Jump to content

Talk:Ashikaga Yoshimasa: Difference between revisions

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Content deleted Content added
BattyBot (talk | contribs)
m Talk page general fixes & other cleanup using AWB (9466)
Line 24: Line 24:
The teenage Yoshimasa became ''[[Shogun|Seii Taishogun]]'' six years after the death in [[1443]] of his older brother, the seventh shogun [[Ashikaga Yoshikatsu]].
The teenage Yoshimasa became ''[[Shogun|Seii Taishogun]]'' six years after the death in [[1443]] of his older brother, the seventh shogun [[Ashikaga Yoshikatsu]].
If someone can provide a citation which verifies this as correct, then of course it should be re-integrated into the article text. --[[User:Tenmei|Tenmei]] ([[User talk:Tenmei|talk]]) 15:19, 27 February 2008 (UTC)
If someone can provide a citation which verifies this as correct, then of course it should be re-integrated into the article text. --[[User:Tenmei|Tenmei]] ([[User talk:Tenmei|talk]]) 15:19, 27 February 2008 (UTC)

== Inconsistent date for reign? ==

It appears that two different dates are given for the beginning of his reign. In the first line: "who reigned from 1449 to 1473", but in the next paragraph: "On the August 16, '''1443''' (Kakitsu 3, 21st day of the 7th month), 10-year-old shogun Yoshikatsu died of injuries sustained in a fall from a horse. He had been shogun for only three years. '''Immediately''', the bakufu elevated '''Yoshinari''', the young shogun's even younger brother, to be the new shogun.[3] Several years after becoming shogun, '''Yoshinari changed his name to Yoshimasa''', by which name he is better known."

Could it be that the date confusion is due to Yoshinari changing his name to Yoshimasa, and the date 1449 being the date of his name change rather than his shogunate?

Also, the date in the family tree at the bottom of the page also has 1449. However, this would leave a clear 5-6 year gap in the shogunate. The word "immediately" in the second paragraph seems to indicate that there was no such gap.

IMO, the dates should be amended to 1443, but I have no references to back this up, but nor to confirm that it's officially considered to be 1449 instead. -- 24.57.77.150 14 January 2015

Revision as of 17:00, 14 January 2015

Akamatsu Norinao

The following was temporarily removed from the text because it lacks the verifiable support of an in-line citation. Without more, this could be merely spurious:

  • Like most shoguns, he practiced the shudo tradition, taking Akamatsu Norinao as his wakashu. A number of Ashikaga shoguns chose their beloveds from the Akamatsu family. Norinao, granted lands at the time in possession of Yamana Sozen, was attacked by the latter and took his own life. This is said to have been another factor leading to the Ōnin War.
-- <.ref>The Love of the Samurai: A Thousand Years of Japanese Homosexuality by Tsuneo Watanabe and Jun'ichi Iwata<./ref>

These bare statements, standing alone, are inadequate without more -- without some sort of better developed context and possible internal links to other articles in Wikipedia ...? --Tenmei (talk) 22:38, 20 February 2008 (UTC)[reply]

Unverified statement

I've removed the following statement because I think it is incorrect. The teenage Yoshimasa became Seii Taishogun six years after the death in 1443 of his older brother, the seventh shogun Ashikaga Yoshikatsu. If someone can provide a citation which verifies this as correct, then of course it should be re-integrated into the article text. --Tenmei (talk) 15:19, 27 February 2008 (UTC)[reply]

Inconsistent date for reign?

It appears that two different dates are given for the beginning of his reign. In the first line: "who reigned from 1449 to 1473", but in the next paragraph: "On the August 16, 1443 (Kakitsu 3, 21st day of the 7th month), 10-year-old shogun Yoshikatsu died of injuries sustained in a fall from a horse. He had been shogun for only three years. Immediately, the bakufu elevated Yoshinari, the young shogun's even younger brother, to be the new shogun.[3] Several years after becoming shogun, Yoshinari changed his name to Yoshimasa, by which name he is better known."

Could it be that the date confusion is due to Yoshinari changing his name to Yoshimasa, and the date 1449 being the date of his name change rather than his shogunate?

Also, the date in the family tree at the bottom of the page also has 1449. However, this would leave a clear 5-6 year gap in the shogunate. The word "immediately" in the second paragraph seems to indicate that there was no such gap.

IMO, the dates should be amended to 1443, but I have no references to back this up, but nor to confirm that it's officially considered to be 1449 instead. -- 24.57.77.150 14 January 2015