, but maybe not.

It would make sense to look for the sources on the "plateau", which might not be quite a plateau, but just the less steep area west of the Rift Valley. Maybe already that upper section is divided into several segments. Second, there's the steep section going down the escarpment, canyon-style. Third, the last short bit is less steep and narrow once it reaches the valley and flows towards the Dead Sea. There might be more names on SWP maps than the better-known 3, which were promoted by tourism and archaeology.

Arabic
  1. Wadi Darga
  2. Wadi Mashash, maybe same as upper Wadi Darga
  3. Wadi Murabba'at, maybe the same as Wadi Mushash - see below for map where Wadi Mushash has Muraba'at Cave on its N bank; or maybe just a section of Wadi Mushash, so a sub-subset of the entire wadi.
Hebrew
  1. Nahal Darga, Wadi/Nahal Dargot, mixing Hebrew with Arabic, sing. or plural (Darga/Dargot). Whole valley?
  2. Metsoke Dargot/Dragot, 'steep cliffs' - fully in Hebrew. Maybe just for escarpment section? Settlement by that name on the edge of plateau, right above the escarpment.

Adventure-Israel.com has: "Upper Wadi Darga (Mashash)", offering hiking and rappelling tours there.

Bishop Pike page has: Wadi Mashash (Hebrew names: Wadi Dargot or מצוקי דרגות - Metsoke Dargot/Dragot, which translates to 'steep cliffs')

Here is a map of "Wadi Mushash" with Muraba'at Cave at ps.geoview.info. Mapio has Wadi Darga-Mashash.

Not to be confused with Wadi Mshash in the Negev! See for instance here. Mshash/Mushash is probably a common word or name in Arabic, see for instance Qasr M(u)shash (only German Wiki has an art., "Qasr Muschasch". Arminden (talk) 14:07, 5 March 2024 (UTC)[reply]